Am I entitled to compensation?
Am I entitled to compensation?
Author
Discussion

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Apologies for luring you in under slightly false pretenses but all this talk of suing for electricity supply failures, house valuations, etc, did remind me of an issue I've been intending to raise for a while and I had forgotten about.

I appreciate for this to go anywhere I'll quite rightly have to write to the company concerned, but in the first instance I'd find it quite useful to hear if anyone has encountered a similar issue or even to point out that I'm missing the bleedin' obvious somewhere.

As I said, I'm not actually after compensation but I wonder if I might be due at least a partial refund of contributions so I'll post the main details here and then fill in and answer any specifics depending on the replies I get.

I had two insurance policies until recently, both provided by the same insurance company and recommended by the same advisor at the same time. They were both started about 10 years ago, certainly no earlier than 2000, and between them they provided a mix of life, critical illness and income protection cover (no payment protection). One policy was around £90 pcm and the other around £35 pcm. I'm sure it's not relevant but no claims were ever made on either policy.

These policies both became redundant last year due to changes in my personal circumstances. When I cancelled the first policy I read through the policy docs for probably the first time since it started and was somewhat surprised to read, or at least interpret, a clause which suggested that if I claimed, any payments due under the policy would be offset by any payments I was receiving from the company under another policy. Since both policies paid out under the same conditions, it seemed to me that I could only ever claim on one policy, despite paying premiums for both.

I subsequently cancelled the second policy and iirc those documents had a similar clause about payments under it being offset against any other payments from other policies. I then forgot about it all as I was overtaken by more important events. I'll try and dig out the documents tonight but does anyone have any experience of this sort of thing? My current feeling is that if the policies were written in such a way that I could never only claim on one of them, at least one of the two should never have been sold. From there on I start to confuse myself!


Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
If your interpretation is correct, probably. You need an insurance expert to fathom the documentation.

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
Just write to the company that sold you the policy explaining your concern and they will take from there as they are legally obliged to do so.

At face value it sounds like a potential misselling case, but the above is your first port of call.

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
ellroy said:
Just write to the company that sold you the policy explaining your concern and they will take from there as they are legally obliged to do so.

At face value it sounds like a potential misselling case, but the above is your first port of call.
As I said, I will do this, but being a Bank Holiday evening and no realistic prospect of a reply for at least a fortnight, opinions or industry insights are useful before I put pen to paper.

Wozy68

5,436 posts

201 months

Wednesday 1st January 2014
quotequote all
I think you have a fair shout with the second ins company if they knew you already had a policy.

I have read these kind of terms somewhere before with (I think) car ins./

Edited by Wozy68 on Wednesday 1st January 20:47

Tc24

533 posts

170 months

Thursday 2nd January 2014
quotequote all
Forgive me if I've got the wrong end of the stick, but it is late hehe

The clauses you mention are standard in pretty much any insurance contract, and are probably referred to as the contribution clause within the wording. This, as you say, means that in the event of a claim where a particular loss is covered by both policies, each policy will contribute towards a share of the total claim payment.

If a certain event is only covered by 1 of the policies, then that policy will pay out in full (contribution does not apply as there is no cover for the loss elsewhere).

I can only assume that each policy covers something different with some slight overlap where contribution might apply.

If this is not the case, and both policies give identical cover, why did the adviser recommend taking these 2 policies? It would be pretty poor form for them to do this, and I imagine if it could be proven that you were given this advice that some sort of refund would be given.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Thursday 2nd January 2014
quotequote all
Tc24 said:
Forgive me if I've got the wrong end of the stick, but it is late hehe

The clauses you mention are standard in pretty much any insurance contract, and are probably referred to as the contribution clause within the wording. This, as you say, means that in the event of a claim where a particular loss is covered by both policies, each policy will contribute towards a share of the total claim payment.

If a certain event is only covered by 1 of the policies, then that policy will pay out in full (contribution does not apply as there is no cover for the loss elsewhere).

I can only assume that each policy covers something different with some slight overlap where contribution might apply.

