Defamation Act 2013 in force wef 01/01/14
Discussion
The Defamation Act 2013 comes into force on 1 January 2014. This is a good thing, as it improves the position of defendants and gives greater protection to free expression.
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2013/26/conten...
Of perhaps greatest moment to online blatherers, the defence of fair comment is replaced by a new defence of honest opinion.
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2013/26/conten...
Of perhaps greatest moment to online blatherers, the defence of fair comment is replaced by a new defence of honest opinion.
Not really. It's the result of long standing concerns about the way in which libel law had developed in the UK, leading to libel tourism, celeb lottery litigation, and a chilling effect on free speech.
Telling porkies online may still be risky, unless the criteria for a defence set out in the Act are satisfied. Website operators gain better protection in relation to ranties published on their sites by others.
Telling porkies online may still be risky, unless the criteria for a defence set out in the Act are satisfied. Website operators gain better protection in relation to ranties published on their sites by others.
Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 31st December 07:54
Does this mean that the horrors of the McCann thread will be unleashed once more over in NP&E ?
Presumably it takes a while for new legislation of this type to build up a bit of case law, so in the early days does legislation of this kind tend to get interpreted fairly 'conservatively' by you legal types?
Presumably it takes a while for new legislation of this type to build up a bit of case law, so in the early days does legislation of this kind tend to get interpreted fairly 'conservatively' by you legal types?
The Act is pretty clear, and modern interpretation is often purposive and not conservative. The McCann haters will be a bit assisted by it (although the Act is still not a licence to say whatever you like). Allowing nutters to rant and rave is part of the price of free speech, but let's not encourage their pathologies!
Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 31st December 08:51
Breadvan72 said:
The Defamation Act 2013 comes into force on 1 January 2014. This is a good thing, as it improves the position of defendants and gives greater protection to free expression.
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2013/26/conten...
Of perhaps greatest moment to online blatherers, the defence of fair comment is replaced by a new defence of honest opinion.
Is it a "good thing" for lawyers? http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2013/26/conten...
Of perhaps greatest moment to online blatherers, the defence of fair comment is replaced by a new defence of honest opinion.

Streaky
How pleasing to see a concise piece of legislation, written in clear pithy English. How nice it would be to see the judiciary following this precedent in their judgments.
Replacement of Reynolds by public interest defence and the introduction of the single publication rule seem to me to be significant additions to freedom of speech. I wondered if Mitchell can plead PID in the case brought against him by the Downing Street gatekeeper, but I see that the new defences do not apply to causes of action that have already accrued.
Replacement of Reynolds by public interest defence and the introduction of the single publication rule seem to me to be significant additions to freedom of speech. I wondered if Mitchell can plead PID in the case brought against him by the Downing Street gatekeeper, but I see that the new defences do not apply to causes of action that have already accrued.
Not quite:-
(1)It is a defence to an action for defamation for the defendant to show that the following conditions are met.
(2)The first condition is that the statement complained of was a statement of opinion.
(3)The second condition is that the statement complained of indicated, whether in general or specific terms, the basis of the opinion.
(4)The third condition is that an honest person could have held the opinion on the basis of—
(a)any fact which existed at the time the statement complained of was published;
(b)anything asserted to be a fact in a privileged statement published before the statement complained of.
(5)The defence is defeated if the claimant shows that the defendant did not hold the opinion.
Honest belief is a tautology anyway, as you can't have a dishonest belief.
(1)It is a defence to an action for defamation for the defendant to show that the following conditions are met.
(2)The first condition is that the statement complained of was a statement of opinion.
(3)The second condition is that the statement complained of indicated, whether in general or specific terms, the basis of the opinion.
(4)The third condition is that an honest person could have held the opinion on the basis of—
(a)any fact which existed at the time the statement complained of was published;
(b)anything asserted to be a fact in a privileged statement published before the statement complained of.
(5)The defence is defeated if the claimant shows that the defendant did not hold the opinion.
Honest belief is a tautology anyway, as you can't have a dishonest belief.
Does it mean that PH (and other online forums) can be a bit more relaxed about 'Name & Shame'?
For example, if I stated an opinion that a manufacturer and/or dealer were incompetent and had provided me with shoddy service, would me stating this as an honestly-held opinion be sufficient to allow PH to leave my post without editing it or deleting it?
For example, if I stated an opinion that a manufacturer and/or dealer were incompetent and had provided me with shoddy service, would me stating this as an honestly-held opinion be sufficient to allow PH to leave my post without editing it or deleting it?
oobster said:
Does it mean that PH (and other online forums) can be a bit more relaxed about 'Name & Shame'?
For example, if I stated an opinion that a manufacturer and/or dealer were incompetent and had provided me with shoddy service, would me stating this as an honestly-held opinion be sufficient to allow PH to leave my post without editing it or deleting it?
Depends whether they are an advertiser or not. For example, if I stated an opinion that a manufacturer and/or dealer were incompetent and had provided me with shoddy service, would me stating this as an honestly-held opinion be sufficient to allow PH to leave my post without editing it or deleting it?

It is up to PH to decide on its own rules, so long as these conform with the general law. Even under the new Act, there is still potential for hassle for a website operator if people start dissing named parties online, and PH could choose to maintain its rules in order to reduce the burdens on the Mods, who provide their services to us for free.
oobster said:
Does it mean that PH (and other online forums) can be a bit more relaxed about 'Name & Shame'?
For example, if I stated an opinion that a manufacturer and/or dealer were incompetent and had provided me with shoddy service, would me stating this as an honestly-held opinion be sufficient to allow PH to leave my post without editing it or deleting it?
But is your statement that it's an honestly-held opinion itself honestly-held? How do you prove that?For example, if I stated an opinion that a manufacturer and/or dealer were incompetent and had provided me with shoddy service, would me stating this as an honestly-held opinion be sufficient to allow PH to leave my post without editing it or deleting it?
There is still non-zero risk of litigation although it will be a little harder to prove loss than before.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


