Advice from publisher/libel lawyer sought
Advice from publisher/libel lawyer sought
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm writing a book about being a police officer in Brighton. I want to mention a boxer, well known in the area and nationally. I can't cover his identity by suggesting his name was Kevin and that he was an undefeated middle heavyweight champion and on that day had been fighting Dan Sherry.

He was arrested under a distress warrant and I want to bring this up. The whole thrust of the bit is improper conduct by two officers out for a laugh. It would be wrong to ignore the reason for the arrest as most people would jump to the conclusion that it was for a criminal offence.

The arrest, but not the reason, is a matter of public record.

Do I make myself liable for libel damages if I include this in the book? What precautions can I take?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Um... Contact the agent of the boxer and ask if they are happy for you to include the story?

If they are OK with it you can perhaps write a better account of the story than one that tries to jump through legal loopholes.

If they say no, you can still write the story, but will need to do that jumping.

williaa68

1,540 posts

197 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
The law has just changed (1 Jan) but you should be ok. I was looking at something last week in a corporate context and decided we were stuffed. I found the guide at the link below quite helpful:

http://www.taylorwessing.com/fileadmin/files/docs/...

Good luck with the book.

wildcat45

8,160 posts

220 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all

The libel laws changed a bit a few days ago. I am not a lawyer however.

Is what you plan to say true? Was it reported at the time? So long as you tell the full true story, I would imagine yuo would minimise the risk of a problem.

So and so was arrested, but later released without charge. if it happened, it happened. They may be issues if it went to court relating to injunctions erc.

In a nutshell, the new libel laws mean it has to be proved that you caused serious harm by publishing something. There is also potentially the public interest defence too.

I have a working knowledge of this, but it would be better in my view to let a solicitor cast their eyes over what you plan to say.

I enjoyed your last book - especially the bit about the bloke the Fleet Street bar. Look forward to the next one.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
You bank on one or the other...........

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
It's a question rather than an opinion... would the person arrested have any expectation of privacy relating to information surrounding the arrest that was not in the public domain or heard in open court? Did the court dealing put in place any reporting restrictions that may last into perpetuity?

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
williaa68 said:
The law has just changed (1 Jan) but you should be ok. I was looking at something last week in a corporate context and decided we were stuffed. I found the guide at the link below quite helpful:

http://www.taylorwessing.com/fileadmin/files/docs/...

Good luck with the book.
Thanks for the link.

wildcat45 said:
The libel laws changed a bit a few days ago. I am not a lawyer however.

Is what you plan to say true? Was it reported at the time? So long as you tell the full true story, I would imagine yuo would minimise the risk of a problem.

So and so was arrested, but later released without charge. if it happened, it happened. They may be issues if it went to court relating to injunctions erc.

In a nutshell, the new libel laws mean it has to be proved that you caused serious harm by publishing something. There is also potentially the public interest defence too.

I have a working knowledge of this, but it would be better in my view to let a solicitor cast their eyes over what you plan to say.

I enjoyed your last book - especially the bit about the bloke the Fleet Street bar. Look forward to the next one.
My last book, thanks for the comments, was read by a publisher who gave me advice about what I could and could not include. It was difficult to understand why one thing was perfectly OK, yet another gave her palpitations. This is what is worrying me.

Oddly enough two bits she cut because, she said, they were unbelievable. I mentioned that I had pocket book entries to support both and there would be court records but she said that being true didn't matter. If people read it and didn't believe it, then they'd rubbish it.

I put one on here and, sure enough, two people said that it was lies. So she knew what she was talking about.

I might include the other in the new book but modified slightly.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
It's a question rather than an opinion... would the person arrested have any expectation of privacy relating to information surrounding the arrest that was not in the public domain or heard in open court? Did the court dealing put in place any reporting restrictions that may last into perpetuity?
The arrest was under warrant for sort of non-payment. I won't be specific as I don't want to cause anyone any distress so to speak, especially his previous wife.

The matter was settled without the chap going to court.

It would not be difficult to cover the warrant type as such, just by mentioning that it wasn't criminal, etc.

The arrest itself was quite generously covered by the press at the time and a release from the police PR clarified that he had been taken to the station, but not processed, and released without charge.

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
I am sure BV will be along soon.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
And, as if by magic....

Truth is an absolute defence to a claim of libel.

10PS astutely raises the more tricky issue: would the publication infringe a protectable right to privacy? I would say not, as the reason for an arrest is a legitimate matter for publication, but it could be argued that in relation to an old matter there is now a legitimate expectation of privacy.

Note that a non public body has no directly enforceable obligation to respect privacy, but a court, as a public body, must respect privacy where article 8 ECHR is engaged. The law of confidence is not quite the same thing, and can bind an individual. It would perhaps be arguable here that if the info came to your knowledge in the course of your police work, it was impressed with a confidence.

Could you not simply say "X was arrested in relation to a civil matter that was later resolved"?


anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Um... Contact the agent of the boxer and ask if they are happy for you to include the story?

If they are OK with it you can perhaps write a better account of the story than one that tries to jump through legal loopholes.

