Car dealer query
Discussion
Hi folks, I was looking for some advice for a friend who bought a car from a dealer and is having a few problems, I'll try and keep it brief.
He bought a 57 plate car from dealer for 5k cash on 1st of January.
car went in for a "health check" at a local independent specialist.
Car came back with the following problems :-
1. Upper suspension arm needs replaced
2. Air in brakes ( needs bled)
3. Gear pot needs replaced ( struggles to go into reverse gear sometimes)
4. Exhaust flexi needs replaced (poor condition)
5. Car has no anti freeze in it
Total bill £560.
Now he/we appreciate that if you put a 5 year old car into a garage you're going to get things that are needing addressed.
After having the car for 3 weeks it suddenly cut out, total loss of power, with a "oil pressure low warning" light.
The car was checked (briefly) at independent garage where he changed the oil and done a diagnostic which turned up nothing.
It has since cut out daily and is now wary of driving the car, the independent garage says the car will need to be dropped off for a more detailed check but he suspects crankshaft sensor.
The dealer has not offered any help apart from passing us onto a warranty company, ( he got 1 month warranty) who say nothing is covered apart from possibly the gear pot.
We spoke to CAB who said dealer has a responsibility to make sure car is road worthy and should get to A>B as a normal person would expect and that we shouldn't be passed on to the warranty company as its the dealer that is responsible to repair or refund.
We totally appreciate some things on the list are wear and tear and are expected on a car of that age.
When asked if he was going to help us the dealer said that's what the warranty company was for, he's been selling cars for years etc etc, "knows his rights" and we should have took an extended warranty to cover more things.
My mate isn't expecting everything sorted by the dealer but the estimate is up to nearly £800 and the car isn't reliable at all.
Is the dealer within his rights to do this?Any advice appreciated.
Thanks for reading.
He bought a 57 plate car from dealer for 5k cash on 1st of January.
car went in for a "health check" at a local independent specialist.
Car came back with the following problems :-
1. Upper suspension arm needs replaced
2. Air in brakes ( needs bled)
3. Gear pot needs replaced ( struggles to go into reverse gear sometimes)
4. Exhaust flexi needs replaced (poor condition)
5. Car has no anti freeze in it
Total bill £560.
Now he/we appreciate that if you put a 5 year old car into a garage you're going to get things that are needing addressed.
After having the car for 3 weeks it suddenly cut out, total loss of power, with a "oil pressure low warning" light.
The car was checked (briefly) at independent garage where he changed the oil and done a diagnostic which turned up nothing.
It has since cut out daily and is now wary of driving the car, the independent garage says the car will need to be dropped off for a more detailed check but he suspects crankshaft sensor.
The dealer has not offered any help apart from passing us onto a warranty company, ( he got 1 month warranty) who say nothing is covered apart from possibly the gear pot.
We spoke to CAB who said dealer has a responsibility to make sure car is road worthy and should get to A>B as a normal person would expect and that we shouldn't be passed on to the warranty company as its the dealer that is responsible to repair or refund.
We totally appreciate some things on the list are wear and tear and are expected on a car of that age.
When asked if he was going to help us the dealer said that's what the warranty company was for, he's been selling cars for years etc etc, "knows his rights" and we should have took an extended warranty to cover more things.
My mate isn't expecting everything sorted by the dealer but the estimate is up to nearly £800 and the car isn't reliable at all.
Is the dealer within his rights to do this?Any advice appreciated.
Thanks for reading.
POORCARDEALER said:
Has the work been carried out by the specialist already?
If yes then you are goosed.
If no, then you need to give the dealer the chance to rectify certain faults
No works been carried out, the car is at his house and won't be driven due to the random cut outs.If yes then you are goosed.
If no, then you need to give the dealer the chance to rectify certain faults
We asked the dealer to help rectify the problems and he just kept telling us to contact the 3rd party warranty company, its a basic warranty and said only gear pot may be covered but will have to get a detailed report from the independent garage, which we would need to pay for.
Thanks
Raverbaby said:
POORCARDEALER said:
Has the work been carried out by the specialist already?
If yes then you are goosed.
If no, then you need to give the dealer the chance to rectify certain faults
No works been carried out, the car is at his house and won't be driven due to the random cut outs.If yes then you are goosed.
If no, then you need to give the dealer the chance to rectify certain faults
We asked the dealer to help rectify the problems and he just kept telling us to contact the 3rd party warranty company, its a basic warranty and said only gear pot may be covered but will have to get a detailed report from the independent garage, which we would need to pay for.
Thanks
POORCARDEALER said:
I would get another opinion from a general garage rather than a specialist...its not unknown for specialist to be ultra picky in order to create work for themselves
Yeah I know what you mean.He's not expecting the dealer to get the car into perfect condition, if he got the gears sorted and random cut outs sorted he would be happy to get the other items sorted himself but the dealer isn't willing to help in any way apart from fobbing us off to warranty company.
SmithyAG said:
Raverbaby said:
5. Car has no anti freeze in it
No anti freeze? Anti freeze and coolant are one and the same on any car I can think of. If the car has no coolant/anti freeze, surely it would not be able to be driven? The following is a bit like telling you to close the stable door after the horse has bolted, but I think it's worth saying.
The lesson here is to get the health check done before you buy the car.
It's worth also remembering my rule about user cars - they will always cost an extra 10% to fix little niggles.
Your mate probably does have a bit of a case.
But, the car drives, it's roadworthy, the warranty was explained at the time of purchase.
Nothing on your list actually makes it unsafe or unroadworthy.
