Recovery of losses from an accident
Discussion
My 17 year niece has just had her car written off.
She was stationary behind a car that was waiting to turn right, when a van drove into the back of her car. The police say they are considering a careless driving charge for the van driver, so I think its as clear as it can be where the fault lies.
When she renews her insurance, she is going to be paying more, less that a years experience with a claim for a write-off. Can she pursue the van driver or his insurance for these additional costs? The additional premium she will have to pay seems to be directly attributable to him.
Should she look to claim direct on the 3rd party's insurance? would that mean she still has her NCB at the end of the year - or will they void the policy as the car is a write-off.
I feel for her - she's a lovely young lady, who hasn't come from money and worked hard to buy her car, I can see this will end up costing her a lot.
thanks
She was stationary behind a car that was waiting to turn right, when a van drove into the back of her car. The police say they are considering a careless driving charge for the van driver, so I think its as clear as it can be where the fault lies.
When she renews her insurance, she is going to be paying more, less that a years experience with a claim for a write-off. Can she pursue the van driver or his insurance for these additional costs? The additional premium she will have to pay seems to be directly attributable to him.
Should she look to claim direct on the 3rd party's insurance? would that mean she still has her NCB at the end of the year - or will they void the policy as the car is a write-off.
I feel for her - she's a lovely young lady, who hasn't come from money and worked hard to buy her car, I can see this will end up costing her a lot.
thanks
She can either claim direct from tp insurer or if she has comp, claim from her own insurer who will then recover their outlay from tp insurers. Either way she should keep her bonus when the claim is settled.
Some insurers charge for a non fault claim, some don't. If hers does, she cannot claim that back from the tp or his insurers.
Lots of people will tell you that you can but you can't. Some people even claim to have done it but they can never produce the evidence.
Some insurers charge for a non fault claim, some don't. If hers does, she cannot claim that back from the tp or his insurers.
Lots of people will tell you that you can but you can't. Some people even claim to have done it but they can never produce the evidence.
If her car is written off she will not generally be able to get a refund for the "unused" portion of her premium, but she should be able to transfer it to her new car. In the past not all insurers have allowed this, but the Financial Ombudsman has recently said that they should ( link). If the policy were to be cancelled mid-term she would not accrue any no claims for the half year, but if she transfers it to her new car she should have a years NCB at the end (assuming no more accidents). Before she chooses a new car it's worth checking that her current insurer will cover her to drive it and that they won't charge too much extra premium.
You wouldnt be able to claim for the difference because its an undocumented loss... However theres probably somebody who would take it on. How would you quantify the loss though is another matter. Could you have guaranteed that the premium would have gone down? Some renewals go up. Its one of them things like depreciation thats so in the air. I guess if you could get it in writing from whoever insures her next that she has paid an extra premium because of that claim then you could claim it!
My advice, shop around and find an insurer who doesn't charge for non fault claims.
I know my dads policy which I sorted recently wasn't loaded at all for a non fault claim.
My advice, shop around and find an insurer who doesn't charge for non fault claims.
I know my dads policy which I sorted recently wasn't loaded at all for a non fault claim.
whoami said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Some insurers charge for a non fault claim, some don't.
The fact that some do is questionable, at the very least.TwigtheWonderkid said:
Not at all. This has been done to death on here and many examples have been quoted to show someone involved in a non fault accident can be justifiably categorised as a higher risk for the future.
Justifiably from an insurance company's point of view - or justifiably from a real, statistical, scientific point of view.Insurance companies seem to apply the rule that correlation = causation, whereas anyone who has studied statistics knows that this isn't the case.
Moonhawk said:
Insurance companies seem to apply the rule that correlation = causation, whereas anyone who has studied statistics knows that this isn't the case.
No they don't. They apply the rule that correlation in the past (claims histories) is likely to mean correlation in the future. Causation doesn't come into it.Moonhawk said:
Justifiably from an insurance company's point of view - or justifiably from a real, statistical, scientific point of view.
Insurance companies seem to apply the rule that correlation = causation, whereas anyone who has studied statistics knows that this isn't the case.
