Joining a business as shareholder & director (questions)
Joining a business as shareholder & director (questions)
Author
Discussion

Splats

Original Poster:

625 posts

193 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
First, allow me to take this opportunity to apologise for anything I say or ask that is stupid or naive. I intend no malice, I’m just a little wet behind the ears in the operational structure of businesses.

I am shortly going to be entering into discussions with a view to joining a recent start up business as a shareholder and director. Essentially, I’m trying to establish what I should be looking out for and what terms would be reasonable to agree at this time. It therefore seems prudent to start with some background:

The company is a limited company and was founded about 7 months ago by a father and son (John & Gary). John is the only listed director; Gary however, makes the day to day decisions and effectively runs the business. I don’t know the full details of start-up finances, but I would estimate that John put up around £10,000 to get going (most of which remains as the overheads aren’t excessive).

I’ve been self-employed for 2.5 years and arrived on the scene for about 5 months working on a commission only and consultative basis. Working closely with Gary I have effectively done the following:

1. Developed the entire sales strategy for the business
2. Developed all the selling platforms for the business (website, setting up other software)
3. Developed and built the ‘Brand’ (both business and individual products)

Effectively, without my input the company would not exist in its current form. However, it is also more than fair to say that without Gary, I couldn’t have put this together on my own. We are, essentially, the perfect little partnership. If matters were restricted to just Gary and I, it would be obvious and easy 50/50% split of ownership, responsibility, etc.

However, the issue – or at least, I think the issue – is John. John is lovely but lacks the skills and drive that Gary and I share. While John effectively fronted up some cash to get things going, the job he performs is menial and he has little to offer in terms of input going forward. That sounds harsh but it’s not meant to, John has been quite content to do his role and let Gary get on with it.

However, John’s role in the business is creating some questions I cannot answer for myself. I suspect when we start to chat things through the suggestion will be a 33.3% split between all parties and that all three of us are made Directors. I’m struggling to establish in my own mind if this is fair and reasonable and whether it’s an outcome I should be aiming for during negotiation.

In the short term is probably makes no odds. However, I do believe that Gary and I will grow and build this business and establish [hopefully] some real value. Apart from undertaking his role, John will have almost no input into such growth and development. Instinctually, I’m just not sure I’m comfortable with him sitting on a 33.3% share of the company going forward when he ultimately brings little to the table.

I think that a 40:40:20 split would make more sense with any monies already being put into the business by John being repaid in full (when cash flow allows) would be more reasonable. I guess I’m looking for some advice and discussion to establish if that’s the case.

Thanks smile

Eric Mc

125,936 posts

296 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Why isn't Gary listed as a Director?

Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
In the end its cash that starts / drives / grows a business - there are plenty of business ideas out there - the problem is always getting them funded...

If one person has put up the majority of the start up cash, and he will certainly want a say in how it is spent / managed.

If you don't want him involved then why not offer to buy him out - can you / would you put in the equivalent of his cash input plus a profit for him? (say a 20% return) ?

Splats

Original Poster:

625 posts

193 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Eric, I don't know, but I'll ask the question. It won't be anything sinister and it's probably just a hangover from the way the business started, it wasn't carefully planned. It all just sort of happened after the break up of another company.

I could probably look at something along the lines of a buy in/out. Perhaps not right at this moment, but maybe at a later stage.

Eric Mc

125,936 posts

296 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
I would ask and find out. Don't assume anything.

darreni

4,551 posts

301 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Have you been asked to join as a shareholder & director, or are you about to suggest this to the others based on your work over the past 5 months?

Splats

Original Poster:

625 posts

193 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Eric I will smile

I've not asked as such, it's something that we've discussed informally many times over the last few months. I do believe now is the time to put something down on paper. Increasingly I am finding things that I could be doing for the business and it would be a whole lot easier to just get on with it and do them as opposed to proposing it, agreeing a fee/rate and then doing it.

In many respects the whole thing is very relaxed and informal. I guess this is why I struggle with the whole thing a little. I am keen to avoid either of the following scenarios:

1. Asking for something that would be deemed as unreasonable or bordering on insulting
2. Making naive decisions now that cost me dearly in the future (i.e. allowing my inexperience to result in a bum deal for me).

Big E 118

2,468 posts

200 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Burrow01 said:
In the end its cash that starts / drives / grows a business - there are plenty of business ideas out there - the problem is always getting them funded...

