Why do businesses cap commissions?
Why do businesses cap commissions?
Author
Discussion

Frimley111R

Original Poster:

19,429 posts

265 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
I have just been talking to a friend who has found out that his company has capped his (and colleagues) commissions. The cap is very high (£150k) but I can't for the life of me work out why they would do this. Surely the more he earns the more his company earns and once he reaches that cap he'll just stop until the following year.

It reminded me of a another friend who had the same issue at BT many years ago. He earned £££ and was one of their top performers but left to join a Canadian company who essentially said 'the sky's the limit'.

Shaoxter

4,618 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Has anyone actually ever hit the cap? Presumably if someone was close then they would start having discussions?

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
You do it to cover yourself as an employer contractually against some bizarre mathematical outcome that no-one foresaw which makes you liable to pay out 200% of sales.

Not really needed if it's "here, sell as many chocolate bars as you can, we'll pay you 5% of the gross". But it's certainly needed in any form of complex sales environment, with multi-year deals, renewals, joint sales, volume multipliers, service contracts, house accounts, etc etc.

And there's nothing to stop the company paying more than the cap. I'd expect any good salesman to be knocking on my door saying "look, I hit the 150k cap, without it I'd have made 180k, I'd like the 30k please".

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Is it also to do with the changes within the bankinfg sactor which of the top of my memory means you cannot give bonuses that exceed salary without shareholder approval?

Not sure of the field of the guys the OP refers to but maybe the EU law affect all firms not just financial ones?

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
its not just about revenue. Also might not just be about 1 guys commission if a team are paid on the target. Many companies also have "accelerator" deals where you get 2 or 3x normal commission when you exceed your target. Also margin levels , anyone can sell and beat the competition if you sell at a loss wink

We once had the occasion where a large deal was done but margin was low (pretty normal these days) the way it worked out on the old commission plan was that we had a 14 man team potentially walking away with £250-500K each and the company being negative on the deal by the time products shipped

Commission has been capped since then at 2x OTE e.g. your on £100K and can make an extra £200k in commission on top

Every company will be different, depending on the market they are in ...selling one shot deals at fixed margin is different to £100m per year accounts where there is other potential to earn more in year 3 or exchange rate fluctuations will make the company out of pocket etc

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
In addition to what has been said by others the cap is probably also there so a top sales guy doesn't take home more than the head of the company. Or chase contracts that are so big that getting one could cripple the company, I know a sales guy who will promise impossible delivery times etc to get a sale despite it being impossible for the department to meet the demand.

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
In addition to what has been said by others the cap is probably also there so a top sales guy doesn't take home more than the head of the company.
This (sales guy comp > MD) happens quite frequently and is entirely appropriate. Senior people should be looking to make their comp through long term equity value, not annual salary. Having your top sales people making enough comm to be the highest paid employee is a great thing in a sales driven organisation.


Simpo Two

93,100 posts

296 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Didn't 3M do this after one of their employees accidentally invented Post-it notes?

Terminator X

21,017 posts

235 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Greed? At my previous company bonuses were capped at your annual salary despite it not even getting close ... that could have just been my bonus though of course cry

TX.

StevieBee

15,516 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
There are many reasons to this and much depends on the size and type of company.

I once worked for a company that capped commissions and there reasoning was that if one of a team of sales people strikes it lucky and earns significantly more than the rest of the team, the risk is that this can demotivate the rest of the salesforce which then has a detrimental effect on overall sales. I can understand this. You do want a team working as a unit of sorts.