Rental income from commercial property - basic question.
Rental income from commercial property - basic question.
Author
Discussion

budfox

Original Poster:

1,510 posts

160 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Bored this afternoon, so I was browsing Rightmove. Came across this:

http://www.rightmove.co.uk/commercial-property-for...

I really don't understand anything about commercial property, so am I reading it right? You can buy the place for £150k and someone has already signed a nine year lease to use it, and they pay £17k/year for doing so. That's a huge return on your money.

What's the catch?

Thanks.

Eric Mc

125,939 posts

296 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Landlords have costs.

EskimoArapaho

5,135 posts

166 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
And companies (as tenants) come and go.

But it's still potentially interesting.

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Fewer costs for commercial than residential when let. For instance insurance is recharged and market norm is tenant responsible for internal and external repairs. LL even dodges the gas safety certificate.

Risk are potentially income more variable. If you lose tenant LL becomes responsible for rates.

Longer voids for re-letting.

BAEM

94 posts

202 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Risks are; if tenant goes bust and leaves and you have to find a new tenant. How long will that take? You will have associated costs of reletting and to possibly pay the business rates. Is the property over rented ? Will you get the same rent again. Or the same long term?

Rewards ; if the tenant stays in the black and pays the rent, potentially you can just forget about it and collect the rent ( assuming a full repairing and insuring lease).

If you are looking at buying an investment I would advise paying for the right advice (lease terms and purchase price) otherwise you could make a costly mistake.

budfox

Original Poster:

1,510 posts

160 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks all.

I'm not seriously considering it as an investment, but as someone with little idea about such things I wanted to know why this wasn't a 'no brainer'.

I'd worked out that the tenant might go out of business as one of the drawbacks, and I'd guessed there were associated costs, but it seems like a lot less bother than buying a house as an investment.

I would of course seek professional advice on any such matters, I'm hugely cautious with money. I do however have a few quid spare and wouldn't mind seeing a better return on it than sod all.

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
There are a number of units on that estate for sale, including one of a similar size which is vacant. May r may not prove anything depending how long it has been vacant for.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Commercial property is great until the tenant stops paying (whether because they move or because they go bust). Unless it's in a really desirable spot then commercial properties tend to stay empty A LOT longer than residential premises. I rented a unit until last year on a very nice site and would estimate that at any one time an average 50% of the site was vacant. When it's not rented, you play the rates, which are likely to be between £5-10k/year on a building like that.

Also depends on what sort of lease it is. A 9 year lease where the tenant has an annual break clause is pretty meaningless.

It can also be much more difficult to secure finance against a commercial property.

It can be very profitable, but it's a minefield for the inexperienced.

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
It has a 9 year lease but it doesn't say how long it has to run...you might be in year 8 of the lease

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Monday 13th January 2014
quotequote all
Inkyfingers said:
Commercial property is great until the tenant stops paying (whether because they move or because they go bust). Unless it's in a really desirable spot then commercial properties tend to stay empty A LOT longer than residential premises. I rented a unit until last year on a very nice site and would estimate that at any one time an average 50% of the site was vacant. When it's not rented, you play the rates, which are likely to be between £5-10k/year on a building like that.

Also depends on what sort of lease it is. A 9 year lease where the tenant has an annual break clause is pretty meaningless.

It can also be much more difficult to secure finance against a commercial property.

It can be very profitable, but it's a minefield for the inexperienced.
You'd be surprised about the rates payable on that unit. Put it this way I wouldn't be submitting an appeal.

The unit is Unit 3 and it is 309 sq m. Its let for a term of 9 years from 1 April 2012 for a 9 year term, at a rent of £17,160pa. The RV is £6,800 which for a qualifying small business (and assuming they get all the reliefs) gives rates payable of under £400! If it was empty the empty rates would be around £3,400 pa. Either the rents on that estate are higher than the local average or the VOs valuations are particularly conservative.

There is a link on the Rightmove site to the selling agents particulars in case you wonder how I know the additional info.

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
Inkyfingers said:
Commercial property is great until the tenant stops paying (whether because they move or because they go bust). Unless it's in a really desirable spot then commercial properties tend to stay empty A LOT longer than residential premises. I rented a unit until last year on a very nice site and would estimate that at any one time an average 50% of the site was vacant. When it's not rented, you play the rates, which are likely to be between £5-10k/year on a building like that.

