Arsonist jailed for 6 years for crisp factory fire.
Arsonist jailed for 6 years for crisp factory fire.
Author
Discussion

onyx39

Original Poster:

11,349 posts

181 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/colin-gouldin...
A crafty smoker has been jailed after he accidentally burnt down his crisp factory - causing £25million of damage.

Colin Goulding, 31, destroyed the Real Crisp factory in Crumlin, near Newport, South Wales, when he sneaked away for a fag break on the factory floor.

He worked on a production line boxing packets of crisps.

But he broke company policy by bringing cigarettes and a lighter down to a storeroom on the factory floor where he was surrounded by flammable material.

Newport Crown Court heard Goulding was worried about being caught smoking by his bosses and threw his cigarette away in a hurry.

But it landed in a pile of crisp packet wrappers, starting a blaze which engulfed the factory in just 10 minutes.

More than than 100 workmates lost their jobs after the fire, including Goulding’s parents who also worked there.

Sentencing him to six years and three months behind bars at Newport Crown Court, Judge Richards said: “This is far and away the most serious arson I have ever dealt with as a judge in these courts.

“This was a ridiculous thing to do.”

He added: “The wholly exceptional circumstance in this case is the amount of damage accompanied by the loss suffered by, not only the company, but also the work force and community.”

Dad-of-one Goulding, who has already spent 15 months in custody since he was remanded in September 2012, will have to serve at least half of his sentence in prison.

The court heard the defendant, who has learning difficulties and is said to have the “intellectual level” of an 11- to 13-year-old, started the fire at the Real Crisps factory on September 20, 2012, when he flicked a lit cigarette in a flammable area.


Could not find a thread for this, so apologies if it's a pearost.
Personally I think this was spot on, and the sentence was a absolutely justified, but "Facebook" thinks otherwise apparently. Thoughts from the collective?

Edited by onyx39 on Saturday 11th January 18:02

XCP

17,763 posts

259 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Sounds pretty clear cut to me.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Man with learning difficulties, intellecutual skills of 11 to 13 year old.
No doubt it was a stupid thing to do but would he really have been aware of the potential consequences? I would say "probably not" else he wouldn't have done it.

Depends whether you sentence for the action or for the impact. Action small. Impact huge. 6 years for what's clearly negligent, but still an unintended act (i.e. not premeditated or deliberate) seems pretty harsh to me, given his learning difficulties.

However I don't have all the facts, only those reported. So I have to trust the judge to have made the right decision.

One thing I find surprising was the fact that he was remanded whilst awaiting trial. I wonder why what was? Had previous? Dunno.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Im surprised that he has been charged with arson as he clearly had no intention of starting a fire. Of course, you cant charge him with being a bleeding idiot...

mike-r

1,539 posts

222 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Seems bob on given the damage done, although maybe a tad strong given the lack of intent. I'm sure there are arsonists out there with lesser sentences having actually intended to damage property/people.

At what point does mental age factor into employment law?

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
I don't understand this at all
i thought arson had to be deliberate
This is the definition from wikipedia
"Arson[1] is the crime of intentionally and maliciously setting fire to buildings, wildland areas,[2] vehicles [3][4] or other property with the intent to cause damage."

why would they criminalise and punish so harshly something which was clearly an accident

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
That's his bacon smoked, then. The sentence sounds cheesy to me. I wonder if the story is to be taken with a pinch of salt?

Etc


Crap jokes apart, the sentence sounds pretty harsh.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
mike-r said:
Seems bob on given the damage done, although maybe a tad strong given the lack of intent. I'm sure there are arsonists out there with lesser sentences having actually intended to damage property/people.

At what point does mental age factor into employment law?
This is not employment law, but criminal law.

Recklessness supplies intent. I still think the sentence to be over the top, especially as the man is developmentally impaired.

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Lucky no-one was burnt to a crisp..

Seriously though, if it is true, methinks Mr Judge needs to go back to Judge school. That is not the way to deal with someone who has learning difficulties, or as we used to say, a mental handicap.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
ging84 said:
I don't understand this at all
i thought arson had to be deliberate
This is the definition from wikipedia
"Arson[1] is the crime of intentionally and maliciously setting fire to buildings, wildland areas,[2] vehicles [3][4] or other property with the intent to cause damage."

why would they criminalise and punish so harshly something which was clearly an accident
Recklessness amounts to intent/malice. The test for recklessness is subjective (ie you look at the circumstances and perception of the individual).


I am no expert on this subject, but would have thought that an appeal, at least on sentence, could be a runner. It is not clear from the Mirror whether the dude pleaded guilty or was potted by a jury.

onyx39

Original Poster:

11,349 posts

181 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
They had a chap on Radio 2 yesterday who was going into this in slightly more depth.
When he realised what he had done, rather than raise the alarm, he got out his mobile and started filming it.
I would imagine the factory would have been occupied by more than just him at the time, so it was reckless to the extreme, even taking into account his learning difficulties.
They say he has the mental age of an 11 year old, I would like to think even an 11 year old would have the sense to raise the alarm rather than film it burning.
There was also a comment on the show (from a former fire officer) that he believed the authorities are going to clamp down n people who (accidentally) start fires with discarded cigarettes.

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Covered under the Criminal Damage Act. Arson is Criminal Damage by fire.
Intentional or reckless. Mens rea, but CPS guidelines are:
"(Archbold 23-8 to 23-12)
After the House of Lords decision in R v G [2004] 1 AC 1034, the mens rea for criminal damage is no longer as stated in Caldwell.
"Recklessness" for the purposes of the Criminal Damage Act is now defined as follows:
"A person acts recklessly within the meaning of section 1 of the Criminal Damage Act 1971 with respect to:

1) A circumstance when he is aware of a risk that it exists or will exist;

2) A result when he/she is aware of a risk that it will occur; and

3) It is, in the circumstances known to him, unreasonable to take the risk.

