Bike has been written off, can I continue to insure it?
Discussion
Hello, has an accident recently, bike has been declared a Cat C and I'm going to be paid out for it, I also believe I will be keeping the bike as well. Now, my insurance doesn't finish until July, I would like to continue to insure it until that time so that I don't lose this years no claims bonus, and the bike is currently in my possession in my back garden, so in the unlikely event I'd still like it covered for theft purposes at least, even if it is a Cat C now, I haven't decided if I'm going to repair it, scrap it, or break it yet though, but will likely repair it so it could well be back on the road before July.
Just wondering what the standard outcome of cases like this is, or is it purely on an insurer by insurer basis? Will many insurance companies continue to insure vehicles after they've been declared a write off, as I imagine there'll be plenty of times where older vehicles are written off, but are still driveable and their owners will want to continue to use it, or will they just cancel my policy straight away?
Will obviously be ringing my insurance company to sort it all out, would just like to know what I'm up against.
Thanks in advance
Just wondering what the standard outcome of cases like this is, or is it purely on an insurer by insurer basis? Will many insurance companies continue to insure vehicles after they've been declared a write off, as I imagine there'll be plenty of times where older vehicles are written off, but are still driveable and their owners will want to continue to use it, or will they just cancel my policy straight away?
Will obviously be ringing my insurance company to sort it all out, would just like to know what I'm up against.
Thanks in advance
Spangles said:
If it's your own insurance that has paid out for a total loss then in most cases the insurance will cease.
The Insurer should offer to provide cover for any replacement bike or there's an argument the should provide a refund of the balance of premiums. Not all Insurers are happy to cover previously written off bikes, some will totally refuse and some may require it to be have a new MOT etc.
If your Insurers do not offer cover send them an "Official Complaint" requesting a pro rata refund of the balance of premiums less any standard cancellation fee.
The above is assuming you claimed directly off your own policy
It may depend on your insurer so check with them, I had a vehicle written off a few years ago, I was paid out but I kept the salvage & had it repaired using either non OEM or second hand parts which kept the cost down, when roadworthy I phoned my insurer & they were happy to cover it.
One of the things you mentioned was trying to keep your NCB - but it sounds like its your insurer paying out; why do you think you'll be able to keep this years NCB? Surely you'll lose it all? If you've got protected NCB then its probably worth making sure you understand the small print for what happens following a claim.
dacouch said:
The Insurer should offer to provide cover for any replacement bike or there's an argument the should provide a refund of the balance of premiums.
Not all Insurers are happy to cover previously written off bikes, some will totally refuse and some may require it to be have a new MOT etc.
If your Insurers do not offer cover send them an "Official Complaint" requesting a pro rata refund of the balance of premiums less any standard cancellation fee.
The above is assuming you claimed directly off your own policy
I think you have this back to front. The normal situation is that insurance ceases once it has paid out for a total loss. Not all Insurers are happy to cover previously written off bikes, some will totally refuse and some may require it to be have a new MOT etc.
If your Insurers do not offer cover send them an "Official Complaint" requesting a pro rata refund of the balance of premiums less any standard cancellation fee.
The above is assuming you claimed directly off your own policy
Likewise, where you are paying your premium by instalments any pay out, for a total loss, is normally reduced by the amount of the outstanding installments so that you end up "paying" in full the quoted annual premium.
Cat
Cat said:
dacouch said:
The Insurer should offer to provide cover for any replacement bike or there's an argument the should provide a refund of the balance of premiums.
Not all Insurers are happy to cover previously written off bikes, some will totally refuse and some may require it to be have a new MOT etc.
If your Insurers do not offer cover send them an "Official Complaint" requesting a pro rata refund of the balance of premiums less any standard cancellation fee.
The above is assuming you claimed directly off your own policy
I think you have this back to front. The normal situation is that insurance ceases once it has paid out for a total loss. Not all Insurers are happy to cover previously written off bikes, some will totally refuse and some may require it to be have a new MOT etc.
If your Insurers do not offer cover send them an "Official Complaint" requesting a pro rata refund of the balance of premiums less any standard cancellation fee.
The above is assuming you claimed directly off your own policy
Likewise, where you are paying your premium by instalments any pay out, for a total loss, is normally reduced by the amount of the outstanding installments so that you end up "paying" in full the quoted annual premium.
