The VAT Margin Scheme on second-hand cars
The VAT Margin Scheme on second-hand cars
Author
Discussion

Escy

Original Poster:

4,132 posts

180 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm looking to start a business as a used car trader. I'm likely to hit the 79k turnover that would make me need to be VAT registered. I'm reading up on it from the HMRC website. I've hit a potential issue with my business plan. I intend to buy cars that are spares and repairs needing major work as that'll give me a higher profit margin.

From the HMRC website.
"You must not include any cost to you of bringing the vehicle to sale. Your purchase price does not include the cost of any repairs, refurbishment, accessories or your business overheads."

That's a problem for my plan. Any advice from anyone in the trade?

maxmc2

2,063 posts

216 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm an accountant and had a company that sold old cars.

I seem to remember we claimed the repairs as a separate expense like normal in the VAT return, its just for the sale you don't include the repair bills.

A fair while ago, might be worth picking up the phone to HMRC and speaking to someone.

Magic919

14,589 posts

232 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
What exactly is the problem?

Escy

Original Poster:

4,132 posts

180 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
The problem is that you pay the tax on difference between the purchase price and sale price, not the profit. Not ideal if I'm spending thousands repairing cars

Magic919

14,589 posts

232 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
No, you pay VAT on the difference between the buying and selling price. Your tax liability is a separate matter.

amirzed

1,790 posts

207 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
Escy said:
The problem is that you pay the tax on difference between the purchase price and sale price, not the profit. Not ideal if I'm spending thousands repairing cars
I think that's referring to your output tax, so you can't minimise your output VAT on sold vehicles, however you can claim VAT on costs incurred to make the sales as input tax, so the VAT you will actually pay will take into account VAT paid on repairs/parts etc

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Friday 24th January 2014
quotequote all
Escy said:
The problem is that you pay the tax on difference between the purchase price and sale price, not the profit. Not ideal if I'm spending thousands repairing cars
Correct.

Maz_uk

590 posts

229 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
It's only really a problem if you use non vat registered suppliers as you still pay the vat but can't reclaim for that money spent.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
Escy said:
Not ideal if I'm spending thousands repairing cars
I'm curious - are you thinking of buying damaged repairables, or cars that are in need or major mechanical repairs?

How much of the work will you do yourself?

Escy

Original Poster:

4,132 posts

180 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
Major mechanical repairs typically. I do all the work myself.

CRA1G

7,256 posts

226 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
Maz_uk said:
It's only really a problem if you use non vat registered suppliers as you still pay the vat but can't reclaim for that money spent.
Yea hit it bang on the nail.. Buy for £2000 spend £800 on second hand parts with no VAT and sell for £3800 your profit is £1000... but you will pay VAT on £1800.... which is £300 so nets down to £700 before any other overheads and your labour........oh and don't forget income TAX........!cry

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
Escy said:
Major mechanical repairs typically. I do all the work myself.
Hmm.. Well good luck with it.


Escy

Original Poster:

4,132 posts

180 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
daemon said:
Hmm.. Well good luck with it.
go on...

dvs_dave

9,040 posts

256 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
You've seen wheeler dealers I presume?

Escy

Original Poster:

4,132 posts

180 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
I have.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
Escy said:
daemon said:
Hmm.. Well good luck with it.
go on...
Well speaking as a self employed motor trader, dealing in cars £1000-£5000 for a couple of years there, underwriting dealer trade ins, taking trade ins, etc, and having had a few of those either traded in knowingly with major problems or underwritten with known major problems my findings were...

(a) If a car has been neglected to the point of a major failure, rarely does "curing" the major failure make it a good car. Eg, you buy a car needing a turbo, and it also then needs an EGR valve and DPF, but you dont know that until you get it up and running.

(b) Dealers will know roughly what a car is worth and be expecting that price, ie, if they know a DMF is a £700 repair, then they'll be knocking £700 off the price. So you may as well go and buy a good car in the first place because you're not getting it "cheap" enough in the first place to be bothered with the hassle.

(c) If you're buying private, the seller will be saying "oh my mechanic says that engine management light is nothing to worry about", when their mechanic knows it needs a fortune spent, so you wont be able to get it priced accordingly.

(d) if you buy at auction there'll always be someone willing to pay a bit more than you.

I could go on but i guess what i'm saying is that i dont think you'll be able to get enough cars cheap enough to make a viable business of it. If you're buying something that other traders wont touch because it needs that much work, then you really are buying a piece of crap, and theres the old adage you cant polish a turd.

I dont really see what you're bringing to the party to be honest. If you're a motor trader, then you farm out the mechanicing, valeting, etc, to someone else, because you're flat out viewing, reviewing, underwriting, maintaining relationships, dealing with customers, organising viewings, dealing with problems, picking up cars, delivering cars, etc, etc. If you're a mechanic then you wont want to be bothered motor trading because you wont have time to do all the work plus all of the above.

On top of that you'll have bought something needing ££££'s spent on it, got it going again, and then have to stand over it for up to six months under the SOGA.

And, as you're finding out, you'll be giving 20% of your margin away to the VAT man...

Certainly what i took out of the time i did it full time was it was better to AVOID the problem cars rather than actively look for them.

I would have thought you'd have been better spending your time sourcing reasonably decent trouble free cars, giving them a service and a fresh MOT and moving them on.

Escy

Original Poster:

4,132 posts

180 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
daemon said:
Well speaking as a self employed motor trader, dealing in cars £1000-£5000 for a couple of years there, underwriting dealer trade ins, taking trade ins, etc, and having had a few of those either traded in knowingly with major problems or underwritten with known major problems my findings were...

