Sue the property valuer?
Author
Discussion

Backtobasics

Original Poster:

1,182 posts

214 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
I'm just preempting a potential issue, we have just sold our house and have a valuation through a valuations company expected imminently who are known for low balling, these guys valued our property in 2011 at less than market value. They didn't take into account any improvements or extensions on the property over others in the area. Reading up this is quite common practice as the mortgage value can be less than open market value to cover the valuers (and the lenders) back. So should we get into the sticky situation of the mortgage valuation being less than the sold price (which is under market value), can I sue the mortgage valuer after we had sold? (if we did have to accept a lower valuation), and what would I need to prove?





UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
I'm just preempting a potential issue, we have just sold our house and have a valuation through a valuations company expected imminently who are known for low balling, these guys valued our property in 2011 at less than market value. They didn't take into account any improvements or extensions on the property over others in the area. Reading up this is quite common practice as the mortgage value can be less than open market value to cover the valuers (and the lenders) back. So should we get into the sticky situation of the mortgage valuation being less than the sold price (which is under market value), can I sue the mortgage valuer after we had sold? (if we did have to accept a lower valuation), and what would I need to prove?
Surely the potential low valuation is a problem for your buyer to resolve with his lender. What are you going to sue them for exactly?

Six Fiend

6,067 posts

246 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Valuation from 2011 and just sold? Seems a big old gap to me.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Have you sold the house or agreed a sale? Who are the valuers working for? Bit more detail please.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
I'm not entirely sure of the problem - but I think it's unlikely you'll be able to sue.
The valuation is just thier opinion on the price.

You may be able to ask the bank to get a second valuation though. It depends on the circumstance.


anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
The mortgage valuer owes you no legal duty. Take some anti compo culture pills and call me in the morning.

Mortgage value is commonly below market value. This is prudent lending practice. Mortgage value assumes a forced sale. If your sale falls through because your potential buyer cannot raise funds, that is bad luck, but not a basis for a lawsuit.

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 1st January 17:41

Burgmeister

2,206 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Presumably the valuation is being done for the lender who is financing the purchase for your buyer?

If so then it has nothing to do with you.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
the sold price (which is under market value)
The sold price IS the market value.

9mm

3,128 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
I'm just preempting a potential issue, we have just sold our house and have a valuation through a valuations company expected imminently who are known for low balling, these guys valued our property in 2011 at less than market value. They didn't take into account any improvements or extensions on the property over others in the area. Reading up this is quite common practice as the mortgage value can be less than open market value to cover the valuers (and the lenders) back. So should we get into the sticky situation of the mortgage valuation being less than the sold price (which is under market value), can I sue the mortgage valuer after we had sold? (if we did have to accept a lower valuation), and what would I need to prove?
It's not about low-balling or covering the lender's back. The lender is quite naturally concerned to ensure that they can recoup as much of the loan in the shortest space of time at the lowest possible cost, in the event of you defaulting.

Valuations based on these concerns are therefore more likely to be conservative (safe?) than those conducted by homeowners. In addition, as many improvements or extensions fail to add value as increase it.

As for legal action, I suspect as in most cases you would need to prove and quantify your loss. Others more qualified than me will undoubtedly advise you before too long.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
I'm just preempting a potential issue, we have just sold our house and have a valuation through a valuations company expected imminently who are known for low balling, these guys valued our property in 2011 at less than market value. They didn't take into account any improvements or extensions on the property over others in the area. Reading up this is quite common practice as the mortgage value can be less than open market value to cover the valuers (and the lenders) back. So should we get into the sticky situation of the mortgage valuation being less than the sold price (which is under market value), can I sue the mortgage valuer after we had sold? (if we did have to accept a lower valuation), and what would I need to prove?
How do you reckon it was below market value? Why do you think your changes were actually improvements? Why did you sell at the offered price, there was no obligation.

Sue the valuer? Good luck with that.........

