RE: PH 2013: Our favourite cars
RE: PH 2013: Our favourite cars
Thursday 26th December 2013

PH 2013: Our favourite cars

The personal favourites of the PH team, as driven in the last 12 months



Even by the standards of the job we're especially privileged here on PH. No need to earn our spurs driving Priuses or dull MPVs here - we get to pick the fun stuff. It's always an honour too, especially when you get to drive something a little out of the ordinary or unusual and have the pleasure of sharing it with likeminded folk here on the PistonHeads homepage.

Here then are our personal picks from the cars we've driven in the last year. All choices are the writer's own, etc...

Enjoy!



Mercedes McLaren SLR MSO Edition (Dan T)
It's always nice to return to a car and find it better than you remembered. Better still if that gives you a chance to bust some well-established myths. And even better still if it's got a 600hp-plus V8 and announces that fact through side exhausts at 115db.

Yes, the favourite car I drove this year was a blast from the past, re-imagined by McLaren's Special Operations division and fitted with its wonderfully sinister all-carbon rebody. Beneath it the modifications to the SLR's notoriously twitchy steering and unforgiving chassis turned a flawed hero into an absolute hoot, less muscle car than monster car that made good on its jaw dropping looks with a driving experience that was more fun than frightening.

If the SLR's mechanical underpinnings have dated a little the raw performance and the looks haven't. I loved every minute in this car and, seemingly, so did everyone who saw it. Magnificent!



VW XL1 (Matt)
Favourite car driven in 2013: It's a tough decision! With Mr Trent having already nabbed the PH Mercedes vote (that's C63 507 out then, and the SLS GT3 for that matter), I need to look elsewhere. As a first 911 driving experience, the 997 GT3 was outrageous, although it can't be my favourite as I never drove it in the dry. It was undeniably exhilarating, absorbing and challenging, but the underlying fear means it can't quite be the best. Call me a wuss, but I want to drive something like that in the dry.

But my favourite car of 2013 is rear-engined. It's the VW XL1, easily the slowest car I've driven since starting in July. But it's just so innovative, original, cool and desirable. The engineering work is just phenomenal and yet it just works like any other VW, albeit from much lower down and with great steering. There's a place in the 10-car garage reserved for it, easily.



Porsche 911 Carrera 2.7 1974 (Dan P)
As if in preparation for his Caterham Academy adventures in 2014, Matt lunged through on the inside and had a 911 in the running for this section before I could get my vote in. The editor may have therefore preferred me to choose the Porsche Cayman or Jaguar F-Type that had so impressed me in 2013, but the 1974 Carrera 2.7 was so wonderful that I stood firm.

As part of the 911's extensive 50th anniversary celebrations a few colleagues and I had travelled to Stuttgart to revisit some of the earlier models. Over the course of a full day in early spring I drove each of the first five generations, from 1965 original to first-of-the-water-cooled 996. The orange Carrera 2.7, not far off a 2.7 RS in drag, stood head and shoulders above everything else; the unassisted steering, the superb engine, the sound, the compactness. I adored it. The 991? For me, it just doesn't compare as a sports car or as a 911.



'The Lister' (Chris)
I begin every year with the slightly weird hope that the Ferrari F40 won't be the best car I will drive, because for me it remains the driving experience. We need progress after all.

The best, in the conventional sense, was a new BMW 318d hire car which cruised at 120mph and didn't appear to use fuel.

The first time a 991 GT3's rev-counter moved beyond 8,000rpm I laughed loudly, and the RS6 was truly excellent. As you all know the F12 comprehensively blew my mind to the extent that I spent a while investigating finance options. Silly boy.

All the while my daily wheels, a new CLS 63 AMG Shooting Brake and the NFG Audi S4 were always great company and, because of the sheer volume of time spent in them, they provided some of the most memorable drives.

I love the fact that the Alfa 4C exists, I will always love the Lister I drove at Goodwood this year, and I'm eternally grateful for the opportunities this job brings. I will miss my motorsport pals Graham Gleeson and Sean Edwards something rotten in 2014.

And the F40 was, again, the road car experience I will remember most. But that Lister Jaguar, screaming at 6500rpm as it slid past Jean Alesi - yep, safe to say it doesn't come much better than that.

Merry Christmas, and thank you for your support in 2013.

 

Author
Discussion

leedsutd1

Original Poster:

770 posts

216 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
fiesta st or focus st estate ?

0a

24,139 posts

224 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
3 old cars and one non production car - is this PH journalists saying modern cars are dull to drive smile

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

200 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
0a said:
3 old cars and one non production car - is this PH journalists saying modern cars are dull to drive smile
I think it is and I have come to the same conclusion. As good and fast as they are the FUN has gone

LP570-4 Performante - the last of the FUN SUPERcars

dinkel

27,804 posts

288 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Ouh, that Lister . . .

soad

34,673 posts

206 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all

Robert Elise

958 posts

175 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
I'm sure this will open up the debate:
"The orange Carrera 2.7, not far off a 2.7 RS in drag, stood head and shoulders above everything else; the unassisted steering, the superb engine, the sound, the compactness. I adored it. The 991? For me, it just doesn't compare as a sports car or as a 911."
Just add lightness...

