Sub contractor purchases items from supplier on our account
Discussion
Hi Guys,
We have recently completed a project and our subbie has been purchasing materials 'supposedly' for this job without the say so of my company. When I have gone through the invoices there is more goods bought than required for the project. We have a strict policy on ordering in the company and do not accept invoices from our supplies without specific orders from the office. We have had some invoices with corresponding order numbers for this job which we have paid. Our supplier is now pursuing us for outstanding monies and I have said that we are not paying them as there is no specific orders number from the office corresponding with our ordering procedure which was outlined to them when we set the account up.
To conclude, subbie orders materials (some legitimately for the project), supplier invoices us, we say that we are not paying as we haven't ordered the goods or signed for them.
Legally where do we stand with our supplier as they are threatening us with legal action?
Thanks.
We have recently completed a project and our subbie has been purchasing materials 'supposedly' for this job without the say so of my company. When I have gone through the invoices there is more goods bought than required for the project. We have a strict policy on ordering in the company and do not accept invoices from our supplies without specific orders from the office. We have had some invoices with corresponding order numbers for this job which we have paid. Our supplier is now pursuing us for outstanding monies and I have said that we are not paying them as there is no specific orders number from the office corresponding with our ordering procedure which was outlined to them when we set the account up.
To conclude, subbie orders materials (some legitimately for the project), supplier invoices us, we say that we are not paying as we haven't ordered the goods or signed for them.
Legally where do we stand with our supplier as they are threatening us with legal action?
Thanks.
What were the terms and conditions you had in place with the sub-contractor regarding HIS ordering of goods on behalf of YOUR business?
How much authority did he have to buy goods?
Was there any check system in place to allow you to authorise individual purchases or did he have carte blanche to buy what he liked when he liked?
Who did the supplier think he was "contracting" with - your company or the subbie?
How much authority did he have to buy goods?
Was there any check system in place to allow you to authorise individual purchases or did he have carte blanche to buy what he liked when he liked?
Who did the supplier think he was "contracting" with - your company or the subbie?
Thanks Eric, they did not have authority from the directors to purchase goods on behalf of the company. Our supplier new full well our ordering procedure but still let the goods be dispatched and was signed for by the sub contractor, not our staff who were there.
To top things off, the sub contractor we employed subcontracted the project out to a third party who was ordering the materials.
To top things off, the sub contractor we employed subcontracted the project out to a third party who was ordering the materials.
Gorgonzola said:
Legally where do we stand with our supplier as they are threatening us with legal action?
If they haven't received any orders from you, and can't produce a receipt, docket or delivery note signed by someone from your company, I don't see how they can possibly charge you for the goods. If you needed the goods to do the job does it matter who ordered them?
It seems to me it's a paperwork issue, confusion etc etc.
Why make a big deal of it and upset a good supplier, who you may need again?
As long as you know you have had the materials and you needed the materials there is no reason not to pay the supplier.
It would then be a good idea to induct all suppliers and subcontractors with your T&C's and get them to sign and return a copy, so everybody is singing off the same hymn sheet going forward
It seems to me it's a paperwork issue, confusion etc etc.
Why make a big deal of it and upset a good supplier, who you may need again?
As long as you know you have had the materials and you needed the materials there is no reason not to pay the supplier.
It would then be a good idea to induct all suppliers and subcontractors with your T&C's and get them to sign and return a copy, so everybody is singing off the same hymn sheet going forward
Edited by Birkin1932 on Saturday 28th December 14:19
Gorgonzola said:
Hi Guys,
We have recently completed a project and our subbie has been purchasing materials 'supposedly' for this job without the say so of my company. When I have gone through the invoices there is more goods bought than required for the project. We have a strict policy on ordering in the company and do not accept invoices from our supplies without specific orders from the office. We have had some invoices with corresponding order numbers for this job which we have paid. Our supplier is now pursuing us for outstanding monies and I have said that we are not paying them as there is no specific orders number from the office corresponding with our ordering procedure which was outlined to them when we set the account up.
To conclude, subbie orders materials (some legitimately for the project), supplier invoices us, we say that we are not paying as we haven't ordered the goods or signed for them.
Legally where do we stand with our supplier as they are threatening us with legal action?
Thanks.
Might be worth moving over to Speed, Plod & Law sub-forum and asking the legal chaps about the above and the concepts of explicit and apparent authority.We have recently completed a project and our subbie has been purchasing materials 'supposedly' for this job without the say so of my company. When I have gone through the invoices there is more goods bought than required for the project. We have a strict policy on ordering in the company and do not accept invoices from our supplies without specific orders from the office. We have had some invoices with corresponding order numbers for this job which we have paid. Our supplier is now pursuing us for outstanding monies and I have said that we are not paying them as there is no specific orders number from the office corresponding with our ordering procedure which was outlined to them when we set the account up.
To conclude, subbie orders materials (some legitimately for the project), supplier invoices us, we say that we are not paying as we haven't ordered the goods or signed for them.
Legally where do we stand with our supplier as they are threatening us with legal action?
Thanks.
I am fairly certain that where you've made levels of authorisation clear to suppliers they will struggle to claim that, where they've accepted orders outside these, the company is on the hook for them - UNLESS you've suggested through prior conduct etc that others (i.e. subbies in general) can deviate from your established procedures and act as your agents even if they do not possess purchase orders from the office. There will however be subtleties that I am unaware of.
Of course, the real "elephant in the room" is: where are the "extra" supplies now?
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


