DPA and ET judge's notes
Author
Discussion

uknick

Original Poster:

1,067 posts

215 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
I posted this on the employment section with one response (shown below, thanks Zeeky), but they were not sure of the specifics with regard to judge’s notes and the DPA. I thought I’d try here to see if there are any other views.

I'm trying to get hold of the judge's/tribunal's notes from my ET. After being led to believe by the ET office they're available under a Subject Access Request I'm now told they can only be released upon the order of an Employment Appeal Tribunal judge. I was told this by letter from the Tribunal indicating this answer has come from another judge.

Is this true, or is this another example of somebody not correctly interpreting the Data Protection Act rules?

I'm not intending to appeal my ruling, but want the notes for another issue relating to my case.

Zeeky said:
The Judge's notes will not form part of your case file to which the DPA does apply. I haven't heard of notes being disclosed other than as part of an appeal. I do not know the specifics of the DPA applicable to notes taken by the Tribunal but would be surprised if they must be disclosed.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
My understanding is that the DPA would not apply were the information be necessary for actual or prospective legal proceedings (including seeking legal advice).

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
My understanding is that the DPA would not apply were the information be necessary for actual or prospective legal proceedings (including seeking legal advice).
S.35 applies.

A question a legal eagle is better placed to answer, is whether the Judge's notes are covered by legal privilege.

Streaky

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
No, the notes are not subject to LPP, as that only applies between lawyer and client (I simplify, but the point is good in context).

Also, section 35 is not in play here as that disapplies the non disclosure provisions of the DPA when documents are required for legal proceedings. It is not part of the subject access request regime.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
The OP is not asking if data can be used in proceedings. He is asking if he can obtain data via a subject access request when the data is not intended to be used in proceedings. I do not know if this question has been tested. On the face of it, a subject access request could be made, but as the notes will usually contain data about people other than the applicant, they would have to be summarised or redacted, so a complete copy could not be obtained in this way. There is no automatic entitlement to a complete document when instead you can be given the relevant data in another intelligible form.

Why do you want the notes, OP?

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Also, section 35 is not in play here as that disapplies the non disclosure provisions of the DPA when documents are required for legal proceedings. It is not part of the subject access request regime.
A Data Subject is not obliged to make their request under s.7 only. The MOJ advised us that s.35 could be used by an individual, albeit, it was more commonly cited by lawyers. Even LAs used it.

Streaky

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
There are no proceedings. There were some, but the data was not and is not sought for those. I know the DPA is your hobby horse, Streaky, but you are misreading it here. You would be right if the OP wanted to obtain legal advice, but he says he is not going to appeal in his case, so that seems unlikely.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Just pondering here, but s35 also appears to apply to prospective proceedings or even obtaining the data in order to receive legal advice, does it not? That seems to suggest there do not need to be live proceedings for s35 to apply, though I could be misreading it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
The OP says he is not going to appeal. Unless the OP is planning to sue his lawyer for negligence, then there can be no other proceedings in prospect because things said in a tribunal are privileged and cannot form the basis of a further lawsuit.

The OP needs to tell us why he wants the notes before we can advise whether he can get them.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
The OP needs to tell us why he wants the notes before we can advise whether he can get them.
Which is the burning question, as I couldn't think why he would want them other than negligence, an appeal or some sort of contempt/perverting.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Yep. He may have a route via section 35, but not if he just wants to have a gander.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
Don't ETs have recordings as per Crown? A transcript would be more telling than some notes unless you wanted to suggest the Judge's notes made him err, at which point, I'd ask how would you suspect it if you had never seen the notes in the first place or tell people you weren't going to appeal... Curious.

jensenhealey2

163 posts

190 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
I don't think the DPA is relevant here. The DPA is about getting data,i.e. Information, not about getting access to documents, Durant v FSA 2003 EWCA civil 1746. It is often easiest to disclose the documents to convey the information requested under the DPA, but it is not obligatory.

In my experience when seeking information from data controllers it is usually quicker and easier to follow their procedures for disclosure, even when you know they are wrong about the law, than to try and persuade them that the hoops they want to jump through are unnecessary.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 31st December 2013
quotequote all
I mostly agree, but the DPA is still potentially relevant, as some of the info in the notes may be obtainable. People often fail to realise that the DPA does not entitle them to documents.

10Ps, no tapes in ETs, probably for reasons of cheapo-ness. The Judge tapes the decision if given extempore.



Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 31st December 19:04

uknick

Original Poster:

1,067 posts

215 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses.

I’m not intending to bring a case of negligence against my legal team. Also, I didn’t appeal the decision as my funds have run out to take the case any further.

The case was a complex one requiring a long hearing. Whilst I won my unfair dismissal claim, I failed in the part of my claim as to the true reason for my dismissal. However, the judge in his decision omitted significant evidence given during the hearing. This evidence was severely detrimental to the respondent. For example, verbal evidence from one of the respondent witnesses clearly indicated, in their opinion, the true reason for me losing my job. Upon review of the judgement, my brief said it was disappointing the judge ignored this evidence completely. In other evidence given by the respondent witnesses they admitted they were disingenuous with regard to building a case against me for dismissal. But, the judge made great play in commenting how upstanding and honest the respondent’s witnesses were.

I know the judgement does not have to, and in fact would make it far too long, include all evidence. But one would think it should cover the most salient evidence to support the judgement. In the lengthy ruling in my case, there were only one or two references to actual evidence given during the hearing. The judgement includes an introduction to the case and then jumps straight to the conclusion without covering much actual evidence given as to the reasoning for the conclusion.

I want the judge’s notes so I can compare them to the comprehensive notes my team took during the hearing and see if he managed to completely miss the above examples from his notes, or he just chose to ignore the evidence when making his judgement.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
So, you just want to rub salt in your own wounds, even though you won? On this basis, at best, you might receive a summary of the parts of the notes that contain your personal data. Section 35 won't help you.

Perhaps litigating was a mistake for you, as it is for so many, as it has not brought you closure.

The ET is there to decide if your dismissal was unfair, which it was. It is not there to dispense psychological relief, or to put anyone in the dock. You appear to say that the ET reached the right result but for the wrong reasons. There is nothing you can do about that. As for people telling porkies, well, it happens.

I add that Judges are like Victorian mountaineers and usually take the easiest route to the summit. If the ET could find the dismissal unfair for reason A, it need not decide whether reason B would also have applied. Also, an ET does not have to accept every part of a party's case. It can accept some parts and reject others. An ET decision is not expected to be a work of scholarship, and is usually give in fairly summary form.



Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 1st January 12:01