1.6 TDI Question
Author
Discussion

VX5195

Original Poster:

147 posts

167 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
I am currently considering purchasing a Seat Ibiza (second hand but the new shape one) and was wondering what the 1.6 TDI CR is like in comparison to the 2.0 TDI CR which you can also get in the Ibiza (FR trim only though)

I was thinking in terms of performance and torque, and obviously fuel economy?

Thanks in advance

SteBrown91

3,169 posts

160 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
The 1.6 is not a bad engine, will probably go mid 50's to the gallon easily, but apparently in golfs and the like it a bit gutless. However in the lighter ibiza might be a better engine

I once had a 143 2.0 golf as a hiire car (same engine as ibiza 2.0) and I averaged mid 40's driving it like a hire car should be driven. Should also do low-mid 50's in the ibiza I would assume. Personally I'd go for the 2.0 as 0-60 time is almost the same as the Golf GTD 170 due to the lighter body so should shift a fair bit. Also, the 6th gear would be a godsend on a cruise.

Dr G

16,015 posts

273 months

Tuesday 7th January 2014
quotequote all
We've got 1.6 TDI Tourans as courtesy cars and I'd say performance is just fine. They're not supposed to be fast but there's certainly enough torque for day to day driving and they do over 40 MPG even if you drive like a complete gonk.

missing the VR6

2,540 posts

220 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
It goes pretty well in a Fabia, assuming it's the 105PS.

VX5195

Original Poster:

147 posts

167 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all of the replies and help smile
I'm kind of drawn towards the 2.0 for the additional torque and power.
Although the only way to find out would be to test drive both of them smile

Dr G

16,015 posts

273 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
If you're already thinking 'I want more power' then you want more power.

You'll drive the 2.0 TDI and like it more than the 1.6.

VX5195

Original Poster:

147 posts

167 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Yeah I think that I would be happy with a 1.6 but happier with a 2.0. In terms of long term reliability, are the 2.0 TDI CR's proving to be okay?

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Unless you're doing big miles why not go for the new 1.4 TSI ACT? Its better than the 2.0 TDI in every measurable way being faster, having the same economy, lower CO2 and cheaper to buy. Brand new engine with heavy investment from VW/ Audi and cylinder de-activation technology. The 1.6 and 2.0 diesels aren't that new anymore and the paper figures are below class best.



Edited by va1o on Wednesday 8th January 19:45

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
It's also much noisier and unrefined compared to the 2.0.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
edc said:
It's also much noisier and unrefined compared to the 2.0.
1.6 is yes, but the 1.4 TSI ACT is seriously quiet and refined compared to both the TDIs.

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Any petrol is refined compared to the tdi. If I am honest I am disappointed by the 1.6tdi. It is no more economical, powerful or refined than the old 1.9tdi 100PS I had in an A3 in 2008.

BFG TERRANO

2,172 posts

179 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
I have a 2011 Ibiza Sport Tourer 1.6tdi, 105 I think it is. YS11 ZTG if you want to check. Its basic a to b transport. The build quality is awfull bits regularly rattle and fall off. The boot trim came clean off in my hand when closing the boot, the badge on the boot that releases it has been changed twice, its on its 2nd gearbox, the boot lets in water, the passenger footwell is always wet (not coolant) the dpf is on regularly despite 60,000 of motorway miles,and I spent Christmas with a loan car as a top engine mount broke off. Its my first and last Seat.

Engine wise its dull but I didn't expect a rocket anyway. It does 55mpg ish on the motorway if your within the limit, less if your in a rush. Low 40s round town is average. Its typical vag with all then nothing power delivery. Ive had golf 2.0TDis before and advise you go for that engine over a 1.6. There is little in economy but quite a bit in performance and general driving pleasure. If your near Wiltshire your welcome to come and have look. (Its not for sale its a company car)!!

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
My A1 I everything your Ibiza isn't except the engine is still rubbish lol

74merc

602 posts

223 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
Unless you're doing big miles why not go for the new 1.4 TSI ACT? Its better than the 2.0 TDI in every measurable way being faster, having the same economy, lower CO2 and cheaper to buy. Brand new engine with heavy investment from VW/ Audi and cylinder de-activation technology. The 1.6 and 2.0 diesels aren't that new anymore and the paper figures are below class best.



Edited by va1o on Wednesday 8th January 19:45
The CR engines may be around since 2008, but have you driven an early one and a late one? We replaced a 2008 Tiguan with a 2013 Golf 2.0 TDi and the difference between the two engines is night and day. The old one has the PD style narrow power band but the newer engine revs and has a powerband more like a petrol engine. Still sounds shi-ite mind!

VX5195

Original Poster:

147 posts

167 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all of your help guys smile
I hadn't thought of the Audi A1 until it was meantioned so that will be worth a look into.

taylormoran

1 posts

154 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I've had an A3 Sportback 1.9TDIe (105BHP) since I bought it new in 2009 to replace my previous 2.0TDI (140BHP) A3. The 1.9 has just got better as the mileage increases, although it has only done 24,000 since new. I have a new 1.6TDI (105BHP) on order and recently drove a new model 1.6TDI (105BHP) with just under 20,000 miles on the clock. It went as well, if not better, than my 1.9. On the test drive I went up Haldon Hill on the A38, three up. Doing 70 at the bottom in 6th gear, it cleared the top of the hill easily without changing gear and without losing momentum. OK, it won't win any traffic light drag starts, but it will do everything most owners would wish, most of the time. The new 1.6 engine is much quieter than my current (older technology) 1.9 too.

As a treat, the dealer let me have a go in a brand new R8 V10 Spyder just before Christmas. Now that is an awesome machine! No problems with the traffic light drag starts, but I reckon my licence would be history in no time....... wink

Edited by taylormoran on Thursday 9th January 11:20


Edited by taylormoran on Thursday 9th January 11:23

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Step mum has the 1.6TDI DSG in her Golf MK6 and it's still pretty good for an engine and the fuel economy is high 50's low 60's too.

I've got a 2.0TDI 170 DSG in an A3 for comparison and I'd say they're not miles apart.

VX5195

Original Poster:

147 posts

167 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all of your replies smile I'm going to have a drive of both and also have a look into the Audi A1 smile

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
74merc said:
The CR engines may be around since 2008, but have you driven an early one and a late one? We replaced a 2008 Tiguan with a 2013 Golf 2.0 TDi and the difference between the two engines is night and day. The old one has the PD style narrow power band but the newer engine revs and has a powerband more like a petrol engine. Still sounds shi-ite mind!
Nothing wrong with the 2.0 TDI cr, I've always found it to be a good engine, but I can see no reason you'd have it over the new 1.4 tsi act?