Next car - sound and fury
Next car - sound and fury
Author
Discussion

AcesHigh

Original Poster:

39 posts

159 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Hi all

Last year I took the plunge and bought an F430, which I love. Typically for me however, I'm already thinking of the next trade-in. I love the car, but after 1-2 years I can see myself hankering for a change. I'd value folk's thoughts on possible routes to go.

It's not a daily drive, it's every weekend and the very occasional weekday. Has to be a flappy paddle or sequential box. And absolutely has to be an event every time. To be fair that's what's great about the 430, even pootling along at 30 feels fantastic. Where I live has loads of cameras, just everywhere, and for time reasons only occasionally can I venture further afield to find decent roads (though I have a track close by). I'd considered a track-only Radical, or looking at the BAC Mono, but if I'm honest I enjoy the ownership proposition of a proper supercar, the look, feel and sound of the thing and ability to drive (mostly) anywhere in it even if it's not too comfy....

Budget would be up to say £100k (including trading in the 430).

So....which way to go? Improving on the 430 is tricky (maybe I just keep it). In a year, maybe there's an older Scuderia to consider, or a Murcielago, or 997 GT3? Pressing the throttle has to unleash hell and make mad grins unavoidable, each drive an event. I'm thinking a big V12 may be the way to go... The 430 is a monster already and just brilliant, but there's no harm in planning ahead....

Grateful for views...

AH

runner911

631 posts

274 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Audi R8 V10 GT ?

Pretty quick car with a monster sound !

I went from a Lamborghini Gallardo to an R8.

Haven't regretted it yet .

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
For the given budget I'd say 599 would be the way forward!

johnnyreggae

3,175 posts

191 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
In a year's time a 458 will probably be within budget

AcesHigh

Original Poster:

39 posts

159 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks guys. Never driven an R8 but is it much more of an occasion than the 430 I wonder? My local track has an R8 Experience package so I might try that to see.

The 599 is a cracking car I'm sure and already in a similar price bracket to my 430. I'd be interested in driving one to feel the difference - they are gorgeous in my view.

Then there's the 458. Like so many of us I'm sure, I've been watching 458 prices keenly. I've only driven one once and it was epic, though (and maybe I'm on my own here) the sound of my 430 holds it's own, even if the performance is down.

Has anyone moved from a 430 to a 599? Or a to a Murcielago?

I concede it's a great problem to have.....

projectgt

321 posts

191 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
599 is a good shout. It is going to be hard to beat on a number of levels…

- Sense of occasion every time taken out
- Classy, respectable, not shouting look at me (creates envy not jealousy). Can take grandmother out in it as well as a mistress without upsetting/offending.
- V12, best sounding engine configuration
- Flappy paddles as requested by OP
- Ages more gracefully than the V8 models
- Rare on the roads compared to V8 models yet more usable

I'd have one in a shot over the 430. I love the 430 but its a car I would like an hour's hoon in, but I would rather be in the 599 for the other 95% of the time.

Look for the fiorano pack equipped cars and you cannot go wrong.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
johnnyreggae said:
In a year's time a 458 will probably be within budget
This maybe a good call but under 100k it will be a LH drive car even in a years time.
599's have been under 100k for quite some time now and I think they're a great looking car and stonkingly quick. Only down side is they really like a drink.
I went from 430 -360cs then 430 Scud. The car I miss most is the CS as I felt I didn't need to be doing silly speeds to enjoy it, the 430 isn't a great looking car in my opinion but the Scud addresses most of the issues and looks better.
I went 458 next which is a fantastic steer but if I couldn't stretch to a 458 I'd definitely go 599.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Had a similar dilemma and after a lot of research driving loads of cars I went from a 2009 F430 spider to a 2012 LP570-4 Performante and its a proper supercar. Performance in abundance and a sound to die for. The F430 is stealth in comparison and the Lambo is the perfect blend of Italian flair and styling and German build quality and reliability. I chose it over cheaper 458's and McLarens just because its so outrageous and great FUN.

Cheapest LP570 Pet I've seen was an early higher mileage one at £120k so in a couple of years time it will be close to your budget.
My neighbours have seen me with a host of supercars over the years but nothing has taken their attention as much as the Lambo.

runner911

631 posts

274 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
....................Or a to a Murcielago?

Tried a Murcielago before I bought my Gallardo.

Very noisy in the cabin , and virtually no visibility to the rear. To reverse the thing I had to sit on the door jamb. Very exotic , but simply not practical in my view.

