Watkins & Friends
Author
Discussion

Exige77

Original Poster:

6,523 posts

222 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/Resources/JCO/Document...

You have probably read snippets from the case and the verdict but here is the Judges view.

Warning: it makes grim reading.

So I am sure we all know the law, the verdict has been given, but what do we think "Should" happen to these people ?

agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
After doing general criminal work in the early part of my career, i'm pretty hard to shock, but the details of this case are horrific. Would caution against reading the judgment.

There's no doubt about their guilt. Death sentence.

Edited by agtlaw on Thursday 19th December 16:06

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
It's a very difficult question to answer.

Ever since I became a father I have found stories like this a lot more upsetting.

My heart would say that these people should be shot.

My head says that it's not right for the state to take a life in this way.


ShawCrossShark

4,300 posts

265 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Sick, sick people

Make them suffer for the duration of their sentence. A cold, dark, damp cell with nothing to live on but gruel and social calls from other prisoners

Make them miserable rather than putting them out of their misery!

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
It's a very difficult question to answer.

Ever since I became a father I have found stories like this a lot more upsetting.

My heart would say that these people should be shot.

My head says that it's not right for the state to take a life in this way.
I too am a father, however much the details of this sickening case revolt me - there is no way any civilised society can condone further acts of horror, such as execution. Life imprisonment (without any possibility of parole) should be the only sentence handed down, due to the danger posed to young children by these depraved (insert favoured expletives)!!!!

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I am broadly in favour of the death penalty.

No fanfare, no public display.
Just taken away and put down. Just as one would do with a dangerous animal.

But - that relies on 100% sure of guilt.
Which might be more than reasonable doubt.
And then we get into the question of reasonable doubt and different levels of found guilty or innocent.
And it all gets unravelled.




Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
That's sickening, I agree with the poster up there who said they should suffer for the rest of their lives.

storminnorman

2,357 posts

183 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
I am broadly in favour of the death penalty.

No fanfare, no public display.
Just taken away and put down. Just as one would do with a dangerous animal.

But - that relies on 100% sure of guilt.
Which might be more than reasonable doubt.
And then we get into the question of reasonable doubt and different levels of found guilty or innocent.
And it all gets unravelled.
putting aside the capacity for the death penalty to cause huge miscarriages of justice, I don't think in the case of Watkins he should be allowed the release of death (unless you are of the belief that after death he will receive his punishment).
I agree that the death penalty is still viable in some cases (perhaps fitting for the case that has reached a verdict today).

However, I can't think of anything worse than being left alone with yourself for tens of years, the rest of your life even, to consider your own evil.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
storminnorman said:
However, I can't think of anything worse than being left alone with yourself for tens of years, the rest of your life even, to consider your own evil.
Perhaps not being left alone by other prisoners?

My only knowledge on this comes from reading accounts from people who have been in prison as to how child sex offenders are treated. One can only hope that these accounts have some truth to them.

podwin

652 posts

233 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I have stopped reading that, up to page 4 was too much for me.

Christ, I cannot believe it, I feel sick, and I feel like I could cry.

I have 2 kids, and how on earth could a mother do this!

How can anyone do this, he really does deserve the death penalty, but then again, I'd like to see him suffer!

Those poor children.

God I'm depressed at how low people can be.

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
storminnorman said:
However, I can't think of anything worse than being left alone with yourself for tens of years, the rest of your life even, to consider your own evil.
Perhaps not being left alone by other prisoners?

My only knowledge on this comes from reading accounts from people who have been in prison as to how child sex offenders are treated. One can only hope that these accounts have some truth to them.
Might be interesting to see how long they last at other prisoners' mercy, although they'll most probably be whisked straight to segregation..... not that segregation will be a total safety net for them - shall we start seeing which bookies will take odds, as to how long they'll last inside?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
It begs the question though;
Should justice be about punishment, prevention, or what?

If we think locking him up in a solitory box is the worst thing we can do then why not tear out his fingernails and his teeth on the way there?
Maybe hack his cock off too?
They are just different types of torture and punishment.


At what point is a lifetime of mental torture the humane thing to do compared to a swift death?


I find there are no good answers about what to do with criminals like this.

Muzzer79

13,264 posts

218 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I don't advocate the death sentence for anything

1. Issues with where to apply it. A lot of people cite cases like this as "100% guilt" but, in terms of law, that has to be defined and calculated as to when to be applied, etc.

2. We don't know what happens on the other side of death. An atheist would have you believe that nothing happens, you just cease to be. Religious folk obviously claim otherwise. If it's the former, where's the punishment in that? Apart from removing a risk to society, what would killing the person achieve?

I am in favour of life, without parole, but proper time. 6 x 4 cell, 23 hours per day, no TV/playstation/etc, simple food and so on.

I firmly believe that a partial element of these crimes is caused by the knowledge that the consequences are simply not that bad.

selym

9,581 posts

202 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
That was shocking, but I made myself read it in total. Hopefully he sees 9/10 of his sentence out before he is finished off by the local head-job.

Same goes for the two utter scumbags who gave up their children to him. They should be on the jagged end of a shanking as well.

mrtwisty

3,057 posts

196 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Holy st, that was very hard to read. You cant really imagine it happening, but evidently it did.

What to do swith these people? I would go with what SCS said:


ShawCrossShark said:
Sick, sick people

Make them suffer for the duration of their sentence. A cold, dark, damp cell with nothing to live on but gruel and social calls from other prisoners

Make them miserable rather than putting them out of their misery!

egor110

17,693 posts

234 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Muzzer79 said:
I don't advocate the death sentence for anything

1. Issues with where to apply it. A lot of people cite cases like this as "100% guilt" but, in terms of law, that has to be defined and calculated as to when to be applied, etc.

2. We don't know what happens on the other side of death. An atheist would have you believe that nothing happens, you just cease to be. Religious folk obviously claim otherwise. If it's the former, where's the punishment in that? Apart from removing a risk to society, what would killing the person achieve?

I am in favour of life, without parole, but proper time. 6 x 4 cell, 23 hours per day, no TV/playstation/etc, simple food and so on.

I firmly believe that a partial element of these crimes is caused by the knowledge that the consequences are simply not that bad.
If nothing else it would save this country money.

We moan like fk on here about spongers not working yet we seem quite happy to pay for prisoners to be locked up for long periods of time.

Usget

5,426 posts

242 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I wish I hadn't read that. 35 years should be the absolute bare minimum with no parole eligibility until the last day.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
On the other hand.
The man is clearly mentally sick.
Perhaps he should just be put in an asylum and treated kindly by nurses and doctors until he dies.

As long as he's never released then society is safe.

(That's just a different perspective for balance)

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
Usget said:
I wish I hadn't read that. 35 years should be the absolute bare minimum with no parole eligibility until the last day.
I had to stop reading the report. Even if it was a script for a horror movie - I'd be sickened!!! Some of the youngest of the victims may be young enough not to remember the depraved attacks, but the older ones may have a hell of a time adjusting.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 19th December 2013
quotequote all
I suppose at least when he's released about aged 50-60 he won't be interested in repeating the offence, oh hang on a minute rolleyes

Maybe whoever gets the final say and signs off the parole form or whatever should have it as a condition of release that they have to let the expeado/rapist or whatever come and live in their family home as they are obviously not going to reroffend. rolleyes