If this is not the case, and both policies give identical cover, why did the adviser recommend taking these 2 policies? It would be pretty poor form for them to do this, and I imagine if it could be proven that you were given this advice that some sort of refund would be given.
You've hit the nail on the head IMO with the first bit. The policies will have a cap on payout so that you're. It better off by being off sick, that's where the offsetting is likely to be applied to.

Old critical illness policies did have a cap of £150k payout across any and all policies sold as a total payout, but that cap faded in the early to mid 1990s.

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Thursday 2nd January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies so far. I get the idea of a cap on how much you could receive but my recollection was that the wording was different to this. However, I'll try and dig out the policy docs later and then post the precise wording. Just to confirm, both policies were issued by the same company - it's not a Pru versus Scottish Amicable kind of thing, but 2 x Pru. I know how frustrating it is when people ask for advice and don't provide full details so I'm happy to post up anything that helps me get my thoughts in order before I write to the company.

Futuramic

1,763 posts

236 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
9mm said:
Apologies for luring you in under slightly false pretenses but all this talk of suing for electricity supply failures, house valuations, etc, did remind me of an issue I've been intending to raise for a while and I had forgotten about.

I appreciate for this to go anywhere I'll quite rightly have to write to the company concerned, but in the first instance I'd find it quite useful to hear if anyone has encountered a similar issue or even to point out that I'm missing the bleedin' obvious somewhere.

As I said, I'm not actually after compensation but I wonder if I might be due at least a partial refund of contributions so I'll post the main details here and then fill in and answer any specifics depending on the replies I get.

I had two insurance policies until recently, both provided by the same insurance company and recommended by the same advisor at the same time. They were both started about 10 years ago, certainly no earlier than 2000, and between them they provided a mix of life, critical illness and income protection cover (no payment protection). One policy was around £90 pcm and the other around £35 pcm. I'm sure it's not relevant but no claims were ever made on either policy.

These policies both became redundant last year due to changes in my personal circumstances. When I cancelled the first policy I read through the policy docs for probably the first time since it started and was somewhat surprised to read, or at least interpret, a clause which suggested that if I claimed, any payments due under the policy would be offset by any payments I was receiving from the company under another policy. Since both policies paid out under the same conditions, it seemed to me that I could only ever claim on one policy, despite paying premiums for both.

I subsequently cancelled the second policy and iirc those documents had a similar clause about payments under it being offset against any other payments from other policies. I then forgot about it all as I was overtaken by more important events. I'll try and dig out the documents tonight but does anyone have any experience of this sort of thing? My current feeling is that if the policies were written in such a way that I could never only claim on one of them, at least one of the two should never have been sold. From there on I start to confuse myself!
I deal with investment products but have experience with complaints handling/FOS referrals etc

Reading through what you've written raises an interesting point in that you imply that claiming on one policy will cancel the other out i.e. Claim on Policy 1 for critical illness - pays out. Attempt to claim on Policy 2 for critical illness - doesn't pay out as it would duplicate the first claim.

So I would read that as meaning they won't pay you twice for the same event because you held two insurance policies.

However you mentioned a mix of life, critical illness and income protection. The crucial fact to establish is whether the cover offered by Policies 1 and 2 is identical, if it isn't then there would be instances where you could claim on one but not the other.

For example (silly examples - I know the actual examples would be more esoteric)

Policy 1 Covers:

Falling off a ladder
Rickets

Policy 2 Covers:

Falling off a ladder
Malaria

So if you fell off a ladder you couldn't claim on both policies. You could claim on one - the company would sort that out. But if you contracted Rickets, you couldn't claim on Policy 2. Ditto for Malaria.

Thus the Pru, as presumably this was sold by a tied agent, may take the line that you were offered an insurance portfolio to cover a portmanteau of risks. They could argue that whilst there was overlap, there were also discrete factors in each policy that made both necessary for the level of cover you agreed to have. The clause in question was inserted to stop people taking out multiple policies and making duplicate claims.

I think you need to establish exactly what was covered by each. Or you could write to the Pru and get them to do it for you! They would (probably).

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Futuramic said:
9mm said:
Apologies for luring you in under slightly false pretenses but all this talk of suing for electricity supply failures, house valuations, etc, did remind me of an issue I've been intending to raise for a while and I had forgotten about.

