Speed Camera/ Trap/ limit detectors
Discussion
I was curious what others use on here.
I am not interested in a debate on should you/ shouldn't you, and fluffy kittens etc, but the vast majority of road users I am sure have, at some time on their lives inadvertently drifted over the limit for all sorts of excuses, so better that we are alerted to this fact than finding out later when we are dinged by a van.
Many cars now have some sort of satnav built in, so the obligatory tomtom get binned, but for one problem... most built-in units don't have any speed-alert or camera alarm, which IMHO is an oversight.
...and so, with this in mind, I decided to do a bit of research on t'internet, and was surprised to see that many unit models sold in the UK appear to be quite old, with reviews from mostly terrible to very average. Go look at the USA sites, and this is quite different. Units like Beltronics, and Whistler heading the pack with great User reviews. But these are hard to get in the UK, with Vivid racing being the only company I can find selling some of these.
So what has happened to the UK market and products? Certainly the likes of Snooper, road Angel etc. seems to get a slating in the user reviews I have read...
The worry is inadvertently buying something that is not well supported in the UK (including maps)or worse still buying a model made in 2006!
I am not interested in a debate on should you/ shouldn't you, and fluffy kittens etc, but the vast majority of road users I am sure have, at some time on their lives inadvertently drifted over the limit for all sorts of excuses, so better that we are alerted to this fact than finding out later when we are dinged by a van.
Many cars now have some sort of satnav built in, so the obligatory tomtom get binned, but for one problem... most built-in units don't have any speed-alert or camera alarm, which IMHO is an oversight.
...and so, with this in mind, I decided to do a bit of research on t'internet, and was surprised to see that many unit models sold in the UK appear to be quite old, with reviews from mostly terrible to very average. Go look at the USA sites, and this is quite different. Units like Beltronics, and Whistler heading the pack with great User reviews. But these are hard to get in the UK, with Vivid racing being the only company I can find selling some of these.
So what has happened to the UK market and products? Certainly the likes of Snooper, road Angel etc. seems to get a slating in the user reviews I have read...
The worry is inadvertently buying something that is not well supported in the UK (including maps)or worse still buying a model made in 2006!
I'm currently running a Road Angel Gem. Database seems complete as I travel 1k a week and it hasn't let me down yet. Battery life poor tho and the hard wire isn't fab. Good point is that it is always hooked up to their data base. Biggest downside tho is the size of it and the lack of ability to really personalise the alerts so DAB/conversation often interrupted by beep beep beep...irritating, especially when on work calls en route.
Ran a Road Pilot Micro for 7 years until 2013. Absolutely brilliant, but darn thing broke and since Road Angel bought Road Pilot they don't support them.
Everyone raves about Valentine One, but I don't know anyone that has one. Most other systems seem to be phone based, but I prefer a dedicated unit.
Ran a Road Pilot Micro for 7 years until 2013. Absolutely brilliant, but darn thing broke and since Road Angel bought Road Pilot they don't support them.
Everyone raves about Valentine One, but I don't know anyone that has one. Most other systems seem to be phone based, but I prefer a dedicated unit.
I'm currently running a Road Angel Gem. Database seems complete as I travel 1k a week and it hasn't let me down yet. Battery life poor tho and the hard wire isn't fab. Good point is that it is always hooked up to their data base. Biggest downside tho is the size of it and the lack of ability to really personalise the alerts so DAB/conversation often interrupted by beep beep beep...irritating, especially when on work calls en route.
Ran a Road Pilot Micro for 7 years until 2013. Absolutely brilliant, but darn thing broke and since Road Angel bought Road Pilot they don't support them.
Everyone raves about Valentine One, but I don't know anyone that has one. Most other systems seem to be phone based, but I prefer a dedicated unit.
Ran a Road Pilot Micro for 7 years until 2013. Absolutely brilliant, but darn thing broke and since Road Angel bought Road Pilot they don't support them.
Everyone raves about Valentine One, but I don't know anyone that has one. Most other systems seem to be phone based, but I prefer a dedicated unit.
Zedboy1200 said:
Everyone raves about Valentine One, but I don't know anyone that has one. Most other systems seem to be phone based, but I prefer a dedicated unit.
I have one. It's very good for detecting Gatso cameras, which are now used on VSL motorways as well, so it's great for long distance drives.However, by the time it's detected a camera van, you've already been caught, and it won't detect non-radar based cameras such as Truvelos, which are often the ones that are most likely to catch you as they're forward facing.
