DVLA Tax Refund
Author
Discussion

uuf361

Original Poster:

3,185 posts

253 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Just got home to a nasty letter form the DVLA informing me one of my cars was untaxed......

So, I bought a car at the end of October form a dealer who did not have the tax disc.

I got the car registered in my name then applied for a duplicate tax disc (this can't be done until the V5 is in your name.

Today the DVLA have told me they issued that disc in error and that after I had got the duplicate tax disc they refunded the previous owner the tax.

I had previously been under the impression that the DVLA could not refund tax to anyone other than the RK (in this case on the date they have admitted refunding it that was me).

Their letter was rather threatening even though it's their error and they won't even refund me the cost of the duplicate tax disc, which is of no use to me whatsoever.

Anyone else experienced something similar or advice on what to do?

I've re-taxed the car so I can use it but apparently also have to phone them to pay the arrears but that can't be done now until Monday as their opening hours are rubbish.

Seems massively incompetent to me.......

Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Refund can be given to current or previous registered keeper.

Sounds like whoever traded the car in cashed in the tax as the dealer can't do it anymore.

uuf361

Original Poster:

3,185 posts

253 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
Didn't realise it could be former keeper also....

Thought I was quite fortunate to be able to get the duplicate as their were 10 months left...................

solo2

1,027 posts

178 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
I was under the impression once a duplicate had been issued, only that one could be refunded and not the original.

I'd query that when you call although I could be mistaken.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Friday 20th December 2013
quotequote all
OP, welcome to the surreal world of the DVLA.

uuf361 said:
Today the DVLA have told me they issued that disc in error and that after I had got the duplicate tax disc they refunded the previous owner the tax.[/b]

I had previously been under the impression that the DVLA could not refund tax to anyone other than the RK (in this case on the date they have admitted refunding it that was me).
Are the bits in bold verbal or in writing? If it's the latter, it may well prove to be to your advantage (see below).

uuf361 said:
Their letter was rather threatening even though it's their error and they won't even refund me the cost of the duplicate tax disc, which is of no use to me whatsoever.
Threats are normal currency for the DVLA and what they use to intimidate people into complying with their demands no matter what. This holds even if their case is without merit. In some cases (not this one) they even attempt to invent non-existent regulations/legislation in their rabid desire to extract money from motorists.

The letter stating the vehicle is untaxed and demanding payment of arrears is triggered by the computer record and takes no account of how that situation came about. The refusal to refund when it was their error in issuing adds insult to injury and is typical of the DVLA.

uuf361 said:
Anyone else experienced something similar or advice on what to do?

I've re-taxed the car so I can use it but apparently also have to phone them to pay the arrears but that can't be done now until Monday as their opening hours are rubbish.

Seems massively incompetent to me.......
Par for the course with the DVLA.

It depends how big your cojones are but I would tell them that as they refuse to refund, demanding that you pay for the arrears as well is an unacceptable desire to have their cake and eat it. Tell them (politely) to poke it.

If they won't play ball get your MP onside. That's what he's there for: to represent your interests. He/she has to do so for all constituents not just those who voted for him/her. If that doesn't work and all other avenues have proved fruitless take your complaint here. If the DVLA have admitted that they censored up (as above) it will be a useful weapon to turn against them. If it is only verbal so far, box clever, and try to get them to confirm it in writing (preferably on parchment rather than by e-mail).

uuf361

Original Poster:

3,185 posts

253 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Sadly it's over the phone they admitted their error. Their letter states the day the car was untaxed from (this date is after I was the RK and after the duplicate had been issued though......)

As you can imagine they were massively unsympathetic when I spoke to them......

I'll see where I get filling in their complaints form (for nuisance value) in the first instance......

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
Did the dealer claim the car was taxed then? If so you may have a complaint against them. If not then did it not occur to you that the previous owner may have kept the disc to cash it in?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 21st December 2013
quotequote all
uuf361 said:
Sadly it's over the phone they admitted their error. Their letter states the day the car was untaxed from (this date is after I was the RK and after the duplicate had been issued though......)

As you can imagine they were massively unsympathetic when I spoke to them......

I'll see where I get filling in their complaints form (for nuisance value) in the first instance......
I wouldn't worry too much about the letter. It's almost certainly the standard template spiel. If the date is after the issue date of the V5C (this will be on its face) and the duplicate tax disc that can only help your case.

Do you have the name of the person you spoke to and the date of the conversation? If so, try writing back confirming (to the best of your recollection if you did not make a contemporaneous note) what was said (by both parties). That way if they insist on continuing to pursue you they will have to refute it in order to bolster their case. Something which might cause them a few problems further down the line.

The DVLA are judge, jury, and executioner with the ultimate arbiter being their Chief Executive (see page 4), the recently appointed Oliver Morley. Hopefully he will be more approachable than the smug Simon Tse (of Watchdog fame) who departed for the DWP in February this year.

There is nothing in INS101 that says the Chief Executive must refer a dissatisfied complainant to the ICA or that they will take it if he does. The MP and Parliamentary Ombudsman is a useful avenue and more people need to be aware that it's open to them.