Catching a murder
Discussion
I've been watching a few of those day time tv type murder detective shows, the sort people might watch during the school holidays.
The story line as almost always the same, the detective solves the crime, but has no evidence, so they plant an idea with the suspect which makes them return to the scene of the crime to destroy the incriminating evidence. But the evidence didn't really exist, or has already been removed, and when they are confronted, they have no other reason to explain their presence or what they are doing, so they instantly confess.
Does this sort of thing ever really happen, and if it does, does it ever work?
The story line as almost always the same, the detective solves the crime, but has no evidence, so they plant an idea with the suspect which makes them return to the scene of the crime to destroy the incriminating evidence. But the evidence didn't really exist, or has already been removed, and when they are confronted, they have no other reason to explain their presence or what they are doing, so they instantly confess.
Does this sort of thing ever really happen, and if it does, does it ever work?
ging84 said:
I've been watching a few of those day time tv type murder detective shows, the sort people might watch during the school holidays.
The story line as almost always the same, the detective solves the crime, but has no evidence, so they plant an idea with the suspect which makes them return to the scene of the crime to destroy the incriminating evidence. But the evidence didn't really exist, or has already been removed, and when they are confronted, they have no other reason to explain their presence or what they are doing, so they instantly confess.
Does this sort of thing ever really happen, and if it does, does it ever work?
It's well known that many serial killers return to the scene of the crime and some even use one spot as a kind of personal cemetery (Bundy). However, I have never read of the Police staking out a site and then catching the killer dropping off a new victim or interfering with the evidence apart from possibly Wayne Williams in Atlanta. They tried it with the Green River killer without success.The story line as almost always the same, the detective solves the crime, but has no evidence, so they plant an idea with the suspect which makes them return to the scene of the crime to destroy the incriminating evidence. But the evidence didn't really exist, or has already been removed, and when they are confronted, they have no other reason to explain their presence or what they are doing, so they instantly confess.
Does this sort of thing ever really happen, and if it does, does it ever work?
I think Sutcliffe also returned to the scenes of some of his crimes and interfered with bodies on at least one occasion. It's also well known that these people usually operate in a clearly defined area so those that work all over on a seemingly random basis (although it's often dictated by things like their job and they then select targets of opportunity) are particularly difficult to catch - think Robert Black.
I don't think it's much different where it's a one off as in the case of the sort of dramas you've been watching.
Murderers do sometimes return to the scene. Sometimes to see the effect of their 'work', sometimes a little more cunning and to put themselves at the scene to negate forensic links. These are a couple of reasons why scenes are fiercely guarded.
What you're describing looks like it belongs only in the world of fiction.
On the most basic level, a confession alone isn't enough to convict. One of the reason is to stop people, who for whatever reason, want to confess to things they've not done and there isn't any additional evidence to commit.
Murders have a very high detection rate. Most murderers are known to their victims. Many are domestic related. Detections come from solid basic police work, and in the modern world, strong forensic work.
Even when you get something like a gang shooting where the 'community' are highly reluctant to come forward and speak to the police, the information flow of who has done what comes in thick and fast from anonymous sources and other intelligence-gathering means, allowing for early investigatory opportunities.
They are also quite boring after the initial 'excitement'. Lots of laborious enquiries for the Major Incident Team detectives to do. Lots of house to house, loads of CCTV watching etc. I imagine the interviewing is quite interesting, but I suspect there's a bit of a pecking order. For the switched-on an ambitious, the SIO (Senior Investigation Officer) role must be one of the best senior-ranked roles available.
What you're describing looks like it belongs only in the world of fiction.
On the most basic level, a confession alone isn't enough to convict. One of the reason is to stop people, who for whatever reason, want to confess to things they've not done and there isn't any additional evidence to commit.
Murders have a very high detection rate. Most murderers are known to their victims. Many are domestic related. Detections come from solid basic police work, and in the modern world, strong forensic work.
Even when you get something like a gang shooting where the 'community' are highly reluctant to come forward and speak to the police, the information flow of who has done what comes in thick and fast from anonymous sources and other intelligence-gathering means, allowing for early investigatory opportunities.
They are also quite boring after the initial 'excitement'. Lots of laborious enquiries for the Major Incident Team detectives to do. Lots of house to house, loads of CCTV watching etc. I imagine the interviewing is quite interesting, but I suspect there's a bit of a pecking order. For the switched-on an ambitious, the SIO (Senior Investigation Officer) role must be one of the best senior-ranked roles available.
ging84 said:
I've been watching a few of those day time tv type murder detective shows, the sort people might watch during the school holidays.
The story line as almost always the same, the detective solves the crime, but has no evidence, so they plant an idea with the suspect which makes them return to the scene of the crime to destroy the incriminating evidence. But the evidence didn't really exist, or has already been removed, and when they are confronted, they have no other reason to explain their presence or what they are doing, so they instantly confess.
Does this sort of thing ever really happen, and if it does, does it ever work?
It would be very difficult to film in an hour's programme - about 40 mins airtime - to show the 'normal' enquiry into a murder. It is all about record keeping and following up information, or leads. What will be at the back of the senior investigating officer's (SIO) mind will be the file he or she has to send to the CPS as that is the important thing. Everything else is secondary.The story line as almost always the same, the detective solves the crime, but has no evidence, so they plant an idea with the suspect which makes them return to the scene of the crime to destroy the incriminating evidence. But the evidence didn't really exist, or has already been removed, and when they are confronted, they have no other reason to explain their presence or what they are doing, so they instantly confess.
Does this sort of thing ever really happen, and if it does, does it ever work?
