Speed cameras
Author
Discussion

Matt 211988

Original Poster:

223 posts

155 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
here is the scenario....

I'm driving along a single carriageway way 'A' road, limit 60mph, doing lets say.... 80mph. I'm heading northbound and on the southbound side of the road there is a fixed speed camera (gatso?) pointing towards me and a set of lines painted on the road to mark the distance etc.
its 3am and pitch black, and the camera is plain grey with no yellow or reflective markings on the side thats facing me, on the back of it, it is yellow and reflective so you can see it when heading southbound.

as I get halfway along the painted lines i notice it, but by then its too late, i then think, 'oh it hasnt flashed', then all of a sudden, it does flash! im fairly certain that my reg plate will not be visable due to the angle as i was quite close to the end of the painted lines before it flashed.

where would I stand on this hypertheritcal situation?
lets say it happened recently and no ticket has come through the door yet. if it did get my reg and i did get a ticket, shouldnt the camera be visable etc?

then lets say, hyperthetically again, i was a bit sleepy and had the same situation as above, but on a dual carriageway section!

where would I stand on this? I've been under the impression that the fixed cameras must be made visable to road users by means of bright colours and reflectiveness, not painted battleship grey to blend into the night and scare me half to death by striking me with lightning!

I guess its not bad being hit by two cameras on a 300mile trip that involves 27 cameras in total!

thanks for any help!

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
The government's guidelines states they must be well signed, and visible.

I think you'll struggle to get out of it based on that, and these are only guidelines, not law. Nothing to stop the councils hiding them in hedges in theory.

They have 14 days to post the NIP to you, so let the wait begin. If/when it arrives and you find it dated outside of this 14 day window, it's invalid anyway.


anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
Matt 211988 said:
hypertheritcal
Is that a PH record?

craigjm

21,723 posts

231 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
Do any of the front facing speed cameras flash? Are you sure it wasn't just a gatso on the other side of the road and someone else went through it or it malfunctioned?

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
craigjm said:
Do any of the front facing speed cameras flash? Are you sure it wasn't just a gatso on the other side of the road and someone else went through it or it malfunctioned?
Yes, I've had front facing cameras flash before.

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
Gatso's aren't type approved to 'get you' from the front over here.

It was the same question that I first joined here to ask years ago when I did the same at 2am and was 17 with 3 points already. You'll (or the person subject to the hypothetically will) be fine smile

SegueUK

71 posts

162 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
If it's a Gatso then you can't be done for it forward facing, even if they have your reg number clear as day. It's not home office approved.

If I was you I'd check on google maps what type of camera it is first. If it's a Gatso you are sound.

For example, a speed camera I pass every day regularly flashes cars coming away from the lights too quickly. Infact just before Xmas it caught a bike over taking someone going against the camera.

Once I was going through the camera 'zone' and a Jag raced around the corner, past me going the opposite way and set the camera off. Never heard anything off it so at least they actually check the pictures.

Camera in question: https://maps.google.co.uk/?ll=51.58691,-0.043559&a...


Edited by SegueUK on Sunday 29th December 19:48

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
As above.

If a Gatso (not Truvelo) and it flashed you going towards it rather than away from it you will be fine.

Not type approved for forward facing capture in the UK.

Matt 211988 said:
here is the scenario....
its 3am and pitch black, and the camera is plain grey with no yellow or reflective markings on the side thats facing me, on the back of it, it is yellow and reflective so you can see it when heading southbound.
IME, it's not uncommon for the yellow/reflective markings to only be on the back (i.e. visible to those who would be caught going past it) with the front left plain.

Edited by g3org3y on Sunday 29th December 20:04

Matt 211988

Original Poster:

223 posts

155 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
yes, both cameras were on the opposite sides of the road and im guessing to catch people speeding southbound, I was heading north. I was just wanting a bit of advice on if they got me as they still flashed me, sounds like I should be fine smile

as for the spelling..... my god that was bad :| my excuse.... I went to get at 11 after 3 days of being drunk and was up at 2:30this morning for my 6hour drive to Aberdeen wink

as you can guess.... this might have been the a90 I was on..... wink

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
I'd go further and if you are certain it's a gatso ,report it to the SCP .Next thing you'll get called MR and thanked for informing them .What this really means is that they're terrified of this getting to local press for a solicitor representing a client ,as this poses doubt on the reliability of this camera .

SegueUK

71 posts

162 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
Who me said:
I'd go further and if you are certain it's a gatso ,report it to the SCP .Next thing you'll get called MR and thanked for informing them .What this really means is that they're terrified of this getting to local press for a solicitor representing a client ,as this poses doubt on the reliability of this camera .
How do you mean? because it flashes forward facing?