If one person has put up the majority of the start up cash, and he will certainly want a say in how it is spent / managed.
There's a lot of people out there with ideas to start a business and not so many who are willing or able to stump up the cash to enable people to do it. That is why the investors, even if they do not contribute further to the business in a working sense can demand a fair slice of the pie.

I'd be up front and ask the father what is he expecting form his investment. He's either put the money up to help the son and doesn't really expect a return or maybe it's his life savings and he expects to retire on dividends.

There are also other options apart from splitting the shares of the business, you could pay the father a retainer/wages as a consultant (justified as he set up the business?) but not give him shares?



Du1point8

22,974 posts

223 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
I find it weird when I see stuff like this, that someone stumps up the capital that others couldnt, its them that got it off the ground, like a dragons den investor (maybe not so much expertise) and then when its up and running, the people that are doing the work then want rid of the person that made it happen.

The split was negotiated from the off, dont like it dont accept it at all and then no company.

As for the director bit, I know that my company has only 1 director and other person owns 50% of it as an owner... this was simply for failing a credit check during the company setup and certain aspects of the business could not be set up with a director that we knew would fail the credit check.

The credit check failure was down to the person not being in the country very long and the council had not registered them properly so they failed for not being on the electoral role due to council cock up.

Splats

Original Poster:

625 posts

193 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Big E 118 said:
That is why the investors, even if they do not contribute further to the business in a working sense can demand a fair slice of the pie.
I agree completely, but the problem is what is a 'fair slice'. That's what I'm grappling with. £10,000 isn't really a lot of money these days and it is my hope [belief] that it will one day be small change in terms of the business profits. If push came to shove, I could lay my hands on £10k with fair ease so the initial cash injection (before I was on the scene) is not fundamental to this business getting off the ground.

Theoretically, suppose John did faff all going forward and we sold up in 5 years time for £1M. I can't see myself being happy with him bagging £333,333 for a £10,000 stake when, invariably, it will be Gary/myself that will have sweat blood and tears to get us to that point. I totally take on board the comments about dragon investors, but this wasn't an impossible sum by any stretch [and the dragon at least bring knowledge, contacts and other benefits].

darreni

4,551 posts

301 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Splats said:
I agree completely, but the problem is what is a 'fair slice'. That's what I'm grappling with. £10,000 isn't really a lot of money these days and it is my hope [belief] that it will one day be small change in terms of the business profits. If push came to shove, I could lay my hands on £10k with fair ease so the initial cash injection (before I was on the scene) is not fundamental to this business getting off the ground.

Theoretically, suppose John did faff all going forward and we sold up in 5 years time for £1M. I can't see myself being happy with him bagging £333,333 for a £10,000 stake when, invariably, it will be Gary/myself that will have sweat blood and tears to get us to that point. I totally take on board the comments about dragon investors, but this wasn't an impossible sum by any stretch [and the dragon at least bring knowledge, contacts and other benefits].
It's their business though, not yours.


Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Splats said:
Big E 118 said:
That is why the investors, even if they do not contribute further to the business in a working sense can demand a fair slice of the pie.
I agree completely, but the problem is what is a 'fair slice'. That's what I'm grappling with. £10,000 isn't really a lot of money these days and it is my hope [belief] that it will one day be small change in terms of the business profits. If push came to shove, I could lay my hands on £10k with fair ease so the initial cash injection (before I was on the scene) is not fundamental to this business getting off the ground.

Theoretically, suppose John did faff all going forward and we sold up in 5 years time for £1M. I can't see myself being happy with him bagging £333,333 for a £10,000 stake when, invariably, it will be Gary/myself that will have sweat blood and tears to get us to that point. I totally take on board the comments about dragon investors, but this wasn't an impossible sum by any stretch [and the dragon at least bring knowledge, contacts and other benefits].
Splats said:
I could probably look at something along the lines of a buy in/out. Perhaps not right at this moment, but maybe at a later stage..
Why not now - would you consider the risk too big at the moment? Reality is that the cash is as fundamental to getting the business running as all your graft - why do you think there are so many Dot Com millionaires who stumped up some cash for a startup and reaped a massive return without actually being involved in the technicalities.

From the other point of view, why would the original investor give away 33% of his equity in the business to you when he can just keep on paying you as a consultant, if all you are looking to put in are skills that he can currently buy and not bring any cash to the party.

If you want it just to be you and the other person, I'd suggest you need to buy out the third person

williamp

20,476 posts

304 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Also remember that a director has certain legal ramifications. Are you aware what this might entail? A director could go to prison because of the actions of others.