If they say no, you can still write the story, but will need to do that jumping.
I do not agree with this suggestion. It is unwise to let someone think he has some degree of editorial control over your work (unless he is your editor). A journalist offering the right to rebut is one thing, but engaging in correspondence with the agent of a present or former celeb is in my experience rarely likely to be helpful in the present context.

The law of libel is plain, and no loopholes are required. As noted above, the real issue, if there is one, is in the less plain area of privacy and confidence.

wildcat45

8,160 posts

220 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
That's good advice. And not just from a legal perspective. Only under exceptional circumstances will I allow someone to see a script, or story before transmisison or publication.

I have seen TV programme productinos stop dead in their tracks when the subject of a show saw sight of a script before air. (This may have been the fault of a very young inexperienced me thinking he was being helpful in handing them the script..)

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
In my youth, I worked for a while as the night libel lawyer on the Observer, and briefly as a chat show libel lawyer for Sky TV (thirty minutes from recording to transmission), and we were always chary of anything that might involve handing over editorial control. There were some spirited debates in the editor's office at the Observer, especially on Maxwell stories. The chat show was easy, and had an audience of about twelve anyway. A friend of mine is chief legal honcho at ITV, and he has to battle the company's own journos sometimes as they don't even want him to get his oar in.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
10PS astutely raises the more tricky issue: would the publication infringe a protectable right to privacy? I would say not, as the reason for an arrest is a legitimate matter for publication, but it could be argued that in relation to an old matter there is now a legitimate expectation of privacy.
That last bit, as to it being an old matter, was of concern. This was 1991, but it has to be said that the person was far from shy about publicity in those days and after a quick Google it could be seen that this has persisted.

I liked the bloke. He was obviously a tremendous boxer, his record shows that, and was something of a character as well. He was arrested for a criminal matter some time later, but I wasn't involved.

The bit in the book hardly does him a disservice. We did have a bit of a face-off one time but he was under a lot of moral pressure to take sides and one could not criticise him for that.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Of course, if the boxer is generally so well known and has a particular association with a place, perhaps having purchased title of being "Lord of the Manor" there, you might still have issues sufficiently anonymising it. wink

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Would my suggested wording above fit the bill? I think I can guess which one of a few boxers of that era this might be.

wildcat45

8,160 posts

220 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
It can be tough. I used to work for a big broadcaster and our company legal man would say no to just about anything you wanted to do.

I have a working knowledge of defamation, libel and reporting from court. If anything I am over cautious about stuff using the "if in doubt, leave it out" excuse perhaps too much to the frustration of journalists I have been in charge of.

Our legal guy did sometimes make things worse.

An example was a case where we reported that a bloke had appeared in mags court charged with something or other. The bloke didn't like that his name had benn mentioned on the radio. We were free to report this as his solicitor well knew. Somehow our company lawyer got involved and it invovled days of hassle, when the solictor should simply have been told to jog on.

I ended up handling a lot of stuff like that in my own way, rather than getting our man invovled. A bloke convicted of child porn charges but only fined, turned up shouting the odds outside the studios one day. He was going to sue us, me, my dog, ruin our lives, you name it. I delt with that in about 3 minutes with the help of our security guard and the threat of a call to the cops.

There was the time I was accused of contempt. Somethign mis-heard by a court employee and reported to the judge. Myself and another guy went to see the judge ourselves. It was sorted within minutes - though quite an intimidating experience. Our man would have probably had me say sorry and do 2 years on H wing for it!

Edited by wildcat45 on Sunday 5th January 12:33

daveinaravecave

1,149 posts

166 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Do you have Professional Indemnity Insurance?

Google "Indemnity Insurance for Writers" and one of the first links that appears is www.societyofauthors.org/insurance

You could contact insurers directly for a quote although you will that they are likely to be non-advisory i.e. can provide info about what it might cover (the basics) but can't tell you about levels of cover required etc.

The Society of Authors will likely have a scheme deal in place with a selected insurer and it will maybe cost less for membership/guidance & insurance combined.

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
My last book, thanks for the comments, was read by a publisher who gave me advice about what I could and could not include. It was difficult to understand why one thing was perfectly OK, yet another gave her palpitations. This is what is worrying me.
Presumably you're going the same route this time, and will take the publisher's advice, as and when?


Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
daveinaravecave said:
Do you have Professional Indemnity Insurance?

Google "Indemnity Insurance for Writers" and one of the first links that appears is www.societyofauthors.org/insurance

You could contact insurers directly for a quote although you will that they are likely to be non-advisory i.e. can provide info about what it might cover (the basics) but can't tell you about levels of cover required etc.

The Society of Authors will likely have a scheme deal in place with a selected insurer and it will maybe cost less for membership/guidance & insurance combined.
I have but there are conditions. I'll have to check with them but, of course, that's shutting the stable door sort of thing.

SV8Predator said:
Presumably you're going the same route this time, and will take the publisher's advice, as and when?
I've got no intention of going against the advice or professionals. I'll have to change the story a bit, something that I wanted to avoid unless absolutely necessary. With the first book, I made certain that, apart from those I wanted to put the boot into, individuals were impossible to identify. With the new one, recent history means that this is impossible. Readers will have to put emphasis on what I don't say.

There was one super who tried to fit up a PC. I'd love to give his name, or make him easy to identify, but can't.