In relation to self-induced intoxication, DPP v Majewski [1977] AC 443 still applies."
http://www.cps.gov.uk/legal/a_to_c/criminal_damage...

If he was asked' Did you think it possible that your thrown away lit cigarette could cause a fire but threw it anyway' and answered 'Yes' then I think he might be stuffed.

smileymikey

1,446 posts

257 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
I accept the outcome was a bit nasty....You do have to take intent into account though, he mucked up but not six years worth......you would get the equivalent (or less, a lot less) for a premeditated rape ??

mike-r

1,539 posts

222 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
mike-r said:
Seems bob on given the damage done, although maybe a tad strong given the lack of intent. I'm sure there are arsonists out there with lesser sentences having actually intended to damage property/people.

At what point does mental age factor into employment law?
This is not employment law, but criminal law.

Recklessness supplies intent. I still think the sentence to be over the top, especially as the man is developmentally impaired.
My apologies, I was on a tangent regarding the legitimacy of his employment in the first instance.

Surely child labour is illegal on the basis of mental capacity rather than physical stature or facial hair, so why would someone with a mental age of 11, if it has been officially recognised, be legally employed anywhere?

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
All adults are deemed to have legal capacity unless the contrary is declared by the Court of Protection. The law as to employment of children works on physical age.

Adults who have developmental impairment need to eat, and some of them find employment. The employer may even have been trying to help the man by employing him. In a fairer society, an adult who is incapable of functioning as an adult would be supported without having to work, but then PH would complain about carrying passengers.

Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 11th January 21:00

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
paintman said:
After the House of Lords decision in R v G (2004) 1 AC 1034, the mens rea for criminal damage is no longer as stated in Caldwell.
For those who are interested in the detail - R v G and another
(I know it should be square brackets above but doing so censored up the quote format)

IANAL - why is it quoted as R v G [2004] when the opinions of the Appellate Committee were handed down in October 2003?

English law seems to have a particular penchant for treating offences/crimes against property more harshly than those against the person. This was particularly evident in the sentences handed down to the participants in the 1963 Great Train Robbery.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
The case was published in the 2004 volume of the Law Reports, and 2004 therefore forms part of the citation. It can also be cited by what is known as a neutral citation, and that uses 2003.

John Locke wrote in 1689: "The reason why men enter into society is the preservation of their property." English law is indeed flavoured with Lockeanism. I would place offences against the person above offence against property, but I don't get to make the rules.

NB, one or more of the train robbers beat the hell out of the train driver.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
See also William Blackstone, writing in 1765:-

"The original of private property is probably founded in nature, as will be more fully explained in the second book of the ensuing commentaries: but certainly the modifications under which we at present find it, the method of conserving it in the present owner, and of translating it from man to man, are entirely derived from society; and are some of those civil advantages, in exchange for which every individual has resigned a part of his natural liberty. The laws of England are therefore, in point of honor and justice, extremely watchful in ascertaining and protecting this right."

XCP

17,763 posts

259 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Is the maximum sentence for Arson life imprisonment?

I am sure it used to be.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
The case was published in the 2004 volume of the Law Reports, and 2004 therefore forms part of the citation. It can also be cited by what is known as a neutral citation, and that uses 2003.
Thanks. Trust the English to come up with a system of needless complexity!

Breadvan72 said:
John Locke wrote in 1689: "The reason why men enter into society is the preservation of their property." English law is indeed flavoured with Lockeanism. I would place offences against the person above offence against property, but I don't get to make the rules.
Quite. You may own the freehold of the land on which your house is built but AIUI it is in fee simple 'of the Crown'. In other words the land really still belongs to Her Majesty and she is graciously pleased to allow you to hold it as her tenant.

Breadvan72 said:
NB, one or more of the train robbers beat the hell out of the train driver.
True. Jack Mills never recovered fro being hit with an iron bar. However I believe it was only one man who wielded the cosh and it was done by someone who wasn't part of Bruce Reynold's 'firm'. He wasn't best pleased as he had made a point of telling his associates to be sure of refraining from violence.

The size of the haul was far in excess of what Reynolds expected, and that not only created far more heat but was to a large extent why the sentences handed down were far higher than for any previous robbery. The injury to Mills did not, of itself, come anywhere near to justifying what they got.

Breadvan72 said:
See also William Blackstone, writing in 1765:-

"The original of private property is probably founded in nature, as will be more fully explained in the second book of the ensuing commentaries: but certainly the modifications under which we at present find it, the method of conserving it in the present owner, and of translating it from man to man, are entirely derived from society; and are some of those civil advantages, in exchange for which every individual has resigned a part of his natural liberty. The laws of England are therefore, in point of honor and justice, extremely watchful in ascertaining and protecting this right."
That could almost have been dictated word for word by one of the ruling elite. England, with its unbroken monarchy (except for the short lived Commonwealth after they topped Charlie) and titled families, has far more grand houses that still exist compared with, for example, France. The Duke of Westminster owns huge tracts of London. The Duke of Buccleuch (and Queensberry which is distinct from the Marquessate) is the largest private landowner in the country.

The English aristocracy usually followed a distinct pattern. The eldest son inherited the lands and title. Any second son became an Admiral or a General. The third went into the Church. Below that it was do the best you can and preferably marry a wealthy merchant's daughter.

The nobs may have undergone subtle changes over the years but they still lord it over the plebs.