Does this look right?
Discussion
On my travels the other day I approached a junction in Lewisham that didn't seem right at all. It's the junction of Lewisham Way, Shardeloes Road and Amersham Road.
On approach to the traffic lights I noticed that the stop line is a good 4-5 metres in front of the traffic light, I don't think I've ever seen a junction like this in London.
This is the road in question:
http://goo.gl/maps/pnXEh
It doesn't look that far back on street view but if you look at it on the satellite images it looks really far back:
https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Shardeloes+Rd&...
Anyway, my question mainly centres around the red light camera that's in operation on said junction and how any prosecution would work. I've read that the offence is complete once any part of the vehicle crosses the white stop line but just wondered if there were any guidelines as to how far the line had to be from the lights. While trying to look for said regulations I stumbled upon something from TFL that said all bicycle boxes must have a cycle lane going into them for entrance for cyclists (which this one doesn't have) does that make the ASL invalid?
I think originally the stop line was further forward just before the crossing but they've moved it back to facilitate buses turning left from Amersham Road.
From looking at it when I was there and on google maps I don't think the camera is working anyway (as there's no sensors on the surface of the road) but couldn't get my head around them sending out a picture in a prosecution of a car waiting at a set of traffic lights and being accused of jumping said lights. Also think it's a bit cheap if you're concentrating on the road ahead - looking at the cars ahead and the lights - to then miss a stop line in a place that's unusual.
Probably bored you to tears reading that but have just wondered since I saw it. Probably need to get out more.
On approach to the traffic lights I noticed that the stop line is a good 4-5 metres in front of the traffic light, I don't think I've ever seen a junction like this in London.
This is the road in question:
http://goo.gl/maps/pnXEh
It doesn't look that far back on street view but if you look at it on the satellite images it looks really far back:
https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Shardeloes+Rd&...
Anyway, my question mainly centres around the red light camera that's in operation on said junction and how any prosecution would work. I've read that the offence is complete once any part of the vehicle crosses the white stop line but just wondered if there were any guidelines as to how far the line had to be from the lights. While trying to look for said regulations I stumbled upon something from TFL that said all bicycle boxes must have a cycle lane going into them for entrance for cyclists (which this one doesn't have) does that make the ASL invalid?
I think originally the stop line was further forward just before the crossing but they've moved it back to facilitate buses turning left from Amersham Road.
From looking at it when I was there and on google maps I don't think the camera is working anyway (as there's no sensors on the surface of the road) but couldn't get my head around them sending out a picture in a prosecution of a car waiting at a set of traffic lights and being accused of jumping said lights. Also think it's a bit cheap if you're concentrating on the road ahead - looking at the cars ahead and the lights - to then miss a stop line in a place that's unusual.
Probably bored you to tears reading that but have just wondered since I saw it. Probably need to get out more.
That is really quite poor and I bet that it catches a lot of people out, why don't they move the light on the pavement up to the stop line? If you're following a large vehicle through that junction it is quite possible that the only light that you see is 70 meters-ish past the stop line.
I saw a TV programme once where they showed the red light camera flashing twice, just to see if the car that triggered it had stopped or gone through the junctions. Those that stopped weren't prosecuted. Without a box junction, you could legally follow a vehicle which was turning right, but the lights turn red on you whilst you're waiting to follow them.
I can't see how they'd ever get away with prosecuting someone for it as they always go on about things being in the best interest of the public.
How can you prosecute someone for sitting at a red light?
There's a similar lay out at the bottom of my road so the junction doesn't get blocked but there's space for a car behind the stop line and then a KEEP CLEAR box. They should do that there to stop cars just driving up to the lights and stopping.
I'd say it's an inactive camera though due to lack of sensors but it's still a bit of a peetake.
How can you prosecute someone for sitting at a red light?
There's a similar lay out at the bottom of my road so the junction doesn't get blocked but there's space for a car behind the stop line and then a KEEP CLEAR box. They should do that there to stop cars just driving up to the lights and stopping.
I'd say it's an inactive camera though due to lack of sensors but it's still a bit of a peetake.
That's poor. I'm a highways (design) engineer (have worked for several LA's) and that would very likely catch me out. The traffic signals should be closer to the stop line, IMO. I can't see why they would position them so far away. It can't be for cost saving (sharing posts etc), to duct the cables would cost peanuts. Entrapment is 100% not the case. Designers have no link to prosecution/revenue at all. I would send a friendly email off to the highways dept - FAO Network Manager - and ask if there's any reason for it.
But again, it is absolutely not entrapment - we don't have anything to do with enforcement or the revenue from the cameras, so please don't go tearing in to him, no need for tin foil hats. I'm sure there's an engineering reason behind it, misguided or not.
But again, it is absolutely not entrapment - we don't have anything to do with enforcement or the revenue from the cameras, so please don't go tearing in to him, no need for tin foil hats. I'm sure there's an engineering reason behind it, misguided or not.

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