Cat
dacouch said:
It's changed recently
Really? So you pay £1200 up front to insure your £10000 car for the year. At the end of the first month you write of the car. The insurance company pay out £10000 plus give you back £1100 because you were only insured for month. I don't think so.Cat
Cat said:
Really? So you pay £1200 up front to insure your £10000 car for the year. At the end of the first month you write of the car. The insurance company pay out £10000 plus give you back £1100 because you were only insured for month. I don't think so.
Cat
"Most motor insurance policies are yearly contracts – so the full premium is payable even if the vehicle is written off during the year. If the consumer paid the yearly premium upfront, they will not receive any refund. Or if the consumer was paying the yearly premium by monthly instalments, they must still pay the outstanding instalments after the vehicle is written off.Cat
When an insurer declares a vehicle a write-off, we expect it to offer a consumer the option of bringing a replacement vehicle onto the insurance policy so that the remainder of the policy term can be used. Depending on the make and model of the replacement vehicle, an additional premium may be required by the insurer. This should be calculated on a pro rata basis for the remainder of the policy term."
http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications...
The above has changed fairly recently, it used to say to the effect that there is normally no refund of premium in the event of a total loss and did not state the Ombudsman expects an Insurer to provide cover for a replacement vehicle.
The Ombudsman's new stance (Which most Insurers do not seem to be aware of) means that if an Insurer does not provide cover for a replacement vehicle (Assuming they would normally cover the replacement) then an "Official Complaint" and then going to the Ombudsman is worth doing. It's untested so far and the Ombudsman's decisions can be inconsistent. However if the Insurer does not offer cover for the replacement (Which many still do not) and they don't offer a refund then (In my opinion) if it gets as far as the Ombudsman there's a very good chance they will require the Insurer to provide a pro rata refund less any standard cancellation charges.
dacouch said:
"Most motor insurance policies are yearly contracts – so the full premium is payable even if the vehicle is written off during the year. If the consumer paid the yearly premium upfront, they will not receive any refund. Or if the consumer was paying the yearly premium by monthly instalments, they must still pay the outstanding instalments after the vehicle is written off.
When an insurer declares a vehicle a write-off, we expect it to offer a consumer the option of bringing a replacement vehicle onto the insurance policy so that the remainder of the policy term can be used. Depending on the make and model of the replacement vehicle, an additional premium may be required by the insurer. This should be calculated on a pro rata basis for the remainder of the policy term."
http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications...
The above has changed fairly recently, it used to say to the effect that there is normally no refund of premium in the event of a total loss and did not state the Ombudsman expects an Insurer to provide cover for a replacement vehicle.
The Ombudsman's new stance (Which most Insurers do not seem to be aware of) means that if an Insurer does not provide cover for a replacement vehicle (Assuming they would normally cover the replacement) then an "Official Complaint" and then going to the Ombudsman is worth doing. It's untested so far and the Ombudsman's decisions can be inconsistent. However if the Insurer does not offer cover for the replacement (Which many still do not) and they don't offer a refund then (In my opinion) if it gets as far as the Ombudsman there's a very good chance they will require the Insurer to provide a pro rata refund less any standard cancellation charges.
Do you have any information about the ombudsman's new stance? The information you have posted contradicts what you claim and your opinion that they will require a refund is at odds with what you have posted. When an insurer declares a vehicle a write-off, we expect it to offer a consumer the option of bringing a replacement vehicle onto the insurance policy so that the remainder of the policy term can be used. Depending on the make and model of the replacement vehicle, an additional premium may be required by the insurer. This should be calculated on a pro rata basis for the remainder of the policy term."
http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications...
The above has changed fairly recently, it used to say to the effect that there is normally no refund of premium in the event of a total loss and did not state the Ombudsman expects an Insurer to provide cover for a replacement vehicle.
The Ombudsman's new stance (Which most Insurers do not seem to be aware of) means that if an Insurer does not provide cover for a replacement vehicle (Assuming they would normally cover the replacement) then an "Official Complaint" and then going to the Ombudsman is worth doing. It's untested so far and the Ombudsman's decisions can be inconsistent. However if the Insurer does not offer cover for the replacement (Which many still do not) and they don't offer a refund then (In my opinion) if it gets as far as the Ombudsman there's a very good chance they will require the Insurer to provide a pro rata refund less any standard cancellation charges.
