Scotland’s most lucrative mobile speed cameras
Discussion
http://www.deadlinenews.co.uk/2014/01/16/scotlands...
"A spokeswoman for the Scottish Campaign Against Irresponsible Drivers (SCID) said: “At SCID we are only too aware of the devastating consequences following death and serious injuries on Scotland’s roads.
“From the figures it appears that when drivers are forewarned of fixed safety cameras they are more likely to adhere to the speed limit and as you know these cameras are located at areas of concern. The mobile cameras on the other hand appear to be highlighting the fact that outwith an “area of awareness” many drivers, almost twice as many, ignore their speed.
“What worries me is the fact that while speed cameras are helping reduce road casualties as it is a fixed penalty fine and points on licence, the courts continue to take a lenient view when there are no consequences of the standard of driving. How can drivers take bad driving seriously when the courts do not?”
It's interesting that the A74(M)/M74 has generated just over £500k in a year and features in the top 20 most lucrative cameras list 5 times!
But of course, we must be reminded that it has absolutely nothing at all to do with revenue generation and many lives have been saved.
"A spokeswoman for the Scottish Campaign Against Irresponsible Drivers (SCID) said: “At SCID we are only too aware of the devastating consequences following death and serious injuries on Scotland’s roads.
“From the figures it appears that when drivers are forewarned of fixed safety cameras they are more likely to adhere to the speed limit and as you know these cameras are located at areas of concern. The mobile cameras on the other hand appear to be highlighting the fact that outwith an “area of awareness” many drivers, almost twice as many, ignore their speed.
“What worries me is the fact that while speed cameras are helping reduce road casualties as it is a fixed penalty fine and points on licence, the courts continue to take a lenient view when there are no consequences of the standard of driving. How can drivers take bad driving seriously when the courts do not?”

It's interesting that the A74(M)/M74 has generated just over £500k in a year and features in the top 20 most lucrative cameras list 5 times!
But of course, we must be reminded that it has absolutely nothing at all to do with revenue generation and many lives have been saved.
Edited by XDA on Thursday 16th January 22:29
Or to put it another way it's yet another bunch of raving speed vigilantes calling for the courts to take an increasing line of turning the offence of exceeding the speed limit into one of dangerous driving,which involves a custodial sentence,at ever lower speed thresholds.No surprise that it seems to have links with the 'sustainable transport' ( rail ) sector.
www.transformscotland.org.uk/home.aspx
www.transformscotland.org.uk/home.aspx
Edited by XJ Flyer on Thursday 16th January 22:48
I'm guessing one of the mobile scamera sites on the A74(M)/M74 is the spot where they sit on a flyover which you only usually spot at the last second.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
Snappy89 said:
I'm guessing one of the mobile scamera sites on the A74(M)/M74 is the spot where they sit on a flyover which you only usually spot at the last second.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
There are 5 A74(M)/M74 sites listed in the top 20 revenue generators. The 5 sites listed are all bridges with a bend so ideal scamming territory.If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
I travel up and down this road most days. The accident rate is pretty low and I can't recall any deaths on this road caused by speed.....

XDA said:
Snappy89 said:
I'm guessing one of the mobile scamera sites on the A74(M)/M74 is the spot where they sit on a flyover which you only usually spot at the last second.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
There are 5 A74(M)/M74 sites listed in the top 20 revenue generators. The 5 sites listed are all bridges with a bend so ideal scamming territory.If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
I travel up and down this road most days. The accident rate is pretty low and I can't recall any deaths on this road caused by speed.....

While the mobile speed cameras are on the M74, M90, A9, etc., for healthy pickings I see idiots regularly speeding around my area and my children's school. The recent 20 mph zones have been a complete waste of money as they are ignored by virtually everyone.
It's a complete con, it really is.
OP's link said:
18. A71 westbound Kilmarnock west of the Campbell Street slip road – 445 – £26,700
This section of 2 lane dual carriageway was a 70 limit for about 20 years. It was never an accident blackspot but they reduced the limit to 50. Mobile camera here is nothing more than a cash generator.I can vouch for the M/A74 being luctrative as I travel it everyday to get to work.
On one ocassion last year, I was going into Larkhall to collect my mountain bike and I decided to go to the top exit southbound and on the climb up the hill an Audi marked car, SF13 CYS was in the hard shoulder with a van in front, obviously having been pulled over for something. On collection of the bike I proceeded home on the southbound side and on climbing between Lesmahagow and Douglas the very same marked car, SF13 CYS was again in the hard shoulder this time with a car in front. As I descended to the Douglas exit, there was a 5 series tucked up on the northbound side slip road waiting to pounce on any unsuspecting motorists passing.
