Car damaged by kerb in a car park - do I have a valid claim?
Car damaged by kerb in a car park - do I have a valid claim?
Author
Discussion

Edinburger

Original Poster:

10,414 posts

199 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Looking for some opinions here...

I recently damaged my car in the car park of a supermarket (in Scotland).

I drive a BMW 5 series estate, standard M Sport spec. I recently parked in a space which - in my view - had a poor condition corner kerb stone which was stupidly halfway across the width of the space. I was aware of this silly design when I entered the space and thought my front spoiler / air dam would clear it, which it did.

My tyres never touched the kerb so there much have been a good few inches room. I returned to my car and reversed out and the front spoiler / air dam got caught in the inside lip of this kerb and has damaged the underside of my car.

In my view, the supermarket has an obligation to maintain the road surfaces, paving and kerbing. Supermarkets must surely therefore take effective measures against all hazards that may cause injury to customers on foot - and so surely that extends to customer' cars too?

I have contacted the supermarket and have had no response yet. Do you think I have a valid claim against them? Or do I just put this one down to experience.


Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
I doubt you have a legal claim.
I don't really think you have a moral claim, you could see the state of the kerb and you miscalculated.

But, you may get some customer service goodwill payout.

Gaspode

4,167 posts

227 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
I think this is going to turn into one of those threads. Brace yourself, OP...

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Don't supermarkets have signs advising you that you park at your own risk? That probably covers their arses for such eventualities.

0a

24,160 posts

225 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
I would start off by raising this to the supermarket, as they will hopefully want to resolve such issues, and may make a goodwill claim.

DoubleSix

12,575 posts

207 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Gaspode said:
I think this is going to turn into one of those threads. Brace yourself, OP...
yes


Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
So you knew it was there and you hit it anyway?

Butter Face

35,162 posts

191 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Gaspode said:
I think this is going to turn into one of those threads. Brace yourself, OP...
Quite.



matchmaker

9,091 posts

231 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Gaspode said:
I think this is going to turn into one of those threads. Brace yourself, OP...
coffee

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
I doubt you have a legal claim.
I don't really think you have a moral claim, you could see the state of the kerb and you miscalculated.

But, you may get some customer service goodwill payout.
I agree with this but would add that I know nothing about Scotish Law so can't advise on the legal bit.

On the moral bit, honestly, I am quite stunned that you could even begin to think about claiming after seeing it when you chose to park in that space. They need to be advised that their kerb needs fixing but you need to accept that, every once in a while, you will cock up, costing you money, and this is one of those times.

Edinburger

Original Poster:

10,414 posts

199 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Rude-boy said:
Snowboy said:
I doubt you have a legal claim.
I don't really think you have a moral claim, you could see the state of the kerb and you miscalculated.

But, you may get some customer service goodwill payout.
I agree with this but would add that I know nothing about Scotish Law so can't advise on the legal bit.

On the moral bit, honestly, I am quite stunned that you could even begin to think about claiming after seeing it when you chose to park in that space. They need to be advised that their kerb needs fixing but you need to accept that, every once in a while, you will cock up, costing you money, and this is one of those times.
That's fair enough but I've parked the front of my car over probably thousands of kerbs over the years and have never damaged it before. Surely the supermarket is legally obliged to maintain their kerbs and have them at a height which will not damage cars?

They'll surely be looking at potential hazards to visitors and making sure they are identified and eliminated as quickly as possible. If they must take effective measures against all hazards that are reasonably likely to cause injury to customers and employees, then why is that any different for customer's cars?

If I could post a picture from my iPhone then you'd see what I mean about the standard of it and the stupid design. Will try that at home later.

Grandad7184

2,107 posts

166 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
So you see the kerb intrudung but still park in that space. The supermarket will problay tell you it was your choice to park in the space but thanks for letting them know about the kerb.

Me personally would take the hit and learn from it and if you have any doubt find another space.

No cue all the stupid comments like many have seen in other threads.

Al

Edinburger

Original Poster:

10,414 posts

199 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Grandad7184 said:
So you see the kerb intrudung but still park in that space. The supermarket will problay tell you it was your choice to park in the space but thanks for letting them know about the kerb.

Me personally would take the hit and learn from it and if you have any doubt find another space.

No cue all the stupid comments like many have seen in other threads.

Al
I had no choice but to park in that space as it was a small car park which was virtually full, and to make matters worse this was a 'parent & child' space.

Edinburger

Original Poster:

10,414 posts

199 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Davel said:
So you knew it was there and you hit it anyway?
That's the point - no I didn't hit it.

My car cleared the height of it but there was a lip of the kerb where the tarmac was worn and that clipped my car as I reversed out the space.

That'll make more sense when I post pics.

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
How is the state of disrepair relevant to the damage?
Presumably the damage occurred because it was higher than you anticipated?
I feel your pain as I hate ill designed car parks and the damage we all do in them, but I cant see you getting much luck from this.
You knew it was there, you drove over it taking the risk and want someone else to pay for the consequences.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Edinburger said:
that clipped my car as I reversed out the space.
I would suggest that you clipped it rather than the other way around, unless the kerb/tarmac was moving.

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Worth a try as you have nothing to lose.
Problem is that you chose to park in a space that you admit to seeing might cause problems. That it was the only space left cuts little ice, after all, if there was a six foot deep hole in the only space you wouldn't park in it would you?
Don't forget to keep us posted.

Grandad7184

2,107 posts

166 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
I know a few supermarkets in Edinburgh that have wk parent and child spaces not like here in the SE as they need to park there Chelsea tractors in then

My 3er has a lip in the bumper what can catch the kerbs if I get to close.

Did it pull the bumper out or just scratch it?

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
entirely OP's fault.

CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Let us know if you are successful in your claim, might come in handy next time I drive into a lamp post or a telegraph pole.

rolleyes