Arrest for not having I.D.
Author
Discussion

Bigends

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Just watching a programme on Policing in Brighton - PC breaks up a fight and arrests one of the participants for failing to produce i.d. and being anti-social - is there some sort of bye-law down there?

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

201 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Are you suggesting a police officer can't arrest someone in order to ascertain their identify when they are suspected of an offence?
That would be a bit silly, no?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
If you commit an offence (any offence) it can result in arrest, where an arrest is necessary. An arrest can be necessary for a number of stipulated reasons. One of those is to enable the name of the person in question to be ascertained (in the case where the constable does not know, and cannot readily ascertain, the person’s name, or has reasonable grounds for doubting whether a name given by the person as his name is his real name). the same applies to their address.

Bigends

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
The script went

Pc grabs miscreant and shouts ' I.D - I.D.'

Miscreant- 'I aint got none'

PC 'Right, your under arrest for not having ID and for being anti-social'


Its not an offence not to carry ID in the UK as far as i'm aware.

Now -had he nicked him for the assault we'd all just witnessed or a public order offence.......

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
PACE General Power of arrest.
Probably 'Name & address not known and cannot be ascertained'
Simple version here:
http://www.west-midlands.police.uk/contact-us/comp...

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
How many of us walk about without ID of some form or other ?

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
It's been discussed before but I think it should be mandatory to carry your photo driving licence.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Bigends said:
The script went

Pc grabs miscreant and shouts ' I.D - I.D.'

Miscreant- 'I aint got none'

PC 'Right, your under arrest for not having ID and for being anti-social'


Its not an offence not to carry ID in the UK as far as i'm aware.

Now -had he nicked him for the assault we'd all just witnessed or a public order offence.......
The offence isn't not having ID.

Arrest needs to be supported by two strands
1) An offence - i.e. assault, public order etc.
2) Necessity to arrest - i.e Code G PACE 1984 - Not satisfied as to identity or danger of physical injury to self or another etc.

Pet Troll

1,363 posts

209 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
I can't remember the last time I went somewhere without ID on me. I don't go out without my wallet, in case I need to buy something, and my wallet has my photocard driving licence in it. Failing that I always have my phone on me and could easily dig out a scan of some ID from my emails.

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Unfortunately the majority suffer for the actions of the minority.
Responses to 'What's your name' of 'M. Mouse, officer' or other can be included in the list.
That said, I believe we are still one of the few countries where carrying ID is not compulsory. Again IIRC that's why we need passports to travel around the EEC unlike everyone else who just do it national identity cards.

Bigends

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Bigends said:
The script went

Pc grabs miscreant and shouts ' I.D - I.D.'

Miscreant- 'I aint got none'

PC 'Right, your under arrest for not having ID and for being anti-social'


Its not an offence not to carry ID in the UK as far as i'm aware.

Now -had he nicked him for the assault we'd all just witnessed or a public order offence.......
The offence isn't not having ID.

Arrest needs to be supported by two strands
1) An offence - i.e. assault, public order etc.
2) Necessity to arrest - i.e Code G PACE 1984 - Not satisfied as to identity or danger of physical injury to self or another etc.
Exactly my point - he had a perfectly good public order offence to nick him for and he needed nicking to stop things escalating. I doubt any assault allegation would have been supported looking at those involved. Just wondered if there was any byelaw in relation to carrying i.d. in Brighton

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
No, it really should not.

issues of liberty aside, what about people who cant drive? Perhaps we can chip them, or maybe theyd prefer a barcode tattoo that can be scanned?

Bigends

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Mr GrimNasty said:
Are you suggesting a police officer can't arrest someone in order to ascertain their identify when they are suspected of an offence?
That would be a bit silly, no?
No, i'm saying they dont have to carry i.d - I carry credit cards and my works id but probably wouldnt produce either on request without a damn good reason

Edited by Bigends on Sunday 5th January 18:32

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Bigends said:
vonhosen said:
Bigends said:
The script went

Pc grabs miscreant and shouts ' I.D - I.D.'

