Daughter's GTi Has Died..... Help Please..
Daughter's GTi Has Died..... Help Please..
Author
Discussion

V8 Disco

Original Poster:

474 posts

238 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Hi, eldest has a Mk3 Golf GTi 2.0 8v - which broke down Christmas eve in heavy rain. Apparently it spluttered, then died. AA patrol came out and found no spark. Car was running well beforehand.


Please can someone suggest where to start? (ie common faults/failures?) There is fuel in the tank and the engine spins without any worrying mechanical noises but there's no hint of it firing.

Cheers.

cuprabob

19,958 posts

245 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Possibly a crank sensor. I had the same same symptoms on an Ibiza fitted with the same engine many years ago and that's what it was.


Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Being a female did she drive through a flood and not tell you? wink. Could be any ignition part, i.e something as simple as an ht lead, or the coil, or the coil lead, or the condenser, or the points, dont know if Golf mk3 had electronic ignition. Start with the cheap bits and work through them methodically....

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Monday 6th January 2014
quotequote all
With modern ECU control and injection fueling the days of guessing have gone. Did the AA man not offer any suggestions from his examination? When was the car last serviced? Could be Cam sensor, Crank sensor, coil packs or ECU problem. Indeed without an appropriate computer loaded up to the car then: Who Knows? I do hope you get it sorted out but with modern cars you need specialist electrical appreciation. Good Luck.

bob bobbleton

68 posts

196 months

Monday 6th January 2014
quotequote all
The badge on the front is the problem

FEZZA BOB

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Monday 6th January 2014
quotequote all
Does seem very much like a water/electrical issue. First off start with the basics like the battery, the terminals, the alternator/starter wiring and then move onto the earth lead from the batttery>wing?gearbox

The ECU on mk3 golfs is up in the scuttle panel under the wiper motor , it is fairly common for the the scuttle drain holes to get blocked up and the entire scuttle ending up like a lake - with a ECU floating in it! Get the plastic cover off and inspect the corners and clean up the drain holes

Other common mk3 issues are water leaks from the sunroof drains that go down the A pillar , through the inner wing and into the inner wheel arch. If you feel the carpet on the drivers side footwell is it wet going up the firewall and behind the fuse box? Water can get in and soak the fusebox.

Another common and cheap fix is the ECU relay which if it is being temperamental will lead to no spark/no fuel.

Luckily though your car has VAG-COM so a code reader can be used to test all the sensors which makes fault finding a whole lot easier.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Monday 6th January 2014
quotequote all
aka_kerrly said:
Does seem very much like a water/electrical issue. First off start with the basics like the battery, the terminals, the alternator/starter wiring and then move onto the earth lead from the batttery>wing?gearbox

The ECU on mk3 golfs is up in the scuttle panel under the wiper motor , it is fairly common for the the scuttle drain holes to get blocked up and the entire scuttle ending up like a lake - with a ECU floating in it! Get the plastic cover off and inspect the corners and clean utp the drain holes

Other common mk3 issues are water leaks from the sunroof drains that go down the A pillar , through the inner wing and into the inner wheel arch. If you feel the carpet on the drivers side footwell is it wet going up the firewall and behind the fuse box? Water can get in and soak the fusebox.

Another common and cheap fix is the ECU relay which if it is being temperamental will lead to no spark/no fuel.

Luckily though your car has VAG-COM so a code reader can be used to test all the sensors which makes fault finding a whole lot easier.
I do not know how the OP got on but the advice above detailed model specific and absolutely excellent advice particularly the last line:

"Luckily though your car has VAG-COM so a code reader can be used to test all the sensors which makes fault finding a whole lot easier."

This is really the only way with ECU driven cars nothing else works like a code reader. Modern cars require computer based diagnostics. That is apparently progress. It certainly allows the remarkable performance economy and reliability offered by modern engines.

Good luck with the repairs.

V8 Disco

Original Poster:

474 posts

238 months

Monday 6th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the helpful replies. I have someone lending a code reader next weekend so I hope to have a better idea what's going on then. Water ingress was my first concern, it is very lowered and as a result has no arch liners.. (yes, I know.. was just grateful she's a petrol head!) .... however much wd-40 on the visible electrics did nothing so maybe not. Am worried about the ECU being awash - will check tomorrow.

Thanks again, will update when I get it running again. MOT time after that... more expense!

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Monday 6th January 2014
quotequote all
In Order of likely

Crank Sender
Distributor Hall Sender (don't get confused if the code reader says no signal when the car isn't running btw)
ECU Relay
Coil (only 1 on these beauties smile )

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
I had a mk2 ibiza 1.4 8v and hit a puddle in the dark i didn't see as i would have slowed down, car would not accelerate and was running awful afterwards and thought i'd got water in the cylinder it was that bad

left the car for a number of days while i was away and came back fine, sounds like water ingress as stated but its a case of finding where i think

Ads17

66 posts

224 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
One thing it could be:

Does the distributor cap (orange colour) have a black cover over it?
Common issue on the MK3 that moisture can get trapped between the 2 and cause the spark to arc and not fire.

Solution is to take off black cover and throw it away over your left shoulder then ensure the distributor cap is bone dry inside and out then re-assemble.


V8 Disco

Original Poster:

474 posts

238 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Worth a try, thank you - Due to the rain I have water inside the house at the moment, let alone the DC of V8 minor's broken down VW... but will check asap.