Invoice Issue
Author
Discussion

jpringle819

Original Poster:

734 posts

270 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Last summer I arranged for 2 pallets of personal household items to be shipped from Canada to the UK following a decision to live in the UK permanently. My father in law organised the shipping on the Canada side and all fees and container transport to the UK cost £600. I provided the shipper with details of a receiving agent over here to arrange clearing customs. My father contacted the company they use and they agreed to do the job for us.

The container arrived a week early in October last year whilst we were on holiday which added some complications in dealing with it. The first we heard was when we were contacted by warehouse company that we were not dealing with saying that the pallets had arrived. We passed this information onto the agent we were using and they agreed to chase it up and sort out the clearance. We chased them daily asking for progress and an idea of how much it would cost.

The original idea was to rent a van and collect the pallets ourselves but due to being on holiday we asked them to quote for delivery to my fathers warehouse, my fathers company is already a customer of the agent. A few more emails were exchanged asking for a quote but none was forthcoming. We finally got an email saying that the pallets had cleared customs and were being delivered to my father warehouse. I had some rough quotes suggesting that to ship 2 pallets from Liverpool to Nottingham would be less than £300 and I expected a charge of £70 for clearing customs and 7 days free warehousing.

As they had already begun shipping and the estimated cost (in my head) was not much more than the cost of hiring a van plus fuel we waited for the delivery to turn up. About a week after it had been delivered (end of October) we got an email asking if they could invoice my fathers company for the delivery and customs clearance. As this was nothing to do with the company we said it would not be possible and they would have to invoice us directly.

At this point it was obvious that someone hadn't followed the correct processes at the agent and had done all the work without setting us up as a customer so there was no way to invoice us. They also had shipped the stuff without giving us a quote, despite us asking for one, and without our agreement to go ahead with the shipping. At this point asked again what was owed and waited for them to send an invoice.

We were just coming up to 3 months since the last contact and I was hoping that this would have been forgotten about or covered up internally as they hadn't followed the correct process. Unfortunately today we have had an email asking for £800 to cover the cost of getting 2 pallets from Liverpool plus the customs charges which is considerably more than it cost to get from Canada to Liverpool. They have asked us to fill out a credit application so that we can be setup as a customer and to pay the full amount by bank transfer today. They have said they can't issue an invoice until they have processed the credit application.

At this stage I am not sure what to do, whilst I agree that we owe something as they have provided a service I don't agree on the cost. I also think they haven't followed the correct process as we weren't a 'customer' with them at the time they provided the service, they didn't provide a quote and they shipped it without any agreement from us. This is a large multinational company and I don't think they are setup to deal with individual non-business customers.


joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Make them a reasonable offer in full and final settlement.

Their internal processes are their problem, not yours :-)

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Whether they've set you up as a "customer" on their accounting software is neither here nor there really.
The only issue is whether there was a contract (written, oral or otherwise) for them to carry out the service for you.
It seems like they have carried out the service, but not at an agreed price.

Are you saying you didn't authorise them to deliver the stuff for you?
Did you tell them not to do it until you'd had a quote?
Once you knew they were going to do it, did you tell them to stop until a price was agreed?

I don't think the matter is as complicated as the back story makes it seem. In a nutshell a company did some work for you without agreeing the price first, now they want to raise a large bill you're not happy with. Is that about right? If so then you're by far not the first person this has happened to in the world and there will be plenty of people along to offer advice on how to deal with it.

My main advice would be not to get hung up on the "setting up as a customer" bit, that's a red herring. You need to focus on the "authorisation to carry out the work", bit.

jpringle819

Original Poster:

734 posts

270 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
I have spoken to them and I am waiting for a breakdown of the cost, I also pointed out that they did not give us the quote as asked and they delivered without our go ahead. He is going to respond by email later today. At the moment I have no contract with them to do the work and no explicit permission in any emails giving them permission to do the work. It would appear that they have also given me 'credit' without me filling out the credit application form.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
The credit thing is a red herring.

FWIW, I pay £36 to ship a pallet to London from Notingham (and £36 to ship it to Liverpool from Nottingham).

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
jpringle819 said:
At the moment I have no contract with them to do the work
You may not have a piece of paper which says "contract" at the top but that doesn't mean you don't have a contract.

jpringle819

Original Poster:

734 posts

270 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
My understanding that any implied contract was for clearing customs. The additional work they undertook in delivering the goods was not part of the initial agreement.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
When did they deliver the goods? Where to and who took delivery? What was signed when the goods were delivered?
What protestations did you make when they originally tried to invoice your company for the delivery and customs clearance?

berlintaxi

8,535 posts

204 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
jpringle819 said:
It would appear that they have also given me 'credit' without me filling out the credit application form.
So what,he obviously perceives you as a good risk.

h0b0

9,103 posts

227 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Are you the customer or is the agent? That might be why they did not set you up as a customer because the agent is already the customer. If so, pass it along to the agent. I know in my world a one off customer will get charged around double a standing customer so your agent may have terms that mean the final cost is considerably less than the 800 pounds you have now

jpringle819

Original Poster:

734 posts

270 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
berlintaxi said:
So what,he obviously perceives you as a good risk.
We are talking about a large multinational company I don't think the person I am dealing would be able to accept a new customer and arrange services without some formal process in place. I believe the contact at this company assumed that they were dealing with my fathers company and not an individual.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Unclear how that strengthens your position.

