2005 Monaro for sale in Keighly - write up
2005 Monaro for sale in Keighly - write up
Author
Discussion

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Hello all - my name's Stuart and as yet I'm not a Monaro owner. I'm very keen to change this though and as such I went to see a promising looking Monaro that was based 10 miles away from me. At the moment I'm driving a 3L V6 406 Coupe but I've wanted to get involved with the 5.7 V8 for a few years now. So I went to visit the garage in question as the £6489 price tag looked great. Here's the link to autotrader of the car:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

After viewing the car, it was in a sorry state. Stone chips all over the bonnet. A large deep scratch on the passenger side door which goes down to the metal. 2 stone chips in the windscreen and a 6" crack also. It took 3 attempts to get it from 1st to 2nd gear and the gearstick was rattling/wobbling around all over the place so from what I've read on various places it felt like the prop shaft and gear linkages were ruined? Bad repair job on the front N/S bumper where someone has scuffed it and painted over it with non matching paint. The interior wasn't bad though in fairness. Just the outside that looked very tired.

The mileage of this motor? - 127,486 miles (not stated on the advert). As a result I walked away!! Just wanted to write up my findings in case anyone was curious about going to see it or anything like that. Maybe save someone some time and a wasted trip?




VinceM

1,906 posts

169 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Paint fiarly easy to sort but don't like the sound of that gear linkage. Might be that the gearbox fluid needs changing but probably not a chance I'd want to take.

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
It's a pity really - had it been in goo condition with lower miles, I'd have probably gone for it. I'm not in any real rush though, Just had to MOT and Tax my car so I can afford to be picky and choose one that's been looked after. Is it common for the silver paint on the engine block to be all flaking off? Under the bonnet there didn't appear to be any leaks of anything that I could see. No rubbing on any of the pipes either.

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
yomchi86 said:
It's a pity really - had it been in goo condition with lower miles, I'd have probably gone for it. I'm not in any real rush though, Just had to MOT and Tax my car so I can afford to be picky and choose one that's been looked after. Is it common for the silver paint on the engine block to be all flaking off? Under the bonnet there didn't appear to be any leaks of anything that I could see. No rubbing on any of the pipes either.
The blocks are bare alloy.

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Could be me that is mistaken in that case - is it a plastic cover on the top of the engine then that is silver and black underneath the paint? If it is, this was all flaky and not looking great. Suppose if it is just a cover, it's just cosmetic.

KMud

2,924 posts

187 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
The gear stick does vibrate a bit (the stick is pretty directly linked to a box being driven by a V8 after all), which may be more obvious with the long CV8 gear stick, but hard to say if what you experienced was more than that...could well have been. The gearbox is a potential weakness (have you seen the buyer's guide on facebook?).

Find an extra £1k and you'll get a CV8 with a much much lower mileage I'd have thought (might have to wait a little though, not much up at the moment it seems). A busted gearbox could set you back £3k! Count up which mods you want too, best considered before buying a monaro as they will be much cheaper bought already on a car.

Good luck! smile

jhfozzy

1,345 posts

221 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Looks like they haven't got the best of reputations. "the seller" (from your link) and another seller in that area have the same address.

A few threads that I've seen on them.

http://www.lancerregister.com/showthread.php?t=160...

http://www.skylineowners.com/forum/showthread.php?...

ETA: Naming and shaming removed





Edited by jhfozzy on Wednesday 8th January 13:03

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
KMud said:
The gear stick does vibrate a bit (the stick is pretty directly linked to a box being driven by a V8 after all), which may be more obvious with the long CV8 gear stick, but hard to say if what you experienced was more than that...could well have been. The gearbox is a potential weakness (have you seen the buyer's guide on facebook?).

Find an extra £1k and you'll get a CV8 with a much much lower mileage I'd have thought (might have to wait a little though, not much up at the moment it seems). A busted gearbox could set you back £3k! Count up which mods you want too, best considered before buying a monaro as they will be much cheaper bought already on a car.

Good luck! smile
Thank you KMud - I don't think I've seen the facebook buyers guide but have been trawling this forum and many review sites and buyers guides for the Monaro. I'll check the facebook one out too - thanks again!

That makes sense about the gear stick. When idling the engine, it was rattling about 3/4 inch side to side. It did look like the standard stick that was in place. I completely agree with you, for a grand more you can get a much better condition one. When I handed the keys back to the garage he asked me "so - was it any good for you?". I expressed my findings about bodywork, windscreen and mileage etc to which he replied "yeah - that's why we have it listed at the price it is listed at". Still seems like a lot to me for this particular vehicle when there are better examples for not much more smile

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
jhfozzy said:
Looks like they haven't got the best of reputations. Motorhub (from your link) and the infamous Keighley trade centre have the same address.