I love posts like this. Do you have any idea how qualified actuaries are? They would piss all over you in a statistics driven debate. Insurance companies seem to apply the rule that correlation = causation, whereas anyone who has studied statistics knows that this isn't the case.
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Not at all. This has been done to death on here and many examples have been quoted to show someone involved in a non fault accident can be justifiably categorised as a higher risk for the future. Some insurers take this on board, some don't. Some do for certain age groups or postcodes, but not others. It's entirely their prerogative.
I can see the logic, but it's undeniable that being rearended by an inattentive driver could happen to anybody at any time and surely can't be attributed to their standard of driving in the slightest? I can think of no possible reason why if you've been rear ended once you're more or less likely to have the same happen to you again than any other motorist on the road.Twin brothers, share a house and drive identical cars. Same risk. Brother A regularly visits his mum, who lives in a narrow street on a bend, where accidents are common. Brother B has fallen out with mum and they haven't spoken for years. He never visits.
Brother A's car get hit whilst parked outside his mums. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Now, which of the 2 brothers do you think is at greater risk of having the same thing happen again, perhaps not being lucky enough to have a note left next time?
Brother A's car get hit whilst parked outside his mums. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Now, which of the 2 brothers do you think is at greater risk of having the same thing happen again, perhaps not being lucky enough to have a note left next time?
LoonR1 said:
Moonhawk said:
Justifiably from an insurance company's point of view - or justifiably from a real, statistical, scientific point of view.
Insurance companies seem to apply the rule that correlation = causation, whereas anyone who has studied statistics knows that this isn't the case.
I love posts like this. Do you have any idea how qualified actuaries are? They would piss all over you in a statistics driven debate. Insurance companies seem to apply the rule that correlation = causation, whereas anyone who has studied statistics knows that this isn't the case.
Does having a garage make you less or more likely to claim?
You'd think less as it's safe in there but your car doesn't live in the garage all the time. Plus loads lied about having one so for a lot of insurers the data is corrupt.
However, some insurers are finding there is a connection between keeping your car in a garage and having a fault claim that's not connected directly with this. Shrewder pricing means they'll charge you more for having a garage even though it's counter intuitive for you.
You'd think less as it's safe in there but your car doesn't live in the garage all the time. Plus loads lied about having one so for a lot of insurers the data is corrupt.
However, some insurers are finding there is a connection between keeping your car in a garage and having a fault claim that's not connected directly with this. Shrewder pricing means they'll charge you more for having a garage even though it's counter intuitive for you.
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Twin brothers, share a house and drive identical cars. Same risk. Brother A regularly visits his mum, who lives in a narrow street on a bend, where accidents are common. Brother B has fallen out with mum and they haven't spoken for years. He never visits.
Brother A's car get hit whilst parked outside his mums. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Now, which of the 2 brothers do you think is at greater risk of having the same thing happen again, perhaps not being lucky enough to have a note left next time?
Twin brothers, share a house and drive identical cars. They both shop at the same supermarket and park in the same car park. Same risk. Brother A's car get hit whilst parked outside his mums. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Now, which of the 2 brothers do you think is at greater risk of having the same thing happen again, perhaps not being lucky enough to have a note left next time?
Brother A's car get hit whilst parked in the supermarket car park. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Brother B parks in the same spot in the same car park the next day and his car doesn't get hit. By this logic, although the circumstances are both identical, somehow insurance companies come to the conclusion that Brother A is more likely to get his car hit in a car park again than Brother B. Anyone with a room temperature IQ can see this makes no sense whatsoever. This is without going near the fact that a non fault accident would result in a claim being directed at the other vehicles insurance company and wouldn't cost Brother A's company a penny, a fact that seems to be conveniently ignored when premiums are calculated.
Darkslider said:
Twin brothers, share a house and drive identical cars. They both shop at the same supermarket and park in the same car park. Same risk.