I frequently see police cars tucked up on all the slip roads on this stretch on motorway. I think it is probably the most policed road. It is a busy road and I can see why they do it. Easy pickings to swell the coffers.
I must admit, I dont give them the satisfaction and drive well below the limit.
On one ocassion last year, I was going into Larkhall to collect my mountain bike and I decided to go to the top exit southbound and on the climb up the hill an Audi marked car, SF13 CYS was in the hard shoulder with a van in front, obviously having been pulled over for something. On collection of the bike I proceeded home on the southbound side and on climbing between Lesmahagow and Douglas the very same marked car, SF13 CYS was again in the hard shoulder this time with a car in front. As I descended to the Douglas exit, there was a 5 series tucked up on the northbound side slip road waiting to pounce on any unsuspecting motorists passing.
I frequently see police cars tucked up on all the slip roads on this stretch on motorway. I think it is probably the most policed road. It is a busy road and I can see why they do it. Easy pickings to swell the coffers.
I must admit, I dont give them the satisfaction and drive well below the limit.
0000 said:
XDA said:
It's interesting that the A74(M)/M74 has generated just over £500k in a year
So that's somewhere over 8000 fines in a year... I wonder how many fewer deaths there were.It's a great business model! £500k from just one road. That must more than cover scamera running costs!
Edinburger said:
XDA said:
Snappy89 said:
I'm guessing one of the mobile scamera sites on the A74(M)/M74 is the spot where they sit on a flyover which you only usually spot at the last second.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
There are 5 A74(M)/M74 sites listed in the top 20 revenue generators. The 5 sites listed are all bridges with a bend so ideal scamming territory.If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
I travel up and down this road most days. The accident rate is pretty low and I can't recall any deaths on this road caused by speed.....

While the mobile speed cameras are on the M74, M90, A9, etc., for healthy pickings I see idiots regularly speeding around my area and my children's school. The recent 20 mph zones have been a complete waste of money as they are ignored by virtually everyone.
It's a complete con, it really is.
Raking in vast sums of money from a road (A74/M74) that has few accidents but is very quiet and has many straight sections/wide sweeping bends.
Revenue generation. Pure and simple.
frag68 said:
I can vouch for the M/A74 being luctrative as I travel it everyday to get to work.
On one ocassion last year, I was going into Larkhall to collect my mountain bike and I decided to go to the top exit southbound and on the climb up the hill an Audi marked car, SF13 CYS was in the hard shoulder with a van in front, obviously having been pulled over for something. On collection of the bike I proceeded home on the southbound side and on climbing between Lesmahagow and Douglas the very same marked car, SF13 CYS was again in the hard shoulder this time with a car in front. As I descended to the Douglas exit, there was a 5 series tucked up on the northbound side slip road waiting to pounce on any unsuspecting motorists passing.
I frequently see police cars tucked up on all the slip roads on this stretch on motorway. I think it is probably the most policed road. It is a busy road and I can see why they do it. Easy pickings to swell the coffers.
I must admit, I dont give them the satisfaction and drive well below the limit.
Agreed.On one ocassion last year, I was going into Larkhall to collect my mountain bike and I decided to go to the top exit southbound and on the climb up the hill an Audi marked car, SF13 CYS was in the hard shoulder with a van in front, obviously having been pulled over for something. On collection of the bike I proceeded home on the southbound side and on climbing between Lesmahagow and Douglas the very same marked car, SF13 CYS was again in the hard shoulder this time with a car in front. As I descended to the Douglas exit, there was a 5 series tucked up on the northbound side slip road waiting to pounce on any unsuspecting motorists passing.
I frequently see police cars tucked up on all the slip roads on this stretch on motorway. I think it is probably the most policed road. It is a busy road and I can see why they do it. Easy pickings to swell the coffers.
I must admit, I dont give them the satisfaction and drive well below the limit.
It's not uncommon to see one unmarked police car on the southbound side and another on the northbound side at the same time!
They are parked up most sliproads and hide behind the crash barriers.
XDA said:
0000 said:
XDA said:
It's interesting that the A74(M)/M74 has generated just over £500k in a year
So that's somewhere over 8000 fines in a year... I wonder how many fewer deaths there were.It's a great business model! £500k from just one road. That must more than cover scamera running costs!
Snappy89 said:
I'm guessing one of the mobile scamera sites on the A74(M)/M74 is the spot where they sit on a flyover which you only usually spot at the last second.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
That's been my experience ,and the two I know of are J13 &14 M74/A74 section , both on flyovers following gentle bends which give good forward driving visibility for the road, but short on visibility to the bridges . Any time I've spotted them there was very little traffic around, somewhere like one/two vehicles in any mile . If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
ETA - JUST FOUND THIS ON ANOTHER SITE
1. A9 Edinburgh/Perth road Dunblane district of Stirling, at a part near to Allan Water, recorded 4217 offences, bringing in fines of £253,020.
