Police attitude - seen the best and worst this week
Police attitude - seen the best and worst this week
Author
Discussion

GM182

Original Poster:

1,491 posts

256 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I haven't had cause to talk to the cops in years but this week for some reason I got stopped twice.

I live in Kingston and work in Fulham and I drive, cycle, motorcycle and use public transport as the occasion requires.

So this evening I am absolutely disgusted with the police's proto-fascist, power happy, little Hitler attitude.

Why you might ask?

Cycling back from Chelsea & Westminster Hospital to my office in Fulham I approach the junction of Fulham Rd and Gunter Grove heading west. The light is already red and I coast up nearside of a couple of stationary cars and stop at the pedestrian crossing. After a family crosses I push myself forward to the corner of the junction with my left foot, arse still on the saddle. I spot a group of cops on the other side and look for any evidence of an accident or random stops but think not much more of it. The light turns green and I set off and as soon as I cross the junction a female cop on my side of the road flags me down.

Even though it's pissing down with rain I'm happy to helpful and wondering what she wants so I ask how can I help and to my utter astonishment she beckons me on to the pavement and tells me she is giving me a fixed penalty for running a red light. I have rarely been genuinely incredulous in my life but I just couldn't believe it. She says that I crossed the stop line and she is going to issue me a ticket. At this point another office steps over and asks her if she just going to have a word. She then pops round the corner and he says to me wait, I'll just see if this can be sorted out verbally. My jaw is still hanging.

She then returns with a penalty notice form and says she is issuing me a ticket. I was lost for words. I kept saying this if totally over the top. Anyway, she wanted my personal details so I told her my name and refused to provide any ID which I genuine don't have apart from a debit card. I then asked her how much it was and she told me 50quid.

From there on my adrenaline was pumping with anger and I needed all my self control to remain calm. I refused to give her my postcode so she then went to her patrol supervisor saying I was being aggressive. At no point did I use any swear words or verbals or step closer to her or use any body language that was aggressive. In fact I folded my arms across my chest and refused to make eye contact.

So the patrol supervisor, who is quite a short woman with a 6.2" bike cop standing behind her, (the other reasonable male cop is to my left so I am now surrounded against the wall by four of them) tells me I will be arrested if I don't provide some ID and my post code. Gratingly and with minimal eye contact and no raised voice, swearing or change in my body position I provide them protesting again that this ticket is totally over the top.

The others move away gradually and the first officer then completes the ticket and gives it to me. I tell her I have lost a great deal of respect for the police and Merry Christmas and cycle off.

I was shaking with adrenaline afterwards. I should have refused to confirm my name with the bank card but I actually started to feel genuinely intimidated with four officers around me.

The officer who issued the ticket was Polish (or some eastern European origin judging by her accent) and I am left wondering what sort of country we live in these days. I am incensed that a squad of cops in west London on a quiet Friday night between them cannot see that they might have mentioned that crossing the stop line is an offence even on a bicycle but that the officer felt it was necessary with no by your leave to bash me with the fine for the most marginal of technical offences. What made it even worse was I just spent the past three hours doing voluntary work and I am far from flush at the moment.

On a positive note on Tuesday I was on the motorbike and a bike cop followed me into the Texaco station on Putney Vale as I had put on a spurt from the West Hill underpass under Tibbett's corner to the next set of lights. Three lanes, 60 in a 40, he could have busted me but saw that I looked sheepish, admitted the offence straight away and was not taking the piss. I genuinely felt lucky he didn't ticket me but that yeah, he was right, I should trim the speed a bit. Respect.

Now I reckon bike cops and some of the motorway patrol are pretty okay - the rest...

Edited to remove abusive word.

Edited by GM182 on Saturday 14th December 10:23

Bigends

6,197 posts

159 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
You're under no obligation to provide proof of id. They have the means to check out the details you give to see if they are correct.

Tyre Tread

10,697 posts

247 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
2 admitted offences. One you got away with, one you didn't. One you would have got points for that would have affected your insurance and one you didn't.

Not condoning the officers attitude on the cycle stop but if you broke the law accept the consequences.

GM182

Original Poster:

1,491 posts

256 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Bigends said:
You're under no obligation to provide proof of id. They have the means to check out the details you give to see if they are correct.
Yes, I took that tack to begin with. I gave my name and address and it was during that moment that I asked how much the fine was and when she told me I said if you are going through with this then I have given you my name, house number, street name and town you can look up the post code. 'I am not going to give you any additional help if I don't have to.'

That was when she went and got the officer who I presume was the supervisor who said if I didn't cooperate then they could arrest me. That was the 4-1 point and I felt if I argued they would make out i was being diffcult or aggressive.



GM182

Original Poster:

1,491 posts

256 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Tyre Tread said:
2 admitted offences. One you got away with, one you didn't. One you would have got points for that would have affected your insurance and one you didn't.

Not condoning the officers attitude on the cycle stop but if you broke the law accept the consequences.
First offence was dealt with at the witnessing officer's discretion. Fair enough.

Second instance was totally a disproportionate response and attitude with it. If I had endagered myself or someone else or just been careless then fair enough but 50 forthe sake of 3ft is ridiculous. This is why zero tolerance policing is not helpful. As someone who has always been generally supportive of the police, done Bikesafe, given to the odd Met appeal, it leaves a bitter taste.

Editted to add - I didn't admit the cycle offence at the time because I was doubtful she could see the road markings at night and in the wet and I genuinely wasn't quite sure where the line was, submerged by water as it was.

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Its for this reason when on my pushbike I stop for nothing....

ome of their patrol pushbikes even have flashing red and blue lights!

