Enforcing a court judgment (debt collection question)
Enforcing a court judgment (debt collection question)
Author
Discussion

rswift

Original Poster:

1,181 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
So, I had to chase an ex client through the small claims court for an unpaid invoice, today I got a ruling in my favour.

What is the best way to enforce the judgement, and get the money out of him. He has a LTD company, which appears still to be current....I though he would have closed it, as I know a number fop people are after money.

It's not a huge amount, £420 (£350 & VAT)....so not worth spending a fortune chasing it, but this is my first experience of debt recovery (luck after best part of 30 years in business).

My immediate thoughts are to write/email a polite letter, stating that as the court has ruled in my favour, the fee is payable immediately, or I will have to take further action to recover the debt.....I am just not sure what the "further action" should be.

My gut feeling is that he is in the st, sitting on a pile of unopened bills & letters, so I'd like to get in there quickly.

Thank you

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Is the judgement in the name of the limited company or the individual?

rswift

Original Poster:

1,181 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Hi,

It's in the name of a LTD company.

Edited by rswift on Tuesday 14th January 19:04

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Well that's not my area but from what I glean here the usual plan is a 'winding up order'. However you have to consider how much you spend versus the likelihood of getting paid. If someone really doesn't want to pay it can be phenomenally hard to get them to do so - you have make paying up the least bad option for them. Hence you have to know your enemy and decide what tactics are most likely to work.

Justin Cyder

12,624 posts

180 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
You won't get a winding up order for £400 odd quid. If it's MCOL, the defendant has the right to appeal the judgement. Assuming they don't, ask for payment, keep records. When they don't pay, go back to the court & fill in a warrant of execution. The court will instruct bailiffs & that should do it, all things being equal.

However, all things are often not equal. You should balance the time & costs involved against the likely outcome. I.e. don't bother pursuing someone who is skint, you'll be throwing good money after bad. It's a judgement you have to make in the final analysis, but good luck with it.

GoneBananas

129 posts

167 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
I've been in this situation, the best way to enforce it and get your money is to pay him an unannounced visit. Preferably in as public a place as possible. We all handle things differently, but I normally go in with guns blazing (so to speak) biggrin I pretend to be angry and for a small amount like this he will probably just pay to get rid of you. If he offers a cheque, try and insist on cash.

Happy Jim

1,080 posts

270 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
The sherrifs office will cost £60 (which he will end up paying), they do all the collecting for you!

rswift

Original Poster:

1,181 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks chaps, it is the principle of being fked about by him that I would like to cause maximum embarrassment or grief, however he's about 4 hours away so I'm not planning on a personal visit. I'd happily stick another £60 to the sherifs office, not heard of this. I am guessing that the amount is too low for any of the traditional bailiffs to be interested.

Justin Cyder

12,624 posts

180 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
The Bailiffs will charge. You pay them, they recover it from the debtor. The amount owed is incidental, it all gets added on to the debt owed.

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
As I understand there are county court bailiffs, who are useless, and high court bailiffs who are very good. However to get the latter involved you have to escalate the case to the high court, which I think is not an option for this sum.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Hang on, shirley if you got a ruling in your favour the court should have said what has to be paid and when?? Ie all of it, now, or within 7 days or something?

Justin Cyder

12,624 posts

180 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
In theory yes, but in practice a judgement & four quid will buy you a pint. The kind of people who fail to meet their obligations are not usually inclined to reform themselves until compelled to do so.

rswift

Original Poster:

1,181 posts

206 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Justin Cyder said:
In theory yes, but in practice a judgement & four quid will buy you a pint. The kind of people who fail to meet their obligations are not usually inclined to reform themselves until compelled to do so.
Yes, I failed to realise this when I embarked on the small claims, I thought that if I won (which I have) the court would then enforce it's judgement, but apparently not. If the other party chooses not to pay, the worst that happens is that after a set period of time (not sure what that is) the have a county court judgement registered against them, making credit etc more difficult to obtain, but as LTD Company, barely trading, I don't think they will be in the least bit bothered.

Makes you wonder why the rest of us all get on with things properly paying bills & taxes as required !

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
rswift said:
I thought that if I won (which I have) the court would then enforce it's judgement, but apparently not... Makes you wonder why the rest of us all get on with things properly paying bills & taxes as required !
Yes indeed; all the court really does is confirm the debt is valid and make your further actions to get paid legal. The small claims system is complex, expensive and in the cold hard light of day, toothless.

Seany88

1,249 posts

251 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
What about for larger claims? Are the courts still powerless?

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Seany88 said:
What about for larger claims? Are the courts still powerless?
It's not a question of the courts being powerless, it's a question of what does the law allow a judgment creditor to do to obtain their money? There are legally sanctioned methods of obtaining the money, whether it be by sending bailiffs or enforcement officers in to seize goods or taking sums directly from wages or forcing the sale of property.

All these measures need to be applied reasonably and proportionately, but ultimately if there's no money to pay the debt then there's no money. I for one don't think it's reasonable for someone to be chucked out of their home for a debt of a couple of grand, but it could well be reasonable to order that sum be seized from a deposit account or a vehicle seized and stolen.

Ultimately all debt actions do is provide the winner with a finding from the court that they are owed money, and the court then will sanction various methods for a creditor to try and obtain that money. Although it seems unfair to judgment creditors I'd rather this approach was taken than have government employed debt collectors kicking the door in at 4am to seize anything they could to repay a debt of a few hundred quid.

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Of course if you don't pay your council tax or parking fine you go straight to jail. Funny that. The State CAN be effective but doesn't bother when it comes to Johnny Citizen trying to get paid.

rswift

Original Poster:

1,181 posts

206 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I have to say, that if I had have looked into this a little more carefully (i.e. winning the case, but no closer to getting paid) I would have one down a slightly different route.

In hindsight I could have claimed for more money, as we had contracted work that was cancelled, plus the actual work we carried out and gone straight to a debt collection agency. This would have also been quicker, and would have caught him with a chance of some cash still in the bank.

As far as I can see as of now, I can basically try and "frighten" him with a possibility of a CCJ via a few strongly worded emails, letters & phone calls. Other than that it's chucking another £100 or so.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
As I understand there are county court bailiffs, who are useless, and high court bailiffs who are very good. However to get the latter involved you have to escalate the case to the high court, which I think is not an option for this sum.
No you can get a High Court Writ for smaller sums as well.

I escalated a county court to a high court writ for £600, so would assume £400 to be OK.


johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
rswift said:
I have to say, that if I had have looked into this a little more carefully (i.e. winning the case, but no closer to getting paid) I would have one down a slightly different route.

In hindsight I could have claimed for more money, as we had contracted work that was cancelled, plus the actual work we carried out and gone straight to a debt collection agency. This would have also been quicker, and would have caught him with a chance of some cash still in the bank.

As far as I can see as of now, I can basically try and "frighten" him with a possibility of a CCJ via a few strongly worded emails, letters & phone calls. Other than that it's chucking another £100 or so.
Just because you have made this successful claim, it does mean you have waived your right to make another claim if they cancelled other contracted work in breach.

Did their cancellation amount to a breach? If you think so, merely issue another claim. If the amount claimed is greater than £750 and you win the claim and he fails to pay, you can then threaten to wind up his company.