Two Lane Roundabout - Who's right or wrong?
Two Lane Roundabout - Who's right or wrong?
Author
Discussion

Paul O

Original Poster:

3,186 posts

214 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Junction of the M62 and M1. Dual carriageway all round the roundabout, with two lanes entering and exiting from all sides.

Specific point:
Traffic from the EAST (travelling westbound), going north can use BOTH lanes.
traffic from the South (approaching northbound) going EAST can use BOTH lanes.
At the point you can turn off to go NORTH, there are traffic lights.

Conseqeuntly there is a disruption in traffic flow, meaning people can be legitimelty in the left lane to go right, and people can also be in the right lane legitimiately turning off left.

Its an accident waiting to happen, and I've seen a few people stopped on there exhanging details so assume it has happened in the past.

Theoretical question - who would be in the wrong? The signs suggest both drivers are in their correct lanes and that the setup simply doesn't allow for safe passage.

Just wondered?

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Paul O said:
the setup simply doesn't allow for safe passage.
Nonsense.

If you change lanes/exit when it's not clear to do so, you're to blame.

If you drive into someone while they are changing lane/exiting when it could be reasonably avoided, you're to blame.

The road layout can only increase or decrease the probability of accident.


Edited by trashbat on Friday 10th January 15:41

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

276 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
I had to draw it out to get my head round that, it does look like a recipe for collisions.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
trashbat said:
onsense.

If you change lanes/exit when it's not clear to do so, you're to blame.

If you drive into someone changing lane/exiting when it could be reasonably avoided, you're to blame.

The road layout can only increase or decrease the probability of accident.
i'm not even sure what you are trying to say
If you drive into someone, [who is] changing lane/exiting...
or
If you drive into someone, [while you are] changing lane/exiting...
both arguments seem fairly equal

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
The former. I thought I could have improved that, but I also thought noone would be so pedantic wink

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
trashbat said:
The former. I thought I could have improved that, but I also thought noone would be so pedantic wink
it's not being pedantic, you could easily have meant either

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
From an insurance perspective then roundabout collisions are a nightmare as both sides claim they were in the right. In this case it looks like they both could legitimately claim this and it would settle 50/50.

The overriding precedent on roundabout collisions is Grac vs tanner. that went 50/50 after a court ruling. Effectively one person was turning right at a roundabout but used the left lane the whole way round. Another driver was in the second lane but had signs saying they were OK to turn off from this second lane. They collided and a court (note not an insurer) ruled that they were equally to blame, even though common sense would say the person turning right from the left hand lane was at fault

themoon66

46 posts

224 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
I know this roundabout and I have been hit on there one evening. You're not wrong OP.

andyiley

13,657 posts

183 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
I understand that you have experience of this roundabout & that is why you ask about this one specifically, but it is no different than MANY others that link 2 dual carriageways/motorways at all 4 points.

Therefore the same applies as any others, as has been intimated above.

Whilst the highway code may show general rules to apply, the overriding advice I would give is - Correct is no substitute for alive & safe!

The BIGGEST single issue with roundabouts in this country is lack of lane discipline & incorrect indicating. (IMHO)

How many times do you see people "straigh-lining" 3 lanes of a roundabout when going straight ahead, and how many times do you see people using a roundabout witout EVER indicating!

Hol

9,316 posts

231 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
andyiley said:
The BIGGEST single issue with roundabouts in this country is lack of lane discipline & incorrect indicating. (IMHO)
Sorry to partial quote, but this nails it.

One of our local three lane roundabouts has gotten much better since they remarked the lines to force people to move out a lane as they progress every junction.

That does not stop every knob, but it does reduce them.

klingelton

70 posts

160 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
I know exactly the roundabout of which you speak, It's a terrible design which will have someone killed or seriously injured. I nearly came a cropper there myself once.

