Insurance/Police advice needed please.
Insurance/Police advice needed please.
Author
Discussion

BigBazza

Original Poster:

2,135 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Hello All,
Now that I'm 40 and I've calmed down, I've not had to use this forum for years!
The advice I'm after is on behalf of my Niece who is 21 and in a world of pain.
She was stopped by police yesterday morning in her little Corsa for using an access only road to run her brother to work (he told her everyone uses it etc etc - doesn't make it right I know)
They ran the car through the system and comes back as uninsured so they have seized and impounded it, issued her with a hefty fine and 6 points I believe.
As far as she knew, the car was insured, it is taxed, MOT'd, she has a full license, no points, works hard for a living looking after old people etc which is why I'm trying to help her.
She contacted her insurers "Premium Choice" and they said they sent a recorded delivery letter requesting further documents in early Dec, so she emailed the documents (proof of NCD and her license) then she was contacted again asking for them again so she sent them again and heard nothing further.
Turns out there was ANOTHER recorded delivery letter sent AGAIN asking for these documents which she never received, the insurers have confirmed that this was "returned to sender" so have confirmed my niece did not receive it.
They then cancelled her insurance on 9th Dec with no further correspondence. The policy was paid up to date, last payment was taken in Nov, they didn't take Decs payment.
Turns out they tried texting her but she had input her number a digit wrong so there is blame on both sides etc.
Question boils down to basically is she GUILTY if she was totally unaware and as far as she knew done everything she needed to do to be driving legally?
Seems a shame that she cant now afford to get her car back when she was ultimately a legitimate road user who has been the victim of a catalogue of admin disasters.
Any advice greatly appreciated.
Thanks

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
"World of pain"? I am sorry, but this is a First World Problem, as problems go. Not fun, but not exactly ruin and destruction either.

I am sorry also to say that I detect a whiff of BS about the niece's story about receiving the letters and sending the documents.

From memory, and without checking, I think that the offence here does not require intent (I will be corrected if wrong), but if the story is true that may be mitigation of penalty.

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Unless the insurance company are happy to admit they are in the wrong and issue a letter saying they will backdate the insurance and cover her from November, which I very much doubt they will do, I think she is going to have to take it on the chin I'm afraid.

BigBazza

Original Poster:

2,135 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Well if losing your car and job at 21 when you've tried your best doesn't qualify, I apologise.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Did she not notice that the payment had not left her account in December? Perhaps not, although when I was 21 I was so skint that I read my bank statements avidly because my finances were so marginal. I am more likely to overlook financial snafus now that I am less skint. In any event, the story about the letters looks a tad iffy.

The police cannot issue a fine or points. They can propose a fixed penalty. The facts stated, if true, could be offered to seek a reduced penalty, but that would require a court plea. Can someone not help her with the payment to get the car back?



Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 16th January 11:56

Vaud

60,042 posts

186 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
BigBazza said:
They ran the car through the system and comes back as uninsured so they have seized and impounded it, issued her with a hefty fine and 6 points I believe.
As they didn't take the payment, and she didn't check, I think it is going to be a hard life lesson.

She will get a chance for court though, it isn't automatic by the police.

BigBazza

Original Poster:

2,135 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Not everyone goes through their bank statements every month and checks every payment off. I didn't when I was 21 and I still don't now. Living on the edge eh? wink

I'll see what her insurance say.

Its not just paying to get the car back, its going to be getting insurance having had insurance cancelled and with 6 points etc.

The Ins Co have confirmed the recorded delivery letter was sent back to them unsigned for.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Yes, but what about the two emails that she says that she sent with her docs? My suspicion is that she may have been ditzy and perhaps did not respond to the document requests, but now says that she did in order to avoid appearing ditzy. I speak as a (non 21 year old) ditz.

Once is happenstance, twice is circumstance, three times is enemy action.

IanV12

11,949 posts

189 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Did she have a card through the door about the recorded delivery?
I don't think the insurers will show any compassion, its down to the driver to check that they are insured, not the other way round. Although they should still have sent plenty of letters before it got this far.
She should be glad she did not have an accident and be liable for the damage and potential other damage

BigBazza

Original Poster:

2,135 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
She emailed her docs, she has a Hotmail account and her sent stuff isn't saved after 30 days.

