ebay MC999 Listing policy violation alert:Rights Owner
ebay MC999 Listing policy violation alert:Rights Owner
Author
Discussion

jonny70

Original Poster:

1,280 posts

189 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi

I started listing a branded product that I bought from a distributor and the product was removed by ebay .I used my own pictures.When i contacted ebay they said the copyright owner ie the brand can choose to remove listings


Am I right in saying if the manufacture doesn't want you selling their product on bay , they can just get it removed? (ie becasue they are selling it too cheaply)

Jonny_

4,730 posts

238 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
Seems they can do what they want.

Tomtom had a listing for my old XDA removed because I'd mentioned it had Tomtom software and they assumed it was knockoff.

eBay has reached the point where it's just not worth using to sell. Extortionate fees, one-sided "Seller Is Always Wrong" approach to buyer protection, crap customer support, and pandering to corporations who don't like people buying their products second-hand rather than new have ruined it as a selling platform, IMHO.

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
jonny70 said:
Hi
Am I right in saying if the manufacture doesn't want you selling their product on bay , they can just get it removed? (ie becasue they are selling it too cheaply)
Basically yes. They will probably be part of VERO (look along the bottom of your Ebay screen to find out who some of the companies are). They own the rights to that brand so can pretty much do what they like. Some brands police it more than others i.e. some are very proactive & seem to get listings pulled within hours, some seem less bothered but have a clean up every few months.

As a test, just try listing a Shakin' Stevens album......

Some of the companies will stop you selling on there because it affects their reseller network, some because they assume you're selling counterfeit goods, some because they feel Ebay weakens the brand and some because they are plain daft.

droopsnoot

14,795 posts

273 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
It's not just eBay though. I used to develop software for PDAs on Palm and Pocket PC platforms, and we once had a Google advert removed because we'd said it worked on both Palm and Pocket PC devices. As soon as we removed the Palm name from the advert, no trouble.

98elise

32,891 posts

192 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
e-bay can be very odd.

We listed a childs bike, which looked like a mini BMX bike. We listed it as "BMX style" because it was for a small child, not what most people would think of as a proper BMX bike.

e-bay took the advert down as they said we were passing it off. I explained to them that BMX is a type, like racing bike, mountain bike etc, not a brand.

They just kept pointng me back to their policy.


Simpo Two

93,100 posts

296 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
98elise said:
They just kept pointng me back to their policy.
'Policy' means not having to think.

Whenever anyone refers you to their 'Policy' what they really mean is 'I know you're right but I can't think/am too stupid/have no authority'.

droopsnoot

14,795 posts

273 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
'Policy' means not having to think.

Whenever anyone refers you to their 'Policy' what they really mean is 'I know you're right but I can't think/am too stupid/have no authority'.
True, but I wonder how much of that comes from our litigation-happy society now. Imagine the case - you list your item, eBay (or whoever) removes it because it violates their policy, you appeal the removal and they capitulate, you* then claim for "compensayshun" as it's against your human rights to have been offended in such a way, etc etc. So the policy is "never admit we were wrong, in case it costs us money".

Sorry, that's a rant for elsewhere.

* - obviously not you specifically.

CoolHands

23,717 posts

226 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
they kept removing my mouse traps adverts too, bds. I couldn't be arsed to work out why after a couple of nonsensical policy referalls. I think it was because they kill mice. Which are vermin. Go figure...