Change from B5 RS4 to BMW e60 M5
Change from B5 RS4 to BMW e60 M5
Author
Discussion

craigdonnelly

Original Poster:

686 posts

210 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Hello

I have a lovely B5 RS4 and have been thinking about changing to an E60 M5. Has anyone done this? What are your thoughts?

The B5 RS4 is money in then bank and relatively low tech and reliable.

The M5 has an exciting engine, dating looks and is still depreciating.

It's a nice dilemma to have .

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
The E60/E61 BMW is a particularly fragile car IMHO.

I only had a 530d, but it was the single worst car I've ever owned for things going wrong. A friend of mine had an E60 M5 and sold it as soon as the warranty was up as his had been back in for various things.

And a friend of a friend bought one when they dropped to about £25k and all I hear back is that it's never on the road.

Of course, you only ever hear about the bad ones, but if you were to get one, make sure you have an iron-clad warranty or deep pockets.


graeme4130

3,956 posts

212 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Make sure you go into M5 ownership with your eyes open.
The bills can be huge and as mentioned above, it's a fragile car
The gearbox is genuinely dreadful and although the engine is a real masterpiece, the cars inability to put that power down is frustrating, especially coming from an RS4
I sold mine literally after a month a couple of years back and it's one if the few cars that have genuinely left me disappointed
Still, it had its followers, but just be aware that they're cheap and getting cheaper for a reason

craigdonnelly

Original Poster:

686 posts

210 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Thank you for your reply Graeme. That is interesting. Can you tell me more about your shirt ownership experience? I am only going in reviews in magazines and TV etc.

I am worried I will get a test drive and be thrilled! I will then sell a very nice car, regret it after a month and know I will not be able to get a car as nice as mine back.

graeme4130

3,956 posts

212 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
craigdonnelly said:
Thank you for your reply Graeme. That is interesting. Can you tell me more about your shirt ownership experience? I am only going in reviews in magazines and TV etc.

I am worried I will get a test drive and be thrilled! I will then sell a very nice car, regret it after a month and know I will not be able to get a car as nice as mine back.
It's really a car of highs and lows
The highs are certainly the engine, the interior and before the f10 made it look dated it was one of the best looking cars about.

The lows are mainly the gearbox is super jerky and even once you start to learn it and give the throttle a short lift through the gears, it still sometimes catches you out and it's obviously old tech (especially in comparison to modern DSG style boxes The clutch is made of butter and only lasts a few k it you're lucky and won't take many launches. The car's fun when you want to be a hooligan, but pretty crap when you just want to push on without hassle and the engine's way stronger than the amount of grip, but I guess some will see that as a bonus
I bought one a few years ago simply as I was between cars and one came up cheap. I planned on keeping it a year or so, but I sold it after a month and crawled back into an Audi with my tail between my legs

At the time, BMW warranties were good and reasonably priced, but I'm guessing most will be out of warranty now and parts prices are silly money. They have an awful reputation for little things going wrong, but these 'little' things can still cost thousands of pounds

You'll find it a very different experience to your B5
Find a dealer and drive a couple, you might fall in love

Also, worth noting that was going to use it as an everyday car doing 20k miles a year as I do in my B8 RS4, not as a weekend toy, so that might have swayed my judgment
Also 2, I struggled to get 200miles from a tank and that really irked me that they didn't fit it with a larger tank

Edited by graeme4130 on Thursday 9th January 22:16

craigdonnelly

Original Poster:

686 posts

210 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
The more I read about the m5 the more terrifying it sounds. I looked at Porsche 996's and 997's a while ago and they have lots of reliability issues too. Audi B7 RS4's have suspension problems. Audi RS6's have suspension problems and they have gearboxes made of glass!

Is there super saloon or proper sports car that is reliable? Is it all scare stories because you only hear the worse?


ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
craigdonnelly said:
The more I read about the m5 the more terrifying it sounds. I looked at Porsche 996's and 997's a while ago and they have lots of reliability issues too. Audi B7 RS4's have suspension problems. Audi RS6's have suspension problems and they have gearboxes made of glass!

Is there super saloon or proper sports car that is reliable? Is it all scare stories because you only hear the worse?

E90 BMW M3?

[realises what subforum he's in]

[hides]

hoegaardenruls

1,224 posts

163 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
You can read horror stories about any car once you start digging, and I went through most of the issues you can experience with a B5 RS4 in nearly seven years of ownership.

I found the question of what next particularly difficult after the B5, and if it hadn't been for a change in what I needed from the car may have found myself looking at the M5 (had passed on an E39 to buy the RS4 previously), but even then I had become used to the turbocharged car's power delivery. I just found I missed the low-down torque in the cars I tested..

I ended up in a 997 Turbo this time round, partly because of the different engine in the turbo (don't suffer the same issues as normally aspirated 996 and 7's) but also because I could cover most eventualities with an OPC warranty.

As suggested earlier - if looking at the M5, a good warranty could save some real expense, either that or find a good specialist to look after the car.


ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
M5 BMW E61 M5 was one of the most reliable cars ive had. Too many people with little or no knowledge berate the M5 for no good reason. Its a really easy car to live with if you take the time to learn its ways.

The large number of horror stories are on the net because owners expected an easygoing automatic M5 with 500bhp but instead got an automated single clutch manual that they didn't know how to use. I bet if all the owners who had a good experience with the M5 posted their findings they'd outnumber the bad reports.

Same thing goes with the B7 RS4 does it not? Dirty engine and crap suspension. However, treat it right and its a dream of a car to own.

Eddie

geordieexpat

482 posts

223 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
All
Gone the other way sold my M5 estate (E61) and purchasing new RS6 estate - nothing wrong with my M5 at all, fancied change after 2 years with M5.

Had a M3, M3 conv, 2 x 4.8is X5s and then this M5 so been BMW since 2003 - till 2014 - but I have a Sagaris aswell for the other smiley face driving

Was going to look at RR sport 5.0, and the new Jaguar, Merc E63, but this car just felt right and fits in for my needs at the moment

Pick up in 2 weeks when I am back in the UK from overseas