Any ideas as to how to show they were sent? Can sent Hotmail be retrieved somehow?

Vaud

60,042 posts

186 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
BigBazza said:
Not everyone goes through their bank statements every month and checks every payment off. I didn't when I was 21 and I still don't now. Living on the edge eh? wink
I didn't say I don't feel sorry for her. Everyone was young once. Everyone makes errors. I don't dispute that.

But insurance is an absolute offence; mitigation for her will be very hard (there are a few areas of defence but "I didn't check that I had paid for the service I need" is not a great defence in a court. Note, I am not a lawyer.

Sorry, I'm trying to separate what is likely to happen to her in court and the end outcome from empathy. I empathise - I did silly things last week, let alone when I was 21, but the law in this are tends to be pretty binary.

BigBazza

Original Poster:

2,135 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Ian - yes there was a card through, she was busy etc, time went on and by the time she went to pick it up it had been sent back. Nothing on the card to say who it was from.

Like I say, it has been a catalogue of disasters, just seems that there are enough people/young people who don't try or care, for one of the good ones to be slapped back in this way that's all. I'm sure you all know what I mean.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I do not know about hotmail as I use other Pop3 services, but am surprised that emails sent via hotmail are only retained for 30 days. There also I smell a faint smell, but call me a cynic. Ask the insurer, and contact hotmail and ask for copies - nothing on the net is ever deleted really. Did she use the correct email address? One incorrect character can doom the email to an eternity in mailjail, and you don't always get an error message.

If the story is kosher, I am sorry for the young woman, but she will probably have to grin and bear it.

Vaud

60,042 posts

186 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
I do not know about hotmail as I use other Pop3 services, but am surprised that emails sent via hotmail are only retained for 30 days. There also I smell a faint smell, but call me a cynic. Ask the insurer, and contact hotmail and ask for copies - nothing on the net is ever deleted really. Did she use the correct email address? One incorrect character can doom the email to an eternity in mailjail, and you don't always get an error message.
No, it appears to be partly true.

Hotmail did used to automatically delete items older than 30 days (a few years ago)
It does still from Trash and Junk folders.
It may be set to only show the last 30 days by default on a mobile device, etc but it's a while since I used it.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
From many years ago when I was a clerk in an insurance company. Similar instances as these did occur from time to time and whilst legally the company cannot 'backdate' cover they can say they would have indemnified the insured in a letter which is usually enough for the police to accept.

She needs to find her emails and any other 'proof' she has to back up her story and then follow whatever the legal route is to get matters rescinded - if that is indeed possible.

Not sure how you'd go about this aspect doubtless if the 'proof' exists it should be possible.

Get her car out for her and if things pan out maybe a refund will be possible?

BigBazza

Original Poster:

2,135 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I plan to get her car out, how do I insure it temporarily to get it out of the compound while we sort the other matters out?

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
BigBazza said:
She emailed her docs, she has a Hotmail account and her sent stuff isn't saved after 30 days.

Any ideas as to how to show they were sent? Can sent Hotmail be retrieved somehow?
My Hotmail has sent items dating right back to 2008 (around 800 sent emails) - not sure why her's would only be 30 days?

ETA: As @Vaud said, if she's using a mobile device the time frames can be set for how much mail/days to sync. Try logging into Hotmail on a PC and you should be able to see much further back.

Vaud

60,042 posts

186 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
CallorFold said:
My Hotmail has sent items dating right back to 2008 - not sure why her's would only be 30 days?
Going way back, it was automatic (as in pre 2006) to save space, IIRC.

Most probably she is accessing from a phone/tablet - in which case they aren't locally synced on the phone past 30 days - the PC web interface would be worth looking at. I don't think you can even auto set it now to delete 30 days +.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
BB - get back in touch with her insurers and pay the premium over the phone - they should issue cover immediately (also make sure the NCD proof is sent and acknowledged. Should be able to sort it in an hour.

Fatrat

682 posts

222 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
BigBazza said:
I plan to get her car out, how do I insure it temporarily to get it out of the compound while we sort the other matters out?
tempcover.com