Legal question
Author
Discussion

Bigbox

Original Poster:

666 posts

242 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Someone carrying out some work at my home has invoiced me 50%more than I think is fair for the work that has been done so I am unwilling to pay his invoice. I have heard through a third party that this person has said that if I don't pay it he'll just send the invoice on to a debt collector.

Can anyone clarify what are the legalities of this sort of pursuit - I will be speaking to this person to negotiate a little; I am happy to pay a fair price however I would just like to know how this stands in the eye if the law. Incidentally whilst he was doing the work I had asked for a price but he just told me not to worry about it which I didn't as this person has done work for me previously

Thanks

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
What's been the basis of your agreement to pay him for previous work? £x per hour/day/week? Materials extra? Or a figure given and agreed in advance? Or something else?

Bigbox

Original Poster:

666 posts

242 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Greg66 said:
What's been the basis of your agreement to pay him for previous work? £x per hour/day/week? Materials extra? Or a figure given and agreed in advance? Or something else?
To answer your question for previous work he quoted in full up front (materials plus labour) albeit the job was much much larger

The fee was agreed up front although there were extras which he mumbled to me after they'd been incurred - I paid him in full

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
It is 50% more than you think is fair, but how much more than you had agreed?


Bigbox

Original Poster:

666 posts

242 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Actually his day rate is 50% more than I would have expected and more than his competitors charge and he spent three days doing a two day job

Anyway - does anyone know the answer to my question???!

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
I am attempting ascertain the answer to your questions but further information is needed to do so, hence the basis of my question.

How much did you agree to pay? How much is the bill now? What was the basis agreed for the additional work?
The questions relate to the contract between you.

Bigbox

Original Poster:

666 posts

242 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
I'm not willing to say on a public forum at this moment in time

Question put another way - if I'm trying it on with an invoice and try charging more than is fair and if the customer is then only willing to pay 70% of an invoice can I simply send the invoice to any old debt collector to recover the full amount?

Neither party has anything in writing

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Yes if you have issued invoice which is unpaid then you can refer the matter to debt collectors or issue a claim in the courts for recovery of what is an alleged debt.

Might I suggest you write to him and advise that you will pay X amount and why.



Lawbags

1,074 posts

159 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
But surely that can't be enforced? If I had an extension built for an agreed 20k, a bit extra was needed, say 5 grand, yet I was invoiced 50 grand, how could they make me pay?

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Anyone who believes they are owed money can retain the services of a third party debt collector to act on their behalf to collect the claimed debt.

The debt collector has no greater powers than the creditor though.

Bigbox

Original Poster:

666 posts

242 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks (sincerely)

So, hypothetically speaking, if a tradesman doesn't agree a price up front, is it the case that he then has carte blanche to invoice whatever he wants and then sell the debt on when it is unpaid?

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Lawbags said:
But surely that can't be enforced? If I had an extension built for an agreed 20k, a bit extra was needed, say 5 grand, yet I was invoiced 50 grand, how could they make me pay?
No-one said it could be enforced. However the remit of your question was as it was and I addressed it.

It would take a court judgment for enforcement however.

It is also a disputed debt - hence my suggestion to write to him and set out that you believe the job was worth X and why. You could if you wished enclose a cheque to the sum of the value you are willing to pay and state that it is in full and final settlement any claim he may have against you.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Bigbox said:
Thanks (sincerely)

So, hypothetically speaking, if a tradesman doesn't agree a price up front, is it the case that he then has carte blanche to invoice whatever he wants and then sell the debt on when it is unpaid?
That was not your original post.

Selling a debt to a third party is different to utilising the services of a debt collector.

Businesses that buy debts won't be interested in this one.

Osito

56 posts

175 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Bigbox said:
Thanks (sincerely)

So, hypothetically speaking, if a tradesman doesn't agree a price up front, is it the case that he then has carte blanche to invoice whatever he wants and then sell the debt on when it is unpaid?
I don't think it's quite like that, but the problem is that you didn't agree a price in advance. If you can't agree one now, then assuming the tradesman pursues it, a court or arbitrator will decide for you what a fair price is. In that case you're likely to be in for some legal costs, too.


singlecoil

35,894 posts

277 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Bigbox said:
Thanks (sincerely)

So, hypothetically speaking, if a tradesman doesn't agree a price up front, is it the case that he then has carte blanche to invoice whatever he wants and then sell the debt on when it is unpaid?
He can sell the 'debt' to whoever wants to buy it from him. But if either of them wants to enforce it, that's an entirely different matter.

I suggest you pay him what you think is fair, and he doesn't think that's enough, he can take you to court for the rest. Whether he will win or not remains to be seen, and will depend on what evidence you can both put in front of the court (small claims, I expect).

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Bigbox said:
Actually his day rate is 50% more than I would have expected and more than his competitors charge and he spent three days doing a two day job

Anyway - does anyone know the answer to my question???!
There's a reason lawyers say "it depends". Because it usually does depend on what they are told.

You say that for this job you didn't agree a price up front. For previous jobs you have. You say that his day rate of 50% more than you expected it to be, and that he took 50% longer than you expected him to.

Now he's threatening to use a debt collector.

A debt collector does what it says on the tin: collects debts, with the same rights and limitations that the creditor has. So the debt collector will write you a threatening letter, you'll respond disputing the full extent of the debt, and the debt collector will likely realise that the matter has to go to court.

The real question is what will happen there. The answer is that the court will have to work out what you two agreed, or should be taken to have agreed. Where there's no express agreement but a prior course of dealing, the court will look at that prior course of dealing for clues, or assumptions, as to what you two should be taken to have agreed here.

So if your contractor didn't warn you that he's suddenly put his rates up by 50%, he may be stuck with charging you the historic day rate he's previously charged you. OTOH, whether the three day job could really have been shoehorned into two days is a rather different enquiry, which requires looking at what he did. Previous jobs might help establish his general work rate, but they won't necessarily be conclusive. It's all about reasonableness here.

Whichever way you cut it, you certainly owe him something, so the best bet is to offer his what you genuinely think he is entitled to, and let him come after you for the balance.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
I had a very similar situation a few years back where a builder who had built me an extension came back to fit a rooflight. His blokes were here for less than 3 hours, the rooflight cost about £200 and he tried to charge me in excess of £750 - way more than a whole day rate for the 2 labourers.

I rang and left him a message which he failed to respond to and finally after a month he rang and asked me what was my problem. Told him he was having a laugh (literally) which he didn't like. Told him I'd pay for materials plus his day rate pro rata'd plus a little more - he wasn't happy and said he'd never do work for me again etc.

Wrote to him setting out my reasons for the amount I thought fair and sent him a cheque - never heard from him again. I did hear since that he had gone bankrupt and that he'd lost 2 of his best workers before he set up again - was obviously trying to profiteer out of me to save his business.

Do this