"What sentence" for these serious crimes?
"What sentence" for these serious crimes?
Author
Discussion

andycaca

Original Poster:

472 posts

159 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Reasonable anonymity here as I'm not sure what I can and cannot say before the imminent trial, so please bare with me.

Person M is up in court accused of the following:
Causing death by dangerous driving,
Driving without due care and attention,
Drink driving,
Driving other than in accordance with a driving license.

Brief facts. Person M is at a friend's house one evening. Leaves in the early hours of the morning. Gets in car, drives home on an A road. Has head on collision with small car.Police turn up, breathalyse and arrest. Person M highly intoxicated. Driver of small car dies a few hours later in hospital. Driver of small car was a nurse who was returning home after a late shift.

Obviously Person M is bang to rights. There are lots of other words and phrases we could use to describe the accused too...

I assume the 4th charge of "Driving other than in accordance with a driving license" means the license isn't valid, presumably due to points totting up or Drink/Driving. Or possibly the photocard portion of the license expired, which is not as serious (is it?) as having previous for Drink/Driving.

Now you've had the tasty facts, what kind and length of sentence would you expect the judge to hand down? Obviously it must be a custodial sentence (this webpage has a friendly explanation of sentencing guidelines - http://www.findlaw.co.uk/law/criminal/drink_drivin... ) and having considered the aggravating circumstances surely 10 years or so is on the cards?

I believe sentencing is due take place within the month, OP will return with the result.

edit: link is http://www.findlaw.co.uk/law/criminal/drink_drivin...

Edited by andycaca on Tuesday 7th January 15:24

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Are they serial scum or not?


Someone who has worked all their life and done a one off utterly stupid mistake then 10 to 15 years


Serial scum they might get 5 years out in 1


Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Your link doesn't lead anywhere.

Edit: yes it does. laugh

Edited by Johnnytheboy on Wednesday 8th January 08:37

andycaca

Original Poster:

472 posts

159 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Not serial scum (AFAIK). Used to be something of a high-flyer (oil industry), hit upon difficult times in the last couple of years and turned to the drink whilst everything slipped away. I'm still unsure if Person M has previous convictions or not.

Scum or not, M deserves everything dished out imo.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
andycaca said:
Gets in car, drives home on an A road. Has head on collision with small car.Police turn up, breathalyse and arrest. Person M highly intoxicated. Driver of small car dies a few hours later in hospital. Driver of small car was a nurse who was returning home after a late shift.

Obviously Person M is bang to rights.
Why bang to rights on all counts?
Seems like drink driving (and the license thing) are all provable, but from what you've described it's not possible to comment on the death by dangerous or careless driving.

Playing devils advocate here: Person M could have been stationary in a queue of traffic and the person in the small car could have crossed the white line and hit them head on. Clearly driver M is still drunk, but it is possible they didn't cause the accident. So I think we need some more info on how the crash was actually caused in order to assess culpability.

andycaca

Original Poster:

472 posts

159 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
Playing devils advocate here
Good point. We don't rightly know the exact circumstances. I am hoping to be able to attend court later this month (public gallery) to find out more.

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
Im not sure why I think this, but I seem to recall that if you are pissed you are deemed to have caused the accident by default unless you can prove otherwise.
Did I make that up?

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Im not sure why I think this, but I seem to recall that if you are pissed you are deemed to have caused the accident by default unless you can prove otherwise.
Did I make that up?
I hope so.

KFC

3,687 posts

161 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
andycaca said:
I assume the 4th charge of "Driving other than in accordance with a driving license" means the license isn't valid, presumably due to points totting up or Drink/Driving. Or possibly the photocard portion of the license expired, which is not as serious (is it?) as having previous for Drink/Driving.
I think you really need to clarify this point before anyone could take a sensible estimate at sentence - there is obviously a world of difference between driving with an expired photocard, and killing someone whilst drunk, while currently banned for drink driving...

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
If he was banned rom driving, for any offence or through totting, the charge would be driving while disqualified. Driving otherwise than accordance means he didn't have a licence, either because he'd never passed a test for that class of vehicle, or because it had been revoked for medical reasons... or because he headn't sent it in for endorsement over a speeding ticket or because he hasn't renewed it when he turned 70. How serious it is depends on whether it was essentially a matter of not doing the right admin or whether there was a good reason why he couldn't hold a licence at all, but either way it's less serious than driving while disqualified.

An expired photocard wouldn't (or at least shouldn't) lead to a driving otherwise charge - that's a different offence again, akin to failing to update your licence when you move house.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
andycaca said:
Not serial scum (AFAIK). Used to be something of a high-flyer (oil industry), hit upon difficult times in the last couple of years and turned to the drink whilst everything slipped away. I'm still unsure if Person M has previous convictions or not.