Gallardo is a better car , and I would agree that it is outrageous , particularly if it has a good sport exhaust ( mine had a Larini which belched flames in the dark ).


sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
runner911 said:
....................Or a to a Murcielago?

Tried a Murcielago before I bought my Gallardo.

Very noisy in the cabin , and virtually no visibility to the rear. To reverse the thing I had to sit on the door jamb. Very exotic , but simply not practical in my view.

Gallardo is a better car , and I would agree that it is outrageous , particularly if it has a good sport exhaust ( mine had a Larini which belched flames in the dark ).
Murci is good call!. However the problem I had when it came Lambos was the warranties were crap on second hand cars.

Dolittle

1,256 posts

189 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
I went from Gallardo (loved it) to f430 spider (didnt love it, bored me looks wise) to another Gallardo spider (loved it) to a murcielago, i was always put off the murcielago as I had read people saying how impracticle they are. In my opinion this is not true at all. I take my murci anywhere I used to take my Gallardo, tesco's included. It does lack rear visibility, but you do get used to it. I could never go back to a Gallardo after this. I see now why some people say the Gallardo is not a real lambo, the murci is in another league. Only car I might consider next is the 12c, as that is in a whole new league.

red_duke

826 posts

212 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Dolittle said:
... to f430 spider (didnt love it, bored me looks wise) ...
So why did you buy it in the first place?

LukeyLikey

855 posts

178 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
I have gone from 360 Spider to 430 Spider to California and now 12C Spider (also have a CS). CS would have been a perfect car to follow the 430 but you will struggle on budget now - it is sharper and much more of an event than a 430. The California is excellent but a bit different in its approach. It is much more modern and the DCT gearbox is miles ahead of F1 shift - it really suits the car. I didn't find the California a come down after the 430 (certainly wasn't slower) and never regretted the switch, although with the CS in the garage I could still scratch the mid-engine itch.

12C is a great car. I haven't had the chance to give it a real go on warm roads and tyres (got it in November 13) but I can feel it is going to be great. All this stuff about no character is such nonsense, honestly, where do they get this rubbish from? The performance is miles ahead of equivalent cars and the technology is really interesting and different. It doesn't detract from the driving experience either. These new techno-supercars are not automatically inferior as a driving proposition, they just bring different things to think about.

CS and 12C seem a very good pairing so far.

Mega weekend cars to consider at circa £100k over the next 12-18 months: California, 12C coupe, 458 Couoe, GT3 RS. Not sure you can do much better than one of those.

Dolittle

1,256 posts

189 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
red_duke said:
So why did you buy it in the first place?
Because initially I thought it was quite nice, only had it for a total of 3 months, after 2 of those I found it externally quite dull. I prefer the look that Lambo's have.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Dolittle said:
I went from Gallardo (loved it) to f430 spider (didnt love it, bored me looks wise) to another Gallardo spider (loved it) to a murcielago, i was always put off the murcielago as I had read people saying how impracticle they are. In my opinion this is not true at all. I take my murci anywhere I used to take my Gallardo, tesco's included. It does lack rear visibility, but you do get used to it. I could never go back to a Gallardo after this. I see now why some people say the Gallardo is not a real lambo, the murci is in another league. Only car I might consider next is the 12c, as that is in a whole new league.
I thought about a MP4 12C and 458 before the LP570-4 but both seemed boring and mundane in comparison. Yes they were fast and had the latest technology but they weren't exciting unless you were doing silly speeds.
Probably testament to how good they really are but I'd rather keep my licence.
I think some of the latest stuff is so damn efficient and smooth you have no idea what speed you are actually doing
On the other hand the LP570-4 is a real event every time you drive it. It looks and sounds awesome and the publics reaction to Lambo's is just great.
It might not be the latest technology but the e-gear is a lot better than F1 and suits the car whilst the 4WD means you can exploit more of the 570 horses.
It is definitely THE CAR that makes you smile ( or laugh even ) the most. I loved my F430 and even with doubling my expenditure it was difficult to find something worth the extra £75K but the LP570-4 has been worth every penny and I think its seriously underrated and a future classic with no doubt ( just probably not in my tenure ). Roll on the summer when I can get the roof down and enjoy the full on open air motoring experience to the full

steelej

1,761 posts

238 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
The OP is never going to get a decent answer to his question, it's too subjective. Everyone who's posting likes what they have, some seem to have a strange love for theirs that they like to talk about at every opportunity(not naming names wink ) the reality is that everyone is different and likes different things, case in point is that i don't think any Gallardo is as good as the 430, including the very latest ones, a Gallardo is a side step at best.