I appreciate for this to go anywhere I'll quite rightly have to write to the company concerned, but in the first instance I'd find it quite useful to hear if anyone has encountered a similar issue or even to point out that I'm missing the bleedin' obvious somewhere.

As I said, I'm not actually after compensation but I wonder if I might be due at least a partial refund of contributions so I'll post the main details here and then fill in and answer any specifics depending on the replies I get.

I had two insurance policies until recently, both provided by the same insurance company and recommended by the same advisor at the same time. They were both started about 10 years ago, certainly no earlier than 2000, and between them they provided a mix of life, critical illness and income protection cover (no payment protection). One policy was around £90 pcm and the other around £35 pcm. I'm sure it's not relevant but no claims were ever made on either policy.

These policies both became redundant last year due to changes in my personal circumstances. When I cancelled the first policy I read through the policy docs for probably the first time since it started and was somewhat surprised to read, or at least interpret, a clause which suggested that if I claimed, any payments due under the policy would be offset by any payments I was receiving from the company under another policy. Since both policies paid out under the same conditions, it seemed to me that I could only ever claim on one policy, despite paying premiums for both.

I subsequently cancelled the second policy and iirc those documents had a similar clause about payments under it being offset against any other payments from other policies. I then forgot about it all as I was overtaken by more important events. I'll try and dig out the documents tonight but does anyone have any experience of this sort of thing? My current feeling is that if the policies were written in such a way that I could never only claim on one of them, at least one of the two should never have been sold. From there on I start to confuse myself!
I deal with investment products but have experience with complaints handling/FOS referrals etc

Reading through what you've written raises an interesting point in that you imply that claiming on one policy will cancel the other out i.e. Claim on Policy 1 for critical illness - pays out. Attempt to claim on Policy 2 for critical illness - doesn't pay out as it would duplicate the first claim.

So I would read that as meaning they won't pay you twice for the same event because you held two insurance policies.

However you mentioned a mix of life, critical illness and income protection. The crucial fact to establish is whether the cover offered by Policies 1 and 2 is identical, if it isn't then there would be instances where you could claim on one but not the other.

For example (silly examples - I know the actual examples would be more esoteric)

Policy 1 Covers:

Falling off a ladder
Rickets

Policy 2 Covers:

Falling off a ladder
Malaria

So if you fell off a ladder you couldn't claim on both policies. You could claim on one - the company would sort that out. But if you contracted Rickets, you couldn't claim on Policy 2. Ditto for Malaria.

Thus the Pru, as presumably this was sold by a tied agent, may take the line that you were offered an insurance portfolio to cover a portmanteau of risks. They could argue that whilst there was overlap, there were also discrete factors in each policy that made both necessary for the level of cover you agreed to have. The clause in question was inserted to stop people taking out multiple policies and making duplicate claims.

I think you need to establish exactly what was covered by each. Or you could write to the Pru and get them to do it for you! They would (probably).
Thanks for a helpful reply.

Funnily enough I have just managed to find both sets of policy documents and it was on my list of things to do this afternoon.

You are right in that there is a difference/overlap between the cover offered by the policies and I will clarify that later when I go through the documentation.

In the meantime, using your example above, why would it be appropriate to pay for two lots of falling off a ladder insurance when you could only ever claim on one policy? At the very least, that seems to me that at least part of the premium was unnecessary and the risk could have been covered in a more appropriate way eg 1 x falling off a ladder policy and 1 x malaria and rickets policy, or 3 separate policies, one for each for ladders, malaria and rickets.

It might be understandable if the policies were sold by different companies and they had not established what policies were held (although this would suggest a less than thorough factfind). The issue in my case is that both policies were sold by the same agent at the same time.

I'll get out the Christmas port later and see what I can work out.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Just seen that you bought these policies at the same time. Why didn't you take one policy out adding the different cover levels together. At the very least that would've saved you one lot of policy fees.

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Just seen that you bought these policies at the same time. Why didn't you take one policy out adding the different cover levels together. At the very least that would've saved you one lot of policy fees.
Surely his adviser/broker should have pointed this out to him at the time? A potential case of mis-selling perhaps?