2. A74(M)/M74 northbound Abington near to junction 13, 3163 offences, £189,780 in fines.
3. A74M near to Wicketthorn Kirkpatrick Fleming, 2622 offences, £157,320 in fines.
4. A956 north of Esplanade west Aberdeen near Raik Road, 2027 offences, £121620 in fines.
5. A74M by Torwood Overbridge at J17, 1163 offences, £71760 fines.
6. M80 Glasgow/Stirling motorway Dunipace district of Falkirk at a near part to Barnego Road Overbridge, 1033 offences, £61980 fines.
7. The A90 Edinburgh between Burnshot flyover and Cammo Road, 952 offences, £57120 in fines.
8. A74M near to north O/B J19 Ecclefechan, 825 offences, £49500 in fines.
9. M9 Edinburgh/Perth motorway near to Falkirk and Alloa road Overbridge, 764 offences, £45840 in fines.
10. A9 (T) public road near layby 89 by Dalwhinnie, Highlands, 712 offences, £42720 in fines
Edited by Who me ? on Friday 17th January 20:08
[quote=Who me ?]
ETA - JUST FOUND THIS ON ANOTHER SITE
1. A9 Edinburgh/Perth road Dunblane district of Stirling, at a part near to Allan Water, recorded 4217 offences, bringing in fines of £253,020.
2. A74(M)/M74 northbound Abington near to junction 13, 3163 offences, £189,780 in fines.
3. A74M near to Wicketthorn Kirkpatrick Fleming, 2622 offences, £157,320 in fines.
4. A956 north of Esplanade west Aberdeen near Raik Road, 2027 offences, £121620 in fines.
5. A74M by Torwood Overbridge at J17, 1163 offences, £71760 fines.
6. M80 Glasgow/Stirling motorway Dunipace district of Falkirk at a near part to Barnego Road Overbridge, 1033 offences, £61980 fines.
7. The A90 Edinburgh between Burnshot flyover and Cammo Road, 952 offences, £57120 in fines.
8. A74M near to north O/B J19 Ecclefechan, 825 offences, £49500 in fines.
9. M9 Edinburgh/Perth motorway near to Falkirk and Alloa road Overbridge, 764 offences, £45840 in fines.
10. A9 (T) public road near layby 89 by Dalwhinnie, Highlands, 712 offences, £42720 in fines
All mainly motorways or dual carriageways, and a licence to print money. No more dangerous than any other road and the cameras probably do not lower deaths on these sections of road. They are hardly accident black spots.Snappy89 said:
I'm guessing one of the mobile scamera sites on the A74(M)/M74 is the spot where they sit on a flyover which you only usually spot at the last second.
If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
That's been my experience ,and the two I know of are J13 &14 M74/A74 section , both on flyovers following gentle bends which give good forward driving visibility for the road, but short on visibility to the bridges . Any time I've spotted them there was very little traffic around, somewhere like one/two vehicles in any mile . If it's the spot I'm thinking of, then it's located just as you come around a downward left hand turn. I've almost been caught there once or twice but touch wood not as of yet. I travel that particular motorway around once per month and they're certainly set up on in that particular area more than 80% of the time. It doesn't surprise me the amount they make from it.
ETA - JUST FOUND THIS ON ANOTHER SITE
1. A9 Edinburgh/Perth road Dunblane district of Stirling, at a part near to Allan Water, recorded 4217 offences, bringing in fines of £253,020.
2. A74(M)/M74 northbound Abington near to junction 13, 3163 offences, £189,780 in fines.
3. A74M near to Wicketthorn Kirkpatrick Fleming, 2622 offences, £157,320 in fines.
4. A956 north of Esplanade west Aberdeen near Raik Road, 2027 offences, £121620 in fines.
5. A74M by Torwood Overbridge at J17, 1163 offences, £71760 fines.
6. M80 Glasgow/Stirling motorway Dunipace district of Falkirk at a near part to Barnego Road Overbridge, 1033 offences, £61980 fines.
7. The A90 Edinburgh between Burnshot flyover and Cammo Road, 952 offences, £57120 in fines.
8. A74M near to north O/B J19 Ecclefechan, 825 offences, £49500 in fines.
9. M9 Edinburgh/Perth motorway near to Falkirk and Alloa road Overbridge, 764 offences, £45840 in fines.
10. A9 (T) public road near layby 89 by Dalwhinnie, Highlands, 712 offences, £42720 in fines
Edited by Who me ? on Friday 17th January 20:08
Unfortunately with police budgets being cut, we can expect more revenue generating opportunities in the future.