Brother A's car get hit whilst parked in the supermarket car park. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Brother B parks in the same spot in the same car park the next day and his car doesn't get hit. By this logic, although the circumstances are both identical, somehow insurance companies come to the conclusion that Brother A is more likely to get his car hit in a car park again than Brother B. Anyone with a room temperature IQ can see this makes no sense whatsoever. This is without going near the fact that a non fault accident would result in a claim being directed at the other vehicles insurance company and wouldn't cost Brother A's company a penny, a fact that seems to be conveniently ignored when premiums are calculated.
I see you've ignored my statement, so lets have another go.Brother A's car get hit whilst parked in the supermarket car park. Fortunately, the culprit leaves a note. Clear non fault claim, no blame attached to brother A.
Brother B parks in the same spot in the same car park the next day and his car doesn't get hit. By this logic, although the circumstances are both identical, somehow insurance companies come to the conclusion that Brother A is more likely to get his car hit in a car park again than Brother B. Anyone with a room temperature IQ can see this makes no sense whatsoever. This is without going near the fact that a non fault accident would result in a claim being directed at the other vehicles insurance company and wouldn't cost Brother A's company a penny, a fact that seems to be conveniently ignored when premiums are calculated.
I am an insurer.
10% of my policyholders had a claim last year. This was split evenly between fault and non-fault at 5% each.
Over the past 5 years I have seen that of those who claim for a non-fault this year, 50% go on to have a fault claim in the next year.
That is a out of sync with a normal policyholder who doesn't claim at all, they have a 1 in 10 chance of claiming and 1 in 20 of it being fault. Whereas a non fualt claimant is ten times mor elikely to make a fault claim at 1 in 2.
I'm going to charge more for a policyholder with a non-fault claim.
Those stats are simplified and exaggerated, but that is the reality of why some insurers charge more.
Of course other insurers see no such experience driven correlation and don't charge more and in fact some, even see the opposite and charge less (but of course we need to pretend that doesn't happen).
LoonR1 said:
I see you've ignored my statement, so lets have another go.
I am an insurer.
10% of my policyholders had a claim last year. This was split evenly between fault and non-fault at 5% each.
Over the past 5 years I have seen that of those who claim for a non-fault this year, 50% go on to have a fault claim in the next year.
That is a out of sync with a normal policyholder who doesn't claim at all, they have a 1 in 10 chance of claiming and 1 in 20 of it being fault. Whereas a non fualt claimant is ten times mor elikely to make a fault claim at 1 in 2.
I'm going to charge more for a policyholder with a non-fault claim.
Those stats are simplified and exaggerated, but that is the reality of why some insurers charge more.
Of course other insurers see no such experience driven correlation and don't charge more and in fact some, even see the opposite and charge less (but of course we need to pretend that doesn't happen).
Are these insurers statistics available for public or OFT scrutiny?I am an insurer.
10% of my policyholders had a claim last year. This was split evenly between fault and non-fault at 5% each.
Over the past 5 years I have seen that of those who claim for a non-fault this year, 50% go on to have a fault claim in the next year.
That is a out of sync with a normal policyholder who doesn't claim at all, they have a 1 in 10 chance of claiming and 1 in 20 of it being fault. Whereas a non fualt claimant is ten times mor elikely to make a fault claim at 1 in 2.
I'm going to charge more for a policyholder with a non-fault claim.
Those stats are simplified and exaggerated, but that is the reality of why some insurers charge more.
Of course other insurers see no such experience driven correlation and don't charge more and in fact some, even see the opposite and charge less (but of course we need to pretend that doesn't happen).
PurpleMoonlight said:
Are these insurers statistics available for public or OFT scrutiny?
They are made up stats that I used.No company will share data with any memeber of the puclic, as it is commercially sensitive and would be a breach of competition law and arguably lead to price fixing allegations.
The OFT can pretty well ask for what it wants but even then the data would be provided under very tight security and conditions.
I'm always amazed why people think they should have access to this data. Do you ask Shell for the breakdown of their costs and how they price their petrol, or Tesco for their grocery supply contracts?
Some will argue that insurance is compulsory, so is putting petrol / diesel in your vehicle and eating. You have a choice of insurer, petrol filling station and supermarket to get your products from.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


