PCN Issued but had paid & ticket was on the floor!
PCN Issued but had paid & ticket was on the floor!
Author
Discussion

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I would contact them with a photocopy of the ticket that you state was paid for and displayed on your dash when they write to you, not before.

Request that the ticket is cancelled else a POPLA appeal number is requested (This costs them cash but the decision isn't binding on you).

If rejected appeal to POPLA with a copy of your ticket and ask what loss they have suffered, they will not win smile

silverfoxcc

8,478 posts

176 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
DO NOTHING and DONT contact them at all, and WHEN you do write in the thrird pesrson ,not ! did I saw I put, but THE DRIVER DID< THE DRIVER SAID etc. WAIT until you get the notice to keeper. DO NOT contact them at all ,and post this up on pepipoo asap for good advice, Oters will tell you not to go to pepipoo, but that site and the motoring section on Money Saving Expoert are a godsend


At the end of the day you have two options

1) pay up
2) fight it with the help of others who have done hundreds of these type of problems and won in the POPLA appeal and not only save the money BUT make the PPC cough up 30.00 as well

Did i say dont contact them? and post it on pepipoo?

Expect the normal naysayers who disagree, but its a fee world and you do what you want, ME i would go down fighting if i had a choice, and YOU have

Big E 118

2,468 posts

200 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I've encountered this twice, once it happened to me and once to one of my staff who was panicking about it so I dealt with it for her.

Both occasions were with council tickets though.

I took a copy of the tickets and wrote a polite letter explaining what had happened and that I was an idiot and sorry but I had clearly paid for use of the car park for the period I used it and here's the evidence attached.

Both tickets were cancelled.

AW111

9,674 posts

164 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
First option is a polite letter with a copy of the ticket.

Don't go to pepipoo as a first resort.
Yours,
an otter.

Hol

9,316 posts

231 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I have had this in the train station, with CCTV that would have proved I went to the machine, bought a ticket and put something in my car.

In my cases, it was a private for profit parking company they refused to dispute that I HAD bought the ticket - but here is the rub:

The terms and conditions will state that the ticket must be visible and in the car. Thats it!!

Even if you can prove that you bought the ticket (as I could) - if it is NOT visible, you have not complied with their terms.


You are best to pay up TBH and learn to check before you walk away.

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Hol said:
You are best to pay up TBH and learn to check before you walk away.
What has he got to lose by writing a quick letter telling them to do one?

FWIW I've had this problem before and I've had every ticket I've contested withdrawn.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
AGK said:
Hol said:
You are best to pay up TBH and learn to check before you walk away.
What has he got to lose by writing a quick letter telling them to do one?

FWIW I've had this problem before and I've had every ticket I've contested withdrawn.
I don't think the person in the wrong should be the one being rude.

You make it sound like you've had a lot of tickets. Why have you had so many?

Funk

27,818 posts

240 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Willber said:
Im pretty sure that I put it on the dashboard and not on the floor, I assume strong winds may have blown it off through the dash vents/roof (it's a Boxster)

Reading a lot on moneysavingexpert forums and the advice is excellent including someone who had encountered the exact same thing.

I will lose the appeal to them straight away as they explain on their website but by doing this they would have an email address to contact me by. Otherwise they would have to contact the DVLA to gain registered keepers details.

The 'contract' is between the driver not the registered keeper.

I'll keep researching but currently feeling like fighting it as its just such complete rubbish. Fair enough if I genuinely hadn't paid but to claim to refuse an appeal even if I can show there is no loss to the landowner (as in, I have paid) due to a technicality of whether the ticket was displayed or not!

Edited by Willber on Tuesday 21st January 13:40
You can create a throw-away email address for free with any webmail provider.

Even easier, I use https://www.abine.com/maskme/ as a plugin in Chrome which allows me to create disposable email addresses which are still sent to my real email address. The Mask Me service does exactly that - masks your real email. Once you're done with correspondence or someone spams you, you can simply delete the email address.

I use it far more than I thought I ever would, it's very useful for keeping my real email spam-free.

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
herewego said:
I don't think the person in the wrong should be the one being rude.

You make it sound like you've had a lot of tickets. Why have you had so many?
I guess the traffic wardens are too lazy to check the ticket. lick


kowalski655

15,237 posts

174 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Hol said:
I have had this in the train station, with CCTV that would have proved I went to the machine, bought a ticket and put something in my car.

In my cases, it was a private for profit parking company they refused to dispute that I HAD bought the ticket - but here is the rub:

The terms and conditions will state that the ticket must be visible and in the car. Thats it!!

Even if you can prove that you bought the ticket (as I could) - if it is NOT visible, you have not complied with their terms.


