Discussion
Merry Christmas all :-)
I've been wide awake since 2am due to chronic bank pain... So I've been stuck watching random TV programs that included some traffic cop type programs. One clip filmed a chap being pulled over for suspected Drink Driving. He was asked if he has had a drink in the last 20 minutes, to which he responded 'no' and they carried on with the usual procedure.
My question.., and I apologise for the utter stupidity of it but in my delirious, painful, sleep deprived state my thought process is stuck in a loop... As the chap was walking towards the police car for questioning, what would happen if he pulled out a small bottle of vodka and downed a sizeable amount there and then? Let's assume he's had a couple of pints and will likely blow over, but only just.
So, as he walked away, he locked his car, and as he sat in the back of the police car just knocked the vodka down... Presumably they'd have to wait the 20 minutes and presumably the breathalyser would turn red? Is there anyway to separate the vodka drunk infront of the Officer from the two pints drunk earlier?
(All typed out on my iPhone so I beg for leniency from the SPAG police).
I've been wide awake since 2am due to chronic bank pain... So I've been stuck watching random TV programs that included some traffic cop type programs. One clip filmed a chap being pulled over for suspected Drink Driving. He was asked if he has had a drink in the last 20 minutes, to which he responded 'no' and they carried on with the usual procedure.
My question.., and I apologise for the utter stupidity of it but in my delirious, painful, sleep deprived state my thought process is stuck in a loop... As the chap was walking towards the police car for questioning, what would happen if he pulled out a small bottle of vodka and downed a sizeable amount there and then? Let's assume he's had a couple of pints and will likely blow over, but only just.
So, as he walked away, he locked his car, and as he sat in the back of the police car just knocked the vodka down... Presumably they'd have to wait the 20 minutes and presumably the breathalyser would turn red? Is there anyway to separate the vodka drunk infront of the Officer from the two pints drunk earlier?
(All typed out on my iPhone so I beg for leniency from the SPAG police).
There's a section to the drink drive paperwork booklets to go through during a tape recorded interview once sober that all alcohol consumption is recorded and then a blood sample taken at the time of arrest goes off to the clever man or woman at the Home Office lab who works out what the level of blood alcohol would have been at the time of driving.
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/53/sectio...
It's a variation on the hip flask defence ("I had a wee nip after the acshident offisher, just to calm my nerves") which is covered in RTOA 15(2) and 15(3). Basically the prosecution don't have to separate anything - the onus is on him to prove that he would not have been over the limit but for the swig of vodka. As the only reason anyone would swig vodka in that situation would be to subvert the breath test, he would probably find that nobody believed him if he claimed that he was stone cold sober when he was actually driving.
It's a variation on the hip flask defence ("I had a wee nip after the acshident offisher, just to calm my nerves") which is covered in RTOA 15(2) and 15(3). Basically the prosecution don't have to separate anything - the onus is on him to prove that he would not have been over the limit but for the swig of vodka. As the only reason anyone would swig vodka in that situation would be to subvert the breath test, he would probably find that nobody believed him if he claimed that he was stone cold sober when he was actually driving.
Aretnap said:
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/53/sectio...
It's a variation on the hip flask defence ("I had a wee nip after the acshident offisher, just to calm my nerves") which is covered in RTOA 15(2) and 15(3). Basically the prosecution don't have to separate anything - the onus is on him to prove that he would not have been over the limit but for the swig of vodka. As the only reason anyone would swig vodka in that situation would be to subvert the breath test, he would probably find that nobody believed him if he claimed that he was stone cold sober when he was actually driving.
So, guilty until proven innocent? I can believe that.It's a variation on the hip flask defence ("I had a wee nip after the acshident offisher, just to calm my nerves") which is covered in RTOA 15(2) and 15(3). Basically the prosecution don't have to separate anything - the onus is on him to prove that he would not have been over the limit but for the swig of vodka. As the only reason anyone would swig vodka in that situation would be to subvert the breath test, he would probably find that nobody believed him if he claimed that he was stone cold sober when he was actually driving.
The Spruce goose said:
could lead to a false reading by the toxicmeter due to alcohol vapour lingering about.
They can back calculate and work out if you were drunk before trying to cheat the breathalyser.All they would do is arrest on the suspicion of drink driving as you have alcohol on your breath, then wait the necessary time and test you later and back calculate it.
I had to use the hip flask defense last year (successfully) when the police came to take a statement following an accident ( I hadn't been drinking prior to it, but had several very large Scotch's when I got home).... I used the same expert witness that produced the guidelines for the home office, and his calculations were within one miligram of the police results....despite this the prosecutor still tried to tear me another a
hole...not for the fainthearted
hole...not for the fainthearted Baryonyx said:
smileymikey said:
the police came to take a statement following an accident ( I hadn't been drinking prior to it, but had several very large Scotch's when I got home)
Yeah right. 10 Pence Short said:
REALIST123 said:
So, guilty until proven innocent? I can believe that.
If you're trying to assert a defence it's up to you to prove it. Surely that's common sense?Some PHers speaking of guilty until proven innocent have had a warm reception
but your post seems to make their case.The principles of natural justice and alleged motoring offences parted company some time ago.
It's down to the defence to prove that the post incident drinking contributed to the excess alcohol by the time the specimen was obtained. The burden is not 'beyond reasonable doubt' but is pretty high.
Edit. I'm agreeing with 10P. It must be the time of the year
Edit. I'm agreeing with 10P. It must be the time of the year

Edited by XCP on Wednesday 25th December 21:42
What would happen if you had say, had a couple earlier in the day (or morning after if you prefer) and thought you might be very close to the limit with a 50/50 shot at blowing under? Would it make sense to say you have had a drink in the last 20 mins to buy yourself a few more minutes?
I don't know why they ask the 20 minute thing but always assumed it was because you'd blow over if you had drunk a beer inside that window? Saying that, presumably they could then back calculate what it would have been at the time of the stop?
Can anyone explain?
I don't know why they ask the 20 minute thing but always assumed it was because you'd blow over if you had drunk a beer inside that window? Saying that, presumably they could then back calculate what it would have been at the time of the stop?
Can anyone explain?
Disastrous said:
What would happen if you had say, had a couple earlier in the day (or morning after if you prefer) and thought you might be very close to the limit with a 50/50 shot at blowing under? Would it make sense to say you have had a drink in the last 20 mins to buy yourself a few more minutes?
I don't know why they ask the 20 minute thing but always assumed it was because you'd blow over if you had drunk a beer inside that window? Saying that, presumably they could then back calculate what it would have been at the time of the stop?
Can anyone explain?
the specimen at the roadside is only screening. It's the one taken at the station that counts. The 20 minute wait is to exclude 'mouth alcohol'. I don't know why they ask the 20 minute thing but always assumed it was because you'd blow over if you had drunk a beer inside that window? Saying that, presumably they could then back calculate what it would have been at the time of the stop?
Can anyone explain?
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