I appreciate the A9 features there, but at Dalwhinnie, this is probably one of the best overtaking sections on the single carriageway part of the road and I feel sorry for the poor motorist who pulls out to overtake a lorry travelling at 40 mph and gets clobbered.
I appreciate some of the fixed cameras around are in accident blackspots, like Gleneagles, Auchterarder, A90? between Aberdeen and Dundee at some of the junctions, but the one at Newbridge is nothing more than a money making exercise. How many deaths has that one prevented? It is hardly an accident hot spot and is strategically placed to catch the innocent motorist who inadvertently lets their speed increase on the steep downhill section.
Shocking as those figures are, they are still a drop in the ocean compared to the number of people speeding. On stretches of the A9, even the Government (Transport Scotland) estimates that 700 people are day exceed the speed limit by over 10mph. That's over 250,000 "crimes" a year, just at one point on one road. In that light, a few thousand pulls a year are nothing.
To use an analogy appropriate for Scotland, it's like swatting midges for the police. Easy, but the numbers of people who consider it reasonable and acceptable to exceed speed limits are so vast, that the effect will only ever be negligible.
To use an analogy appropriate for Scotland, it's like swatting midges for the police. Easy, but the numbers of people who consider it reasonable and acceptable to exceed speed limits are so vast, that the effect will only ever be negligible.
Lil'RedGTO said:
Shocking as those figures are, they are still a drop in the ocean compared to the number of people speeding. On stretches of the A9, even the Government (Transport Scotland) estimates that 700 people are day exceed the speed limit by over 10mph. That's over 250,000 "crimes" a year, just at one point on one road. In that light, a few thousand pulls a year are nothing.
To use an analogy appropriate for Scotland, it's like swatting midges for the police. Easy, but the numbers of people who consider it reasonable and acceptable to exceed speed limits are so vast, that the effect will only ever be negligible.
That's probably what the speed nazis are complaining about.It's obvious that if they can get the government to lower the dangerous driving speed threshold to US type levels then the possibility of going to jail would make the possibility of being one of those caught would be unteneable because of the severity of the penalty. To use an analogy appropriate for Scotland, it's like swatting midges for the police. Easy, but the numbers of people who consider it reasonable and acceptable to exceed speed limits are so vast, that the effect will only ever be negligible.
I must admit, I try my hardest not to give them the satisfaction, and generally drive below the limit and so far my strategy seems to be working, however I do agree there are countless cars pass me on the M74 day and night when I am trundling along at 60 or 65mph or so, clearly well in excess of the limit plus 10%.
However my point here is that the scamera vans are not generally placed in accident blackspots, but in areas where the pickings are made easy by the motorists I mentioned before. I would much rather see these vans in high risk areas where they are actually cutting accidents and fatalities, which at the end of the day is what they are for.
I agree that there are many people who flout the law, and fair play to them. They are just contributing to the coffers of the treasury, both in increased taxes by using more fuel and by getting caught by these vans, and patrols. What I would like to see is more visibility in the areas where we commonly see bad collisions or fatalities and not on sections of quiet roads where someone doing 10mph over the limit is not a major risk.
However my point here is that the scamera vans are not generally placed in accident blackspots, but in areas where the pickings are made easy by the motorists I mentioned before. I would much rather see these vans in high risk areas where they are actually cutting accidents and fatalities, which at the end of the day is what they are for.
I agree that there are many people who flout the law, and fair play to them. They are just contributing to the coffers of the treasury, both in increased taxes by using more fuel and by getting caught by these vans, and patrols. What I would like to see is more visibility in the areas where we commonly see bad collisions or fatalities and not on sections of quiet roads where someone doing 10mph over the limit is not a major risk.
M74/A74(M) -whatever we call it , I wonder what limit our German cousins would place on this underused main route. Except for a few months in winter it's now a safe road. But the safety nutters have decried it as a place to cash in on delusions of safety. I remember driving it in the late 60's in a RWD car with crossply tyres and no seatbelts at over 90mph. And in those days a lot of junctions were turn right through the central reservation on A74. I never had any problems or saw any nasties except for one bloke who staggered out of a pub at Lesmahago into his Moggie van and ended up driving the wrong way ,and ending up getting flattened by a HGV.Today, they'd be calls for a 30 limit on that stretch.in those days it was seen as what it was -a drunk on the wrong side of the road. Problem not recognised by our pious friends in "safety " vans is that this road is a killer through BOREDOM, NOT speed. Same problem that afflicted HGV drivers when the 56 limit was brought in. It's 100 miles of good road with few challenges and little traffic. It's a road where perhaps less strict adherence to limits and more policing ( by the human kind) might bring a lot more safety. But that would mean that the local SCP would end up bankrupt. But if it brought road safety to a higher level would that be a bad thing.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