You are best to pay up TBH and learn to check before you walk away.
There may be a technical breach of their conditions, but their loss is nil,especially if OP contacts them first
Appeal the ticket & as stated before,ask right way for a POPLA number, or confirmation of cancellation.

silverfoxcc

8,478 posts

176 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Both on MSE and pepipoo, they advise you to wait until you get the 'notice to keeper' letter, as it gives you a little more leeway in 'negotiating'
The ONLY time you get onto the PPC first is if your car is not registered in your name, ie hire/lease/firms. as sometimes the 'owner' will just pay the fine and then charge you.
Hold fire.. wait until you get the letter, and then DONT say who was driving, even if the letter seems to indicate you must... you dont. and alway write in the third person

At the end of the day and all else fails, which it probably wont, is you have to pay.so there is no rush to pay it now, let the buggers wait for as long as possible.
what you MUST NOT do is ignore any letters, always seek advice. its up to you to take it or not. It costs nothing.

EDIT to add

Wilber, the guys on pepipoo, hcandeson, Hiipocrates,Schoolrunmum, are more than wlling to give you their time,and assist you, check replies etc. some of the replies could, rankle you a bit, but they are there to assist

Edited by silverfoxcc on Tuesday 21st January 20:46

Craig85

72 posts

156 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Hol said:
I have had this in the train station, with CCTV that would have proved I went to the machine, bought a ticket and put something in my car.

In my cases, it was a private for profit parking company they refused to dispute that I HAD bought the ticket - but here is the rub:

The terms and conditions will state that the ticket must be visible and in the car. Thats it!!

Even if you can prove that you bought the ticket (as I could) - if it is NOT visible, you have not complied with their terms.


You are best to pay up TBH and learn to check before you walk away.
I have just contested a parking ticket from a ppc through popla and won. However, what people need to remember is you do not owe them the money for their fine (which is technically a speculative invoice) until a judge has ruled in their favour. I was quite prepared to argue my legal and moral case to a judge because I knew I was right.

In this instance forget their terms and conditions, with deliberately non sticky tickets to make it more than likely you will fall short of meeting them, and realise that their loss is nil, you had paid, and if you think you could sit in a room and explain this to a judge (on the one in a million chance they turned up) and think it likely as a reasonable human being the judge would agree with you then do not pay them.

They are trying to make money, people who fall for their scare tactics are easy prey. If you escalate it at every level it stops becoming commercially viable to pursue you. One more thing, to the people who say point blank ignore, I chose to respond because (it was a company vehicle and...) I think it would look better to the judge if it got that far that I had the courtesy to appeal it fairly rather than being arrogant and not responding, I would advise others to do so to if you receive an actual notice to keeper. Although if you prefer to file it under b for bin then I'm sure you would be ok as you are not giving them a bite on the hook I suppose, just stick to your guns if you try this.

Mill Wheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Willber said:
Looking on their website and it states that they will not consider an appeal if it was blown/fell off the dashboard, so theres no point appealing and giving them any of my info in that case! Must be a conspiracy as to why they dont have sticky tickets haha!

Will post on pepipoo - thanks.
Never mind what it says on their website, what does it say on the back/front of the TICKET, or the terms and conditions displayed in the car park???

Launch your appeal by email or recorded delivery, and note the timings of any responses.
According to the Industry’s Code of Practice, issued by the BPA companies or landowners are required to acknowledge or reply to a motorist’s appeal within 14 days of getting it. If they send an acknowledgement, they must fully reply in writing within 35 days of getting the appeal.

Ask for a copy of the contract that allows them to enforce on land not owned by them.
Membership of the Approved Operator Scheme does require the parking company to have clear authorisation from the landowner, if itself is not the landowner, as to their role in relation to the parking control and enforcement. This is set out in the BPA Code of Practice.
However if the point is specially raised by an you in an appeal, then the operator should address it by producing such evidence as they believe refutes a submission that they have no authority. If they fail to do so, POPLA is your friend!!

They have suffered no loss other than anything incurred by their failure to issue tickets that can be secured against winds/drafts when closing the doors and you should not have to pay for their omission!

Willber

Original Poster:

671 posts

200 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for your advice everyone.

As a first step, do you think it's worth emailing the Port Manager to see if there is anything they can do, and to request a copy of the contract between the landowner and parking company?

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Personally I'd just appeal on the grounds I had a valid ticket enclosing a photocopy of it. I wouldn't mention where it was or wasnt displayed. I'd also delete this thread, the parking scum pay minimum wage schlubs to monitor places like this.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Shirley the issue here is not parking but non compliance with terms and conditions in that a valid ticket has to be displayed which is fairly obvious as to why.

As stated worth a try in an appeal with copy of ticket and a grovel unbeknown pressure created by closing door dislodged said ticket. No evasion intended.

dvd