jpringle819

Original Poster:

734 posts

270 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
h0b0 said:
Are you the customer or is the agent? That might be why they did not set you up as a customer because the agent is already the customer. If so, pass it along to the agent. I know in my world a one off customer will get charged around double a standing customer so your agent may have terms that mean the final cost is considerably less than the 800 pounds you have now
There is only the agent/shipping company and myself involved. The one company was contacted to arrange customs clearance but has also taken it upon themselves to arrange delivery without a quote or formal arrangement.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
After you have got the breakdown of costs send them a letter telling them their charges are unrealistic and enclose a cheque for say £150 plus the customs and any other fixed charges they have incurred as previously said - in full and final settlement. Maybe add that we had no contract or agreed cost and that should they wish to you'll see them in court.

Ought to be the end of the matter

skwdenyer

18,707 posts

271 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
As of right now they haven't raised an invoice.

Don't fill in the credit application - you don't want credit. Don't sign anything like an application that might now bind you to their terms. Wait for an invoice and take it from there.

Be very careful about any wording they send you in case you inadvertently agree to terms.

moreflaps

746 posts

186 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
jpringle819 said:
Last summer I arranged for 2 pallets of personal household items to be shipped from Canada to the UK following a decision to live in the UK permanently. My father in law organised the shipping on the Canada side and all fees and container transport to the UK cost £600. I provided the shipper with details of a receiving agent over here to arrange clearing customs. My father contacted the company they use and they agreed to do the job for us.

The container arrived a week early in October last year whilst we were on holiday which added some complications in dealing with it. The first we heard was when we were contacted by warehouse company that we were not dealing with saying that the pallets had arrived. We passed this information onto the agent we were using and they agreed to chase it up and sort out the clearance. We chased them daily asking for progress and an idea of how much it would cost.

The original idea was to rent a van and collect the pallets ourselves but due to being on holiday we asked them to quote for delivery to my fathers warehouse, my fathers company is already a customer of the agent. A few more emails were exchanged asking for a quote but none was forthcoming. We finally got an email saying that the pallets had cleared customs and were being delivered to my father warehouse. I had some rough quotes suggesting that to ship 2 pallets from Liverpool to Nottingham would be less than £300 and I expected a charge of £70 for clearing customs and 7 days free warehousing.

As they had already begun shipping and the estimated cost (in my head) was not much more than the cost of hiring a van plus fuel we waited for the delivery to turn up. About a week after it had been delivered (end of October) we got an email asking if they could invoice my fathers company for the delivery and customs clearance. As this was nothing to do with the company we said it would not be possible and they would have to invoice us directly.

At this point it was obvious that someone hadn't followed the correct processes at the agent and had done all the work without setting us up as a customer so there was no way to invoice us. They also had shipped the stuff without giving us a quote, despite us asking for one, and without our agreement to go ahead with the shipping. At this point asked again what was owed and waited for them to send an invoice.

We were just coming up to 3 months since the last contact and I was hoping that this would have been forgotten about or covered up internally as they hadn't followed the correct process. Unfortunately today we have had an email asking for £800 to cover the cost of getting 2 pallets from Liverpool plus the customs charges which is considerably more than it cost to get from Canada to Liverpool. They have asked us to fill out a credit application so that we can be setup as a customer and to pay the full amount by bank transfer today. They have said they can't issue an invoice until they have processed the credit application.

At this stage I am not sure what to do, whilst I agree that we owe something as they have provided a service I don't agree on the cost. I also think they haven't followed the correct process as we weren't a 'customer' with them at the time they provided the service, they didn't provide a quote and they shipped it without any agreement from us. This is a large multinational company and I don't think they are setup to deal with individual non-business customers.
Some mistake I think, there should be no customs charge associated with personal effects when moving to live in the UK...

HTH

skwdenyer

18,707 posts

271 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
moreflaps said:
Some mistake I think, there should be no customs charge associated with personal effects when moving to live in the UK...

HTH
Isn't the fee for the admin in clearing customs, not any duty itself?

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
There having been no agreement as to price (whether or not there was a agreement -to be inferred from correspondence/conduct- for the provision of a service), the company's claim is for what used to be called (in a now forbidden language) a "quantum meruit" payment. In other words, the claim is for a reasonable price for work done. The price suggested sounds unreasonable. You should, as already suggested above, offer a reasonable amount. I agree that £150 to £200 sounds like the right range. If the company sues (unlikely), defend on the basis of such offer.



anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
PS: Customs charges (ie those charges made by HMRC, not charges by the company for admin) should of course be paid in full, but you knew that. You could say "here is X for HMRC charges and Y for your services."

jpringle819

Original Poster:

734 posts

270 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
moreflaps said:
Some mistake I think, there should be no customs charge associated with personal effects when moving to live in the UK...

HTH
It depends on what you are bringing in if HMRC think there should be any charges. It was marginal in this case as my wife and I have been in the UK for 5 years and have only just arranged to retrieve the stuff from storage and ship it. Although I filled in all the paperwork there seems to be no way for an individual to actually clear the goods through customs. To do this you need an agent and there is a fee for their service.

Thanks for all the help I am still waiting for the breakdown of costs but won't be chasing for this it might take another 3 months for him to do this.