Driver cuts corner, kills cyclist, gets suspended sentence
Driver cuts corner, kills cyclist, gets suspended sentence
Author
Discussion

funkyrobot

Original Poster:

18,789 posts

259 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
http://www.spaldingtoday.co.uk/news/latest-news/su...

A motorist knocked down and killed a cyclist while cutting a corner on a dark country road, Lincoln Crown Court was told.

Joseph Strong failed to see David Hall despite the cyclist wearing a high visibility jacket and having his lights on as he made his way home from work in the early evening.

Phil Howes, prosecuting on Thursday, said that Mr Hall (58) was waiting to turn right off the B1357 onto Green Lane at Moulton Seas End when he was hit.

He suffered head and chest injuries and was pronounced dead at the scene.

“The defendant was driving his Chevrolet travelling south through the village of Moulton Seas End. David Hall was riding his cycle north along that same road coming towards the defendant from round the bend.

“As the Chevrolet negotiated the bend it collided with Mr Hall on his pedal cycle.”

Mr Howes said that Strong stopped at the scene and along with other motorists tried to assist Mr Hall along with paramedics and a doctor but they were unable to save him.

Strong admitted he was “near” to the centre of the road as he took the bend but said “He came out of nowhere. I didn’t see him.”

Accident investigators who reconstructed the incident concluded that Mr Hall was stationary before turning right onto Green Lane and was waiting for Strong’s car to pass. Strong was cutting the corner on the bend and his wheels were over the centre broken white line as he was trying to avoid being too close to the edge of the road.

A survey later carried out by police revealed that over half of motorists cut the corner when negotiating the same bend.

Strong (50), of Burnstone Gardens, Moulton, admitted causing the death by careless driving on February 1, 2013.

He was given a six month jail sentence suspended for a year and banned from driving for 12 months.

Judge Sean Morris, passing sentence, told Strong: “You are a good man and a family man but you made a very bad judgement call. From the minute it happened you have never sought to blame anyone else.

“You never set out that day to take a life. You have never tried to wriggle out of this.”

Neil Guest, defending, said Strong, who works as a site manager, was a broken man as a result of what happened and was full of remorse.

He said the incident happened on a moonless night and the area was very dark.

“There was no excess speed. He was just over the line. He is a man who has dedicated himself to his family and to work.

“He is now a broken 
man. If he could turn the clock back he would but alas he cannot.”

PAULJ5555

3,554 posts

207 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
That is why I will not cycle on our roads, one simple mistake and your dead.

singlecoil

35,889 posts

277 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Can't see any useful purpose would be served by jailing him. Tragic accident.

Guffy

2,372 posts

296 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Sounds about right to me when everything is taken into account.

Who hasn't made a mistake whilst driving? Yes the outcome here was tragic, but not convinced that a jail sentence is appropriate.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
Can't see any useful purpose would be served by jailing him. Tragic accident.
Agreed. Maybe some better road markings at the junction/bend to encourage people not to cut the corner could be considered.

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
"From the minute it happened you have never sought to blame anyone else" said the Judge.

I disagree...given the earlier statement about the cyclist "coming out of nowhere". Incidentally, that's not how it works - stuff doesn't generally just come out of nowhere, certainly not cyclists or cars.

It's a simple mistake of not looking carefully enough, and sadly it had tragic consequences. 99% of the time, nobody would have been there and all would have been ok.

AH33

2,066 posts

166 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
As long as cyclists and heavy metal boxes have to share the roads, this sort of thing will unfortunately keep happening. I would also never cycle on the roads, my life is worth much more than any reason I could come up with to start doing it, seems like far too much risk for no particular gain.

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
I agree - it sounds like he has 'punishment' enough, as it were, and from the brief extract I've read it seems he's a good man that made a mistake and the consequences were extreme.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
PAULJ5555 said:
That is why I will not cycle on our roads, one simple mistake and your dead.
You could say the same about crossing the road and riding a motorbike or even driving.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Guffy said:
Sounds about right to me when everything is taken into account.

