Accident.. Insurers forcing to use their own repair garage.
Accident.. Insurers forcing to use their own repair garage.
Author
Discussion

fizz47

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Sister had accident yesterday - called up insurer today- they said that car needs to go their approved garage.


Sister enquired if she could take it to a main dealer Volvo body shop (car is XC90).

They said if she does then her excess will increase by a further £200 over her already compulsory excess.


Is this right? I thought an insurer couldn't force you to use their body shop...

hdrflow

854 posts

169 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
True, but they can 'steer' you to wink. http://www.aviva.co.uk/approved-repairer/ so in some cases there's a non-approved repair excess fee.

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Fault or non-fault accident?

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Also they will cap the hourly rate at the rate that they have agreed with the approved repairer. This will generally be much, much less than main dealer rates (c£15/hour as opposed to £100/hour). You'll be responsible for the shortfall which could be eyewatering.

itcaptainslow

4,815 posts

167 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
You're thinking of a body shop rate verses a mechanical workshop rate there. Big difference.

Main dealer body shop rates are more but not as much as that in my experience.

Furberger

719 posts

230 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
deckster said:
You'll be responsible for the shortfall which could be eyewatering.
Bullst

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
deckster said:
Also they will cap the hourly rate at the rate that they have agreed with the approved repairer. This will generally be much, much less than main dealer rates (c£15/hour as opposed to £100/hour). You'll be responsible for the shortfall which could be eyewatering.
Bulllst on the rates

Bullst on the shortfall.

Tango13

10,199 posts

207 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
A few years back I had a reversing cock up that cost me and a neighbour a bumper each, my fault entirely.

My insurance steered me towards their prefered repairer but I wanted BMW to take care of things. No Problem from my insurance company but no courtesy car from us.

No problem at all really, I arranged it all so the bumper was fully painted and ready to fit at 9am when I turned up, 1 1/2hrs or free coffee and doughnuts late I was ready to go.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
fizz47 said:
Is this right? I thought an insurer couldn't force you to use their body shop...
To kill this thread.

Many insurers will offer courtesy cars if you use their approved repairer it not compulsory.

Others make it a clear statement in the T&Cs that you will incur a higher excess if you don't.

OP check the policy docs and it'll be in there. Better still tell us who she's insured with and I'll point it out for you.

eatcustard

1,003 posts

158 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
My insurance T&Cs say an extra £150 if I want to use my own garage.

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Friend has a very good and large bodyshop all the latest equipment , he does a lot of insurance work .

They hade tried to cut his rates from £32 an hour to £28 recently...insurance company rep always in saying won't that repair rather than replace etc (trying to save on parts)

You can use who you want

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
eatcustard said:
My insurance T&Cs say an extra £150 if I want to use my own garage.
Worth every penny if it gives you some say in the repair. Last thing you need is the insurer calling the shots.


Tango13

10,199 posts

207 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
POORCARDEALER said:
Friend has a very good and large bodyshop all the latest equipment , he does a lot of insurance work .

They hade tried to cut his rates from £32 an hour to £28 recently...insurance company rep always in saying won't that repair rather than replace etc (trying to save on parts)

You can use who you want
£28hr?

In the precision engineering industry we work on the rule of 1/3's.

1/3 of the hourly rate is for overheads, heating, rent, office drones, rates etc
1/3 of the hourly rate is for investment, new machinery etc
1/3 of the hourly rate is for wages for the bloke on the shop floor getting his hands dirty

There is just as much skill programming a multi axis machining centre as there is in body work and I don't know a single self respecting engineer who will get out of bed for less than £14hr

How much is the insurance industry wasting on sending clients cars back for re-work due to it being done on the cheap in the first place?

richardgcs

150 posts

173 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
I bumped my wifes Focus a couple of years ago, car was picked up my the approved repairer and was left a courtesy car. Great service, however, when the car went into my friends garage for a service (he's a very good fully qualified master mechanic ) he told me the new front bumper etc is not OEM but pattern parts. Perhaps this is a one off, maybe not. I am still waiting to resolve this.

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
eatcustard said:
My insurance T&Cs say an extra £150 if I want to use my own garage.
Worth every penny if it gives you some say in the repair. Last thing you need is the insurer calling the shots.
100% agree with this, to much rushing and bonus work in insurance approved body shops so I'd much rather use the bodyshop were the management and staff are passionate about cars and doing the job to the best of their ability rather than trying to make £25 an hour pay.

fizz47

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies....smile

It was an own fault accident so will have to pay the excess and yes as some one has pointed out and linked the terms and conditions it is with aviva

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Tango13 said:
POORCARDEALER said:
Friend has a very good and large bodyshop all the latest equipment , he does a lot of insurance work .

They hade tried to cut his rates from £32 an hour to £28 recently...insurance company rep always in saying won't that repair rather than replace etc (trying to save on parts)

You can use who you want
£28hr?

In the precision engineering industry we work on the rule of 1/3's.

1/3 of the hourly rate is for overheads, heating, rent, office drones, rates etc
1/3 of the hourly rate is for investment, new machinery etc
1/3 of the hourly rate is for wages for the bloke on the shop floor getting his hands dirty

There is just as much skill programming a multi axis machining centre as there is in body work and I don't know a single self respecting engineer who will get out of bed for less than £14hr

How much is the insurance industry wasting on sending clients cars back for re-work due to it being done on the cheap in the first place?
And for that they expect a perfect job with a warranty.....it pays, just at £32, but at the lower rate i doubt it

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
POORCARDEALER said:
Friend has a very good and large bodyshop all the latest equipment , he does a lot of insurance work .

They hade tried to cut his rates from £32 an hour to £28 recently...insurance company rep always in saying won't that repair rather than replace etc (trying to save on parts)

You can use who you want
So you expect your insurance to come down in price each year, but at the same time you expect the insurer to maintain or increase their supply costs that drive your premiums.

How does that work?

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
Many years ago ,I had a dunt, and my insurance company sent me to their approved garage. Bloke took a look at it and then searched through parts list for body parts. These were not from the maker ,but a copy company, as they were a LOT cheaper than OEM/recommended parts. They couldn't find any, to my relief ,as I'd have doubts on the quality of these parts. Perhaps this is the reason for "APPROVED" REPAIRERS .

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Wednesday 25th December 2013
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
POORCARDEALER said:
Friend has a very good and large bodyshop all the latest equipment , he does a lot of insurance work .

They hade tried to cut his rates from £32 an hour to £28 recently...insurance company rep always in saying won't that repair rather than replace etc (trying to save on parts)

You can use who you want
So you expect your insurance to come down in price each year, but at the same time you expect the insurer to maintain or increase their supply costs that drive your premiums.

How does that work?
Who mentioned premiums coming down?

I expect mine to go up by at least inflation every year, and I havnt been disappointed.

Quite simple, if a very well run bodyshop cant make it pay at 28 an hour, something has to give....quality of materials used? Cost of labour? Gets to the stage where its time to stop doing insurance work as you cant afford to take it on and all the bull that goes with it