Scum or not, M deserves everything dished out imo.
Used to work and have a good job

Probably death sentence

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Im not sure why I think this, but I seem to recall that if you are pissed you are deemed to have caused the accident by default unless you can prove otherwise.
Did I make that up?
Erm, yes you did. The prosecution have to prove all the elements of the offence, including that the manner of driving was careless/dangerous (over and above being drunk), and that the bad driving caused the death.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
The OPs opening post seems contradictory; is 'M' going to trial shortly, or being sentenced next month following guilty verdicts or plea?

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
The full sentencing guidelines are here.

http://sentencingcouncil.judiciary.gov.uk/docs/web...

See especially pages 10-11, and 12-13 for the other possible charge of causing death by careless driving while under the influence of drugs or alcohol. It's difficult to comment meaningfully without knowing just how drunk he was or just how bad the driving was, but if convicted he's certainly looking at several years in prison... though probably not as many as the vuctim's family and friends would probably think would reflect the enormity of what happened.

agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
andycaca said:
Reasonable anonymity here as I'm not sure what I can and cannot say before the imminent trial, so please bare with me.
If there was at least one court hearing then his name, address, charges - anything that has been mentioned in court. Criminal cases are not held in private.

Custody inevitable. 2-6 years. More likely the higher end of that range - brief facts suggest level 1 death by dangerous. Will serve half in a prison and the remainder on licence. Guilty plea at an early stage would significantly reduce the sentence in this case - one-third off is typical at an early stage. No discount given if convicted after trial.

Don't understand multiple offences. Indictment appears over-loaded to me. Are summary only offences on the back of the indictment? Concurrent sentences for all but death by dangerous.

Ban from driving and extended retest. 5 years? Will be minimum 3 if 2nd drink drive conviction within 10 years.


Edited by agtlaw on Tuesday 7th January 22:44

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
andycaca said:
... please bare with me.
I'll strip off after you do. Promise! wink

Streaky

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
If they're insured with an Admiral Group company they can expect the Insurers to pursue them for any money they pay out to the other party

andycaca

Original Poster:

472 posts

159 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Apologies for the delay, I have had to do some work today and only just logged on!

To clear up a few things, M has had a first appearance in Magistrates court the other day, this was then directly bumped up to crown court which is taking place on the 21st of this month. No plea was submitted at Magistrates court, so I assume the most likely course of events will be M turn up at Crown court on the 21st to plead guilty (after seeing the evidence against him) and another Crown court date arranged for actual sentencing? Can agtlaw offer his opinion on the process?

Links to the incident in question as appeared in local press...

Original incident:
http://www.edp24.co.uk/news/woman_dies_following_a...
Magistrate's appearance:
http://www.edp24.co.uk/news/norfolk_man_accused_of...


streaky, fire up the webcam laugh

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Im not sure why I think this, but I seem to recall that if you are pissed you are deemed to have caused the accident by default unless you can prove otherwise.
Did I make that up?
There was a case a while back that rings a bell.
A disqualified driver, or perhaps uninsured, had a crash and was found by default at fault because of it. The argument being they shouldn't have been on the road.

But, this was overturned at a higher court.


agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
In Hughes [2013] UKSC 56, the Supreme Court held that to be guilty of a s3ZB offence, it must be proved that D did or omitted to do something that contributed in more than a minimal way to the death. There must in other words be something more than mere 'but for' causation.

However, the defendant faces a different offence here. Pros to prove:

1. The defendant's driving was dangerous
2. The defendant's [dangerous] driving was "a cause" of death. Not the cause or the main cause, but "a cause".

The sad consequence of death does not mean that the driving was dangerous. It may have been, in law, careless. The brief facts as mentioned by OP (high BAC) suggest that D would have a mountain to climb at trial.

The chronology is:

1. Magistrates' Court hearing - case sent to crown.
2. Crown Court preliminary hearing - timetable set down
3. Crown Court plea and case management hearing
4. Trial

If D pleads guilty at any stage (and plea acceptable) then case adjourned for pre-sentence report.

I wouldn't necessarily expect D to plead guilty at the preliminary hearing. Depends if the prosecution case is overwhelming. At hearing #2 CPS is given a deadline to serve case papers on defence.

Defence strategy is likely to be an offer to plead guilty to death by careless or death by careless or another offence. The purpose of which would be to reduce the available sentence. CPS may accept this but may not. A lot of these cases are not about guilt but whether D is guilty of death by dangerous or some other offence.

Edited by agtlaw on Wednesday 8th January 19:27