More 'invention' by Met officers, leads to payouts
Discussion
Sadly, further instances of police statements not tallying with the facts.
London Evening Standard said:
Police allegations against two students at a tuition fees demo were thrown out after YouTube film and photographs showed “shocking” inconsistencies in Met officers’ accounts of the incidents.
In both cases the students were wrestled to the ground, arrested, strip-searched, fingerprinted and faced charges that could have damaged their careers.
Debaleena Dasgupta, a solicitor from Birnberg Peirce who represented the men, called on Scotland Yard to investigate, adding: “The police are given immense power and malicious prosecution is one of the grossest abuses of this.”
Both arrests came as education minister David Willetts gave a lecture at London’s School of Oriental and African Studies.
Ashok Kumar, 29, had been invited by a government official to interview Mr Willetts at the event. Police claimed Mr Kumar twice pushed an officer and blocked an attempt to stop a protester allegedly pushing a camera in another constable’s face. He was charged with obstruction.
The case against him was dropped in court after YouTube footage showed the police account was wrong and that no assault or obstruction had taken place.
Scotland Yard has agreed to pay Mr Kumar £20,000 in damages after he launched legal action for wrongful arrest, false imprisonment, assault and malicious prosecution. Mr Kumar, who was at the LSE at the time of the incident in June 2011, but is now studying for a PhD at Oxford, today spoke of his relief at being cleared.
But he said he had been appalled by his treatment and the inaccurate accounts given by police. “What was astonishing was I was sitting in court and there were officers there ready to testify that I had done something when it was as clear as day from the video that I hadn’t,” he said.
Mr Kumar said he was stopped from entering the lecture by officers. As he waited outside, he saw a teenager who was filming police being told by Pc Paul McAuslan not to push a camera in his face.
Mr Kumar intervened, to which the officer responded angrily. Moments later, Mr Kumar was wrestled to the ground by several officers. Charges were brought with Pc McAuslan claiming that Mr Kumar had pushed him twice before running off. A letter from Scotland Yard’s legal department to Mr Kumar’s solicitor states that the Met “accepts that there do appear to be inconsistencies between this footage and the notes of Pc McAuslan”.
The other case involved Simon Behrman, 36, a law PhD student at Birkbeck College who had gone to SOAS to demonstrate against Mr Willetts’s policies.
The Met paid £20,000 damages and conceded that testimony given in court by Pc Chris Johnson clashed with the evidence of photos of the incident. Mr Behrman claimed that he fell after Pc Johnson grabbed his rucksack and the protest group he had joined surged forward.
Legal papers claim Mr Behrman was then punched in the chest by another officer, Pc Thomas Ashley, before being taken in a headlock by another officer.
At his trial at Highbury magistrates’ court, Pc Johnson said Mr Behrman had been violent and had struggled with a security guard.
The case was abandoned when pictures taken by a photographer were shown to the court which the judge said “blow this case out of the water”.
The Met said that it had begun an investigation. A spokeswoman added: “Three officers are the subject of the IPCC supervised investigation. At no time had we previously received a public complaint in relation to this matter. As soon as we were aware of the video evidence an investigation was launched.”
StreakyIn both cases the students were wrestled to the ground, arrested, strip-searched, fingerprinted and faced charges that could have damaged their careers.
Debaleena Dasgupta, a solicitor from Birnberg Peirce who represented the men, called on Scotland Yard to investigate, adding: “The police are given immense power and malicious prosecution is one of the grossest abuses of this.”
Both arrests came as education minister David Willetts gave a lecture at London’s School of Oriental and African Studies.
Ashok Kumar, 29, had been invited by a government official to interview Mr Willetts at the event. Police claimed Mr Kumar twice pushed an officer and blocked an attempt to stop a protester allegedly pushing a camera in another constable’s face. He was charged with obstruction.
The case against him was dropped in court after YouTube footage showed the police account was wrong and that no assault or obstruction had taken place.
Scotland Yard has agreed to pay Mr Kumar £20,000 in damages after he launched legal action for wrongful arrest, false imprisonment, assault and malicious prosecution. Mr Kumar, who was at the LSE at the time of the incident in June 2011, but is now studying for a PhD at Oxford, today spoke of his relief at being cleared.
But he said he had been appalled by his treatment and the inaccurate accounts given by police. “What was astonishing was I was sitting in court and there were officers there ready to testify that I had done something when it was as clear as day from the video that I hadn’t,” he said.
Mr Kumar said he was stopped from entering the lecture by officers. As he waited outside, he saw a teenager who was filming police being told by Pc Paul McAuslan not to push a camera in his face.
Mr Kumar intervened, to which the officer responded angrily. Moments later, Mr Kumar was wrestled to the ground by several officers. Charges were brought with Pc McAuslan claiming that Mr Kumar had pushed him twice before running off. A letter from Scotland Yard’s legal department to Mr Kumar’s solicitor states that the Met “accepts that there do appear to be inconsistencies between this footage and the notes of Pc McAuslan”.
The other case involved Simon Behrman, 36, a law PhD student at Birkbeck College who had gone to SOAS to demonstrate against Mr Willetts’s policies.