Who hasn't made a mistake whilst driving? Yes the outcome here was tragic, but not convinced that a jail sentence is appropriate.
A large damages payment to the widow might be appropriate too.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Looks like it was here, from the driver's PoV:

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/preview#!data=!1m8!1...

I can't really see how you could miss them. From the initial description, I suspected A-pillar sightline issues, but it ought to be straight ahead visibility.

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
They are very difficult these cases. I fully accept that the driver never set out to harm anyone on that day, but the fact is that he didn't take care. I accept that sending him to prison would achieve little, but something has to be done to make people take enough care so what better way than imposing a harsh punishment?

After all, the family of the deceased have suffered terribly and they never did anything wrong.

There is another case going on here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-25816281

It seems that in perfect conditions the driver never saw the cyclist at all, yet he denies driving without due care.

I feel I can guarantee he'll walk free from court though.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
I'm convinced the threat of punishment doesn't make any difference to people's desire not to have road accidents. It's just judicial revenge.

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
I'm convinced the threat of punishment doesn't make any difference to people's desire not to have road accidents. It's just judicial revenge.
But do you think that people's desire to not have accidents is strong enough, because I'd suggest that evidence shows it's not.

mdavids

742 posts

215 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
The only thing I'd disagree with is the length of driving ban, 12 months isn't enough in my opinion. I dont think he needed jailing but a lengthy spell without use of a car would act as a bit of a wake up call and deterrent to those who dont pay enough attention on our roads.

As a regular cycle commuter I really try and avoid this type of right turn scenario, being left standing in the middle of the road waiting to cross is not a good place to be. I tend to take liberties with the highway code in this situation and make (careful) use of the pavement, either pulling over to the left then crossing as a pedestrian or crossing to the right pavement early before reaching my junction. Granted this isn't possible in many people's situations but works well for me on my commute.

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Cyclist had lights on, but if he had turned his wheel to the right in anticipation of his manoeuvre perhaps neither of his lights was visible to a vehicle approaching from his left? Yes there is still a reflective jacket and possibly wheel reflectors, but they don't have the same effect on a driver as lights.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
It's a tragic accident.
I don't think he tried to shift blame - the comment about 'came from nowhere' sound like an expression of suprise or explanation not of evasion or blame.

It sounds like a horrible road with a junction on a corner.
It was dark, on a corner with dipped full beams the lights probably wouldn't have been hitting the high vis jacket.

Not an excuse, but mitigating factors.



Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
heebeegeetee said:
But do you think that people's desire to not have accidents is strong enough, because I'd suggest that evidence shows it's not.
People don't mean to have accidents. They're accidents.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
mdavids said:
The only thing I'd disagree with is the length of driving ban, 12 months isn't enough in my opinion. I dont think he needed jailing but a lengthy spell without use of a car would act as a bit of a wake up call and deterrent to those who dont pay enough attention on our roads.

As a regular cycle commuter I really try and avoid this type of right turn scenario, being left standing in the middle of the road waiting to cross is not a good place to be. I tend to take liberties with the highway code in this situation and make (careful) use of the pavement, either pulling over to the left then crossing as a pedestrian or crossing to the right pavement early before reaching my junction. Granted this isn't possible in many people's situations but works well for me on my commute.
I'm fairly sure that when I learned to cycle at school we were told to stop on the left and cross as a pedestrian on junctions like this.
Also, there was can article in the local rag asking police to relax the rules about sensible cycling on the pavement.


Not that I'm blaming the cyclist here - just giving a different perspective.

It's one of this situations where although we might all want to treat bikes as 'real' traffic, they are harder to see, lack airbags and crumple zones, lack bloody great headlights.

With modern led technology I wonder if road going bike lights might be legislated to the same level as motorbike headlights. I think that might help.

supersport

4,646 posts

258 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Always makes me feel better when a driver comes out with the good old "Sorry mate, didn't see you" as once again I come close to be knocked off my bike by someone not paying attention.