Pommygranite

14,472 posts

247 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
But the policies also cover different events so could also feasibly all pay out - therefore where is the mis-sell?

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm working my way through the docs guys but the port is good and the documents are turgid. Bear with me! In the meantime:

Loon - I'm a punter. I told the advisor I wanted to protect myself and my dependants against my death, critical illness, inability to work and inability to pay my mortgage and other bills. As such, I expect a professional advisor to recommend the best product(s), not self-select. There's a high degree of trust involved!

PCdriver - yep, that's what I'm trying to understand.

Pommy - indeed, that's why I need to run a couple of scenarios, eg death, critical illness, unemployment to see what would have paid out in each case. if everything, great, if not, we have a problem Houston (possibly).

I pretty sure if there's a problem it will be one of overlap, but we shall see.

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
9mm said:
I'm working my way through the docs guys but the port is good and the documents are turgid. Bear with me! In the meantime:

Loon - I'm a punter. I told the advisor I wanted to protect myself and my dependants against my death, critical illness, inability to work and inability to pay my mortgage and other bills. As such, I expect a professional advisor to recommend the best product(s), not self-select. There's a high degree of trust involved!

PCdriver - yep, that's what I'm trying to understand.

Pommy - indeed, that's why I need to run a couple of scenarios, eg death, critical illness, unemployment to see what would have paid out in each case. if everything, great, if not, we have a problem Houston (possibly).

I pretty sure if there's a problem it will be one of overlap, but we shall see.
9mm Damn I'm a bit jealous of your fine port. I do have the benefit of a caipirinha available to me.......as well as 35 degree temperatures - currently in Brazil enjoying some winter sun. If you fail to get satisfaction from your broker, or from the company that provided the policies - then refer your case to the FSA who are responsible under law, for all insurance policies.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
9mm said:
I'm working my way through the docs guys but the port is good and the documents are turgid. Bear with me! In the meantime:

Loon - I'm a punter. I told the advisor I wanted to protect myself and my dependants against my death, critical illness, inability to work and inability to pay my mortgage and other bills. As such, I expect a professional advisor to recommend the best product(s), not self-select. There's a high degree of trust involved!

PCdriver - yep, that's what I'm trying to understand.

Pommy - indeed, that's why I need to run a couple of scenarios, eg death, critical illness, unemployment to see what would have paid out in each case. if everything, great, if not, we have a problem Houston (possibly).

I pretty sure if there's a problem it will be one of overlap, but we shall see.
It was a generic "you" rather than aimed at you, if that makes sense. It seems a bit strange to split covers across two policies, especially as they were sold simultaneously. You probably have good reason to write and ask some questions.

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
It was a generic "you" rather than aimed at you, if that makes sense. It seems a bit strange to split covers across two policies, especially as they were sold simultaneously. You probably have good reason to write and ask some questions.
Understood mate - thanks.

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
pcvdriver said:
9mm said:
I'm working my way through the docs guys but the port is good and the documents are turgid. Bear with me! In the meantime:

Loon - I'm a punter. I told the advisor I wanted to protect myself and my dependants against my death, critical illness, inability to work and inability to pay my mortgage and other bills. As such, I expect a professional advisor to recommend the best product(s), not self-select. There's a high degree of trust involved!

PCdriver - yep, that's what I'm trying to understand.

Pommy - indeed, that's why I need to run a couple of scenarios, eg death, critical illness, unemployment to see what would have paid out in each case. if everything, great, if not, we have a problem Houston (possibly).

I pretty sure if there's a problem it will be one of overlap, but we shall see.
9mm Damn I'm a bit jealous of your fine port. I do have the benefit of a caipirinha available to me.......as well as 35 degree temperatures - currently in Brazil enjoying some winter sun. If you fail to get satisfaction from your broker, or from the company that provided the policies - then refer your case to the FSA who are responsible under law, for all insurance policies.
Sadly it's not particularly fine port but after the first glass or two I'm not sure it matters!