The Met paid £20,000 damages and conceded that testimony given in court by Pc Chris Johnson clashed with the evidence of photos of the incident. Mr Behrman claimed that he fell after Pc Johnson grabbed his rucksack and the protest group he had joined surged forward.
Legal papers claim Mr Behrman was then punched in the chest by another officer, Pc Thomas Ashley, before being taken in a headlock by another officer.
At his trial at Highbury magistrates’ court, Pc Johnson said Mr Behrman had been violent and had struggled with a security guard.
The case was abandoned when pictures taken by a photographer were shown to the court which the judge said “blow this case out of the water”.
The Met said that it had begun an investigation. A spokeswoman added: “Three officers are the subject of the IPCC supervised investigation. At no time had we previously received a public complaint in relation to this matter. As soon as we were aware of the video evidence an investigation was launched.”
Had these people actually been convicted, how much would they have lost by having a criminal record, over their working lives? That is the amount of damages that any police officer who is proved to have lied should have taken from them personally.
(I know that they'll loose job and pension etc, but obviously that deterrent is not enough)
(I know that they'll loose job and pension etc, but obviously that deterrent is not enough)
New POD said:
Had these people actually been convicted, how much would they have lost by having a criminal record, over their working lives? That is the amount of damages that any police officer who is proved to have lied should have taken from them personally.
(I know that they'll loose job and pension etc, but obviously that deterrent is not enough)
They've lost their ability to use the USA green card system as things stand !(I know that they'll loose job and pension etc, but obviously that deterrent is not enough)
rewc said:
The President of ACPO, Sir Hugh Orde, is urging that police officers should be paid more, in order to dissuade them from being dishonest.
There's a similar argument for raising MPs' salaries (though it more usually refers to the potentially higher calibre of candidate the increased salary would attract, which I guess goes hand in hand...)
.I posted elsewhere on SP&L today that ACPO is no longer credible now it is a 'political' organisation, and now Orde (hopefully inadvertently
) all-but blows the whole damn politicians' expenses gaffe wide open and shows that "dishonesty" is apparently a wider problem in the public sector than just MPs with their snouts in the trough
.
rewc said:
The President of ACPO, Sir Hugh Orde, is urging that police officers should be paid more, in order to dissuade them from being dishonest.
He's not, he's assessing it as an area of risk whilst looking at corruption overall, as there's a link between people in difficult financial circumstances and taking payments etc.Regarding this, how thick must you be to write things grossly different to what occurred? If it's as it sounds, and the met clearly assess there must be something in it or they wouldn't pay out, then some jobs appear to be under threat.
There's enough demand to be in the police - just obtaining an application is hard enough whilst we're at >7% unemployment - we can pick and choose enough decent people.
aw51 121565 said:
There's a similar argument for raising MPs' salaries
Yeah, pay us more (although we don't really want it 'cos "we're all in it together" but an "independent" body said we should be paid more so we'll take it, thanks) and we'll stop fiddling our (proposterously generous) expenses ...davemac250 said:
La Liga - have you sat on any interview panels?
Applicants may be plentiful. Quality less so.
Only internal. And to be fair, it's hardly going to be a process to be able to judge whether someone will do something dishonest in the future when faced with scenarios they've never faced before. Applicants may be plentiful. Quality less so.
I think I mean it in a more theoretical "it's a shame as there are so many good, honest people out there who want to join the police."
carinaman said:
Nigel Worc's said:
They've lost their ability to use the USA green card system as things stand !
Because they've been charged?How would they do getting into the US on holiday or for business?
This is because, in many other countries, the US being one, the Police are actually required to have a reason before they can arrest you, not just think they may have a reason, so they'll arrest you anyway and then seek to see if they actually do have a reason, like in the UK.
Once this has happened to you, you require a visa.
Nigel Worc's said:
New POD said:
Had these people actually been convicted, how much would they have lost by having a criminal record, over their working lives? That is the amount of damages that any police officer who is proved to have lied should have taken from them personally.
(I know that they'll loose job and pension etc, but obviously that deterrent is not enough)
They've lost their ability to use the USA green card system as things stand !(I know that they'll loose job and pension etc, but obviously that deterrent is not enough)
La Liga said:
And to be fair, it's hardly going to be a process to be able to judge whether someone will do something dishonest in the future when faced with scenarios they've never faced before.
Which is why the culture (hate to use that term but it seems appropriate) within the force has to make dishonesty absolutely unacceptable. We can only assume it doesn't - or this would not happen.CoolHands said:
La Liga said:
And to be fair, it's hardly going to be a process to be able to judge whether someone will do something dishonest in the future when faced with scenarios they've never faced before.
Which is why the culture (hate to use that term but it seems appropriate) within the force has to make dishonesty absolutely unacceptable. We can only assume it doesn't - or this would not happen.La Liga said:
In the UK a reason is required. It's not the UK's fault the US is ignorant to what an arrest is over here.
You don't need a reason, you only need to think you may have a reason, if you're a Constable that is.It isn't the US's fault that the arrest criteria in the UK is so much lower than in their country.
It is however the UK citizens that lose out.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


