Question about eBay and faulty goods
Discussion
I bought a steam mop from a guy on eBay and of November and it's stopped working January 10th. I've emailed him 3 times but had no reply, so I'm expecting that he's not going to reply. I therefore have little chance of a replacement or repair. I've contacted the manufacturer and they have said that my warranty lies with the eBay contact.
Couple of questions:
Can I pursue him under SOGA? I don't think he's a private seller as he's sold a few of these.
Do the manufacturer have a responsibility to provide a replacement or do they class it as second hand as they didn't sell it?
Should I write off £60 for something I used twice?
Thanks for any advice, this is getting rather annoying.
Couple of questions:
Can I pursue him under SOGA? I don't think he's a private seller as he's sold a few of these.
Do the manufacturer have a responsibility to provide a replacement or do they class it as second hand as they didn't sell it?
Should I write off £60 for something I used twice?
Thanks for any advice, this is getting rather annoying.
IF he is a business seller it will give his name and address near the bottom of his listings - otherwise you will have to approach ebay for it. You can then write him a letter before action notification and threaten making a money claim online against him. You are beyond the period where you could claim via ebay/paypal.
He may not be a business seller - he may have just picked up a small batch of them - in which case I suspect caveat emptor applies.
He may not be a business seller - he may have just picked up a small batch of them - in which case I suspect caveat emptor applies.
elanfan said:
IF he is a business seller it will give his name and address near the bottom of his listings - otherwise you will have to approach ebay for it. You can then write him a letter before action notification and threaten making a money claim online against him. You are beyond the period where you could claim via ebay/paypal.
He may not be a business seller - he may have just picked up a small batch of them - in which case I suspect caveat emptor applies.
As long as he was selling it/them with an expectation of profit that makes him a trader, in which case SOGA applies.He may not be a business seller - he may have just picked up a small batch of them - in which case I suspect caveat emptor applies.
^^^^^ This. Steam mops = Rubbish concept. Use a mop and bucket.
The manufacturer has no obligation to you, OP, unless the device is so badly designed or made that it causes you physical injury. Your contract is with the eBay seller.
The manufacturer has no obligation to you, OP, unless the device is so badly designed or made that it causes you physical injury. Your contract is with the eBay seller.
Edited by anonymous-user on Monday 27th January 11:34
singlecoil said:
elanfan said:
IF he is a business seller it will give his name and address near the bottom of his listings - otherwise you will have to approach ebay for it. You can then write him a letter before action notification and threaten making a money claim online against him. You are beyond the period where you could claim via ebay/paypal.
He may not be a business seller - he may have just picked up a small batch of them - in which case I suspect caveat emptor applies.
As long as he was selling it/them with an expectation of profit that makes him a trader, in which case SOGA applies.He may not be a business seller - he may have just picked up a small batch of them - in which case I suspect caveat emptor applies.
First, making a sale with a view to a profit does not in itself make a person a business seller. A person who opportunistically sells off one or two items and makes a profit, but who does not engage in such sales as an occupation or on a regular basis is not a business seller. If I buy an old car and sell it on for a profit, I am not automatically thereby in business as a seller of cars. Whether someone is selling in the course of a business is a question of fact.
The seller in the OP's case might be a business seller, especially if he makes a habit of selling steamy mops, but I can't say without knowing more.
For "business", see various tax cases, and also Scarth v Amin (2009, Divisional Court) (where the slightly whacky issue was whether an Electoral Returning Officer has a place of business) -
The Court said:
36 We note that the word “business” can have a broad meaning. The Oxford English Dictionary gives the following meanings:
“III 11.a … a person's official duty …; function occupation… 12.a A person's official or professional duties as a whole; stated occupation, profession, or trade…”
37 There are the following definitions given in other legal contexts:
i) “Business” is a wider term than “trade”, and not synonymous with it, and means almost anything which is an occupation as distinguished from a pleasure. However the term must be construed according to its context: 47 Halsbury's Laws: 4th Ed [2001 Edition] para 6. See Rolls v Miller [1884] 27 Ch D 71 (“The word [“business”] means almost anything which is an occupation as distinguished from a pleasure - anything which is an occupation or duty which requires attention is a business” per Lindley, LJ).
ii) In the Sale of Goods Act 1979 “business” is defined as including the activities of any government department or local or public authority: section 61 (1) . A similar definition appears in section 14 of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 .
iii) Under the Landlord & Tenant Act 1954 section 23 (2) “business” includes a trade, profession or employment, and includes any activity carried on by a body of persons whether corporate or incorporate. Whether an activity which is carried on by an individual tenant is a trade profession or employment so as to attract the statutory protection is a question of degree to be decided in the light of all the circumstances existing: Halsbury's Laws 4th Ed [Reissue] Vol 27 (1) para 565.
Edited by anonymous-user on Monday 27th January 12:03
Thanks all, I can confirm he is a business seller. I will send him recorded delivery letter confirming he has 14 days to make full reimbursement or replacement with working item, or I will go for the online money claim option against him.
The steam mop wasn't my idea, it was the missus that wanted it and, when it works, it's pretty good. Apparently. :-)
The steam mop wasn't my idea, it was the missus that wanted it and, when it works, it's pretty good. Apparently. :-)
Mayhap, but I think that we are probably talking here about the domestic ones sold online and in hardware stores. My mum bought one, and it is pretty ineffectual, I reckon. Oh well, I must let her stop mopping now, as she is 97 after all, and besides, it's nearly time for her to cook my dinner.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



te, don't bother!