In all seriousness though i'd fight it for the lack of sight of the line, only reasonable doubt is required. If you weren't cycling (you say you pushed) across the line you are just a pedestrian surely?

King Eric

300 posts

241 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Bigends said:
You're under no obligation to provide proof of id. They have the means to check out the details you give to see if they are correct.
No but if they cannot ascertain who you are they can arrest you for any offence using an element of code G of Pace. Seems hardly worthwhile does it?

If you were genuinely wrong'd challenge it in court!

GM182

Original Poster:

1,491 posts

256 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
kiethton said:
Its for this reason when on my pushbike I stop for nothing....

ome of their patrol pushbikes even have flashing red and blue lights!

In all seriousness though i'd fight it for the lack of sight of the line, only reasonable doubt is required. If you weren't cycling (you say you pushed) across the line you are just a pedestrian surely?
the pushing angle maybe worth considering. i wasn't actually cycling. cheers.
i nearly didn't stop actually because i couldn't think of any reason they'd want to talk to me. next time...

GM182

Original Poster:

1,491 posts

256 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
King Eric said:
No but if they cannot ascertain who you are they can arrest you for any offence using an element of code G of Pace. Seems hardly worthwhile does it?

If you were genuinely wrong'd challenge it in court!
i may yet go to court because the ticket has a mistake on it, i didn't actually admit the offence and i think the penalty is disproportionate.

Oh well, way past bedtime and I've vented now.

Cheers

Juliet1981

25 posts

156 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Bare in mind that if you do decide to go to court then any errors on the ticket won't matter in the slightest. The "ticket" is just a piece of paper that is an offer to deal with the offence quickly without the cost of a court case. If you do elect to go to court the evidence will be the officers statement & the ticket is not used as any form of evidence.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
GM182 said:
kiethton said:
Its for this reason when on my pushbike I stop for nothing....

ome of their patrol pushbikes even have flashing red and blue lights!

In all seriousness though i'd fight it for the lack of sight of the line, only reasonable doubt is required. If you weren't cycling (you say you pushed) across the line you are just a pedestrian surely?
the pushing angle maybe worth considering. i wasn't actually cycling. cheers.
i nearly didn't stop actually because i couldn't think of any reason they'd want to talk to me. next time...
I doubt a magistrate will accept: "arse still on the saddle" as you being a pedestrian.

Streaky

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
The suggestion that pushing the bike forward with one foot on the ground is not cycling is hopeless. If you are walking with the bike held beside you, you are not cycling, but if you are on the bike, or scooting it, you are cycling. This point was dealt with by the Court of Appeal in Crank v Brooks [1980] RTR 441.

Salesy

850 posts

160 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
GM182

At the end of the day you still crossed the line and therefore run the red light..... had that of been a car and a cyclist was travelling across the front of said car, the cyclist would be giving the old hand gesture to the driver for rolling forward....... plus the fact had it been a car and there was a camera he would of got flashed so fairs fair take it on the chin and don't do it again.
I drive in Fulham at least twice a week in a large van and most cyclists are the biggest muppets out there. When at lights they shoot up the inside, outside, pull in front of you, its no winder so many are knocked off or injured.

I always look out for bikes be it motor or pedal after having a bike myself but sometimes you lot just can't help yourself, yes there are also a lot of drivers that will go out of their way to not let a cyclist through but does that give you the right to either brush the side of the paintwork or hop up the kerb just to gain a few yards..


Sorry mate you was in the wrong


ED209

6,027 posts

275 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
i am not sure what the cops "attitude" has to do with this. You'd didn't even speak to the second cop so how could you know what his/her attitude was?


DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
In the OPs defence. I am sure he was positioning himself forward of the a pillar blind spot of the driver to his immediate right. Thus would have afforded him some mitigation if the said driver ran him over.
Police reaction was over the top. Especially as they are trying to make cycling safer at the moment....

I am not a cyclist.

berlintaxi

8,535 posts

204 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
How does the Police officer nationality/origin make any difference to her ability to carry out her duties? Why was it worth commenting on?

Arms folded and refusing to make eye contact hardly sounds like co-operating to me, guessing your attitude didn't help your cause much, as opposed to the incident on the motorbike.

jodypress

2,130 posts

305 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
I doubt a magistrate will accept: "arse still on the saddle" as you being a pedestrian.

Streaky
But if you are moving yourself along with your feet on the ground, that isn't cycling?

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Yes it is. You are sitting on the cycle and using its wheels to assist your movement. If you dismount and push the bike you are a pedestrian, but if you pedal on a bike, coast on a bike, or scoot on it, you are cycling. The first bikes had no pedals (like the balance bikes given to small children nowadays).

edeath

336 posts

222 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I managed to get myself a £50 fine by going 3ft along a cycle lane on my motorbike by Admiralty Arch last week by a motorbike cop on foot. My fault for not seeing the policeman was there really - was looking the other way to make sure there were no cyclists coming...

He was very polite, made it clear he wasn't going to patronise me and that the enforcement was due to the current crackdown on offences around cycling due to the current media attention. We had a pleasant chat about bikes and I've paid my £50 fine...

Surely you knew about the current media whirlwind around cycling fatalities and Boris sticking his foot in it causing increased enforcement? We all have to be whiter than white at certain road junctions in London until the New Year. You see police at a junction you make damn sure you don't even inch over the ASL as a powered road user and don't go over the stop line as a cyclist - its pretty simple.....that and don't go in cycle lanes as I found out frown

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I was lucky this week, well, unlucky.

After chopping the front of my Elise in Glasgow a pair of officers came to my assistance. Couldn't have met a nicer couple of guys.
Let me sit in their car whilst I waited on the recovery truck, chatted away and made me feel so much better.