Trees fallen onto my land - who is responsible for clearing
Discussion
This came up a few months ago during the earlier storms and was covered in this thread.
Another poster said of their experience:
Another poster said of their experience:
Prof Beard said:
I have personal experience of this. Some years ago, a large fir tree on my property fell in high winds. It lifted a large chunk of my driveway and fell into my neighbour's front garden - largely filling it (missed his house though). The tree surgeon who came stated the tress was in healthy condition and there was no negligence. Result? my insurers covered damage to my property and sawed the fallen tree off at the boundary line, it was my neighbour's responsibility to remove the tree from his property. I paid out of my own pocket for removal of the tree in the interests of good relations with the neighbour.
Thanks guys but already we are into a difficult arena.
The direct link above doesn't actually state the legal requirements of clear up of the tree itself.
No fences have been damaged, all I am worried about is clearing the trees.
As can be seen from previous posts there may be a grey area if it can be proved that the trees were in good condition.
We are talking about two 45 to 50 foot very mature ash trees, it would take alot of time and or money to clear them, natural justice would say the owner has to clear them but natural justice and the law very rarely meet.
Can anyone give me a difinitive answer or do I have to spend time or money to cut them up?
Many thanks
The direct link above doesn't actually state the legal requirements of clear up of the tree itself.
No fences have been damaged, all I am worried about is clearing the trees.
As can be seen from previous posts there may be a grey area if it can be proved that the trees were in good condition.
We are talking about two 45 to 50 foot very mature ash trees, it would take alot of time and or money to clear them, natural justice would say the owner has to clear them but natural justice and the law very rarely meet.
Can anyone give me a difinitive answer or do I have to spend time or money to cut them up?
Many thanks
This is were it gets onto a sticky wicket.
The trees are part of a shooting wood. They were sold about six weeks ago and I do not know the new owners. Before contacting the new owners I would like to know with certainty where I stand legally, to be sure that we both understand each other and then can build a long term professional relationship whether we like each other or not.
The trees are part of a shooting wood. They were sold about six weeks ago and I do not know the new owners. Before contacting the new owners I would like to know with certainty where I stand legally, to be sure that we both understand each other and then can build a long term professional relationship whether we like each other or not.
Grandad Gaz - that actually is my preferred option.
Someone I trust can come in when the ground is dry in spring/summer and clear them.
They will get tons and tons of great burning wood, I get a problem solved and my neighbour thinks I'm great, result for everyone.
I am in Hertfordshire, they are two big big trees
Someone I trust can come in when the ground is dry in spring/summer and clear them.
They will get tons and tons of great burning wood, I get a problem solved and my neighbour thinks I'm great, result for everyone.
I am in Hertfordshire, they are two big big trees
Just because an insurance policy does not cover something, does not necessarily not make the owner liable for the removal costs.
Looking at this logically, the tree belongs to the neighbour and they retain ownership even though part is now on the OP's property. The OP has no rights to the part of the tree now on his property. The OP should request that the neighbour removes his tree from the OP's property, and should they fail he will arrange for it to be removed and seek reimbursement of the costs from the owner.
Negligence does not matter here in my opinion, the ownership of the tree does.
Looking at this logically, the tree belongs to the neighbour and they retain ownership even though part is now on the OP's property. The OP has no rights to the part of the tree now on his property. The OP should request that the neighbour removes his tree from the OP's property, and should they fail he will arrange for it to be removed and seek reimbursement of the costs from the owner.
Negligence does not matter here in my opinion, the ownership of the tree does.
Edited by PurpleMoonlight on Tuesday 24th December 18:14
OpulentBob said:
Stick an advert on Gumtree, "Free logs from felled tree, cut your own/bring your own saw". I reckon it'll be gone in no time - people with log burners are always out in the hedgerows with their chainsaws around here (N Essex) after a big storm. 
from experience of gumtree and free cycle he will get a load of emails asking if he can cut it up and bag it and possibly even deliver it,all for free, then will finally get one sensible person who will come and tkae it all away.
Do you have a log burner or open fire? Free wood if you do...
However provided no damage done to your fence or shed/property then let Xmas pass and pick it up with them after no doubt they will sort it out. If they are as big as you say the wood is worth £ to some and of course to cut it up isn't cheap either
However provided no damage done to your fence or shed/property then let Xmas pass and pick it up with them after no doubt they will sort it out. If they are as big as you say the wood is worth £ to some and of course to cut it up isn't cheap either
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