A few threads that I've seen on them.

http://www.lancerregister.com/showthread.php?t=160...

http://www.skylineowners.com/forum/showthread.php?...
Wow - not a good reputation at all! In my opinion - they seemed more interested in showing off what cars they have in their multi story car park. I felt that as a customer, because I wasn't looking at one of the £250,000 supercars that was there, I wasn't important enough to spend any time with. Oh well - lesson learned!

Gary H 2008

3,507 posts

220 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
OP - I think what all my colleagues are tying to say is thank you for going to the effort to report your findings here and welcome

smile

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Gary H 2008 said:
OP - I think what all my colleagues are tying to say is thank you for going to the effort to report your findings here and welcome

smile
Lol - Thank you very much for the welcome and you're very welcome for the write up - I hope it proves useful to someone. I'm one of the MODS & Site Admin on the 406 coupe site so I know how useful reviews of cars (even by a monaro n00b such as me) can be!

throwyourbike

705 posts

182 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Shame it's in such a sorry state.

Reference the gearstick/box - from my experience what you described doesn't sound too abnormal. When cold the change between 1st and 2nd can be a bit tough, should get easier as the car warms up though.
The vibration/wobble alarmed me the first time I drove a Monaro but I came from a small engined, front wheel drive car. The big V8 characteristics take a bit of getting used too.

I'm not saying there was nothing wrong with the gearbox (could be completely shagged) but it's best to drive a couple of examples so you can see what's normal and what's not.


yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
throwyourbike said:
Shame it's in such a sorry state.

Reference the gearstick/box - from my experience what you described doesn't sound too abnormal. When cold the change between 1st and 2nd can be a bit tough, should get easier as the car warms up though.
The vibration/wobble alarmed me the first time I drove a Monaro but I came from a small engined, front wheel drive car. The big V8 characteristics take a bit of getting used too.

I'm not saying there was nothing wrong with the gearbox (could be completely shagged) but it's best to drive a couple of examples so you can see what's normal and what's not.
Thanks for the helpful info. I'm looking forward to testing others and getting to know the car more. I've currenly got a nice smooth V6 (front wheel drive though) which has no vibration. Turning the engine over on the monaro gave a rather satisfying rumble in the cabin. I like!!

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
Welcome to the site. smile

If it's the company I think it is in Keighley, then from the state of some of their cars I think they could well be repaired write-offs from other RHD countries - as they then wouldn't appear on an HPI check as previously damaged.

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
Welcome to the site. smile

If it's the company I think it is in Keighley, then from the state of some of their cars I think they could well be repaired write-offs from other RHD countries - as they then wouldn't appear on an HPI check as previously damaged.
Thank you smile I only joined the pistonheads forum to get on the monaro specific one lol.

Monaro5.7

7,337 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
Welcome to the site. smile

If it's the company I think it is in Keighley, then from the state of some of their cars I think they could well be repaired write-offs from other RHD countries - as they then wouldn't appear on an HPI check as previously damaged.
System we use at work tells us if cars are imports and this does not come up as an import. But if your trying to sell a car at least make sure the number plate is straight when taking the pics wink

yomchi86

Original Poster:

16 posts

154 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
lol I know! I liked the way they left off the mileage and took all the pictures which casually avoided the damaged areas and the illegal windscreen (well possibly not illegal but I wouldn't want a car with 2 chips and a crack in a main structural componant)

VinceM

1,906 posts

169 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
yomchi86 said:
lol I know! I liked the way they left off the mileage and took all the pictures which casually avoided the damaged areas and the illegal windscreen (well possibly not illegal but I wouldn't want a car with 2 chips and a crack in a main structural componant)
When buying a car, don't look for what the advert mentions, look for what it DOESN'T mention! IMO anyway!

raving

1,183 posts

221 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
yomchi86 said:
It's a pity really - had it been in goo condition with lower miles, I'd have probably gone for it. I'm not in any real rush though, Just had to MOT and Tax my car so I can afford to be picky and choose one that's been looked after. Is it common for the silver paint on the engine block to be all flaking off? Under the bonnet there didn't appear to be any leaks of anything that I could see. No rubbing on any of the pipes either.
If it was in good nick and low miles it wouldnt be 6.5k , if 6k would buy the car that aint bad


preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Wednesday 8th January 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
Welcome to the site. smile

If it's the company I think it is in Keighley, then from the state of some of their cars I think they could well be repaired write-offs from other RHD countries - as they then wouldn't appear on an HPI check as previously damaged.
Ian, I didn't recognise their new name but now realise they used to be the Keighley trade centre (as per in links above), I know they used to have an ? reputation and changed their name, never knew about foreign writeoffs not on uk register. mind you they have gone from selling £8k evos to £250k lambos