Du1point8

22,974 posts

223 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Splats said:
Big E 118 said:
That is why the investors, even if they do not contribute further to the business in a working sense can demand a fair slice of the pie.
I agree completely, but the problem is what is a 'fair slice'. That's what I'm grappling with. £10,000 isn't really a lot of money these days and it is my hope [belief] that it will one day be small change in terms of the business profits. If push came to shove, I could lay my hands on £10k with fair ease so the initial cash injection (before I was on the scene) is not fundamental to this business getting off the ground.

Theoretically, suppose John did faff all going forward and we sold up in 5 years time for £1M. I can't see myself being happy with him bagging £333,333 for a £10,000 stake when, invariably, it will be Gary/myself that will have sweat blood and tears to get us to that point. I totally take on board the comments about dragon investors, but this wasn't an impossible sum by any stretch [and the dragon at least bring knowledge, contacts and other benefits].
Whats fair for the investor? They in theory stumped up 100% of the capital and stand to lose it all, if it werent for the investor the company would not exist, simple as.

It matters not if you think its fair or not, why are you consulting for them and why not set up your own company with your own money and bring that to the table instead of saying how unfair it is that in 5 years the company could be the next microsoft and you ahev to share it.

If it wasnt an impossible sum then why did the original business need an investor?

Big E 118

2,468 posts

200 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Splats said:
£10,000 isn't really a lot of money these days and it is my hope [belief] that it will one day be small change in terms of the business profits.
But it was £10,000 that the other partner did not have. The business would not have started without it
Splats said:
Theoretically, suppose John did faff all going forward and we sold up in 5 years time for £1M. I can't see myself being happy with him bagging £333,333 for a £10,000 stake when, invariably, it will be Gary/myself that will have sweat blood and tears to get us to that point. I totally take on board the comments about dragon investors, but this wasn't an impossible sum by any stretch [and the dragon at least bring knowledge, contacts and other benefits].
OK, John walks of with £333,333 from his initial investment of £10k. Remember you and the third partner would not be walking off with £333,333 either was it not for Johns £10k.

As mentioned before why not ask him what he wants before going in with any offer? You'd be gutted if you offered him the £10k, he took it then down the pub later he mentions he never really wanted anything out of the business in the first place!

If he does want something, is it a lump sum or a regular dividend/wage which may be easier for the business to manage?

Splats

Original Poster:

625 posts

193 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
williamp said:
Also remember that a director has certain legal ramifications. Are you aware what this might entail? A director could go to prison because of the actions of others.
Could you list some of the main ramifications (or point me to a relevant resource).

Some other excellent points being raised. The bottom line is I believe in what Gary and I have put together, I believe in the business and yes, I would be willing to put my money where my mouth is - right now if need be.

I'm a fair bit clearer on how the conversation needs to go down. Establishing John's expectations is probably the first port of call and we can take things from there.

Big E 118

2,468 posts

200 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Splats said:
I'm a fair bit clearer on how the conversation needs to go down. Establishing John's expectations is probably the first port of call and we can take things from there.
Good luck, let us know how things go.

One tip, find a good accountant. They'll have advice on the most financially astute way to achieve what you want.

LooneyTunes

9,522 posts

189 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Splats said:
arrived on the scene for about 5 months working on a commission only and consultative basis.

<snip>

Effectively, without my input the company would not exist in its current form.
They paid you for the work you did? At anything like a normal market rate?

You will have played a blinder if you've done that AND retrospectively negotiated a good slug of the equity.

If however there was an agreement up front that you were building "sweat equity" by working at less than market rate then that's a different story altogether.

Before you broach the subject with the owner, take a really long think about just how important to the business: some owners wouldn't like the idea of someone seemingly holding a gun to their head.

RichB

56,485 posts

315 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
They paid you for the work you did? At anything like a normal market rate? You will have played a blinder if you've done that AND retrospectively negotiated a good slug of the equity.

If however there was an agreement up front that you were building "sweat equity" by working at less than market rate then that's a different story altogether..
I think this is the key, have you been paid the going rate so far?

I've recently become involved with some French colleagues of mine who have asked me to set-up and start the UK subsidiary for their new company having done this successfully for their previous company 10 years ago. I've made it clear I expect equity and we are talking in terms of 4% at the moment, it's difficult to negotiate for more until it proves successful. In return I am being paid roughly half the going rate for the role, but it seems fair to me.

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 23rd January 2014
quotequote all
Being a minority shareholder with the majority held by two family members is not a good position, 50% is worth much more than 49% or less. Much comes down to you but it's not a position I would go for, you are essentially an employee with no power if you disagree with them on anything.