Hotel reviews, do you give them credence?
Hotel reviews, do you give them credence?
Author
Discussion

Glocko

Original Poster:

1,813 posts

280 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
The likes of Tripadvisor, booking.com, laterooms etc.
I've stayed in a few UK hotels in the last year and going by some of the reviews you would not put your dog there.
Are there professional complainers out there, I have not found fault with any of the dozen places I stayed at in 2013 but some people have had their first born swiped away by the night porter by the sounds of it!!
The best was a rant about a hotel I'm staying in tonight where Angry from Leigh complained that his Gacuze (sic) was too cold!!

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Yes and no. I tend to take them with a pinch of salt.

Ikemi

8,611 posts

236 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Yes and no. I tend to take them with a pinch of salt.
This. Especially with bad reviews, as there are so many variables, including people's expectations and fussiness. In general, I normally use TripAdvisor to find good hotels. I rarely read in the in-depth reviews, but I do look at their scoring system for 'excellent', 'very good' and 'terrible' etc. If a hotel has as overwhelming 'poor'/'terrible' score, I'll avoid. If it mainly has 'excellent'/'very good', with the odd 'poor' and 'terrible', it's probably pretty good! smile

vixen1700

29,391 posts

301 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I did put my first review up on Tripadvisor about a hotel we stayed at in Corfu last year as it really was so bad.

Comparing it to Fawlty Towers and Bates Motel, thought I was kinder than a lot of people writing reviews about the place. hehe

Ikemi

8,611 posts

236 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
TripAdvisor did produce a list of the top worst 100 hotels once upon a time ... It made for interesting (and hilarious) reading! biggrin I believe the list was pulled, due to complains from managers/owners of said 100 worst hotels.

g3org3y

22,527 posts

222 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Glocko said:
Are there professional complainers out there
Of course. There was a show on Ch4 a couple of years back (Attack of the Trip Advisors?) all about this.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I always check on Tripadvisor before booking a hotel which I haven't used before. I think it's pretty easy to identify those people who leave bad reviews due to genuinely poor experiences, and those who have either unrealistic expectations, expectations which differ from mine (e.g. I might not mind sleeping above a nightclub or a noisy road) and those who just moan about everything for the sake of it.

If someone's review gives borderline concern, you can always delve into their other reviews and see if a pattern is evident.

Dr Doofenshmirtz

16,952 posts

231 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
You have to read several reviews to get an overall picture. The problem is some bad hotels give themselves glowing reviews, but these generally stick out like a sore thumb. Pontins as an example are renowned for this because they are so awful. The good hotels are easy to spot using TripAdvisor.

CharlesAL

534 posts

155 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
You just have to read plenty of positive, neutral and negative reviews to get a decent picture. I've looked at a few hotels I've stayed in on TripAdvisor and the general feel of the reviews is pretty accurate.

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I caught a couple of episodes of some daytime dross where they take online reviewers back to places after the 'Hotel Inspector' has been there and made changes.

Without exception, the people on there that pride themselves on leaving online reviews are really not the sort of people you'd want to share a hotel with.


Borghetto

3,286 posts

214 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Because hotel star rating systems so often fail to reflect a hotel's quality, I've found this particularly the case with middling ratings in France, Trip Advisor gives a generally unbiased view. Also once a hotel has achieved an excellent rating on TA, they are loathe to put their rating at risk. Without overt threats I have managed to get two rebates from hoteliers who had charged me for breakfasts I hadn't had.

Patrick Bateman

13,219 posts

205 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I'd say yes but you can't help but get the impression reading some reviews on trip advisor that some people will never be happy. If the majority of people are going with a 4/5 rating and a handful give it 1 and sound like colossal wkers then I tend to go with the majority.

vixen1700

29,391 posts

301 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Just looking at my four Tripadvisor reviews, three are excellent for restaurants in Corfu and one is poor for the hotel. smile

GT03ROB

14,037 posts

252 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
If there are enough reviews generally I think they give a fair picture. Some people will never be satisfied & these are normally self evident.

tjl

392 posts

203 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I tend to reply on trip advisor for holiday hotels but don't tend to bother for city centre hotels for business trips. Holiday ones tend to be very accurate (so far) and often give a good guide for other things to look to do whilst on holiday

Rick101

7,191 posts

181 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Just look at the post count and content on TA.

If they've only a few reviews and they are all awful or all outstanding, prob ignore that one.


NRS

26,486 posts

232 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Look for trends as stated above. You also do seem to get the odd place that has a bad room (depending on which side it's facing). The other thing is you get a bit of a difference in reviews depending on expectations. So poorer hotels which might be a bit better than people expected can have higher reviews than a better one that was a bit below what others expected.

mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
Ikemi said:
there are so many variables, including people's expectations
This. I just read a review of a hotel in Paris that got a low rating from a first-time-abroad US tourist because there wasn't free coffee available all day in the lobby. Welcome to Europe!

AlasdairMc

555 posts

158 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I generally look for trends, so lots of negative reviews will put me off somewhere, but a single one amongst a sea of positivity will generally get ignored.

HaplessBoyLard

1,573 posts

219 months

Sunday 19th January 2014
quotequote all
I always wonder whether people who leave the scathing reviews, citing a series of little niggles as ruining their stay, actually do anything to get these niggles fixed while they're there. I always get the feeling they sit there miserable for a week and then moan on the internet when they get home.

I've not found many places that won't sort out pretty much any issue if you approach them with a firm but polite tone.

It's usually pretty easy to spot the professional whiners amongst a collection of mostly positive reviews.