That's not to suggest that a major incident enquiry is not exciting, just the reverse, but it is difficult to film. If you read a police procedural novel then you will see the problems a TV production might experience.
An SIO has been the subject of a number of dramas but they normally concentrate on a love affair or domestic situation. Yet most of the excitement is in the investigation. The general rule is that the team, with the one target, works well together in the early stages. As it goes on and doubts as to the result start to come it, then you can get factions.
It is vital not to go outside normal procedures as these will be exploited by the defence. Every decision, every action, has to have this as the concern.
For the Russell Bishop attempted murder trial, the SIO, as soon as he got the MO details, sent a sergeant and DC to arrest him as it was identical to the 'Babes in the Wood' double murder he was found NG of some years previously. This one decision gave the majority of the evidence against Bishop, a very brave decision by the SIO, but from then on the route the defence would use was apparent: they'd suggest that the incident room had just the once suspect so for the days, weeks and months of the enquiry it had to concentrate to an extent on following leads and suspects who everyone knew were innocent.
It was done so well that other suspects were not mentioned by the defence in the trial. However, it didn't stop the suggestion that the SIO was buddies with the SIO for the previous case and wanted to vindicate him. There were wild allegations of salting the scene with evidence gained from the early arrest. But the jury could see through the lies. But you cannot be too careful. Every move, every action, every entry into the HOLMES system has to be considered for gaps the defence can lever against.
So I doubt if any SIO, at least in England/Wales, could let their imagination go wild given the history of such methods.
I was told that Bishop served his full term.
I remember a murder in the Wrexham area, where the detectives planted a seed in the head of the main suspect that they knew the area where the body was, and it would just be a matter of time until they found it....
They then put surveillance on the main subject, and sure enough he went back to the body.....
They then put surveillance on the main subject, and sure enough he went back to the body.....
Being a Sussex man, I am very familiar with the Bishop case. Terrifyingly, he may well be released in the near future.
http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10656933.Bid_to_kee...__Babes_in_the_Wood__case_Russell_Bishop_in_jail/
http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10656933.Bid_to_kee...__Babes_in_the_Wood__case_Russell_Bishop_in_jail/
9mm said:
Being a Sussex man, I am very familiar with the Bishop case. Terrifyingly, he may well be released in the near future.
http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10656933.Bid_to_kee...__Babes_in_the_Wood__case_Russell_Bishop_in_jail/
The petition will not have, and should not have, any influence on the decision when to release Bishop.http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10656933.Bid_to_kee...__Babes_in_the_Wood__case_Russell_Bishop_in_jail/
As an aside, he tried to sue Sussex Police for malicious prosecution, amongst other things, for the Hadaway/Fellows investigation. His legal aid solicitor was very supportive but then, by some strange means, it was pointed out to Bishop that, as it was a civil case, all the evidence excluded at the trial might well be introduced and other things, like his lie about never having worn a watch, cleverly brought in when cross examination was impossible. You've got to hand it to Bishop, thick as two short, thick planks but could still manipulate the court with lies.
Many people felt that he was a danger to the public and should not be released and this was, I think, reflected in the penalty and the length of time he's been inside.
Shame that a retrial was rejected.
I'd put money on him doing it again. He is probably institutionalised by now and going back inside will hold no fears so some little girl will be sacrificed.
Derek Smith said:
9mm said:
Being a Sussex man, I am very familiar with the Bishop case. Terrifyingly, he may well be released in the near future.
http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10656933.Bid_to_kee...__Babes_in_the_Wood__case_Russell_Bishop_in_jail/
The petition will not have, and should not have, any influence on the decision when to release Bishop.http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10656933.Bid_to_kee...__Babes_in_the_Wood__case_Russell_Bishop_in_jail/
As an aside, he tried to sue Sussex Police for malicious prosecution, amongst other things, for the Hadaway/Fellows investigation. His legal aid solicitor was very supportive but then, by some strange means, it was pointed out to Bishop that, as it was a civil case, all the evidence excluded at the trial might well be introduced and other things, like his lie about never having worn a watch, cleverly brought in when cross examination was impossible. You've got to hand it to Bishop, thick as two short, thick planks but could still manipulate the court with lies.
Many people felt that he was a danger to the public and should not be released and this was, I think, reflected in the penalty and the length of time he's been inside.
Shame that a retrial was rejected.
I'd put money on him doing it again. He is probably institutionalised by now and going back inside will hold no fears so some little girl will be sacrificed.
9mm said:
Was that the actual killer or the bloke they totally stitched up?
Totally stitched up? who was that then?As far as I know, no-one has been charged in relation to this, although I have a strong suspicion who was responsible. He may be able to instruct libel lawyers so I won't say who however.
carreauchompeur said:
I'm sure it was done with the Susie Lamplugh case or similar, lots of overt Police activity digging up a field and the killer was pinged watching them...
Susie Lamplugh's body was never found and nobody has ever been charged with her abduction/murder ( linky), so you must be thinking of a different case.XCP said:
9mm said:
Was that the actual killer or the bloke they totally stitched up?
Totally stitched up? who was that then?As far as I know, no-one has been charged in relation to this, although I have a strong suspicion who was responsible. He may be able to instruct libel lawyers so I won't say who however.
Aretnap said:
carreauchompeur said:
I'm sure it was done with the Susie Lamplugh case or similar, lots of overt Police activity digging up a field and the killer was pinged watching them...
Susie Lamplugh's body was never found and nobody has ever been charged with her abduction/murder ( linky), so you must be thinking of a different case.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Rachel_Nick...
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