Also depends on what sort of lease it is. A 9 year lease where the tenant has an annual break clause is pretty meaningless.

It can also be much more difficult to secure finance against a commercial property.

It can be very profitable, but it's a minefield for the inexperienced.
You'd be surprised about the rates payable on that unit. Put it this way I wouldn't be submitting an appeal.

The unit is Unit 3 and it is 309 sq m. Its let for a term of 9 years from 1 April 2012 for a 9 year term, at a rent of £17,160pa. The RV is £6,800 which for a qualifying small business (and assuming they get all the reliefs) gives rates payable of under £400! If it was empty the empty rates would be around £3,400 pa. Either the rents on that estate are higher than the local average or the VOs valuations are particularly conservative.

There is a link on the Rightmove site to the selling agents particulars in case you wonder how I know the additional info.
One of the cowboys will no doubt still have a go though....

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
surveyor said:
One of the cowboys will no doubt still have a go though....
I must admit I checked the Rating List rather expecting that they would already have, but they haven't.................yet!

TVR MAN

1,038 posts

253 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
The RV is £6,800 which for a qualifying small business (and assuming they get all the reliefs) gives rates payable of under £400!
Can you give any more detail on this? £400 is amazing!

Vocal Minority

8,582 posts

183 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
That has a net initial yield of 11.25%, which is actually not all that competitive. For a basic industrial unit in an unestablished location I would say that could be considered steamy. There are certainly higher returns out there - though I have no idea how much risk this has attached.

The principal questions you want to ask are:

Are there any break clauses where the tenant could vacate prior to the 9 year term completing?

What is the financial strength of the tenant, can they see out the 9 years and not default on their rent?

Do they have a guarantor or not?

If for any reason you are not certain they will be there in 9 years time (looking at the type of property - I sure as hell wouldn't be) you need to ask:

How long will it take me to find another occupier?

How much rent will I get - am I looking at a big drop in income if I need to get a new tenant?

What sort of tenant incentive do they want - namely will they want a rent free (meaning you are looking at a big gap in income)?

Can you afford the mortgage, rates, insurance, agents fees, security etc whilst it stands tenantless?

IF the property is significantly over-rented (namely the passing rent is higher than the rent you could achieve in the open market) the value could actually decrease the closer you get to the end of the lease. Therefore you need to be very careful with your Loan to Value clause on your mortgage.


This is just a very brief over-view of the sort of things you would need to look at. If you are seriously considering it, appoint a specialist solicitor to help you. It is not usually the license to print money that it looks like - there is still a lot to think about and you need to be pretty careful.

Let's put it this way. On poor industrial or office units you could potentially get returns 0f 15% to even 20%. But these would be high risk and potential money pits.

Commercial property is seriously management intensive. You may even want to appoint a knowledgable management firm to deal with it on your behalf - commercial leases are very technical and a totally different animal to a residential lease and need specialist knoweldge to deal with properly - so you would either need to learn it or appoint someone. This will all eat into your return!

I don't mean to piss on any bonfires here. It is very possible to make money off commercial property, and many people do. However, you need to go in with your eyes wide open. Don't be seduced by what on first glance looks like a good return and get carried away.

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Inkyfingers said:
Commercial property is great until the tenant stops paying (whether because they move or because they go bust). Unless it's in a really desirable spot then commercial properties tend to stay empty A LOT longer than residential premises. I rented a unit until last year on a very nice site and would estimate that at any one time an average 50% of the site was vacant. When it's not rented, you play the rates, which are likely to be between £5-10k/year on a building like that.

Also depends on what sort of lease it is. A 9 year lease where the tenant has an annual break clause is pretty meaningless.

It can also be much more difficult to secure finance against a commercial property.

It can be very profitable, but it's a minefield for the inexperienced.
Exactly this - speaking as a person that is currently working out distressed commercial property portfolios

As others have also said the NIY on that isn't that good, especially for Taunton (likely that low owing to the lease but i'd like to see any personal gtee's for rent/accounts of the tenant etc which if in place would be fair)

I have come across some that were sold at over 20%

Edited by kiethton on Tuesday 14th January 13:25

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
TVR MAN said:
Can you give any more detail on this? £400 is amazing!
Bascially there is government scheme which means that qualifying small businesses get relief on their rates payable. To be a qualifying small business you have to occupy only one non-domestic hereditament (although there is an exemption for certain other small hereditaments) and that qualifying hereditament has to have a RV of less than £12,000.