Miscreant- 'I aint got none'

PC 'Right, your under arrest for not having ID and for being anti-social'


Its not an offence not to carry ID in the UK as far as i'm aware.

Now -had he nicked him for the assault we'd all just witnessed or a public order offence.......
The offence isn't not having ID.

Arrest needs to be supported by two strands
1) An offence - i.e. assault, public order etc.
2) Necessity to arrest - i.e Code G PACE 1984 - Not satisfied as to identity or danger of physical injury to self or another etc.
Exactly my point - he had a perfectly good public order offence to nick him for and he needed nicking to stop things escalating. I doubt any assault allegation would have been supported looking at those involved. Just wondered if there was any byelaw in relation to carrying i.d. in Brighton
Well that's what he was arrested for then, the public order offence. After that the officer would have to provide to the custody officer both evidence of the offence & evidence to support the necessity to deal with it by way of arrest that would satisfy Code G.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Do we get the police that we deserve? I suspect that the yute was in line for a fixed penalty, but without the means to identify himself he was being arrested for whatever offence he committed.

Youd hope that the PC would be able to articulate this, of course.

Reminds me of the ignorant bell-end from TVP in the Roads Wars programme, who greeted everyone s Mate and then became aggressive and confrontational when a (or another, depending on your point of view) scrubber addressed him as Mate.

Bigends

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Bigends said:
vonhosen said:
Bigends said:
The script went

Pc grabs miscreant and shouts ' I.D - I.D.'

Miscreant- 'I aint got none'

PC 'Right, your under arrest for not having ID and for being anti-social'


Its not an offence not to carry ID in the UK as far as i'm aware.

Now -had he nicked him for the assault we'd all just witnessed or a public order offence.......
The offence isn't not having ID.

Arrest needs to be supported by two strands
1) An offence - i.e. assault, public order etc.
2) Necessity to arrest - i.e Code G PACE 1984 - Not satisfied as to identity or danger of physical injury to self or another etc.
Exactly my point - he had a perfectly good public order offence to nick him for and he needed nicking to stop things escalating. I doubt any assault allegation would have been supported looking at those involved. Just wondered if there was any byelaw in relation to carrying i.d. in Brighton
Well that's what he was arrested for then, the public order offence. After that the officer would have to provide to the custody officer both evidence of the offence & evidence to support the necessity to deal with it by way of arrest that would satisfy Code G.
Read above -he was nicked at the scene for not having id!!! No doubt dealt with in custody for other matters but was arrested for an offence that doesnt exist

mygoldfishbowl

4,304 posts

174 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
How many of us walk about without ID of some form or other ?
It may be a generation thing but I do quite regularly without planning or thinking about it. I also like having paper money in my pocket & leaving my mobile, which I only really need for work, switched off at home.

4v6

1,098 posts

157 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Exige77 said:
It's been discussed before but I think it should be mandatory to carry your photo driving licence.
Theres no photo on a paper licence. smile

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Bigends said:
The script went

Pc grabs miscreant and shouts ' I.D - I.D.'

Miscreant- 'I aint got none'

PC 'Right, your under arrest for not having ID and for being anti-social'


Its not an offence not to carry ID in the UK as far as i'm aware.

Now -had he nicked him for the assault we'd all just witnessed or a public order offence.......
If I understand correctly you dont necessarily need to explain in detail why the person is being arrested - they just need to get the gist - obviously the copper should be able to explain if asked.

So perhaps he got the shorthand version but the copper had a mroe legal explanation that he could have provided?

Bigends

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
4v6 said:
Exige77 said:
It's been discussed before but I think it should be mandatory to carry your photo driving licence.
Theres no photo on a paper licence. smile
It is...while youre driving a car -I only have one of the old pink 'uns