Anyone with experience of the VAG 1.6TDI with 6 speed box?
Anyone with experience of the VAG 1.6TDI with 6 speed box?
Author
Discussion

TheCarMadDad

Original Poster:

317 posts

154 months

Sunday 26th January 2014
quotequote all
Chaps,

I wondering if any of you have any experience with the 1.6TDI with the later 6 speed manual as opposed to 5 speed?

I'm very tempted with the Audi A3 1.6TDI Sportback S Line as my next company car. I want to go with the 1.6TDI rather than the new 150bhp 2.0TDI as I do around 65% town driving and 35% motorway/dual, Also the 2.0 is pushing the upper limits of my company car budget.

I specifically want to know about fuel economy; I know that some owners have been disappointed with the mpg they have been getting with the 1.6TDI, most of them are pre-march 2013 though when the engine was paired with a 5 speed box. Now that it has a 6 speed box as standard is it more refined and less strained at motorway speeds? In turn does the 6th gear improve the economy at all?

Lastly what is it like overtaking at motorway speeds? does it need dropping down a gear or is it just about torquey enough to to cope when it matters?

Thanks in advance...

dunmow70

198 posts

194 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
It may help, but I had a 1.6TDI A1 3 door as a courtesy car a while back. It only had the 5 speed manual. It was showing 70+mpg for a 60mph cruise. Acceleration from 0 to 40 was good enough and in fairness, I was mildly surprised by it, but beyond that, it drops off quickly. I had to plan overtakes well in advance. Acceleration from 60 to 70 was near on impossible in 5th unless going down a hill. There wasn't enough power to maintain speed going up inclines in 5th.

In the heavier A3, I would expect it to be even worse.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
Might be worth going for the newer 110PS version of the 1.6 TDI if you're after best economy possible. The 105 is starting to get a little old now.

TheCarMadDad

Original Poster:

317 posts

154 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
the 110 isn't available on the Audi website???

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Our courtesy cars are 2012 VW Tourans with the 1.6 diesel and 6 speed box; for a 'normal' car they've got plenty of torque and return 45mpg even if you drive like a bit of a knob. Mid 50s easy if you're smooth and that's in a big, heavy brick of a car.

Not had a single problem on either in 20 months and ~22k miles each.