AJI

5,180 posts

248 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
The highway code, to my memory, still doesn't give any guidance on lane-roundabouts, or ones with traffic lights. (Stand to be corrected of course).
I still see many people on 2 lane roundabouts choosing to change lane at what is arguably the most critical point of a roundabout, the exit.
The one near to me has had countless minor collisions, but as these collisions are generally low speed, they never really result in serious injury and the problem is not addressed.


Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
AJI said:
The highway code, to my memory, still doesn't give any guidance on lane-roundabouts.....
There is a diagram in section 185 which shows the correct procedure for a double lane entrance - double lane exit roundabout (just like the OPs example).

https://www.gov.uk/using-the-road-159-to-203/round...

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
I love spiral roundabouts. Correct lane in, no lane changing required. Unf they are not standard and you don't know in advance either.

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Paul O said:
Specific point:
Traffic from the EAST (travelling westbound), going north can use BOTH lanes.
But they shouldn't according to the highway code.

If you are approaching the roundabout from the east (i.e. are westbound) and want to take the northbound exit - you should position your vehicle in the right hand approach lane unless the road markings indicate otherwise (which they dont on this particular roundabout).

Traffic in the left approach lane should only be intending to exit south or west.


Edited by Moonhawk on Monday 13th January 16:45

AJI

5,180 posts

248 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Moonhawk said:
AJI said:
The highway code, to my memory, still doesn't give any guidance on lane-roundabouts.....
There is a diagram in section 185 which shows the correct procedure for a double lane entrance - double lane exit roundabout (just like the OPs example).

https://www.gov.uk/using-the-road-159-to-203/round...
Ah yes, but there are no lane markings on the roundabout itself.
If there are no lane markings then in effect a vehicle can position itself on the offside, nearside or in the middle of the carriageway and still be 'legal' so to speak.
An HGV for example would normally use most of the carriageway width if there is an absence of roundabout lane markings (even if there is an obvious two lane entry).

The problem as I see it is that the Highway Code does not address laned roundabouts and people are using the diagram (the one you posted) and are changing lane at the exits (the green maneuver), causing a lot of problems when vehicles are exiting also in lane 1.
There is the argument that if people used their mirrors etc. , but often enough people simply don't.

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
AJI said:
Ah yes, but there are no lane markings on the roundabout itself.
If there are no lane markings then in effect a vehicle can position itself on the offside, nearside or in the middle of the carriageway and still be 'legal' so to speak.
An HGV for example would normally use most of the carriageway width if there is an absence of roundabout lane markings (even if there is an obvious two lane entry).

The problem as I see it is that the Highway Code does not address laned roundabouts and people are using the diagram (the one you posted) and are changing lane at the exits (the green maneuver), causing a lot of problems when vehicles are exiting also in lane 1.
There is the argument that if people used their mirrors etc. , but often enough people simply don't.
But the lane markings aren't restrictive (i.e. cannot cross) unless they are solid.

On that roundabout the lane markings are dashed - meaning you treat them like any other lane marking and can change lanes if safe to do so.

Interestingly - on approach to the exits themselves there are no lane markings. This implies you can use the green manoeuvre as depicted in the highway code - again if its safe to do so.

SK425

1,034 posts

180 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Moonhawk said:
But they shouldn't according to the highway code.

If you are approaching the roundabout from the east and want to take the northbound exit - you should position your vehicle in the right hand approach lane unless the road markings indicate otherwise (which they dont on this particular roundabout).
Signs or road markings, and yes they do.

And there's a similar sign for traffic coming from the south, saying that they can approach the roundabout in either lane for their right turn at the roundabout for M62 eastbound.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Moonhawk said:
But the lane markings aren't restrictive (i.e. cannot cross) unless they are solid.

On that roundabout the lane markings are dashed - meaning you treat them like any other lane marking and can change lanes if safe to do so.

Interestingly - on approach to the exits themselves there are no lane markings. This implies you can use the green manoeuvre as depicted in the highway code - again if its safe to do so.
You can change lanes on solid lines also.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
The signs on the M1 North sliproad put the traffic heading East into conflict with that heading North onto the M1/M621. The signs on the M62 Westbound similarly create the conflict. It's poor road signing.