The only way for the OP to make a decision is to get out there and drive some of the options then buy the one you like the most. It will most likely be different to all the opinions given so far smile

John.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
steelej said:
The OP is never going to get a decent answer to his question, it's too subjective. Everyone who's posting likes what they have, some seem to have a strange love for theirs that they like to talk about at every opportunity(not naming names wink ) the reality is that everyone is different and likes different things, case in point is that i don't think any Gallardo is as good as the 430, including the very latest ones, a Gallardo is a side step at best.

The only way for the OP to make a decision is to get out there and drive some of the options then buy the one you like the most. It will most likely be different to all the opinions given so far smile

John.
That's exactly what I did and IMHO the LP570-4 Performante was the car that was the most FUN even if it wasn't technically the best ( IMHO that was the MP4 12C ). If it was a daily driver I would of chose a 458 Italia but foe weekend hooning the Gallardo was the most dramatic and exciting SUPERcar - all IMHO but I am expressing an opinion formed after extensive research and driving of all the cars in that territory.
I'm not a novice to supercars and have a trail of classics in my wake so apart from always selling them I must be doing something right

Dolittle

1,256 posts

189 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
That's exactly what I did and IMHO the LP570-4 Performante was the car that was the most FUN even if it wasn't technically the best ( IMHO that was the MP4 12C ). If it was a daily driver I would of chose a 458 Italia but foe weekend hooning the Gallardo was the most dramatic and exciting SUPERcar - all IMHO but I am expressing an opinion formed after extensive research and driving of all the cars in that territory.
I'm not a novice to supercars and have a trail of classics in my wake so apart from always selling them I must be doing something right
Gallardo's are FUN, but the 570 I drove, wasn't, £100k more fun than the 07 Gallardo spyder, or the 05 coupe I have owned. The 12c, was amazing in comparison, I only had the 12c a few days, so can't tell if in a couple of months it would become sterile or not. Like the 430.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Dolittle said:
Gallardo's are FUN, but the 570 I drove, wasn't, £100k more fun than the 07 Gallardo spyder, or the 05 coupe I have owned. The 12c, was amazing in comparison, I only had the 12c a few days, so can't tell if in a couple of months it would become sterile or not. Like the 430.
I agree its no way £100k better than a regular Gallardo like a Scuderia isn't that much better than a F430. I drove a Scuderia and didn't think it merited an extra £40k to change up from my F430 spider and for that sort of extra outlay I wanted something a bit different. Most of my neighbours wouldn't have noticed I had even changed cars.

I think if you have already experienced a marque and particular car in a previous incarnation it will be hard to experience the same wow factor 2nd time round. I rated the MP4 12C as a euro cruiser but because it was so fast and efficient and didn't sound great it wasn't a car I would get out of bed at 5.00 am on a sunday morning to go for a drive in. Maybe a spider would add a little more to the experience but they were outside my £160k budget at the time

AcesHigh

Original Poster:

39 posts

159 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Many thanks all. I know there is no 'right' answer and it's all so subjective, but I do value the interesting points being made and the ownership experiences being shared by folk on PH are if anything more valuable to me than the latest review in Autocar or whatever.

For me, regardless of seemingly being in a minority of one, I love my 430's looks. I concede I've never driven a Gallardo and I'm sure they're fabulous, but I do take the point about the 430 to LP-whatever being a side-step. Then again without getting out in one, I'll never know for sure, so I need to do that.

I love the 599's looks and sound, but I'm not so sure it's the exotic, mad smiley-beast I crave. In fact, isn't the 430 already more of a shouty hoon-around car than the GT car that is the 599? Again, need to get out in one, I know.

The 458 is interesting, I've driven and loved it. LHD is perfect for me (live in the Middle East). But though immeasurably better than a stock 430, I'm not yet convinced its a massively more dramatic experience, which is what I'm after.

I do think though that the Murcielago could be the one. It looks insane, by all accounts sounds insane, and is properly fast. I'm after sound and fury, a total and utter experience, and i think that car has it in spades. Truth be told, it does look dated to me, but I recently saw an orange one and it's jaw dropping. Petrol is thankfully cheap as chips where I live and it'd be a weekend drive only, so already it's ticking boxes. But as everyone says, I need to get out in them all.

Thank you again to one and all for responses.