So, the case is probably limited to a small amount of the stuff you listed. So, it's probably not worth it.
The lesson here is to get the health check done before you buy the car.
It's worth also remembering my rule about user cars - they will always cost an extra 10% to fix little niggles.
Your mate probably does have a bit of a case.
But, the car drives, it's roadworthy, the warranty was explained at the time of purchase.
Nothing on your list actually makes it unsafe or unroadworthy.
So, the case is probably limited to a small amount of the stuff you listed. So, it's probably not worth it.
Snowboy said:
The following is a bit like telling you to close the stable door after the horse has bolted, but I think it's worth saying.
The lesson here is to get the health check done before you buy the car.
It's worth also remembering my rule about user cars - they will always cost an extra 10% to fix little niggles.
Your mate probably does have a bit of a case.
But, the car drives, it's roadworthy, the warranty was explained at the time of purchase.
Nothing on your list actually makes it unsafe or unroadworthy.
So, the case is probably limited to a small amount of the stuff you listed. So, it's probably not worth it.
I know, totally understand where your coming from, cheers.The lesson here is to get the health check done before you buy the car.
It's worth also remembering my rule about user cars - they will always cost an extra 10% to fix little niggles.
Your mate probably does have a bit of a case.
But, the car drives, it's roadworthy, the warranty was explained at the time of purchase.
Nothing on your list actually makes it unsafe or unroadworthy.
So, the case is probably limited to a small amount of the stuff you listed. So, it's probably not worth it.
JimmyConwayNW said:
What type of car is it and what type of dealer did they buy it from?
Was it considerably cheaper or the fair market rate?
Alfa GT, wasn't a large main dealer but he certainly had around 25/30 cars on his forecourt.Was it considerably cheaper or the fair market rate?
I think it was the going rate, £5k with 50k on the clock with FSH?
Probably more bother than it's worth chasing it up, just wanted to see if there was anything concrete I could give him, he's just had a baby and bought the car with his savings so doesn't need any hassle.
Not the end of the world,live and learn I suppose

Thanks.
Raverbaby said:
... I think it was the going rate, £5k with 50k on the clock with FSH?
Probably more bother than it's worth chasing it up, just wanted to see if there was anything concrete I could give him ...
I've posted this "continuum" before for people in this situation:Probably more bother than it's worth chasing it up, just wanted to see if there was anything concrete I could give him ...
At one end of the line we have a car that is a month old with 500 miles on the clock that cost £25k. Excluding the manufacturer's warranty (that TOTALLY muddies the waters
) it can be argued that the dealer is 100% responsible for any repairs which are needed, yes? 
Three factors to consider here - the vehicle's age, its mileage and the price paid for it
.At the other end of the line we might have a 20 year old car with moonshot mileage that cost £300. It could be argued that the dealer may reasonably be expected to replace any bulbs that fail and maybe contribute something towards the cost of a new battery (on a "give me a tenner and I'll get you a new one" basis as he can get it for trade prices
and on top of the punter's tenner he'll only lay out a few more quid for a cheap 'un) if the car won't start one winter's day... Anything more substantial and the dealer arguably really doesn't have much responsibility at all?Having said this, SOGA (Sale of Goods Act) is only applicable for 6 months after a car is purchased - and it could be argued that the dealer's responsibility is 100% for any problems (bearing in mind the above paragraphs regarding the mileage vs. cost vs. age "continuum"
) when the car rolls off the forecourt and receding down to NOWT on the 183rd day.The car under discussion has done 50k (recorded) miles in 6 years therefore has lower than average mileage, but I don't know about its market value. The car has been owned for 3 weeks-ish out of the 6 months so that's around 12% depreciation on the dealer's responsibilty? So what percentage of repair costs should arguably be met by the dealer? I'd suggest maybe a pretty optimistic 40% or so? But as the dealer can get parts and materials at trade costs maybe ask them to source parts and materials and contribute something to the labour cost at the specialist?
Or try another garage, or put it in for an MoT, or even check it yourself??
Regardless, the dealer has some responsibility
.Hope this waffle helps
PS Dealer is talking bo
ocks when he/she/it refers to the 1 month warranty and the owner speaking only to the warranty company; they CANNOT discharge their responsibility under SOGA in this way. Did I mention this? 
The one month warranty doesn't eliminate soga.
That's true.
But on the other hand, the buyer was well aware the car was being sold with just a one month warranty.
The spirit of the soga laws is to stop buyers being cheated out of thier money.
In the context of used cars it's roughly to do with; is the car roadworthy, is the car reliable for it's age, was it advertised properly.
The "soga is six months" comment isn't true from a legal perspective.
It's a fairly accurate guideline on a newish car, but not so much on an older car.
That's true.
But on the other hand, the buyer was well aware the car was being sold with just a one month warranty.
The spirit of the soga laws is to stop buyers being cheated out of thier money.
In the context of used cars it's roughly to do with; is the car roadworthy, is the car reliable for it's age, was it advertised properly.
The "soga is six months" comment isn't true from a legal perspective.
It's a fairly accurate guideline on a newish car, but not so much on an older car.
All Alfas of that era need at least one suspension component replacing at any one time. IMO that one's not worth pursuing because it won't last longer than the argument. However get it powerflexed by a specialist and you'll probably reduce the wear rate.
The JTS I have, and presumably this applies to others, can also be difficult to get into reverse, but double declutching solves that.
The JTS I have, and presumably this applies to others, can also be difficult to get into reverse, but double declutching solves that.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


