Driving without insurance - summons received
Driving without insurance - summons received
Author
Discussion

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Hi all,

This is actually a post on behalf of my brother who is a Class 2 licence holder and a drives for a living.

He was pulled by an ANPR police car for driving without insurance in a company van. At the time he was under 25 and the initial problem seemed to be that the fleet policy didn't cover drivers under 25. On investigation his boss, who had arranged a new fleet policy only a few days before was able to get confirmation by email from the insurance company that in fact an additional sum had been paid to cover drivers under 25 and so my brother was in fact covered at the time of the pull. He is contacting his boss for copies of the information at the moment.

He has received a letter asking to appear at court or to plead guilty by post, I've not got the full details but presumably the mags.

Clearly he intends to plead not guilty but my reading online indicates that this will simply result in a trial being listed at a later date which we want to avoid.

His fiancé is just about to give birth (tomorrow!) and he already has 6 points so it is extremely important this be dealt with properly. I'm going to help him find a local solicitors for advice or maybe to appear but his finances are limited. I've also asked him to check if he has legal cover on his personal insurance policies as I think this would be covered.

Is there any way of nipping this in the bud now or will we be able to do it on the day?

Thanks,



Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
He may have to appear at court. He shouldn't need a solicitor if he can simply present evidence of cover at the relevant time.

SVTRick

3,633 posts

226 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
And when case dismissed put in his expenses / defence costs claim smile

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Amateurish said:
He may have to appear at court. He shouldn't need a solicitor if he can simply present evidence of cover at the relevant time.
Yes, that's what I thought we'd have to do. I didn't mention it above because it's detail that clouds the point but he no longer works for the old company so it's going to be slightly more difficult for him to get the info that normal.

Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Isn't he not liable as it was a company vehicle and he had no need to think he wasn't insured?

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Roo said:
Isn't he not liable as it was a company vehicle and he had no need to think he wasn't insured?
I always thought that it's the driver's responsibility as with tyres etc. Seems slightly wrong to me as I bet there isn't a professional driver in the country that rings his boss to check his insurance each morning and nor would it be practical to do so.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Roo said:
Isn't he not liable as it was a company vehicle and he had no need to think he wasn't insured?
Ignorance is not a defence.

richardgcs

150 posts

173 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
This doesnt make sense to me, why would an ANPR pick up that the driver was under 25 unless the vehicle wasnt insured at all ? Am I missing something(my marbles excepted)

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
I believe that it *is* a defence to show that you are driving a company vehicle and you had good reason to believe that it was insured (even though it wasn't).

But, the OP doesn't have to go there if he can show that he was in fact insured.

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
Roo said:
Isn't he not liable as it was a company vehicle and he had no need to think he wasn't insured?
Ignorance is not a defence.
But there is a statutory defence;

Road Traffic Act 1988
1988 c. 52 Part VI Compulsory insurance or security against third-party risks Section 143

(3) A person charged with using a motor vehicle in contravention of this section shall not be convicted if he proves—
(a) that the vehicle did not belong to him and was not in his possession under a contract of hiring or of loan,
(b) that he was using the vehicle in the course of his employment, and
that he neither knew nor had reason to believe that there was not in force in relation to the vehicle such a policy of insurance or security as is mentioned in subsection (1) above.

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Statutory defence. S143(3) Road Traffic Act 1988
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/52/sectio...
"(3)A person charged with using a motor vehicle in contravention of this section shall not be convicted if he proves—
(a)that the vehicle did not belong to him and was not in his possession under a contract of hiring or of loan,
(b)that he was using the vehicle in the course of his employment, and
(c)that he neither knew nor had reason to believe that there was not in force in relation to the vehicle such a policy of insurance or security as is mentioned in subsection (1) above."

ETA Looks like a few of us were posting at the same timelaugh

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Amateurish said:
Given the wording it would seem your brother has a statutory defence to the accusation. I therefore do wonder why he has been charged.

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
That's very useful to know of that defence!

I think that the company had changed insurances companies a day or two before the pull and so the ANPR database was slightly out of date. I may have got the reason for the pull wrong but it's not really the point I suppose as it could have come up for a more routine stop.

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
ywouldi said:
That's very useful to know of that defence!

I think that the company had changed insurances companies a day or two before the pull and so the ANPR database was slightly out of date. I may have got the reason for the pull wrong but it's not really the point I suppose as it could have come up for a more routine stop.
I've just called him up apparently it was an ANPR checkpoint and it pinged as not having a registered owner. Road side checks proved this was incorrect and a call to the insurer brought up the age issue. Obviously whoever the PC spoke to was incorrect (assuming the message from the boss is correct!)

The letter (awaiting a scan) says driving a motor vehicle without insurance, or words to that effect.

He had been employed with this established company for a year or so before this so he would have very good reason to believe that insurance was in force.

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
I once reported a fail to stop accident after someone hit my truck. After a month or so the local BiB contacted me and said they could do nothing but also commented that my truck wasn't showing on the insurance database. I work for an extremely large company and I'm insured to drive anything they own or hire and explained this and she said I'm not liable anyway as I can reasonably expect the vehicle I'm given by a company to be insured so that confirms the last few posts from the police point of view.

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
The alleged offence is:

Use a motor vehicle on a road/public place without third party insurance.
On DATE, in PLACE, blah blah used a motor vehicle.... when there was not in force in relation to that use such a policy of insurance or such a security in respect of third party risks as complied with the requirements of Part VI of the Road Traffic Act 1988.
Contrary to section 143 of the Road Traffic Act 1988 and Schedule 2 to the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988

I'm getting him to get the details of insurance from his then employer but it's looking promising with that statuary defence at lease. The PC's witness statement says that he called the company director who also (presumably before checking with the insurance company) confirmed that he believed the driver was insured.

What is crucial I suppose is the supporting docs from the insurance and if they can't be found then rely on the defence that he reasonably believed that he was covered under the companies insurance policy.

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
Surely if you can get hold of a human at the CPS and supply the relevant correspondence they would drop this rather than pushing it through to a hearing?

Makes sense to me, although in the real world who knows.

ywouldi

Original Poster:

765 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
surveyor said:
Surely if you can get hold of a human at the CPS and supply the relevant correspondence they would drop this rather than pushing it through to a hearing?

Makes sense to me, although in the real world who knows.
Yes, I'm rather hoping that is what I can manage to do!

I suspect it will be rather more difficult than that though!

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Friday 3rd January 2014
quotequote all
ywouldi said:
Yes, I'm rather hoping that is what I can manage to do!

I suspect it will be rather more difficult than that though!
What area did this happen in? Our local police that deal with NIPs and such for the Met area is in Sidcup Kent and are contactable and you also get someone sensible to talk to.