Discussion
Mrs BC and I retired just over a year ago and have been travelling a lot in America including a 5 week Route 66 drive and some others. When we arrived this time the TSA agent advised us to apply for a B2 Visa as we are apparently entering too often for our ESTA's.
Anybody here have any experience of this?
Anybody here have any experience of this?
A couple of things to consider with a B2....
How frequently and for what duration do you intend to visit the US?
As a retiree, you are a more appropriate candidate for this visa, but if you qualify to utilize the visa waiver program, your B2 petition might still be denied and visa denials have to be revealed for ESTA and can be detremental.
Do you have property in the US? If so, that's another point in your favor.
Do you have family here?
How frequently and for what duration do you intend to visit the US?
As a retiree, you are a more appropriate candidate for this visa, but if you qualify to utilize the visa waiver program, your B2 petition might still be denied and visa denials have to be revealed for ESTA and can be detremental.
Do you have property in the US? If so, that's another point in your favor.
Do you have family here?
Matt
Thanks for the response. We just want to be able to spend 3 - 4 months of the year in the USA. We don't own a property or have family in America.
Surely if we owned a property in the US that would indicate that we may stay so would be detrimental to the application?
We were very happy using the ESTA but as I said the TSA agent said that we really should get a visa.
Thanks for the response. We just want to be able to spend 3 - 4 months of the year in the USA. We don't own a property or have family in America.
Surely if we owned a property in the US that would indicate that we may stay so would be detrimental to the application?
We were very happy using the ESTA but as I said the TSA agent said that we really should get a visa.
megaphone said:
My mate travels to the USA many times a year, often staying a month sometimes two. He goes on an ESTA. Can't understand why your being advised to get a visa.
I'm wondering if that is the best option. The TSA guy said that we could be refused entry as we are apparently 'not using the ESTA system as it was meant to be used'. Another potential problem is that if we apply and get refused for a B2 Visa that could I think cause problems with our current and future ESTA's as we will have to declare that we were declined a Visa.megaphone said:
My mate travels to the USA many times a year, often staying a month sometimes two. He goes on an ESTA. Can't understand why your being advised to get a visa.
They don't like repeated long stints. Most people will be advised the same after enough entries.I've done a bunch of 3 months stints back to back before getting my proper visa. Most of the time were fine, but after the last two I got a serious grilling about it and told I'd likely be denied entry if I were to try again if there wasn't sufficient time between visits.
I wouldn't be sweating a 3 month trip once a year, it's only when I was dong them back to back they got the hump - but do bear in mind that the TSA are a useless shower of morons at the best of times and have form for making it up as they go along.
That being said, there's probably no reason not to go for a b2, they're relatively painless to get.
bad company said:
Matt
Thanks for the response. We just want to be able to spend 3 - 4 months of the year in the USA. We don't own a property or have family in America.
Surely if we owned a property in the US that would indicate that we may stay so would be detrimental to the application?
We were very happy using the ESTA but as I said the TSA agent said that we really should get a visa.
B2 is used a lot by 'snowbirds' people from overseas who own vacation property here (predominantly in FL, CA, AZ and the Rockie states).Thanks for the response. We just want to be able to spend 3 - 4 months of the year in the USA. We don't own a property or have family in America.
Surely if we owned a property in the US that would indicate that we may stay so would be detrimental to the application?
We were very happy using the ESTA but as I said the TSA agent said that we really should get a visa.
Regarding the VWP the general rule of thumb seems to be spend as much time out as in - i.e 3 months once per year is perfectly reasonable once per year - just don't try to back-to-back your visits.
CBP officials are VERY often inaccurate in their advice and suggestions. It's not exactly the most intellectually challenging role after all. Downside is that they have absolute power of veto, so best not to argue the toss with them. Personally I would NEVER trust what a CBP official told me as being accurate.
You should minimize your risk of a visa denial, because a B2 denial can (not always does) lead to a subsequent ESTA denial too. Being a retiree should help significantly, but unless you really need to spend more than 90 days continuous in the US, I'd be tempted to continue to utilize the VWP.
Excellent advice ^.
As mentioned above, the real issue the US have is people spending 90 days on the ESTA and then hopping over to Mexico for a day and then returning etc. That (whether or not this is written in the legislation) is not what the ESTA was designed for.
If you are only planning on spending 3 months a year in the US, then you should not have a problem.
Careful not to spend more than 180 days there though otherwise you will be subject to taxation.
Chris
As mentioned above, the real issue the US have is people spending 90 days on the ESTA and then hopping over to Mexico for a day and then returning etc. That (whether or not this is written in the legislation) is not what the ESTA was designed for.
If you are only planning on spending 3 months a year in the US, then you should not have a problem.
Careful not to spend more than 180 days there though otherwise you will be subject to taxation.
Chris
We have spent a long time in the USA since 2013:-
3 weeks in January 13
1 week in March
6 weeks in May - June
4 weeks in October - November
4 weeks in January 14
Due back late February for 3 weeks.
All in all I can see why that is causing a stir. Has anybody here applied for the B2 Visa? Some tips on what to take and what questions they ask would be good.
3 weeks in January 13
1 week in March
6 weeks in May - June
4 weeks in October - November
4 weeks in January 14
Due back late February for 3 weeks.
All in all I can see why that is causing a stir. Has anybody here applied for the B2 Visa? Some tips on what to take and what questions they ask would be good.
Try asking on www.britishexpats.com in the USA forums. There are some insufferable smart-asses on there, but there's also a wealth of knowledge.
B2 is one of only a few non-immigrant visas I haven't had some dealings with, so can't help with direct experience - evidence of strong ties to the UK will be essential, I suspect (reasons why you HAVE to come home). Never lose sight of the fact that USCIS treats every visitor as a potential illegal immigrant.
B2 is one of only a few non-immigrant visas I haven't had some dealings with, so can't help with direct experience - evidence of strong ties to the UK will be essential, I suspect (reasons why you HAVE to come home). Never lose sight of the fact that USCIS treats every visitor as a potential illegal immigrant.
Matt Harper said:
Try asking on www.britishexpats.com in the USA forums. There are some insufferable smart-asses on there, but there's also a wealth of knowledge.
B2 is one of only a few non-immigrant visas I haven't had some dealings with, so can't help with direct experience - evidence of strong ties to the UK will be essential, I suspect (reasons why you HAVE to come home). Never lose sight of the fact that USCIS treats every visitor as a potential illegal immigrant.
Thanks Matt, I just posted the question there.B2 is one of only a few non-immigrant visas I haven't had some dealings with, so can't help with direct experience - evidence of strong ties to the UK will be essential, I suspect (reasons why you HAVE to come home). Never lose sight of the fact that USCIS treats every visitor as a potential illegal immigrant.
Gassing Station | Holidays & Travel | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


