Crossing double white lines in the Clyde Tunnel
Discussion
A few hours ago I was going through the Clyde Tunnel in the right hand lane, I was giving my friend a lift home and he was giving me directions. As we got half way through the tunnel he told me that I need to take the exit immediately after the tunnel finishes so I need to be in the left hand lane.
Going thought the tunnel, there was a taxi tailgating me, however the left lane was clear of any traffic. I crossed the double white lines, the taxi passed me and I exited the tunnel and took the first exit.
This is where I changed lanes : https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?f=q&source=s_q&...
It turns out that there was a unmarked Audi A4 behind the taxi who saw me make the manoeuvre, stopped me and gave me 3 points and a £100 fine for 'not obeying white lines'
Now, I know that the double white lines are in place for when one tunnel is shut and they make one tunnel two way. Also, reading this: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2002/3113/regul...
"subject to paragraph (6), every vehicle proceeding on any length of road along which the marking has been so placed that, as viewed in the direction of travel of the vehicle, a continuous line is on the left of a broken line or of another continuous line, shall be so driven as to keep the first-mentioned continuous line on the right hand or off side of the vehicle."
This reads to me, like I should always be in the left hand lane?
Can I fight this ticket?
Thanks
Going thought the tunnel, there was a taxi tailgating me, however the left lane was clear of any traffic. I crossed the double white lines, the taxi passed me and I exited the tunnel and took the first exit.
This is where I changed lanes : https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?f=q&source=s_q&...
It turns out that there was a unmarked Audi A4 behind the taxi who saw me make the manoeuvre, stopped me and gave me 3 points and a £100 fine for 'not obeying white lines'
Now, I know that the double white lines are in place for when one tunnel is shut and they make one tunnel two way. Also, reading this: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2002/3113/regul...
"subject to paragraph (6), every vehicle proceeding on any length of road along which the marking has been so placed that, as viewed in the direction of travel of the vehicle, a continuous line is on the left of a broken line or of another continuous line, shall be so driven as to keep the first-mentioned continuous line on the right hand or off side of the vehicle."
This reads to me, like I should always be in the left hand lane?
Can I fight this ticket?
Thanks
A previous topic on this:
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Start on page 2 with the post from v70d
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Start on page 2 with the post from v70d
Edited by rewc on Sunday 5th January 00:00
rewc said:
A previous topic on this:
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Start on page 2 with the post from v70d
Thanks, I had a good read through it!http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Start on page 2 with the post from v70d
Edited by rewc on Sunday 5th January 00:00
If I'm reading this correctly, I'm buggered?
Red Devil said:
BonzoG said:
Regarding the existence of the some bye-law covering the Clyde Tunnel, a bit of digging reveals the imaginatively titled Strathclyde Regional Council Clyde Tunnel (Traffic Management) Order 198, but it seems nigh on impossible to find the full contents online. It'll be quite old given that SRC no longer exists!
The above order doesn't help. It merely transfers the powers in the extant Clyde Tunnel Byelaws to SRC.http://www.edinburgh-gazette.co.uk/issues/22046/pa...
Nothing online but I did find this - http://openlibrary.org/books/OL21482243M/Byelaws_f...
There is a tantalising clue in this list of charge codes here - http://www.disclosurescotland.co.uk/pdf/CHARGE%20C...
RTRA 1984 Sections 1&2: Cross separated traffic lanes when not authorised - Clyde Tunnel
Also
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukla/1991/20/schedul... - Part IV
BonzoG said:
Regarding the 'STAY IN LANE' markings though - how can they be relevant/add to the 'enforceability' of the lines, if they are upside down for traffic in lane 2. 
See above.
I think the only conclusion from the previous thread was that if you followed the letter of the law exactly as written, it would be illegal to even use the right hand lane in the tunnel.
Clearly this is ridiculous and not the intent - in my opinion it's fecking obvious from the upside down writing that the markings are meant for when the tunnel is in contraflow during roadworks - not normal day-to-day running.
I reckon you need to get in touch with Glasgow City Council and see the relevant orders/byelaws relating to traffic management in the tunnel - none of it appears to be online. Otherwise you are in a total grey area as the TSRGD wording only seems to make sense in the context of opposing lanes of traffic. Of course, the byelaws might mention nothing about the lines either - in which case you're still in a grey area and would need to convince a sheriff...