I think you've got the better deal. It's cold, wet and windy here with not a single Brazilian in sight. wink

pcvdriver

1,819 posts

230 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
9mm said:
Sadly it's not particularly fine port but after the first glass or two I'm not sure it matters!

I think you've got the better deal. It's cold, wet and windy here with not a single Brazilian in sight. wink
I think we're running the risk of going off topic here - but since you started off the thread - it's your perogative. I think I may have the better deal. I'm sure there are websites which show all the "Brazilians" you'd care to look at - I'm enjoying the real thing - and very nice they are too!!! Best of luck in your quest.

9mm

Original Poster:

3,128 posts

241 months

Saturday 4th January 2014
quotequote all
Right, here's the result of what I've been able to glean from the policy documentation. It's a long old read so don't waste your time if you aren't into insurance policy technicalities.

I'll also state up front my needs (as stated by me to the advisor) at the outset back in 2001. These are very simple, not unusual, and can be summarised as ensuring my mortgage would be paid off on death and that if I was incapacitated, terminally or temporarily, my mortgage would be paid until I recovered or died, and during that period I would also receive an income.

Despite the fact I said there were two policies in force, things are a little bit confusing as although I paid two separate single premiums and had two separate policy numbers, I see that the first policy did in fact contain TWO premiums. These are specified in the illustration but the policy schedule just shows the total figure that was paid monthly by direct debit. I guess the separate premiums shown is just a technical issue, given that the elements of the cover are all grouped under one policy number.

The other policy is simpler and standalone. This is what I had:

First, a product called Personal Cover. Cover commenced in April 2001. This contained the following elements:

Decreasing term assurance including critical illness cover - premium of £60 a month (all figures are rounded for simplicity).
Waiver of mortgage payment - premium of £30

Therefore a total of £90 a month which is the only figure I ever looked at.

Second, a product called Income Protection Plan. Cover commenced in April 2001. No sub-elements to this, just an index-linked payment (and premium) every month if ill/incapacitated, limited to two years of payments. Premium of £30 a month, index linked.

I can't see any problem with the pure life cover element of the Personal Cover because it wouldn't be affected or affect the Income Protection Plan. I die, my dependants get paid out and Income Protection is either paid up to my death and/or afterwards. The conflict, if I'm correct, is with the critical illness and waiver of mortgage payment components (WOMP) of the Personal Cover and the Income Protection Policy. This is why.

The first policy document for the Personal Cover plan, under the sub-section of Waiver of Mortgage Payment, contains this clause, pretty much verbatim:

Any continuing income from the following will be deducted:

Benefits under any other insurance payments for disability caused by illness or injury. These include other mortgage payment protection plans, INCOME PROTECTION POLICIES (my caps), creditor insurance covering loans and credit card payments and waiver of premium benefits.

The policy document for the Income Protection has different sub-headings but states:

The benefit payable will be reduced so that the total income received directly or indirectly by the policyholder while incapacitated is no more than the level set above. Income to be taken into account will be benefits payable under any other insurance policies for incapacity caused by illness or injury. These include other income protection policies, creditor insurance covering loans and credit card payments, WAIVER OF PREMIUM AND MORTGAGE PROTECTION PLANS (my caps again).

Sooooo......scenario one.....I drop dead with little or no warning.

In this case the life cover pays out and there's no need for critical illness, mortgage payment waiver or income protection to pay out. Conclusion - no policy conflict.

Scenario two - I get some nasty qualifying terminal illness and have say a couple of years to live.

In this case the critical illness cover kicks in and pays out the life sum assured. I also start to claim Waiver of Mortgage Payment and Income Protection. As I interpret things, either the waiver of mortgage payment (WOMP) would be reduced by the amount of income protection payments I receive or vice versa.

Scenario three - I can't work due to illness but its not terminal.

In this case, same as scenario two, I would claim WOMP and income protection but one would be offset against the other.

There you have it, am I missing something or is there a clear policy conflict meaning at least part of the premiums I have been paying for over a decade haven't provided the protection I wanted at all?

Instead of getting my mortgage paid each month and a separate income, what I WOULD have received is my mortgage paid and no separate income or an income but no mortgage paid - they would to a greater or lesser extent have cancelled themselves out.

Help!