For the average user, the best option is an updated tomotom/smartphone app such as PocketGPSworld or Trapster. The only way to successfully combat the vans is to install a laser jammer, which are expensive and risky from a legal perspective.
motco said:
I have an Inforad but it's limited use on motorways as it seems to go mad much of the time. Works reasonably on other roads though.
I have an inforad fitted to my bike and the same bike model fitted to the car.It's unobtrusive and gives warning of fixed cameras and potential mobile units.
It doesn't mean that I speed when it's green but indicates problem areas which is useful when you are in unfamiliar territory.
It also logs your position every minute so you can save all your journeys if you wanted to. They are available for less than £20.
I used a Road Angel Gem too... for about 7 days. Useless.
It is supposed to have "Road Angel Gem Plus has the UK’s most accurate database of road speed limits". Utter tosh. I was driving over the Hammersmith Flyover after buying it and it told me I was on a 25mph speed limit road. Now, if it had said 20 I would of assumed that the GPS position was wrong and it was thinking I was on an adjacent road.... but there is no legal 25mph speed limit in the UK.... Go figure. I noticed quite a lot more speed limit inaccuracies while I had it.
Also... I also run a TomTom Live unit, that uses the same Road Angel speed camera database and gets it own notifications of 'Live' camera.
Several times over the few days I had it, as I drove Scotland to London return, my TomTom would ping to say a 'Live' speed camera van was about yet the Gem didnt. Go figure.
So, personally... I wouldn't recommend them at all.
It is supposed to have "Road Angel Gem Plus has the UK’s most accurate database of road speed limits". Utter tosh. I was driving over the Hammersmith Flyover after buying it and it told me I was on a 25mph speed limit road. Now, if it had said 20 I would of assumed that the GPS position was wrong and it was thinking I was on an adjacent road.... but there is no legal 25mph speed limit in the UK.... Go figure. I noticed quite a lot more speed limit inaccuracies while I had it.
Also... I also run a TomTom Live unit, that uses the same Road Angel speed camera database and gets it own notifications of 'Live' camera.
Several times over the few days I had it, as I drove Scotland to London return, my TomTom would ping to say a 'Live' speed camera van was about yet the Gem didnt. Go figure.
So, personally... I wouldn't recommend them at all.
Tomo1971 said:
I used a Road Angel Gem too... for about 7 days. Useless.
Yup, rubbish for so many reasons. Apart from the crappy interface;It thinks the M62 toll road is a 50mph with average speed cameras. I have to switch it off there.
Wont warn of gatsos in a specs area.
Database is well crap
Thinks the M57 is littered with a dozen 30mph zones.
The list goes on and on... Dont buy it.
Most of the UK stuff seem to have no-so-good ratings, but as I said the fav across the pond seems to be Whistler which covers GPS and physical detection (radar and laser), indeed I saw a site that said that they would pay any speeding fines for users if they managed to get caught (if they were using their equipment). Tall boast... wonder how true that is!
Seems that Whistler has a European branch, but surprised, if they are as good as people say, thet more dealers are not stocking them in the UK... maybe it is a Map thing...
Seems that Whistler has a European branch, but surprised, if they are as good as people say, thet more dealers are not stocking them in the UK... maybe it is a Map thing...
Having had Road Angel camera detector years ago I went for a Road Angel Sat Nav.
When that got old and decrepit I looked for something to replace it with. It had a great feature which meant you could switch off the nav and just use the speed display / camera alert function.
RA stopped making sat-navs but continued to supply their (IME very good) data to TomTom. So I bought a TomTom nav which I've used for some time without issue.
Recently I've bought the TomTom app for the iphone which is good (about £20 plus subscription for updates) but if I know the route I use the free TomTom cameras app which has been good. And seems to get updated regularly.
Because it's all on the phone and bluetoothed to the car stereo the music is muted slightly when I'm getting a warning so I don't miss it
When that got old and decrepit I looked for something to replace it with. It had a great feature which meant you could switch off the nav and just use the speed display / camera alert function.
RA stopped making sat-navs but continued to supply their (IME very good) data to TomTom. So I bought a TomTom nav which I've used for some time without issue.
Recently I've bought the TomTom app for the iphone which is good (about £20 plus subscription for updates) but if I know the route I use the free TomTom cameras app which has been good. And seems to get updated regularly.
Because it's all on the phone and bluetoothed to the car stereo the music is muted slightly when I'm getting a warning so I don't miss it
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