Cat
Cat said:
Do you have any information about the ombudsman's new stance? The information you have posted contradicts what you claim and your opinion that they will require a refund is at odds with what you have posted.
Cat
Do you not mean the information I posted contradicts what you posted eg you posted that the insurance normally ceases after a total loss.Cat
As I stated in my post, this changed fairly recently eg a few months ago so the Ombudsman does not appear to have published any cases on this as yet.
From my experience of the Ombudsman who bearing in mind tend to be very sympathetic to consumers but also not always consistent I think that an "Official Complaint" quoting the Ombudsman's guidance will in most cases result in the Insurer offering cover for the replacement vehicle (Assuming they offer cover for it). Should they not offer cover for the replacement vehicle I would expect some Insurers to offer a refund but some to be happy for it to go to the Ombudsman. I think that the Ombudsman would rule that as the Insurer did not offer for the customer to cover their replacement vehicle that a refund is due.
Bearing in mind that if the FOS rules in favour of the consumer, they would normally rule that they should be put in the position had the complaint not needed to be made and assuming by the time the Ombudsman had given a decision the OP would probably have had to reinsure the bike they would insist on a pro rata refund plus any other additional costs the OP reasonably incurred.
As I said it's fairly new guidance and the Ombudsman can be inconsistent so is not guaranteed but in my experience that is how they would rule, there's a good chance that the bike Insurers would not allow it to go that far with a well worded "Official Complaint" referencing the Ombudsman's guidance on this matter
Nothing in what you have posted supports what you have said.
This:-
"Most motor insurance policies are yearly contracts – so the full premium is payable even if the vehicle is written off during the year. If the consumer paid the yearly premium upfront, they will not receive any refund. Or if the consumer was paying the yearly premium by monthly instalments, they must still pay the outstanding instalments after the vehicle is written off.
States the opposite.
As does this from Admiral's policy
Cat
This:-
"Most motor insurance policies are yearly contracts – so the full premium is payable even if the vehicle is written off during the year. If the consumer paid the yearly premium upfront, they will not receive any refund. Or if the consumer was paying the yearly premium by monthly instalments, they must still pay the outstanding instalments after the vehicle is written off.
States the opposite.
As does this from Admiral's policy
Admiral said:
10. Total loss of your car
If your car is a total loss, all cover including the driving of other cars extension, if applicable, is cancelled for you and any other drivers on the policy. Once we make a payment to you, your car will become our property. We will deduct any outstanding premium and charges owed from any claim settlement we make to you.
If your car is a total loss, all cover including the driving of other cars extension, if applicable, is cancelled for you and any other drivers on the policy. Once we make a payment to you, your car will become our property. We will deduct any outstanding premium and charges owed from any claim settlement we make to you.
Cat
Cat said:
Cat
As I said the Ombudsman's guidance has changed relatively recently and Admiral as have many other Insurers not caught up with it yet. I do not dispute that in the event of a write off, the full premium would normally be due, however now days the FOS expects the Insurer to offer cover for the balance of the period for a replacement vehicleYou seem to be ignoring the relevant part of the Ombudsmans guidance.
"When an insurer declares a vehicle a write-off, we expect it to offer a consumer the option of bringing a replacement vehicle onto the insurance policy so that the remainder of the policy term can be used. Depending on the make and model of the replacement vehicle, an additional premium may be required by the insurer. This should be calculated on a pro rata basis for the remainder of the policy term."
Do you believe that an "Official Complaint" to Admiral and then if needed a complaint to the Ombudsman would not over rule what Admiral have in their Policy wording with regard to cancelling the cover which is directly at odds with the Ombudsmans stance will not mean the Ombudsman will not rule that the customer should be put in the place they would have been had Admiral followed the Ombudsman's guidance. They did not offer cover for the replacement vehicle (The ombudsman expects them to) so in my view the Ombudsman would rule they would need to offer a refund of the balance of premiums and make good any other reasonable costs the complainer incurred.
You also seem to have forgotten that part of your original argument with me was
Cat said:
The normal situation is that insurance ceases once it has paid out for a total loss.