(a) If a car has been neglected to the point of a major failure, rarely does "curing" the major failure make it a good car. Eg, you buy a car needing a turbo, and it also then needs an EGR valve and DPF, but you dont know that until you get it up and running.

(b) Dealers will know roughly what a car is worth and be expecting that price, ie, if they know a DMF is a £700 repair, then they'll be knocking £700 off the price. So you may as well go and buy a good car in the first place because you're not getting it "cheap" enough in the first place to be bothered with the hassle.

(c) If you're buying private, the seller will be saying "oh my mechanic says that engine management light is nothing to worry about", when their mechanic knows it needs a fortune spent, so you wont be able to get it priced accordingly.

(d) if you buy at auction there'll always be someone willing to pay a bit more than you.
Good post. I'd like to say i've been dabbling for a few years, have experience of what I want to achieve and that i'm not going into this after having watched a few episodes of wheeler dealers.

a) I know the point you're making, i've been there, found unexpected things in the past that have doubled the amount of work/and or costs required. I'd like to think that i've learnt lessons and now make pretty good judgements when choosing cars.

b) I don't yet have many contacts within the trade so this won't apply to me often. I've bought a few cars from traders in the past, yes they know their figures but they also know it needs to have a profit in it for me. I've made good money on the car's i've picked up from traders.

c) When I buy privately, I only view the cars that the figures work for me on and I budget for worse case scenario. I don't buy cars needing minor work so it's not really an issue.

d) I've not yet bought at auction, i've only been to my local ones and I see the same st going through all the time with reserves not met and the cars that are worth bidding on end up going for similar money to what you can just pick them up on Auto Trader/Ebay for. This isn't how I plan to source my cars.

daemon said:
I could go on but i guess what i'm saying is that i dont think you'll be able to get enough cars cheap enough to make a viable business of it. If you're buying something that other traders wont touch because it needs that much work, then you really are buying a piece of crap, and theres the old adage you cant polish a turd.
You maybe right, I might not be able to source enough cars. The type of cars i'm after are hard to find, they can be like busses, nothing comes up for a few weeks and then a few come up at the same time. I want to have enough money behind me to be able to snap up the cars when they come along and have a backlog. I guess time will tell on this one. I've got some back-up plans to keep money coming in if my supply does run dry.


daemon said:
I dont really see what you're bringing to the party to be honest. If you're a motor trader, then you farm out the mechanicing, valeting, etc, to someone else, because you're flat out viewing, reviewing, underwriting, maintaining relationships, dealing with customers, organising viewings, dealing with problems, picking up cars, delivering cars, etc, etc. If you're a mechanic then you wont want to be bothered motor trading because you wont have time to do all the work plus all of the above.
I'll be doing what I like to do. I don't plan on having a big operation. I'll be working from home to start with (low overheads), the idea is to do 3 cars a month but making a better margin than I could otherwise. I should have plenty of time to be able to cover both sides of the business.

daemon said:
On top of that you'll have bought something needing ££££'s spent on it, got it going again, and then have to stand over it for up to six months under the SOGA.

And, as you're finding out, you'll be giving 20% of your margin away to the VAT man...
These are both things that concern me. You only have to read the SOGA jokers on this website that try to reject cars with minor issues to realise that there are loads of people with unrealistic expectations. Time will tell on this aspect, maybe i'll have problems, maybe I won't.

As for the VAT issue, that's the reason for this thread. It seems like if I can buy all my parts from VAT registered businesses which i'd assume the majority of breakers are, i'll be ok.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
Escy said:
These are both things that concern me. You only have to read the SOGA jokers on this website that try to reject cars with minor issues to realise that there are loads of people with unrealistic expectations. Time will tell on this aspect, maybe i'll have problems, maybe I won't.

As for the VAT issue, that's the reason for this thread. It seems like if I can buy all my parts from VAT registered businesses which i'd assume the majority of breakers are, i'll be ok.
Most of the local breakers around me are reluctant to give receipts, and if they do, they charge you the price you'd agreed + VAT. Maybe its different where you are.

Another thing i'd say is if you are planning on selling three cars a month, then you probably will need another two or three in the pipeline to keep the "production line" going, as it were. So you'll maybe need to budget for five or six cars.

Once i dropped back to part time i changed tact a bit as i realised it was harder to find the right car to make profit on, than find a customer to buy them. So if the customer didnt seem "right" or had a dopey trade in or a trade in i didnt like the look of, i'd not do the deal.

As i said, fair play and good luck. You're coming at it from a different angle than i did - i did a lot of underwriting which generated a lot of volume (20-25 cars a month) which meant i was taking less profit to keep the production line moving. If i'd my time at it again i'd definitely be looking at buying a few high margin cars a month, rather than trying to keep main dealers happy.


POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Saturday 25th January 2014
quotequote all
daemon said:
Escy said:
These are both things that concern me. You only have to read the SOGA jokers on this website that try to reject cars with minor issues to realise that there are loads of people with unrealistic expectations. Time will tell on this aspect, maybe i'll have problems, maybe I won't.

As for the VAT issue, that's the reason for this thread. It seems like if I can buy all my parts from VAT registered businesses which i'd assume the majority of breakers are, i'll be ok.
Once i dropped back to part time i changed tact a bit as i realised it was harder to find the right car to make profit on, than find a customer to buy them. So if the customer didnt seem "right" or had a dopey trade in or a trade in i didnt like the look of, i'd not do the deal.
In todays market that is excellent advice

7even

462 posts

224 months

Sunday 26th January 2014
quotequote all
Youll also need you licence from your local council, this for me involved planning, fire and police checks.
Another thing to consider is the implications of shifting on category C vehicles (if you get any).

Good Luck and I wish you well. smile