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
can I sue the mortgage valuer after we had sold? (if we did have to accept a lower valuation), and what would I need to prove?
I suppose my first question is

What do YOU think?
What you think you would be suing them for?


Backtobasics

Original Poster:

1,182 posts

214 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Wow, I only went for some tea. Thanks for the input!!

I would expect the buyer to try and re negotiate if a lower value was suggested.

I have agreed a sale, not sold.

Right, the valuation in 2011 was for a remortgage, but with the same valuation company.

The improvements in the property are a loft conversion, extra bathroom and small rear extension

Point taken on market value.

Sue the valuer? The banks seem to have been very successful in this en devour.

On what grounds can I sue?

Thats a good question.

Probably the inverse of this.

http://www.theguardian.com/money/2008/apr/12/prope...

Backtobasics

Original Poster:

1,182 posts

214 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Sorry I missed the anti compo culture.

I had that that as one of my default replies! Thanks for that one.

Just waiting for MX-5 and powerfully built company director

Got a bonus point if anyone can mention ambiwlans

Burgmeister

2,206 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
I don't understand why you think you can sue. You're not paying for the valuation. It's not yours.

eldar

25,366 posts

227 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
It isn't sold, then.

Increase the price to match the market value and get a buyer. No need to sue anyone.

Backtobasics

Original Poster:

1,182 posts

214 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
OK, I'm just asking the question (perhaps on the wrong forum I admit) in that there appears to have been a number of precedents set (noted in the media) where valuers have over valued a property and been successfully sued by banks / individuals / companies. In the last few years properties have been undervalued and again I have seen sellers suing the valuer to recoup the loss (again reported in the media).

Noted the contract is not with me.


Wacky Racer

41,420 posts

278 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
Sorry I missed the anti compo culture.

I had that that as one of my default replies! Thanks for that one.

Just waiting for MX-5 and powerfully built company director

Got a bonus point if anyone can mention ambiwlans
You forgot frozen sausages...teacher

av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Backtobasics said:
I'm just preempting a potential issue, we have just sold our house and have a valuation through a valuations company expected imminently who are known for low balling, these guys valued our property in 2011 at less than market value. They didn't take into account any improvements or extensions on the property over others in the area. Reading up this is quite common practice as the mortgage value can be less than open market value to cover the valuers (and the lenders) back. So should we get into the sticky situation of the mortgage valuation being less than the sold price (which is under market value), can I sue the mortgage valuer after we had sold? (if we did have to accept a lower valuation), and what would I need to prove?
You say the mortgage valuation can be less than open market value "to cover the valuers and lenders back." Incorrect. As has been mentioned, the mortgage vauation is really a forced sale valuation taking into account all relevant factors and any repairs required to the property and as such will generally be lower than the OMV.

The valuer owes you no duty of care whatsoever and is acting solely for the lending institution and their client as purchaser. Furthermore the valuer has to be able to justify his scrutinised valuation which will have to be proved in court should the need arise. yes

Whilst most professional mortgage valuations are accurate, this is to a degree subjective and valuations often vary up to perhaps 10 per cent.

You say the valuation did not take into account improvements or extensions compared to other properties in the area. Really? Have you been round all of these other properties with a tape measure to find their exact floor area, type and quality of improvements in addition to having knowledge of numerous other factors including condition and structural issues etc etc? nono

Not sure on what basis you may consider suing the valuer, but good luck with that even if you are prepared to throw £ thousands at persuing a hopeless case, bear in mind that the second most difficult professional negligence case to prove after medical are valuation surveyors.......thumbup

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
The agreement between the buyer and seller determines the value of the house.

The property valuer gives a guide as to what the price it is not set in stone.

If you want to sue somebody try the bloke who agreed to sell at a price he thought was too low.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
They are not valuing your house for the open market
they are valuing the property for the lender, as it's potential for a loan security, according to the rules of the lender. Some lenders may ask for an open market valuation, but not all do, and they are under no obligation to.