Vetteran

238 posts

207 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Sports cars have to be a bit scary older cars get scary at lower speeds. I remember the 2.7 RS I owned jumping a little in cross winds at about 120mph on a motorway because it was so light. My current car probably needs to be travelling at 180mph before it starts to scare. Needless to say I have never had the opportunity to find out.

scubadude

2,619 posts

227 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Much better list than the Road Test of the Year debacle...

Dan Trent

1,866 posts

198 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
scubadude said:
Much better list than the Road Test of the Year debacle...
Debacle? Was based on the clicks each story had attracted from PHers so hopefully indicative of the interest in each of the featured cars among the readership! So not a ranking of the 'best' cars of the year, just those that had attracted the most attention on the site. Hope that clarifies.

Cheers,

Dan

Foggy748

323 posts

190 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Merry Christmas to all the PH team. It's been a cracking motoring year, a lot of which is down to you guys, so thanks very much indeed. Looking forward to 2014!

scubadude

2,619 posts

227 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Dan Trent said:
...just those that had attracted the most attention on the site. Hope that clarifies.
No need to clarify it, still a poor list... not sure how the site data is mined but "clicks" isn't very scientific with all the bots, affiliate systems and crap sloshing around online, also hardly fair when some reviews are a week old and others 11months old! :-)

The video of Harris sliding the Lister around alone is more interesting. (IMVHO)

dangerousB

1,701 posts

220 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Chris said:
I will miss my motorsport pal Graham Gleeson
+1

Great bloke. Taught me heaps. He left us far, far too early.

CooperS

4,580 posts

249 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
scubadude said:
Dan Trent said:
...just those that had attracted the most attention on the site. Hope that clarifies.
No need to clarify it, still a poor list... not sure how the site data is mined but "clicks" isn't very scientific with all the bots, affiliate systems and crap sloshing around online, also hardly fair when some reviews are a week old and others 11months old :-)

The video of Harris sliding the Lister around alone is more interesting. (IMVHO)
Scuba has a point

marka1781

44 posts

195 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
F40 is just a drivers car no posuers, exactly wot driving is all about! Old is often more fun u r some in touch with the whole experience which new cars just don't have. Harris this year has delivered on so many platform's with his videos the deserves a medal! Each week is a highlight & he is enthusiasm is great 2 see roll on 2014! Ph makes cars fun & celebrates what most don't really get

skyrover

12,700 posts

234 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
No corvette C7?

hog 1

400 posts

253 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
scubadude said:
No need to clarify it, still a poor list... not sure how the site data is mined but "clicks" isn't very scientific with all the bots, affiliate systems and crap sloshing around online, also hardly fair when some reviews are a week old and others 11months old! :-)

The video of Harris sliding the Lister around alone is more interesting. (IMVHO)
Not much excitement here

Matt Bird

1,554 posts

235 months

PH Reportery Lad

Thursday 26th December 2013
quotequote all
0a said:
3 old cars and one non production car - is this PH journalists saying modern cars are dull to drive smile
Hmm, does look that way doesn't it? XL1 is being made though so that does qualify as production car, albeit one made in very small numbers. As the first comment mentioned though, the Fiesta ST is an absolute riot and would have made a longer shortlist. As would the Cayman. And the F-Type. Not all modern cars are dull to drive!


Matt

powertrainjock

6 posts

163 months

Thursday 26th December 2013
quotequote all
leedsutd1 said:
fiesta st or focus st estate ?
Fiesta ST. Not an easy one as I have kids and the focus estate is handy-but have now owned a fiesta ST(combined with a family bus) I think it trumps the focus at putting a smile on my face.

Bezza1969

777 posts

178 months

Thursday 26th December 2013
quotequote all
Actually I think there has been too much hype this year. Wasn't that much around that impressed me...its all getting very silly with overweight, overcomplicated cars that are too fast for the road...

so my top cars are:

Fiesta ST - old school Ford, loads of fun, relatively light, not too fast, not too complicated...its tops for me!

Then honourable mentions to the Ferrari F12 (for that engine), 991 GT3 (ditto) (but not the turbo) and Audi RS6 (best all round day to day performance car in the world?) -but again too fast for the road really..

Leftfield award = Alpina D3 bi turbo diesel....(petrol is rather nice too!)


DJRC

23,563 posts

266 months

Friday 27th December 2013
quotequote all
Wtf would anybody ever get excited about a Fiesta when you are comparing it against things like Gt3, F-type, '74 2.7 911, an F12, SLS Black, SLR MSO and the Lister lowdrag????
Or even the tech astoundment of the xl1?