Under the original scheme you originally had 100% relief at RV £0 and then lost 1% of relief for every increase of £120 in the RV.. Therefore at RV £120 you got 99% relief, at RV £240 you got 98% relief etc until you got to £6,000 where you got no relief. However for a couple of years, and the Autumn Statement has announced an additional years extension, the relief has been doubled. The result being that if your RV is less than £6,000 (and you are a qualifying small business) you pay no rates, and then as your RV increases by £120 your relief decreases by 1%, so RV £6,120 you get 99% relief etc, until you get to £12,000 where there is no relief.

Information can be found at
https://www.gov.uk/apply-for-business-rate-relief/...

Johnniem

2,758 posts

254 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Vocal Minority said:
That has a net initial yield of 11.25%, which is actually not all that competitive. For a basic industrial unit in an unestablished location I would say that could be considered steamy. There are certainly higher returns out there - though I have no idea how much risk this has attached.

The principal questions you want to ask are:

Are there any break clauses where the tenant could vacate prior to the 9 year term completing?

What is the financial strength of the tenant, can they see out the 9 years and not default on their rent?

Do they have a guarantor or not?

If for any reason you are not certain they will be there in 9 years time (looking at the type of property - I sure as hell wouldn't be) you need to ask:

How long will it take me to find another occupier?

How much rent will I get - am I looking at a big drop in income if I need to get a new tenant?

What sort of tenant incentive do they want - namely will they want a rent free (meaning you are looking at a big gap in income)?

Can you afford the mortgage, rates, insurance, agents fees, security etc whilst it stands tenantless?

IF the property is significantly over-rented (namely the passing rent is higher than the rent you could achieve in the open market) the value could actually decrease the closer you get to the end of the lease. Therefore you need to be very careful with your Loan to Value clause on your mortgage.


This is just a very brief over-view of the sort of things you would need to look at. If you are seriously considering it, appoint a specialist solicitor to help you. It is not usually the license to print money that it looks like - there is still a lot to think about and you need to be pretty careful.

Let's put it this way. On poor industrial or office units you could potentially get returns 0f 15% to even 20%. But these would be high risk and potential money pits.

Commercial property is seriously management intensive. You may even want to appoint a knowledgable management firm to deal with it on your behalf - commercial leases are very technical and a totally different animal to a residential lease and need specialist knoweldge to deal with properly - so you would either need to learn it or appoint someone. This will all eat into your return!

I don't mean to piss on any bonfires here. It is very possible to make money off commercial property, and many people do. However, you need to go in with your eyes wide open. Don't be seduced by what on first glance looks like a good return and get carried away.
To add to this and the other previous excellent advice, it is also possible that the landlord had to incentivise the current tenant by agreeing a schedule of condition on the property prior to the lease term commencing. In essence this will limit the landlords ability to expect the property to come back to him in 'good and substantial repair and condition'. This, in the long (or short run if the tenant is able to activate a break clause), means that the landlord picks up the cost of the disrepair items for which the tenant is not liable. This disrepair can be passed on to the next tenant but eventually it catches up on the landlord and can mean really serious costs so make sure you get a good solicitor/surveyor to report to you on the current state of the lease and make sure you get a good chartered building surveyor to carry out a full structural survey (inc commenting on condition generally and likely recovery of dilapidations at the end of the lease).

Good luck and just go in with your eyes wide open!

budfox

Original Poster:

1,510 posts

160 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Just to bump this back up.

I'm really very unlikely to take this any further, I was more interested in the business brains on here explaining why such a unit might not be the cash cow it appears. I'd worked out some of the pitfalls, but everyone's replies have been really helpful.

My position is that I have money stashed away in boring places, but wouldn't mind taking a little more risk for a little more reward with my remaining cash.

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
budfox said:
Just to bump this back up.

I'm really very unlikely to take this any further, I was more interested in the business brains on here explaining why such a unit might not be the cash cow it appears. I'd worked out some of the pitfalls, but everyone's replies have been really helpful.

My position is that I have money stashed away in boring places, but wouldn't mind taking a little more risk for a little more reward with my remaining cash.

Then it's not a bad investment......you get your money back in 8 years..........bid them 125k on it

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
michael gould said:

Then it's not a bad investment......you get your money back in 8 years..........bid them 125k on it
Before doing that he might want to check the lease terms for the tenant, theur financial stability, whether they are up to date on payments etc!