Personally I think whoever wrote you the ticket should be ashamed at such a petty waste of ink.
Clearly this is ridiculous and not the intent - in my opinion it's fecking obvious from the upside down writing that the markings are meant for when the tunnel is in contraflow during roadworks - not normal day-to-day running. I reckon you need to get in touch with Glasgow City Council and see the relevant orders/byelaws relating to traffic management in the tunnel - none of it appears to be online. Otherwise you are in a total grey area as the TSRGD wording only seems to make sense in the context of opposing lanes of traffic. Of course, the byelaws might mention nothing about the lines either - in which case you're still in a grey area and would need to convince a sheriff...
Personally I think whoever wrote you the ticket should be ashamed at such a petty waste of ink.
BonzoG said:
I think the only conclusion from the previous thread was that if you followed the letter of the law exactly as written, it would be illegal to even use the right hand lane in the tunnel.
Clearly this is ridiculous and not the intent - in my opinion it's fecking obvious from the upside down writing that the markings are meant for when the tunnel is in contraflow during roadworks - not normal day-to-day running.
I reckon you need to get in touch with Glasgow City Council and see the relevant orders/byelaws relating to traffic management in the tunnel - none of it appears to be online. Otherwise you are in a total grey area as the TSRGD wording only seems to make sense in the context of opposing lanes of traffic. Of course, the byelaws might mention nothing about the lines either - in which case you're still in a grey area and would need to convince a sheriff...
Personally I think whoever wrote you the ticket should be ashamed at such a petty waste of ink.
Clearly this is ridiculous and not the intent - in my opinion it's fecking obvious from the upside down writing that the markings are meant for when the tunnel is in contraflow during roadworks - not normal day-to-day running. I reckon you need to get in touch with Glasgow City Council and see the relevant orders/byelaws relating to traffic management in the tunnel - none of it appears to be online. Otherwise you are in a total grey area as the TSRGD wording only seems to make sense in the context of opposing lanes of traffic. Of course, the byelaws might mention nothing about the lines either - in which case you're still in a grey area and would need to convince a sheriff...
Personally I think whoever wrote you the ticket should be ashamed at such a petty waste of ink.
I'd be citing my reasons for changing lanes as one of safety due to the taxi - an unmarked plod car will have cameras surely which will have recorded just how close to your rear bumper he was. Might be worth firing off a letter to the duty inspector and PF explaining your actions. If the PF thinks that the case won't fly in court - they will usually withdrAw the charge to save wasting time and money in the courts, which are pretty full.
pcvdriver said:
I'd be citing my reasons for changing lanes as one of safety due to the taxi
Aye... might be clutching at straws but you could say you thought the taxi was going to run into the back of you as he was dangerously close...TSRGD 2002 Regulation 26 said:
(6) Nothing in paragraph (2)(b) shall be taken to prohibit a vehicle from being driven across, or so as to straddle, the continuous line referred to in that paragraph, if it is safe to do so and if necessary to do so—
(d)in order to avoid an accident;
(d)in order to avoid an accident;
BonzoG said:
pcvdriver said:
I'd be citing my reasons for changing lanes as one of safety due to the taxi
Aye... might be clutching at straws but you could say you thought the taxi was going to run into the back of you as he was dangerously close...TSRGD 2002 Regulation 26 said:
(6) Nothing in paragraph (2)(b) shall be taken to prohibit a vehicle from being driven across, or so as to straddle, the continuous line referred to in that paragraph, if it is safe to do so and if necessary to do so—
(d)in order to avoid an accident;
(d)in order to avoid an accident;
(a) to enable the vehicle to enter, from the side of the road on which it is proceeding, land or premises adjacent to the length of road on which the line is placed, or another road joining that road.
Whilst this was presumably drafted to address a need to turn right across a DWL, it does not appear to be limited to that situation, and arguably applies in the OP's. The further away from the "road joining [the tunnel] road" the OP was when crossing the lines, the weaker the argument might be. Had the OP turned square left at the exit, the exemption would have applied more obviously ... but a s3 RTA 1988 might have resulted instead.
Streaky
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