Cat
The link I've provided from the Ombudsman clearly states the Ombudsman expects the Insurer of a written off vehicle to provide cover for the replacement vehicle...Cat
"When an insurer declares a vehicle a write-off, we expect it to offer a consumer the option of bringing a replacement vehicle onto the insurance policy so that the remainder of the policy term can be used. Depending on the make and model of the replacement vehicle, an additional premium may be required by the insurer. This should be calculated on a pro rata basis for the remainder of the policy term."
What do you think will happen if Admiral ignore this and cancel the policy with no refund and the case goes to the Ombudsman? Complaining to the FOS is not an exact science but in my experience there's a very high chance they will rule Admiral should have covered the replacement and if they did they should put the consumer back to the position they would have been had Admiral followed the FOS guidance.
Just because the bike is an economic total loss, doesn't mean for most policies (unless there's something written into them specifically by that insurer), that they lapse, as it may well still be rideable and roadworthy. You have an old bike, with a dented tank, that could "total loss" the vehicle alone if the new tank is close to the value of the bike.
There is no link between Cat C and rideable or roadworthy. Cat C means something very specific, that the bike CAN be rebuilt, safely, but not economically.
However, even if you continue to be insured for third party risks, subject to any t&c such as a fresh MOT ect, you have had the value of the vehicle. Ie if it's then stolen, you'd need to show that you'd repaired the vehicle to be able to claim more than the loss of the salvage amount.
There is no link between Cat C and rideable or roadworthy. Cat C means something very specific, that the bike CAN be rebuilt, safely, but not economically.
However, even if you continue to be insured for third party risks, subject to any t&c such as a fresh MOT ect, you have had the value of the vehicle. Ie if it's then stolen, you'd need to show that you'd repaired the vehicle to be able to claim more than the loss of the salvage amount.
KingNothing said:
Hello, has an accident recently, bike has been declared a Cat C and I'm going to be paid out for it, I also believe I will be keeping the bike as well. Now, my insurance doesn't finish until July, I would like to continue to insure it until that time so that I don't lose this years no claims bonus, and the bike is currently in my possession in my back garden, so in the unlikely event I'd still like it covered for theft purposes at least, even if it is a Cat C now, I haven't decided if I'm going to repair it, scrap it, or break it yet though, but will likely repair it so it could well be back on the road before July.
Just wondering what the standard outcome of cases like this is, or is it purely on an insurer by insurer basis? Will many insurance companies continue to insure vehicles after they've been declared a write off, as I imagine there'll be plenty of times where older vehicles are written off, but are still driveable and their owners will want to continue to use it, or will they just cancel my policy straight away?
Will obviously be ringing my insurance company to sort it all out, would just like to know what I'm up against.
Thanks in advance
Ermmmmmmm ............Just wondering what the standard outcome of cases like this is, or is it purely on an insurer by insurer basis? Will many insurance companies continue to insure vehicles after they've been declared a write off, as I imagine there'll be plenty of times where older vehicles are written off, but are still driveable and their owners will want to continue to use it, or will they just cancel my policy straight away?
Will obviously be ringing my insurance company to sort it all out, would just like to know what I'm up against.
Thanks in advance
You're claiming on your policy, why do you think you'll get this year's NCD? You won't. You'll also lose two years NCD (if you have that).
NCD = No Claims Discount so making a claim is a bit of a clue.
I have no idea what would happen if they went against the ombudsman's guidance but I doubt it would be as you describe. If it were you would end up with the situation whereby you keep writing cars off and the insurance company are compelled to continue insuring you under the terms of the original policy for a year or as mentioned earlier they have to pay out on a total loss and then give you back the majority of your premium also.
Cat
Cat
Well this has gone off on a tengent.
Here's the answer on the FOS stuff.
A policy ends when the vehicle it covers is written off. That used to be the end fo the policy and the policyholder's money.
Now what happens is that the policy ends and the annual premium (if paid monthly) becomes due in full. However, the FOS expect the insurer to allow the policyholder to offer the policyholder the opportunity to have a new policy covering their new car for the remainig term of the old policy; premium due will depend on the admin fees and additional risk.