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Sunday 29th December 2013
quotequote all
YES, as Gatso's are not type approved for frontal view . If you ever have a gatso flash in your face in part/half light ,then you'll know why .Gatso's are only type approved to photograph from the rear of a passing vehicle. And if half the folks flashed in their face reported these ,with a letter to a local paper, then the camera techs would be run of their feet, and the whole enforcement regime would be subject to a regime of doubt. I'd suggest you read up on Speed camera type approval . Know your enemy .

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Monday 30th December 2013
quotequote all
WaferThinHam said:
They have 14 days to post the NIP to you, so let the wait begin. If/when it arrives and you find it dated outside of this 14 day window, it's invalid anyway.
Almost - the NIP must be posted in such time that, in the ordinary course of post, it would be served (ie delivered) wiithin 14 days of the alleged offence. Absent proof to the contrary, a NIP issued by 1st class post would presume to have been served 2 business days after posting.

Matt 211988

Original Poster:

223 posts

155 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
what if i am away for 16 days after the event and cannot tell when the nip has arrived?, might have just come the morning i get home which is more than 14 days smile

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Matt 211988 said:
what if i am away for 16 days after the event and cannot tell when the nip has arrived?, might have just come the morning i get home which is more than 14 days smile
It will be presumed to have been delivered 2 working days after it was posted, and if you have no idea when it was actually delivered then obviously you have no evidence with which to rebut that presumption.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
1) There is NO obligation to advise of or distinguish scameras. The "painted yellow" requirement went out with the end of hypothecation in 2007.

2) Front-facing (i.e., facing towards the direction of travel) scameras flash. They have a magenta filter over the flash, so can be distinguished from the white flash of a rear-facing scamera.

Streaky

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
I am surprised to see you using the term scamera, Streaky. I would have thought you to be above such childish nonsense. Do you call Tony Bliar?

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
[quote=Who me ?]YES, as Gatso's are not type approved for frontal view . If you ever have a gatso flash in your face in part/half light ,then you'll know why .Gatso's are only type approved to photograph from the rear of a passing vehicle. And if half the folks flashed in their face reported these ,with a letter to a local paper, then the camera techs would be run of their feet, and the whole enforcement regime would be subject to a regime of doubt. I'd suggest you read up on Speed camera type approval . Know your enemy .
[/quote]

Gatso speed cameras are Type Approved for the measurement of vehicles receding from the camera and radar. This means that for receding vehicles evidence from a Gatso is admissible if a section 20 Road Traffic Offenders' Act certificate accompanies the evidence to the court.
It is normal practice for Gatso speed cameras to be set for approaching AND receding traffic when in dummy radar mode. It is therefore unlikely, nay I say it won't happen, that camera partnerships and police will give a toss when a report of a Gatso flashing oncoming traffic is made to them.
When a device is Type Approved to work in one way and is operated in another way the evidence is not barred from admissibility although it is barred from admissibility by a S20 RTOA certificate.
When you are flashed by a Gatso camera from the front it is likely that it is in its dummy, both-ways setting so prosecutions will not result as evidence will not be gathered to prosecute with. If though, evidence was gathered in the front mode, say by a technician observing the speed recorded on the radar and it was an approaching vehicle, that evidence can be used for a prosecution. The evidence would be admitted by way of a statement from the operator.
Any device that is operated outside of its Type Approval or indeed those that have no Type Approval at all can be used as evidence in a speeding case; the court deciding what weight to give to that evidence. I have used a device outside of Approval to evidence speed that way.
Saying an instrument isn't Type Approved in a specific mode so evidence cannot be used indicates very clearly a misunderstanding of Type Approval.
Will the OP be prosecuted from this Gatso event? No...but not for the reasons given regarding its Approval but because it will have been in its dummy mode and there will be no evidence of the event...unless of course there was an officer observing that event and who was reading the radar speed...I would say there was not.

Start the bugle...that's my last post; it has been fun but it is no longer, nothing more to learn here.

Edited by pitmansboots on Tuesday 31st December 16:05

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Wouldn't evidence from a device being used outside of its type approval be susceptible to s78 PACE?

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
I am surprised to see you using the term scamera, Streaky. I would have thought you to be above such childish nonsense. Do you call Tony Bliar?
Have a drink for gawds sake, scamera = abbreviation for speed camera.

I thought the last bit was Tony B liar, or are you a mate of his too ?