Wearing a helmet in an open top car
Wearing a helmet in an open top car
Author
Discussion

fatjon

Original Poster:

2,299 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Had contradictory advice on this. Is it legal to wear a helmet in a car where it it is clearly a good idea. I'm building and MEV Exocet and various people have told me over the years that it's illegal to wear a helmet in a car but I think I would prefer to use one and I'm damn sure I would not let me 13 year old son in the car with me without one. Is there any definitive law on this question?


Vaud

60,043 posts

186 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I doubt there is a law on the passenger wearing one. After all it could be for medical reasons. The passenger is not in control of the vehicle so I can see no reason why not.

The driver is probably more of an open question and down to a traffic officers view of if it is restricting view at all. But in something like your car, I'd doubt you would pulled.

agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
fatjon said:
Had contradictory advice on this. Is it legal to wear a helmet in a car where it it is clearly a good idea. I'm building and MEV Exocet and various people have told me over the years that it's illegal to wear a helmet in a car but I think I would prefer to use one and I'm damn sure I would not let me 13 year old son in the car with me without one. Is there any definitive law on this question?
Completely legal. You'd be daft not to wear a helmet driving some cars (Ariel Atom, Lotus 211, Caterham R500, etc, etc)

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Never heard of any laws that state when you must not wear a helmet, only laws that state when one must be worn.

I wear a helmet regularly in my motor (I have an aeroscreen - see profile pic). It does restrict my view when I'm looking over my shoulder, but not any more than being in a tin top. My view is that I'm far safer on fast A roads and motorways with a helmet than without. Running around on less busy roads, I use a baseball cap and polycarbonate glasses. To wear a helmet all the time would be missing out on the true open top experience.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Absolutely and completely legal and further to that, itd be foolish not to in some open cars.

Id carefully select the lid that I chose though. Nomex linings and narrow apertures serve no purpose on the road and will severely restrict your field of vision.

Id look for a good quality (for fit and comfort, principally) motorcycle helmet: youll not go wrong with a lower end Arai or Shoei.

agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I'd recommend a SNELL approved car helmet with duck bill. E.g. http://www.v2sport.com/Pro/V2pro-white-snell-sa200...

fatjon

Original Poster:

2,299 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks everyone. That seems to be a consensus then, I'll get us both measured up for helmets.

HustleRussell

26,714 posts

191 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Been doing it a lot, didn't even consider that it might be 'illegal'!

SidJames

1,399 posts

264 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
fatjon said:
Had contradictory advice on this. Is it legal to wear a helmet in a car where it it is clearly a good idea. I'm building and MEV Exocet and various people have told me over the years that it's illegal to wear a helmet in a car but I think I would prefer to use one and I'm damn sure I would not let me 13 year old son in the car with me without one. Is there any definitive law on this question?
If I was told this by anyone, I'd happily have taken them out in my Westy (RAC rollover bar), and st them up enough to never give such bks information out in the future. Why, why would anyone make that st up!

ooo000ooo

2,648 posts

225 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
A few years back a bloke and his young son crashed his newly built caterham 7 when a suspension component broke/worked loose and he stuffed it into a bank. They were both wearing crash helmets, his son died because the weight of the crash helmet broke his neck.
Make sure your kid has a light helmet.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I realise that my opinion contradicts that of some other members, but Id opt for a BS6658-A Arai or Shoei. No doubt these will no wbe tested to ECE 22-05 standard, but you wont go far wrong with an entry level Arai or Shoei and you know that their aperture wont restrict your vision, which a Snell approved helmet probably will.

Virtually all 'race' Snell approved full face helmets that I have seen couldnt pass the British Standard test because of their restricted vision, and I believe that you should consider this.

OlberJ

14,101 posts

264 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I think it comes from a spate of people wearing the simpson style stig helmets that restrict your view in something innapropriate.

Wouldn't use a full open top in anything other than pootle mode without a full face helmet.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
OlberJ said:
I think it comes from a spate of people wearing the simpson style stig helmets that restrict your view in something innapropriate.
Those lids are illegal on bikes too, because the viewing angle is too small to pass the requirements.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Hence my suggesting a decent motorcycle-approved helmet. Im reluctant to call anything a 'bike helmet' due to the negative connotation and the bks regularly spouted about their mythical inferiority.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
Anything comfy with a ACU gold sticker on would be my suggestion. Much like you've said tbh.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I nearly mentioned the ACU sticker, but they lost their way and their worth for a while, so I decided to use Arai and Shoei as examples instead.

Its a shame that no one bothers testing to the Bristish Standard any longer as its superior to the new mandatory EU standard.

Stubby Pete

2,488 posts

277 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
No- it's not illegal.
Yes - it's a good idea.

Two pieces of advice:
1. If you use a tinted visor, carry a clear one at all times. You'd be amazed at how quickly visibility changes.
2. Get a helmet designed for open cabin, the lift generated by wind hitting you is amazing at anything over 60mph, especially without an aero screen like an Exocet.

fat80b

3,255 posts

252 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
I would use a helmet, a mate of mine with a Westfield always wears a helmet when out and about.

The other thing I would always do though is make sure you only wear your helmet when:

a) by yourself
or
b) your passenger also has a helmet on.

i.e. not when your passenger is un-helmeted as a passenger without a helmet can be killed by your helmeted head in a smash which wouldn't be very pleasant.

Bob

gfunk

279 posts

243 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all

I've been wearing this before the stig tarnished the image, always the choice of lid for the discerning streetfighter pilot.
I have been pulled many times they have never mentioned the lid.
And I can see just fine until about 140 then your eyes start flapping and watering down your face lol

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 9th January 2014
quotequote all
ooo000ooo said:
A few years back a bloke and his young son crashed his newly built caterham 7 when a suspension component broke/worked loose and he stuffed it into a bank. They were both wearing crash helmets, his son died because the weight of the crash helmet broke his neck.
Make sure your kid has a light helmet.
Is this the one in Brighton?

There is a suggestion that there is a problem when someone wearing a helmet is belted into a car. The force of a front end impact can push the head/helmet forward at the speed of the car. Given the extra weight, it can be too much for a neck. However, a bare head in the same situation can also be fatal. The difference in speed is the critical point and it is not all that much.

A helmet protects a head in an impact. If you are not going to hit your head on anything then there's no point in wearing one over and above the comfort aspect.