This is nothing new and most policies sold in the past 15 years or so did this anyway, so the old style policy was effectively dead and the FOS is merely trying to stop some insurers selling old style policies at a lower rate without the policyholder being aware of this clause.
Ironically, it's really only bike policies that have the old style clauses in them, but again they aren't hugely common. The reason it remains on bike insurance, is that this market is still broker dominated and has not moved to direct underwriting, or aggregator markets with anywhere near the speed. This is due to the market being small and very niche and no more than petty cash from a corporate insurer perspective.
Here's the answer on the FOS stuff.
A policy ends when the vehicle it covers is written off. That used to be the end fo the policy and the policyholder's money.
Now what happens is that the policy ends and the annual premium (if paid monthly) becomes due in full. However, the FOS expect the insurer to allow the policyholder to offer the policyholder the opportunity to have a new policy covering their new car for the remainig term of the old policy; premium due will depend on the admin fees and additional risk.
This is nothing new and most policies sold in the past 15 years or so did this anyway, so the old style policy was effectively dead and the FOS is merely trying to stop some insurers selling old style policies at a lower rate without the policyholder being aware of this clause.
Ironically, it's really only bike policies that have the old style clauses in them, but again they aren't hugely common. The reason it remains on bike insurance, is that this market is still broker dominated and has not moved to direct underwriting, or aggregator markets with anywhere near the speed. This is due to the market being small and very niche and no more than petty cash from a corporate insurer perspective.
Cat said:
I have no idea what would happen if they went against the ombudsman's guidance but I doubt it would be as you describe. If it were you would end up with the situation whereby you keep writing cars off and the insurance company are compelled to continue insuring you under the terms of the original policy for a year or as mentioned earlier they have to pay out on a total loss and then give you back the majority of your premium also.
Cat
Which is not what I said and is also not a very good example as the vast vast majority of the public if they wrote off a vehicle are unlikely to write off another vehicle in the same policy period. Even if they did write off their vehicles multiple times in an insurance period. The Ombudsman's guidance is clear in my eyes how they expect the Insurer to act eg they expect the Insurer to provide cover for the replacement vehicle/vehicles.Cat
If the Insurer decides to not follow the Ombudsmans guidance then they will need to run the gauntlet of how the Ombudsman would view them not providing cover for a replacement. My expectation is they would rule a refund should have been given in lieu of not providing cover for the balance of the year.
dacouch said:
Which is not what I said and is also not a very good example as the vast vast majority of the public if they wrote off a vehicle are unlikely to write off another vehicle in the same policy period. Even if they did write off their vehicles multiple times in an insurance period. The Ombudsman's guidance is clear in my eyes how they expect the Insurer to act eg they expect the Insurer to provide cover for the replacement vehicle/vehicles.
If the Insurer decides to not follow the Ombudsmans guidance then they will need to run the gauntlet of how the Ombudsman would view them not providing cover for a replacement. My expectation is they would rule a refund should have been given in lieu of not providing cover for the balance of the year.
Perhaps I have misunderstood what you are saying. Are you suggesting that original policy will continue and they must offer cover under this for the new vehicle, or are you suggesting, as Loon did, that the old policy ends and they are obliged to offer a new policy, which reflects the new risk, for a replacement vehicle. If it is the latter then I am in agreement with you. If the Insurer decides to not follow the Ombudsmans guidance then they will need to run the gauntlet of how the Ombudsman would view them not providing cover for a replacement. My expectation is they would rule a refund should have been given in lieu of not providing cover for the balance of the year.
Cat
Cat said:
Perhaps I have misunderstood what you are saying. Are you suggesting that original policy will continue and they must offer cover under this for the new vehicle, or are you suggesting, as Loon did, that the old policy ends and they are obliged to offer a new policy, which reflects the new risk, for a replacement vehicle. If it is the latter then I am in agreement with you.
Cat
I agree that Loon's option of a new policy for the remaining period subject to any pro rata difference in premium is acceptable. It is also acceptable for the Insurer to allow a change of vehicle on the existing policy subject to any pro rata additional premium.Cat
What I'm saying if the Insurer does not offer either of the above, then an Official Complaint and then a subsequent complaint to the Ombudsman (In my opinion) has a very good chance of the Ombudsman ruling against the Insurer and requiring them to give a pro rata refund of the balance of the premiums.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


